gr-wvuwl
is; ‘£55 51:35 Cam? (3? KAR:4A’m:s;A
czaztajz? BE:’\iCTr~§ AT auzfgawea
9,5559 THIS we 2935 am! 9?; Jmféf f’25~0,S. – 4′
$EF0§i_AV’
3*:-$3 §~i§:’2§’Bi,,5 :v1;*;,3a:s”r:c:§’LL3«;ém:e;%fm
?v’§,F,;’-*1. is::23§S«2e_r%§g§ %fm?§ ‘- A V
§E”§”v’¥’EE?’§: _ V
Saciéifs
5/G ?”if3b?’3%,’3 ,
Aged: <3 greafi, §~»'é§s*:e-;*:=:*.;__
iiffi cf i?*:§$j:'aa"é 'faifrfeér "ff 2
?!'§ii?15..§ Sis; ?;a2rar:'a;–';::;–'2._a"~% "
figafii 3$ 3f§§F§_ .
£325: ,fiwi==%2nvtT¢each’&r”‘at . ‘
asvarnmeni ?r§”:z1a?’?y VS:?:As:r_5E ”
Aiur-ii; 533%; L.§v1;ar’:g;a~’£§%:;_e¥:§”2,
“g;§,e§g;” 1 _____ .. v
M .+*-sP?§LLs’§i’\i’§’
{E}; SF-§’__$3fi?fé’S§_? Bf:’fs’.§dar, am.)
3:43:
W H ” .. 5:’§ja’si*§<§:.:;"¥:ar
._ V ;ۤ',fr:: Shivtsasagxpa
iégeciz Ivéajér,
; Gas: Business
7 REG E'{–l~Féfi§:3:1'E-lfifié
Mangaépeih,
Bids:
\
&”‘/
4
3
‘mat sag Sachér; a minar bay’ wha was aged 3?
had €:§FE””E1§.? Gui af §1:i$ hause an :4,2g2G§§ at
5223 was pmceeéing is §«’£ar2§ainei§’:,, iré»3V:*§.i:°}*::’:¢f§1.V5.zf§;a’:9–é%3:
¥s5§’i€Tf! he reached §r,Rajs’ne$e:?;ar i-§§’s:.§it§.%§;§T,”‘théfifieij $1′
mater cycia Li’; Freeécxfrn Cyém
,3§f’;’%4: §fr§i..:’é’:’3§’ in ajash VAa.;r?::r;f 1rf:7e”€?3}A§_§e.ir*’r:”‘rfiaavrfiar hit
afifiiiéfii him 6:22 is w?i’§*:£§§–tfzgff–.§r3§”*VL’.$:;:.$i*3_§Vne§ mufitétzie
ffafitufei an his rj§ ;g?fr:: ‘V 351$ ether
garis cf t§~:e:__.f?f§1afi ;_§%:.:<.§.§e«2§:I'g*§§§§§'§t:1e5saa' by me
gergazzsrzs "saga" shifteé is
aE::»va:'r:r%:.§ni "Shay aévigeé iém Say be
gniftéci '"3 *~e::j:s=;=::as?*::a;"%'A2—ssgfigtgas, i-iyéarabaa', Tau: as the
"z":?:Q:ir'se%'–.;§v=,%aS E£.§§I?r'¥e, Sim get him ifééiéfi at
*- {:s,%,'§*::%§$$3:§a%a:: '*–%e:a$§§ta§E He was aémitztaéi ané was
'V
s:;:%_:j"'e :te§§5* :;%;;;..__;§:§'§"g::7er<y an 1?,;=2i.3:';?s§, "mere was zrmitégia
V .f:acti.E'ra a;:2é§T'vf'§r heme aiigénmant, rneiaiéic Empiants wera
. 44"'§;%=;g»§.a;r;te§"é<y safgery, "';"'§°2e fizzy 293$ ééstfiargaé after lfi
hespiiaiizatisn with amrspfiate rneéiaiai aé'-£32 is
..'_4"'i-aiije rest 522$ vie reaeat visit ta hczsgitai cséfrstémausfy far
" tizrsm rnafziiig.
