High Court Karnataka High Court

Smt S Prema W/O S Sudhakara Rao vs The Bangalore Development … on 18 September, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Smt S Prema W/O S Sudhakara Rao vs The Bangalore Development … on 18 September, 2008
Author: L.Narayana Swamy


u§m

§E’?§E §E§§ fifififif G? §%§§&§&K$.§? Efifififififififi

ggrfifi @315 fiag 23:3 §&§ a? 2g§§gm§§§} 2§¢$1′

BEEQRE

3&3 §Q§’S§E ma §§$%x$£”;*§§2§¥$§£V§@§fi% E

§E§§§%§ yzggw ggygiV§§,:§§§”§?»2§§t . ‘

§§%E§§

1 $§% $ §? =’>, « ‘g
fiffi g s§§§gx3g_§§$[;

éifi &§§$% 33 yggasg? _
gig? ga. z,,é§aj¢§$s$, ‘_A ,
2§f§4fi§E§,Efi:L%Y§3f} au ‘*
é§Ki§§a$$5_* ‘_ A.” ‘””

B%§§£E§§Ee?Q,¢_*

,~”g§§3g:$£;§E$:a§§@”g2~”

§§®3%:§§3?, gag §§;2::?,

a 5§HVM§E;A;:”g;émX;

‘~§:R,§;g;.;¥e§$;”

£&$£§’§&§§$.Ii
8&&fi$R§ a:%@as3, v,. QPPELLfiflE

,_:§y $ai;fifs m %a%F7 gvmgg g cm,

_%y;Agggm:§gRAxg§A 2 E.fi§Aflfi xfimga, §?S}

1 ~§§§ §&fi§%L§RE EEVEE§?fiE§T §flf§@RI?Y
.’,3afi£Ey §§A§
‘ §&§§ALsgg

gy 2&5 CQ%fiEE§EGfi§$. ,” §E$§QEfiEfi$

“‘§3§ ggzxa A3332 gfigfifig, g§¥.;

“K

‘”3
336,’.

Egg gzaag fiffi é: E2 2 RF 3 §§ $§£_%§$EEST
§§E $¥§§fiE%§ gag sagagg §§?E$: 28.?,2§%?\§&s$§3
XE §s.ga. 2?élfES%Q 3% $33 $222 ;$§;.§3§,WXv:
fi§§E,C§TE $Z¥E§ é SESSEQES Sfifififi, Eé§G$EQ% SEE?

g$cgsx$&:2;; EESEESSEEQ TEE S3:fH”?GR ?E%Afi§§§

Efi£§§€§I%§

§EES REA $§M:§§« §§7,E§§~zfiggg:§é’ §§:§’f§A§,

€323 €933? §fi§:§EEE§ rag F$§LQ§I§§: f “»z
§g§@§E§%”~ 1
fhe a§pai;a§t i$ ®t§@_ §£éi;ti§f 13 §$
§c.2?§:;2@§e an ésg-figg §§ age 2: gfi§;., City
Civii % segsggns5§§&§§; g$a§#:c%%x§i:y.
2:,i§§#j%th§ gékeg fig u§$§vemiefic%, gartiés
wau@§”§a %§€§§%é§ %@=%§figéf thaiz ranging béfcre
théVa§§£§ §&i%W¢*l
A”3§’_ ?&§’@ §%§%#g$f: fiiad tag sgifi. §¢:

§$xmafi§fit, ifijuxdziafi Xestraisiag the flefafifiaat

‘§f$mWi§t§rf&£ié§ witfi her §Qa$efui gaggasgian anfi

” §fi§$§mgfitx$£ the gaaeduie grsgexty, Tke a&$e cf

% :a@ _§:é;$::f§ ig that :3 tag yaar l§$3 aha

p§r¢§g$&d Kfiafifiafimari §a»i@?, :95, :3; and :32 mi

“~i’§§9ga.2:i:, Kaahazkafiahaili, xasaba Ebbiif

Eangaiara fierth faiax apprmximately masuring

E812 aqéft, ané fiince than aha is tha $%fié$ in

&3&

§¢sse$3ian anfi énjaymnt $f the said ;ag§, She

filed an a§§iicatiafi fiefara tfi&~ é§£§én:§g

GQ&mitt9E* an 20~2~:§§$ in texfiwgMg§u afi;’§zdé:5_§f_

thig aafirt in w? §a,1?é3§’pt§_:;?§5s;;9g8°At§a?V

xegalar:5& thé fiite Via fie; “§m; §fi~ 2§?é#éé$§,
tke éefefidani » gag ;§§t:até§ &gfi§;£é§5fi sf éha
sfimpaunfi val; gag $t§xt$§r£emvfifig”fihé flange gut
aiofig tfie baunéa%§A §§ ;§§§ x%xfi§. Kenae the
yiaifitiff gggeé g§é~é§£:,}_!u xv’

