W'? I IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNA'I'AKA AT BANGALORE Dated this the 8'?" day of November 2010 PRESENT THE HONBLE MR.J.S.KHEHAR, CHIEF _ THE HONBLE MRJUSTICE.i3.S'.PATfI§. " WA Noses/2006. BETWEEN: 1.
SriKLinganna Nayak _h _
S/O K Upendra Nayak,-W -. A
Aged 61 Years, Retircc–i_ Hes:d’«Ma.’ster
Chokkady Aided High S’C1éiO01..’VV’. ”
13.0 Kukujadka ”
Suma T’?1}t1ck’*~D-Ki.’ Di.St_Ty1’ct.4 *
R/At ‘Sf)U1’;*Ibha:’J€1ttipElHLEl’~. A
PO Su’IIi’a«,..¢Su’Iija Tjciltiip _ A ‘
D.K I)iestifi::’t A ..
2. Sri Naréty.:>;na”Bhat””-…__ — .
S/O P ‘l”1)iruina1eshwa:a Bhat
Age:._53. Years,” .Heét”d._ Master
Chokkady Ai’ded_ High School
PIQ Kuktijgtdka
.. ‘*S1;:1.1lia.. Taluk,’ District
T Subigéiya
._ \S/’O”_V__S~h’a’mbhayyz1
‘ Aged ’52’Years
Gmduate Assistant
Clflcikkady Aided High School
1») .
* P.O Kukujadka
x __ _A”Su11ia Taluk, D.K District.
Sri Chandra Shekara Bhata
S / O Sadashiva Bhat
Age: 50 Years
Graduate Assistant.
Chokkay Aided High Schooi
P.O Kukujadka
Sullia Taiuk, D.K District
6.
Smt A Ranjiiiy Bhat
D / O Narayaria Bhat
Age : 49 Years
Head Mistress, Kalleiy Aided Higher
Primary School, P.O Arala.
Bantwal Taluk, D.K District
Sri M Parameshwara
S / O Mahaliriag Baira 1
Age: 47 Years
Kallery Aided Higher Primary * . «. V’
P.O Arala. Baiitwal Tali,-:.l__{
D.K District
Smt Bharathy B” A
D/O Shivaramayyr; B, ”
Age 47 Years A A
Assistant Teacher V v_ «V
Kallery:Aid_e’_d Higher.Primary’- School
13.0 Arala. g1Baci1’tw’al Taliil»; ] .
D.K Dis{i-r:ct”’-‘–i__ » I
Srnt ~ A
W/’ ‘Willia_m–,D ‘st;-ii
Aged .58 Years’ ; ” ”
, -Retired Head’ Mistress
~ ‘-‘.,Vvid3ra B0d’iiin_y_Aided Higher Primary
SL?i1obl,g Balila 13.0 Balila,
A ” i gswairiiarraitaia D.K District 574 2 i 2
H l’.{jBh’askara Rao
S_{U Venkatarao
Age 52 Years
Head Master
A “~.Vidya Bodhiny Aided Higher Primary School
-‘Balila 13.0. Balila Su1lia’l’aiuk
D.K District 574 212
Sri B Baiarina Gowda
S/O B Subbappa Gowda
Age: 56 Years
Graduate Assistzmt, Neharu Memorial Aided
Pre Uiiiversiiiy College, P.O Araiitodu
Sullia Ta.lul«:, UK District 574 314
ll.
14.
15.
Sri Y A Ananda
S / 0 YA. Channappa Gowda
Aged 45 Years, Graduate Assistant
Neharu l\/Iernorial Aided Pro University
College, P.O Arantodu College
Sullia ‘”I’a.1uk, D.K District 574 314
Sri A C Vasantha
S/O A.i\/I Chennappa 1
Age : 47 Years ..
P.E.T. Neharu Memorial Aided Pre
University College, P.0d Ar_antod.u
Sullia Taluk, D.K District}?-
Sri A Abdulla . ._
S/O Anduman B’ea.iy_
Age 49 Years V 1
Hindi Bhasha Sa}’iayal<a "
Neharu E'«ier1i?)ria=}r' '
Aided Preu Ufri_i_Versityi'Coll_egev l
P.O A:ran_:todu,' "S114lii;2;1f T a-luk
_
M
S / O "12 l\rlailapp'a_ Gowda
Age 41-'7'Years7'
.» '(Second Di'Vivsi.o_nH Clerk
A N'eh*ar"u.Mernorial
' ~ ._Ai«ded University College
P.O"Ara.rf1'tovdu, Sullia Taluk
"=i').K'D"ist,fict 574 314
S-.ril?urandara_ N arayana Bhat
s /'O'Sharna Bhat K
I 'Age 47 Years
' «Graduate Assistant
16.