aka/%
xi
4. The Qéfefiifi af tha victim §§r§%psii.e _}Qf’-..:§:i:ii§f:f
§§’§S§¥’i3C§i§G’f’§$ and teak him =::Qnt§m3e1:§§iYV. ié’1.t§:§
:%.«mrs*:a§*:ti”:s, Th”? Qiaimeé &:;:.z§€s,Qi3£’:_;’_-“‘iE:: fae a’1:;*si;afra?e§’;a§sf%
reimbagrsemerzt Q? maéicai ‘V”*»§’::»:;.r::«e2*’:5é’~r.:-4._ ‘a~.?*%fi §§9ba§
tfifrsmansatiafi cf .%SE3F§V£aj’i:fl’.i?fi:i!l’;”§g:§’;§’§?:& §?’fi§fié ‘:i’1′ at”tfr’§e 893;’
has suffefgrfi ;?i’:§iS§£3i éisabiifiyp
Qfifiiéjfiiiifig -:?sa:’:’—i%”3&; a::¢§fié:9:i«-xéfas fiasuii cf rzegiigence éf
tha victim, §f:e2=::é’=2:§f;§ 2′:§:=s*2§a–:f:§r aééas net éiatée. SQ aisé the
é&fEi!'”:Sé éf i:«%?:4gE=i:r*;s:;;:2’a§{%a»2:::j§?i’;f.»2~:r”, Eased cm the ;}¥$ad%}'”2gfS, the
Tr§’§2;,23§§§’V§§.ame§”§e:§éVvan§: issuea The ciaimant’s fatfier Sr?
? rah_?§u t§$?”}éE§’e§ his esiidersce and raiied on 23 dsaasmentsz
:’€é”:;x_éi:_§V;§&T’§:é& .i;s by fag regéméarzts.
v=T §a”seé an praved’ facts, the Tribmai has
h44″‘v.s§V§s;«3.;=«:_eéVV”‘.Rs,,5§,5§6;’-as the Cfiffifiéfifiatiéfi, but the
‘.’_’T’~_.§;§’:”;-.ViV;*’:*:a’§*;t is mt satisfieé.
1 Assaiiina the judgment imauarred, the iearneé
€G§.§’r3§Q§ far appeiiam’: wt:-uifi centend that the amaurzt 31′
W
5
semperegatiars is test: meager” csmfiared ta the na:u§{:e.._T«i3§v
érgjury sufiereé $3; Em ciaimarzi and aim
disabiiity. He wauid 35$: cqfitarzfi _~t¥é’§aft’*~:’.’;f2sé “j’:2$t=-_
campensatian has £9232′: awafdeii t.]é_’wfird7s.
atterzéarrt charges etc.
3. The iaarreefi. ‘”:.«:_ri.1§:seiWrr;a:§3&j’axrAai¥abi锑£:3″ me the
exiidanca G1′ the ciaimanfs fa’t’§*;§~;-. v;:’;3r;a5i5i*z.i;;,.,”
§, i.giasi.fr”:1e}§§’V’ __:;.:L’1.i.¥ E’i 3%.! ‘fag. V Vihfigijrance campany-
Sr; R.V,§iafi3.Qé ~:iE§;§ §?_”.g§pg:;:ié’.’V?i§ impugned judgment
fiGin’€i?§’:§;_§ui ii?Vé¥;’7=:’.?饒§~ f:’i’:v«:>,§;s’g:’3E*: the sufierance fif irsjurieg by
thé ¢ia§:*;*:é*:*:Vi: §;::z*; E322 :é’;§.%.”{p5:;ove§ by the d¢:urr:er:t, there
_ is rgggfbraiscf e*fA.._;;§hVys§:a3i éisabiiity rasuitifia frem 5132?:
i§¥gj’z3.sf§é:._”” ‘szeézgifi further ééféiéfid t’nai”ihe Triburrai has
é’*.figa”:é~’::,_ig’9.§é”v2?é§r:§té.i;%§efi*:e::: 9f the ammmt astuaiéy garersi by
V V _ the ‘i’:;–?aiz*:ii:fa’r:*?:’az1é thérefére there is as degrivai cf just
‘ _<§:i.;§':*::r,§e2';s?'a:iic:§L
1Q; Haxzirgg hear-é {math sides, 3 have exarnineé the
" .réc§;='fi, it is gear: that the ciaimant had uafieuhtaéiy
Siéfféféé !""'I'}E.3§'Z§;:!§& fractures sf his right hag as exiiéencéd
};iL
6
2
frsrm fire éecument §”;:.P61 E sfmws that the ::§airna:rii §va;’$.%_’
aafmittaé tr: K§”§Si”l’!”E32″‘3§ Emspita an 15,2,2fiQ7’§ –ai’:§ 5§$;?%S “‘- ”
Eagatéafit 2:52 2«§.,Z,2QGS,, The :§a§mani._had:’éVE駔‘:§.5(i»;:$é’ué_€*,§
3.? biiis which are cash memes ‘:”:;*1a’:’i<:%-,_;§'~°a$"~E_§L.F_1$V