éf_i:§%§:g §%f%R%%fi%£Qh!$§i%fi’ th$1z- written
$t3%%%%fii$;=i2E%:i ,5 zezraa éésfigggaég he
pxefi-3_:”2:és§;. ‘1;:E”:;:.;i,$_ ;”;§9§;§;,§;?;..” iéwa mass? –
3 ,,- Eé, .f”‘é3;;Ef’7′;”;E’*’i;§:’? – gizfiirfgittgé fiéisaiz Efiigrifig iiée

;¢3::@g;:;,a3;<% »:;§§-.%:;'?;::::~;; 32% mag, »;g:;,;.::-,g::-gag

322$: _$%:z"z;2<;:-'?if;é§'&¥' §:£¥39@m§i3'z;-g %::::v the giaintgff am %;:§§.&

' A '"g;:§I?:%%§;€E§:'«a::s_ HW§.z'§pert%g $2": 13»-m3..§»=~.223§'}'J,

fiigfi 3. pfilififi assfigiaigzén &§;§.iE1'?;$'§';

':?zi§V.3a;:1:;;::2'Ta::f:':.::':%?:. '}:'3§:2L.3 gfigs ta; §;;":<::*r§ %;:E?:s.~s:t the

§ia;.3;::'f:3;f:" 3.3 :23; péagagsiagiz mi' tha §;?@§%z"%;:y 31.3%

V gfiasiisgfi

.§' :2: sz*s:;"é&::" ta afizgbéziazztiatg 33:5 yaaggégfiimfz

avg: iim gzapgzsizy in qzéagtgsmszg izefeaize fiza cmzri

-5}-

beiaw he has grednmeé Ex*§1 — Sezziigaé cap?

éf the fiaie fifiéfi aatea.§§«8m1%§3, EX;§€§ f fiémafié

régigter extract, EX,§E M Tax §§;fi ré§é1§:$;_

%x.§é ££kne1%@dgement,[J Ex;§%§ y.%nfiV Ex}§m$t

?h¢t$gra§h§, §x.?»? &VEx”§w§ §ia¢§§;§*E1i§§r§$:§&
28-=’§-v2C%§§ am 23%§”:*,\.;g{72~s;§arj;2§ Vr;es§e§:;§L;¥:§§é:y’V:.
aaatantiefi. af ggg §;a:%§if£Q_3§« §fa§:§gha aafirz
gsiaw $33 fiat #§fl$§§§%$§ §%&_v$a3§ regazéifig
p@$$e$$1§§5*R “” . ‘ V’

1$,{ §é:§ $%fi%£% _s§§ ué§% piaiatgff, &éE
n$z§hh%$¢:%§§u®;a§$ffigégaéV%a$ examiaea as §%~2.
Eni/ §T%fi§gf;é$a$g%ggi$n, fifi Egg §@§$sed that tfifl

yiaifitiff Lg fig ggggégaififi af aha pramiges whiafi

$%¢ §a§”§§rQ§a$$&;aa£ fig :5 aisa regiéing in the

%éj§:fi:§g pzéfiiéefi gznca :§82¢ §§»3 flag dflfififiéd

‘”T§§§i &é”%fi§w$ the piaggtgffi afid he: éfishafié far

. ‘%fi& laéivé ar 3 yéarg anfi aias atgtafl that ha 13

a;5éx$t&§;fig in tha same i@§a;ity&
1:. fiaaxned &&un3§i far the giaiatifif alga

éfiaws my atagatian ta the 9¥i§Qfi§é cf Efiwl. fifikl

in E33 fizasgwexaminatiafi Egg gtatfifi that he flag

“?