Vidya Bodhiny Aided
High School Balila, R0 Balila
Sullia Taluk.
D.K District 574 314
Sri K Narayzema Bhat.
S / O K Subramzmya Bhat
Age: 58 years
Retired Graduate Assistant.
74 A V’
19.
4
Vidya Bodhiny Aided High School
Baiila, P.O Balila, Siillia Taluk
}’I).K District: 574 212
Sri N G Shrinivasa Rai
S/O P Rarnanna Rai
Age 58 Years
Retired Craft Teacher
Vidya Bodhiny Aided High 1:
Bahia P.O Bahia Sullia Tal11ix’.__
D.K District 574 212 t
Sri K Ventaka Krishna Sharriia
S/O K Narayana”‘Shar1iié ”
Aged 55 Years .. _ ;
Second Divisional C-lerkf’
Vidya Bodhiny Aided :Hig11’ASc:1’iog_1: ”
Balila P; O’ *B:iii1a=:Su11i.ai ..
D.K I)i.s’triei;f 2:2
Sr_i_ MK Kifisliiiia VBh_’at_ ”
s.i/oi’Kiist.i_braiya i3’i:s;t
Age 58
Graduate *ASeijsVtai”-it”
Vitt:–iis1_aiiBva1i’1t;aV Aid.ed High School
_ P.o Viftaia; eaiiiweii Taluk
. District .574 V 243
Siji V 1’viVein__ D’souza
. S,/. O._tSypiriar1 D’souza
— “-«Aged Years
Gr_adu feite Assistant
i{it’ts.11’a Balika Aided High School
R0 Viiiiala, Bantwal Taiuk
District 574 243
“S111: J ayalakshmi
W/O K Krishna Bhat
Age 53 Years
Hindi Bhasha Sahayak
Vittaila Balika. Aided Higli School
13.0 Vittaia, Baritwai ‘I’aiuk
UK District: 574 248
30.
3’1,
6
Sri K Madhusoodana Bhat
S/0 K Shambhu Bhat
Age: 57 Years
Graduate Assistant
Sri Sathya Sai Loka Seva Aided High
School, Alike PO Alike, Bantwal Talukhii’
D.K District 574 235
Sri B Padmanabha Bhat ,’ ,.
S/O B Parameshwara Sharrna
Age: 57 Years *
Graduate Assistant
Sri Sathya Sai Loka Seva Higri , A,
School, Alike POr’Al1’ke,;tBa11,tiAraiiTIfa1uk
D.K District 574 –e235A
Sri K Lingappa Gowdav A . ..
S/O Chem1_appaIGo§.vda ___ H
Age: 53 Years__. . ‘ _V if;
Sri Sathya Sai Loka Seva_VAided High
SCHGCJL ,Alike’7i5O _Alike, Baritwal Taiuk
D7,}: Igistrrc-:~~574_ A A
B Géowfiry V . g _
D / O B”Param’esh.wara Sharma
V, ,_§Aged 62 Years _
‘ __ ~ Retired ,.Graduate Assistant,
Sri Sat.hya__Sai Loka Seva Aided High
A ” _ A1_il§s;e PO Alike, Bantwal Taluk
V. 32.
Djistriet 574 235
A’.44Sm”t:A.Shankary D / O M ishwara Bhat
Aged’ 69 Years
Wfietired Kannada Bhasha Shikshaki
* S-ri Sathya Sai Loka Seva Aided High
School, Alike PO Alike, Bantwal Taluk
D.K District 574 235
Sri I) Puiidarika S/O Narnappayya
Aged 55 Years, Graduate Assistant
Sri Sathya Sat’ Loka. Seva Aided High
School, Alike PO Alike, Baritwai Taluk
D.K Distirict 574 235
W, –
34.
36.
37.
33;
7
Sri M Shieekrishna Bhat
S / O Vasudeva Bhai:
Aged 60 Years
Retired Graduate Assistant,
Sri Sathya Sai Loka Seva Aided High
School, Alike PO Alike, Bantwa1Ta1uk
D.K District 574 235
Sri K Rathnakara Rai
S/O N Narayana Rai ,
Aged 53 Years, Graduate Assis.ta’r2t,
Sri Sathya Sai Loka Seiv’a;”AjdedV’Higi3.