E:x:,F:'? tha finaé fifsiié. Tim fa:":V._§'%:.:faV_t the {:3aV§#;j;§:%fAtA"«:.$'u?fae%:f
§fiji.3§""i&S is iherefbfe vggii e§:a}:i§§iv;$_§'":'a2I.EL’. §>ia _hVa;?$ 3:36
asiafiiésizea’ that he hasv I3:.:;ffe§éé f:fi:;.2§i’i§:fi§ §’r.ag:*:ure Q? right
32¢ and 5:3 wa$4_b:;2vi:§e::3té’G*”.t%§: gnetaiiic mfis
have been _4§:r£*f:g:;§af’§;{*}[Qjtj:_:~§~; __ ~”§fi:a._ — fifrilbazifiéi hafi awaréeé
Rs,2:?:,§QQ;fg:9’s:$;§§’.:é1§;:__paifiV_:é’n:§.__::vsgff’ar§n§ which if? the
Cifiuffifiiafifiéfi §V§s9e:*r2_V”%;§’:g:'<-.§_§vsg;*= -'side, tifiereféra, it wiii ae
raasaaabiéife-e:2?:an'€;é :§"' .Rst3fi,GQ{).i-= A2 raaarfig the
_ §%:';isi"::j§§":§}§Sa§iVEif;:f.V_§Vé':@r%:::err1ed, it was rightiy §c:=i:r::ed cut
ti§?a:'_t:'§3.?r é3 v;§s'«.n9 éacumentary fiféfif, but it is $3331 fmrrz
%§f~""?ra*Qh;s, father arzé guardian éf the
V 'V _:ia§rr:é:—-nt ':'f%":latv "éfier tha fizgrgery, §ia§i'!"!§¥'1i §$ net abie £9 55:,
§?'*:$faEé{ praperéy. Thég srai statement fincis fuii
T.j5i:A:;:¥¥p'r:;a;~–*E frem iha éischarée summary 35 am} the maéizzai
'::'_""§u:–?%mary mi? :5 Shaw that the ciaimant haé sigfieraé
A " ""§*r::3£iEp§e fracturé and E3 stiii with the imfiiafita, with the
OKQV
1-!
5
maiaiiic imfiants CE”f’i§§E’:§? it may net be ¢<::$$%i';i& vs:it§2g::;;:it;_"'»,
éifficuity te sit, squat gr waik, therefaré, thaw rzfe;a"»,.~-=
§}§'2'¥'S§i3§ imgaérmerzi if: the fuaciiwifig af the §§_".£_.?.'iEf:&=';"$_
But Sifiié the same has "ftét agar: E'si3iL£;§fe§ ;f§§ 33$':
Qfficar, the awaré 6"? R.$,,3,8z?:§Q,f- irythe T?i_§iifi§§ taéfiéi ii::é'; .
said an ihé E99333: sida, Timrafczra ti?ii::._s?;e3r*s:e is§"c;afi'fi~fmés3fw
ii, iéswever, as $é$f"§ 'iE'?.& '~"ifs"Vi§:'é;::1é§Li.';'_i':§fs» beer: vary
caicgiaiivaf i逧'!'1°"¥§CE'§_' a_§_"§é mi ":3':fi;E%1_ér:%§L"_:i:a§ ..:%_éV;r 駧$§$"r'2 frag
€Z".§i,§TF':i$£?§ ifse a¥?7:f:¥71.§?Z"*§_'€:?'?3f'§€?§"TE€t_§: .i,_£E':–%"Z§_&f..'E 3§ €?2 biié am awarfiefi
ta» the giairiéafii .QSi;':'§é–:..;§ ?:3:S;'=., 'T%1§.sjam fi{3':.:'§i 5 the actazai
expenééiura S§.::§§2:¥fiE€:§. b"§* i?:é""*§_i§17fi;sffi&fitS. 323: the Yribufzai
has §;§'r':§,rf:§2':iv tijai the_::§'a'iémat:t'5 garants magi have Efitflfféfi
:'é:::i§ efi:_é'i i駧';:*e_f'r§s,_es, expanseg tcwarfigf; fgéé air' the
3iiéL2*-:é§ir'f;t;:;~r§'2':§§§'§iirggecéai fiiet ié tfrae ingasraa' fififi simiiar
ér;3§:;ni"%.§w:;v%§s §::§m:®gang:e far feyaai '~.;"i$:§t is thé hisspitai
a;:«a;:rf§aé we mméihs, The eviéenié cf F*v"v',:., S§"e"§WS
ifiai =,a;;4:s»–i.§*s'é fifiiié was ''3 yeafs 95:3, Frabhu his fathar ané
had is ramairz with tha Ciiiifi if': the imspitai, Thai
*–«. "sé::éé&m&fit is fieiievaéie and €i§f§$éQ§.3:éf'ii§V, it is aisg ta heié
3 that flaring thig fiéfifiiii the ciaérraasfs fiéfefifé may have
W
8
mo».