,,.},..

mat vigitafi fihg su&t Séfiéfifilé pragartyiéfifi tfiat

fia sanfist fiay wig: tyge af stxugturé-§x$$£g§,in

thg fififiééfiié pz§§ézt§* §fi>2 ais§ s:aie& j§ §i$_

ér@53w@xamina:ian ifiat 3% éa§,?na£._§ay_ wh$§he: ”

fifiéfé axigtefi a Emzléing $3 $5: $3 aha éghééage
§rap&rfi§. an t§§%i%£5i£ $f® §§f$§RW§§n§;fi§$
raférred ta aha??? t§§ §§a%n§d é§fin$aé $u§m1fitefi
that. thgrg :3 $@fifl$$fi§i$fi§§§§L:ifiV the fiufimigaifin
game $3: firs} but the Sam
has n$$_§§e% %§§%§%;%te§:$§’§§é’ccuzt baiaw.
1%W fi5§§é@ $§%fi£%%é&}éfiat tha appailant has
nsfi cfifiéléfigéé’tfiéigfiqfiisitian pracaafiings ag aha
was fi§ia’$%§§§§ §%§%r 3f the sshedfiie gxfigerty,

§&Wevar $§é~7ha§-jfiurchafiafi. the gaié’ §r¢§arty* in

a¢§%;v§e3x’ :§$3m”3nd. she is $L paaaasgisn af tha

“l$afi§ §;fiqé than’ Thafigh ska cauié he temfi as a

£re$pa%$@%, the 33% fiaa nafi takan aay atapg tigi

2§3?} i”&., fax mra than twa éfifiééfi. Efififié it

x :§ samit:&§ that sfie shauia have beefi §iV&fi aa

afipfirtnaity fia ragrefiant ha? aafié hfiffifé

§em$ii3h:n§’ fihe ;§x@§%rfiy, Ehe giaintiff whilé

“f

>6′ 3; .,
ziefénaing zzgx yiaygical pasaesaiazz mam: t1′;& iasgci,
£’za$ €.’f§§3.§.l§§3.§?’%fi the amtieza 52:” the :*es§m::¢ ;az:t=-§§A
and it 1g szmmtted that timugh a§c@r&.:i.;2*3;§’-«._’%T:;~a,:°s thé

gazétta natifiaatiarz fiatad 3 — %3V;i§ié’2.:’T’§V°_§;’v’ 3;. __ 91

pfsfisésgiaxa hag beam takgn @a;”er_-‘bj4;..:’£$$z:a§:a<§ '€Z'%f '-

Sac.' 3,5 {2} Eififiiififiatififi, fi €~3_f.E.i%T§3§3d:v $145137 » .§;i$-3é;':§~V$..f$'.G:'-?E:. T Ems'–.

Emit ccérwiéfiafi in; tégzzyg 'the T;?%3:;;1:'§$2.f§x:¥£:%:3:t c';:.f
Se<::.36{3§- sf tag §§&., §g:;%3':;..V&€=?i3.§,$E: a;é ,*.2:°2<:ie2:*:

v3a§3; gffiag ;:§e"~ sagas végté in tha
{§*@¥%§'£'§fiEI2f5: mafia: " Sec pg " £33,215; fiaqaigitian
£62; 189% ,.'. 221% _ ~'i;a:*;"é'i:':3;;§!'§;é;»%fi.::.az* $31333, upaia

gsagrzmzat §._<;:.$t "~:.§::é?"az:§;i2i'3;£"t3,@rzf ma upm:

ézizésg $§2§;§"i:Cé7;E*:7f~?;'§;'~,a.§'§és."3j..,§?,§".' ta: pay $313: farther Qasts
whiéfi * "-~._3'.T§'::~:';.:"z~;iz:"ras3;, an acxzsursiz af the

§.€.7;q":'3..§;S§.Ti»'f{L'.?i.<:*23":, -_':z::;a;3+:s;5£§%:* the iané tr: the autkmrity,

the ~._§£,as.::§.' sézaii 'E§°T:%?f.:"&'i2§$E',¥, vast sin the

….. ..

