High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Venkataramanaswamy vs The Assistant Commissioner on 27 August, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri Venkataramanaswamy vs The Assistant Commissioner on 27 August, 2009
Author: H N Das


ER? ‘:€:E£§?El E-EEQEH C<f}5L3§7{'§.' €;}i?" XE' Bfa§'°éi§_:i.§,,3L}§i§'i–

ETEATEEEZE ":":~§§:~'; THE: 2?" ::m* g:::: i f ~ .

i§E%1§*”{.)}?;}’:l

fizz: H(§E€’BZ§,,§;’ 1%.. ;:_W:s”:’*:<:;%; 3%. :~§;g:;z;;.;;:;3x:':3%:e;;4a,:§'%§}::.,3:

a%r:ei*:* :)§;'r:'r:0:x? 2;"%2$';=3:§§'8;J%L{u::ji ; – . «A "

E:§%';"§"€€§€§iZIZ'é :

=:<-gm '%'E1?€E<:..s&*§'fi%.E%4»§,?xsi;i_,N.§%.S¥'%:?:;'*%I;E'%; 1 " '
§§§}Z*v23sJE'Ri-§S"E"{§E;E£GE}) <
r§€E"§'§§T:-£§.{}:5!.};;'{..:')3;._}';:5i RCEAE':
;2:~a;:::«:.;s,§;"g * $62 "gas;

3>:;x:~s<m§.,§:§; i}.§S-1′}ER§{;’V£7 . _
RE? 2;? mi SE{f§%§£=”i”1%K}{‘§:i A ‘

Sr: *:’§:§»=1;§:;§A:;k
$513» m};}s;:<:r§;aE: $z~:3:§f;*"g% " L
;2.<;;2é:232a§£;::;.éf§ '2'Z&1;2}e:sg*. % " "

E’-l§§.AE_(, ?%l’i’§f§’§.{M}?*§E:L§§

~ Sri; ‘ :3 %§:;s,§:5, »

E}? =

aw.-Q’-ps

‘EEEEZ.._fi;S:§ES’i’:%.E%£’Z’ c{§::gm;$s::=.:%;;a
TB%_?*€G;fi§_,€;§RE $€}’i§”i’E~§ 312:; 3:m$§:;>:\;

x ,fi$€i§’%::}i;%Ei%§v:i;%E\§g §’A_§EE} ‘§”‘R§§{;,: EAL

_ ;é&;£1<:A:%:a:.{;a Raga,

Ls3%;$§A%;<;;:§_y<3;%§: « is5:{:<;%s;§.

‘ PW”


 

it

'  T    ggg; gm Rg%§¢iA§,%§*E

Sfifi, 

.:%.{}§%Z§) ;"§E€§}§,§'§f fiéé 
i<;?:V;%E.£g§£{§SA}§.;§Li,i %"§§,.i,:§{}EL
§<..;'i..S 538;'; BSBEJE'  Eliém-5%, 

(74:/""



Rafi

firm ‘>-‘€E”}-“‘ Same Eazaiis in cguasiéatsza. .x%3?'{a§ zzezfiai r<:a':,1r:c§$ una§

disgcsai in accéréazzce with Eaw. iékiier résmanei fmm i%:§s_.;:: §i3_i_i§»e£:i ‘i>j;*”t§2:<:_ geifioner

£3? impieafiing. Timreafier the théifi ré$:pcié:;ie§i%– gajaéé –.:;:_p his ciainz as;

3 Eeraarzi 333$ cansenied'-§'i3: graiii':yf§3€¢1z.§3.nc;;l:*i.g}%'iS in iiiwmr 6:'

sesezzzi :&$pa::=aé.e;;i;'V, 'ihéi "E22315 '§';"ih:.1nai pasgsé £3}:
§§n§2:g§1e& éiféef "éa*§e§i' _§*2i::i%:2g €§£3€§§§;§;E}i'::x_»' righég in

msgsci sf {he §.:;:~:fa_;i is €g?£e§;f,§é§af1…~*§I1 :§'&'s,»-was €31?" $i?5;fC§§'i§ ffifigfififififii.