School, Alike PO Alike, Bantwzil Taiuk ‘ ‘
D.K District 574
Sri K Somashekariaid Pi’a’b.hEil’V
S / O K Vamana Piiabhii ‘
Aged 64
Retired Gra}:iL1at.e”Assistant, V ”
Sri seithya, ..S’eV_ai Aided High
Schooi–,,.Al.iI-:,e PG Alike, B”ant_wa1 Taluk
ov;’K”:;’ie£iti_et”
Sfi \./’en Pu thuraya
S/ Gopalaéfirishsna Puthuraya
Aged 59 Years ‘
,_%Retired P’;E.__T. Grade I
._ ~ SP1-eSai:hya Saiigoka Seva Aided High
. School , ‘Alike PO Alike, Bantwai Taiuk
” _ “DE-.,,Dis’trict 574 235
4’VSSri,Yeisi1odhara M
“S/”Q M Thimmappa Poojary.
Aged 51 Years, Assistant Teacher,
” _Sri Sathya Sai Loka Seva Aided High
= School, Aiike PO Alike, Bantwal Taiuk
D.K District 574 235
Sri Rukmayya Gowda
S / O Subraya Gowda,
Aged 52 Years, Head Master,
Sri Sathya Sai Loka Seva Aided High
School, Alike PO Alike. Bantwal Taiuk
I).K District 574 235
55.
36,
10
19.0. Vittaia BantWa1Ta1uk
D.K. District 574 243.
52. Sri K Rarnachandra Bhat
S/O K Narayaria Bhat.
Aged 52 Years, Lecturer.
Samyuktha Vitala Aided PU College in
13.0. Vittala Bantwal Taluk
D.K. District 574 243. I
53. Sri Raghuveera V
S / O M Gopaia Krishna’
Aged ~48 Years, Lecturer,’
Samyuktha Vitals; Aide:i”‘PU’ -Co’1Iege 55 ‘
13.0. Vittala Baum;-.I_ T;2_1I1;:;_};.. * 5
D.K. District 574 2423. ”
54. Sri P S1,1b.=’ay’~ana[ , __
S/O 1?_VNVar.:iy*ana”Bhat,
Agedi’57 J ” 1; _
Second..D–iia§$io1:a1 Clerk, _
Samyukf.hé”Vita}1a Aided rm College
P. 0. Vittaia Bantvml _VTa_li;1iistrict’i.5.7;.1.”144.
Srnt Rosyiiobo
‘ ‘ ” 1 ‘ ” Aged 57 ‘{e231rs
A }:loe2id’ Mistress,
iSai.Iit..Fransis Aided Higher
_ “P’rir1’ia1’y School, Moodu Perara,
Moodu Perara,i\/iangalore Taluk
b “D.K.DiStl”iCt 574 216.
Sri Jerald Rodrigues
Aged 51 Years
Assistant Teacher.
Saint Fransis Aided Higher Primary
School, Moodu Perara.
6.
13
The Commissioner of Public Instructions
Nrupathunga Road
Bangalore
T he Director [Secondary Education)
Office of the Commissioner of
Public Instructions,
Nrupathunga Road
Bangalore
The Deputy Director o
Instructions (Admn.]
Dakshina Kannada
Mangalore
fP_1.1.blic” ._ l ”
Sullia, P.OA._Sullia_… _
D.K . i V’
The Block Education’
The s1o’¢’1;4.£;a-dggitiqnj orfiL:ei=.[ t
Bantwal “‘{.’a.-“ink, P.O.”o’.odu’mai§ga
The Block »Cli’ficer
Mangalolre Taluk. Mangalore
Eldtication Officer
. ‘ 2 , _Putt’L1.rTIfal.1,ik,
V’ _ ..[?uTfti;1_i”_:..
Shree Glopalakrishna Aided High School
Bilincie, 13.0. Nettana
V A’ ‘P_uttur Taluk, D.K. District
C mi
it * .Rep. By Its Secretary
Aided Saint Francis Higher
Primaxy School
13.0. Moociupeiara.
Mangalorc Taluk,
D.K. District. 574 166
Rep. By Its Secretaiy
II.
15.