haii 35$ :2? $§lr’¥’3ET£”3§ as he wag privateiy erz?;:g§.;ejé’Tg,ifefLd;f’~VJ.*-
Tfiaréfsre, cefisiderirzfi this exaerzditura a frmtimai “:::_.:irr:jh.a $
:41; he fixed arm? ta be adfieé ts t§*:*eff”‘ai*:2étL§«::2t
aiready, It wiié be :r’eas@§iab§e ‘Er: i§ée__€:’§r_éu;:1si§;%”z:t:as’. ix;é ‘ V
awawi a sum cf Rs,:G,aQG;’- tarwj:’:?–:1?s aii=.tjhe..TEj’23ciéé%év:a’§
charges irzdicaieci agave Er; :”a.d;a?étic;r:”‘ts~:j:i§V;’;’;§§;’- v§i*’:’it%*:”sha$§
Efifiiisifié ihe ammjrzi éf Rs’:,V£’:_:3{.%1.:whE::.i%”-.i$…éi~:&a3fy been
aiiawaa’ by iha Tribzsfiai.tQ$éarfi§_:’,a:’:efifi’a.:1Vt’§i:’aé*gas.
12, “?’i:e–V..f§”:9-§’:s’:;;3a§ “r:éfsivvVL.’ is hate that the
metaiéicf Fféiii Er;r:pAi?a’§*::%*;Va;~’-,<:§ %«:'a: ti'1,é"'-frar:i;:rad 53$ af the ciaimant
has is be rézmévafi @.r:V¥§{'i:y?"§a::§"r';j}&:"y which mearss 'that the
c:%ai"mant;'%':a§ :9.' 1;'-zijelfié VE1i.3i'"§&f'y' fer zrammsaé cf impiants
.f§T!'1 i' §h é';*ef€:'%&,.:V%v:§u§fi isaézur afiditienaé expeaéitgre. Hence
mam?-arafs f;;v*:.§3'ra;'Vr:§.=.§:i1i'¢:ai exgerzsefi ifié "i"':'ii::u:r'rai siismé have
'V"s:sfrée2*eat;;:'«.._a §_§as§f':%éb§e arrzézmt arm? hence it is necasgary is?
– ,ji.” afv§’;’s:fé_t:3 .:%f:.é csaimafit a fiufii éf Rs.:Ce,C:fiQ;”- Therefare,
“2′;§:é–..v:§airéar:t in as; Viifiilifi fie eniitiaé ts: timsards injury,
;:;a.§:%;..7 araé sufieriné Rs§3G,::s£¥fii-, maéicai exgzerzsass
“-~«§i§sg1§,§5§[- gzaias RS.1iI’.2,§Q§;’- which is raurgfiad cf ta
?.3,3f;,§fi§;’-, Rs.::fi,Q§a’::;’~ tewardgig #333 Q? amefiities, Sam
§\,{L
§
9%’ R~sg1§,:3u’:;fi,:’–~ tawairdfi future mééicai a:=<§er:se;ks:.W_"§T,si'–é§~E -..
ciaimant wwid be entities' ta R§:&fi,,§QC*;'-u Tha"A§:2f$::§::,;§::i'2;%éfi H
jafigmeni E3, thereferra, meéifieé t¢"£ha'42;x;i;gr;:.
aémiag Tha ammani sf Campeasatiéa £$_é:r:§'1é§2cie€%
'U1
assgszg sag'— to Rs,§€:,€2Gfi;"– wa;:5Lk%%%ghaa;% a::§rf§t_§':3taé*:é$i' as
2i'_..,
3:' the Tr: zmai vangf s§:.;:fE'i' -fig: Vwéischazfiefi the
m.'
féxaé
Eségurer wiifiin aiqfézt weeks f3r":::;;r':": ':*:.:;"9s:';
Gui fif ti2;:.=":.sé:";f:;§::rs§':j a§«;é:'r§e:e:';7'.j?;$§_.§z§;,Gfifif- sfiai: ta
keg): in fixeé i¥:!a:§§:*:§i%f"'i'§*g..t,§":'e.iJ'j;i.§%*:i§_V.§9fv–rr:§–:ie;:r appaiiafit 'iiii he
"""_tiaiiI'E$ ighe _a.:3T5é7'vegf.VV_f§":aja::if;'i';'., .T?:& baiaraie ammgrai with
prc:p@?i§@*nfa:e" E%nié;ri.a§'§ *3::§….__§a§§ ta tfia ggzarfiian sf the
aiaimafsi; _g%cc§:::'fi'§fi§;i3i, frzé atsgueai shaié siargfi éisacged :3?
5%: igéffis €35?' t?i'i:..'_§r§er$,W
'V-(Sf;~- E%;«…§;%f,%=§;a:.:€2rs§&uda £5 Qefmiiiéé ta fire vaiéaiaih
V " _'*és§§i%3§f"s«.a i;2__e:f§€:é' G? fsufr weeks,
Sd/-
Judge