';%i:::::a:e 33:: _§e:§ié£}!1'§ ~§.',§.'§.»«.'.V§§'1@ 1:331. rspresaiziigag figs iemgis "Er:

i§i;E;€*Si§é'§§'§,*' é _ A .

._ ~a_§g2..€v:°;r:é.:§is am E91}: 2238 aéfia arzé yemseé ‘aha fi§’§’i£3″€

gm: gfififiéffi. .

T ” 3%’: figs fwm R13. ? féieé %:§: ?§€€§}1’§€§ féfifififiiififii fiiéé fififiéfi as?’

_;}:%,5z3e:~ $§§§”a::~: Ezzgfzé £3 ;°::e:n*:§; ‘

a:cn’iemie::’; ficéiare {E28 Lani} ‘”§riE>1;§:a,§ that E33 is fiizsa tegsgagi i§;§T’§aé::r.?1 T’

if: agzzeaiéasrxg Ehrther ii is Sififffi fmm iégg :§%:zp:é§g;I’:;d g<3réie§._%%3:i§;.§§?:e

iampie ii} igiiéfiiiiéfi is §"$§§'ii'$€3§'i§i3{§ E}; $122. 'E'aE:giEé3: <3?' 2$J§'J<:i<,é§'i é;a%:,:i:.' "

Lésamsé <:<}:,an$e§ fey the gecami res %}fi€§'€fi'§' »:idmi*:$ '¥'e§1;1*€'*'£§é;S’i§:3§”‘i. {En {E36 {;i§,:§;.¥r’?¥:;aé::”§ iii»; T-i:’iE3i:::é;i §é_§’£%C§S.E.§§§,? 3.§§§i£:&i§€3.”§’§ faiefi

Egg: $6 gseiééimiaf i;*:::s;§ié:> C{I’¥§’.3,f%_’».°34t.:’}V”;”§’ ‘§”€§’?3i)§’€.”§ réggréserziisgg the: énisfegi 9%’

the §e:z3§§£§–. ii’ is ‘%i§i;”§§i€:f} $;5t§fi=___%§’;T§§’£::. the reateraig that: ééze :§’2.i§a:§

:2:3§>z:s:3&s§:’:. as:Ea{i:*at_EVa§ms tie i%:3_-éioxzvagwr a:;3f”‘£%1:’2 §€3″£}§§t3 fizz {g::&:;t§<s::

ggveg :_:'§':'«:.§1i$.__ é,f§&;§§":"} 21$" 'fu3.:2azi?:' aim? {:{Es{§3€fiES f::;:' g:'2i;3"i 9%' s<;%s.:é:;sa:2::'§;

T§E:.§¥:é'a§:f'«vM.eE£'T –.s::c€:m§ §°»a$§s3:3§ie32%' Yézég materiai €333 mearé

' V' — a:§aa.;5'§§;' e1:::fia%§§s§:é;§ 3&3? wiféhaui §E'O§2€i"i'}-" ;'s;:=§*e:3e;':f,§z;3g {he iempis in

ggaghgsiiefl a§1§§%;§§E}@z;*§. Eiearésgg figs: Eéfifipifi {he imgzzéggzeci affief came 2&3

§ps§gS§é:§, fiaezéfars iim imgizgzgé agéar £3 Eéafiéa {Q ée S83 agiéeg

V' <3. En view igyiéize 533% 2323; '§§"i€i'– iiaéfii :*$:g§@n§$:3§ Efizzzé gézsezz 2:?

fi§3;§§’§”§ fir: féza ianég £3 gaegééaza ‘::efa”;:’::: {E}: 3,33% :§”.:’€!§%z,:2*1:z§: Em %§;»::;

do/I/”