14
Aided Mogaru Higher Primary School
P.O.Mogaru Garijimut
Mangalore Taluk
D.K. District 5’24 414
Rep. by its Secretary
Shree Satya Sai Loka Seva
Aided Higher Primary Schooi””‘
Variivihara, P.O. Alike 7
Bantwal Taiuk,
D.K. District 574 235
Rep.,by its Secretary ”
Shree Satya Saihoka seva
Aided Higher Sch–o_o’1,’A1_ike’v A
P.O.Alike, Bantwal Ta’.iv.i<"'
D.K. District, 574-235= '
Rep. by _itsSecrei.':_ary
Aidedi'Highef"
Pariyalaitfierdiia, _,
P.V<)'.t"Pii–z1};».chaii'§V _
Béi_ntv_r;a_1_ _ " ..
DIKJ. D4istric't"5'jf?4
Rep. by its S'e_cretaiy_.»iw
y'VSe:h-0Vo'1: V
V, Adaiitha Mandaly.
, '-._Vid.ywa Bodhinyfiigh School
. _P.Q.=Ba1i1a.,_ Sullia Taluk
D.K';»..Distrivct, 574 212
r ' Rep.' by its Secretary
twig Belika High Schooi
P.(.},_Vitta1a, Bantwal Taluk
" °~D.K.District 5'24 243
it " Rep. by its Secretary
Janatha Higher Primary School
Adyariadka,
P.O. Adyanadka
Bantvval Talu k,
UK. District
Rep. by its Secretary
15
18. Madakatite Aided Higher Primary
School P.O.Barebettu
Bantwal Taluk
D.K. District 574 323
Rep. by its Secretary
19. Vittal Education Society
P.O. Vittala, Bantwal Taluk
D.K. District, 574 243
Rep. by its Secretary
20. Vidya Bodhiny Higher Primaryl’-._ 2
School, Balila, A
P.O. Balila, Sullia Taluk
D.K. District 5742.12 ._
Rep. by its Secretary _ ; l V
21. Nehru Memorial l?1″e+U¥1iV’e.rsity ‘V V’ ” ll
College, VP.’O.,yAra1=1thodii1 ‘
Sullia ‘Ta-luk’;’_I;).K.: DistriC_t 1;’ V
Rep. by itVS’iSee1*eta’I’§i .’ :
22. Kéillery Aided “Primary
School. P.oV.ix={a1_a'<..__
Bantwali Taluk; iD»;K}j;-5 74 2.1 1
Rep. byes Se.e:re'ta1'y
V' .23.
‘mated 2006)
. _VP.Q.’«K11ykk1_,1jadka, Sullia Taluk
13.I§;~.V_DisVtriC:.t 574 212
‘-Rep.’ liyf its Secretary
[R9 deleted vide order
… Respondents
[Eiy ‘Slim 13. Veerappa, AGA for R.1–8)
This Writ Appeal is filed 1.1/3 4 of the Karnataka
High Court Act. praying to set aside the order passed in
the Writ Petition No.2€:3056/2005 dated 7/2/2006.
This Writ. Appeal coming on for further eoriside,i”z1tion
this day. Chief Justice delivered the 1″ollowi_ng ;
(W
‘W \
‘tree/’tr
16
JUDGl\/EENT
J.S.KHEI-IAR, C.J. (Ora!) :
The appellants claim an increment.__”for~,h’aVi’ng V’
qualified the prescribed examination A_ in
language. on account of the fac.’t;.’_th’at
been extended to Governrn’erit.’*emplogzeestb not a
matter of dispute, not
considered for the that they were
engaged in grant–ir1–
aid from Having waited for a
_app’el1ants approached this
Court ‘the. pointedly for seeking the
aforesaid in”crernevnt.”- On the aforesaid occasion, the
“~-g.(ri”i,. {‘p&it»itibn_s filedfby the appellants came to be
an order dated 22.03.2005. The
ope’rati\fe.’pvcrtio11 of the order dated 22.03.2005 is being
‘ ‘ ” — ._ Vextracted’. hereunder;
Writ Petitions are allowed.
The impugned endorsement issued vide
Annexure~H dated 30.07.2003 in all these
petitions, rejecting the request made by the
petitioners are set aside. The respondents are
directed to consider the claim of the petitioners for
grant of additional increment with all
conseque_ntial benefits under the provisions of the
Karnataka Civil Service [Service and Kannada
21
8. The instant writ appeai is accordingly disposed
of. in terms of the order passed by this
25.03.2010, while disposing of WA
whereby, the order rendered
J udge of this Court in WP No.25:248:’/ sffVL:f’méi,’:_.:A
-A Chief }i;i;S’i:iC’e
‘ Eudgé
mv*
Ir1(Iex: Y/N