X is samsmttaafl; tfixaé: in View mi?” ‘aim

*ne::£:§gt;Qa mnégr $§&.i6§2} iafifi vfifitfi witfi the

j 5§%.;:$.€*m?:m:1t and mat with the auifitimxxzty. ‘iiézae fiaezputgr

V <__$:'A:§f.}m.%'s$1®nez% after veatimg af the Land with the

afivarrgmzzii". E2513 :3 Eraasfar 'ma iazxég ta tire

K

.,§§…

§fi€§$fit? aaé thea agiy fifié ianfi ve$t$7$ith the

&§€hfiEit§6 fiacaréing ta tha ;ea§neésaa§a§&ig”$he
\\ rf ” ‘ ”

§r6$9fifif€ af trangfar hag fififi heegflfiéiiéfiéé.

1%. fig aifia éxawa § ét£$§:g®m.§ég%filé i%w§ 1

Qf tfia éaxfi &mq:$g§1@§xg$§;é5 »%§§£@3m “i§ r;$
prav§§$fi= that an t§é§%§§rrifig; t§%f §%flfi”s%a ifia
aut§@:ity, th@, §eput§3. Cgm:§s;9§$% fifififiéé
zfitzate tfié §a§;s€a§@§§ fQ§f:¢e: abafit tha
tzaafiféz §§*§§e a&§a$;éé;;g$%.%§§ i% is aanténded
that igfl%§éi%§£€§§%{§as§; §%w§fia§ cmmiiagaa has
bea§H§§a§ afi%§%§§i§ $f §§$:§§fi.

J Efig fag §i3;§fi§§ffha3 &;5$ yrafiaaefi gap? fig
tag §gi;$eV§§§i%i§%”§ad tfig pfimtagragha ta 5§§w

tkxt. :hé. E§$f §é§$1$he§: aha atruature af which

‘afia mag in §§$éa$s:Qfi an :3wZ§w2Q§? i,&.g afitax

” fiii&§ fig figig agpaai,

.§§; iearmeé caungei for the plaintiff ralieg

am.::g 23$ KAR §l3$ whezeia it is held in para ?;

» Vé$’§flfifi$Z

?3§1} tfi& awnar gevea if it :3 fihe Stfite ax

a gtatutary bay} flag ma rggfit tg farcibiy

#33″

éispassess an azzautimrised zsacuyant fincluaing :5:
izeapaggesr} rm aattiefi §$sse$§3;c:*z, ethemséfie than
:3 aaazazfiazacza with law. ‘

2?}. (2313,; ‘v%’£m:°§ hztmaver téze t3:’€§§°3aE~.”§{. $f€%%” .::;%S; ._.i:1

saettiad §$,%s$3si0z: and sash aattiséfi §=¢sis7%rr;:3_$’;~;.,£3:1;_

advezge ta the true Q’v§z§.%X” ¢;;;é;z;t:z21a’éé锑f§G;-%f “1.2”.ya=a.3fs.,

the rfimgizt Qf téfze true msgjzzeg: _ i$ “:;=>;2£*§;z?;:*;g*:3–3;.53§’i§e’§_j§mc§~.__

the txespaggax as §e&§é$s2%:§x”§ ¢§%:m&’zf «. éjégfiéigfieg
&$i’§§,i.’&1’i.% titia ta tEm”T§}_:’:’1’*-.§pa:r:”*ty 1:: q§€§e$$t’,1;c=:;V.-V1 L

:3”: §a,ra ‘}’55__ am Ca3.3:£’a._::*§;’if@z’2;”i§1<§ ta
the mafia af gALfi§g% &§g$$$fi*$§§§3g va M3 §E%$%AEE

{gxg :9?§..gc :?§§;' gas fi$ifi tfiat symbazzc

§e;=*;fia§§§'f.;:3,t: ;3;:::é°t,.:': ,§;;a§f?.::a~r §:«<:;3sa"2$?s%;"§L§::*z wmzia not Em

3'*1.1f.'?;5'.".9..£'!.:.'é;€§;t'.V'!v,'w':"£'.%€;- pagsasagxan af tiza aeqiiirad
' Laixaugési 'is; the asqzgiring' bag? in

g¢¢a:afice_§:€n $&c,3€{3) af tha gag gag.

«"":;;aarnefl manage}. far tha giazzztiff aiaa

'= zez$efi@mg é$$§ g1; sag ?fi9§ aa cantend that if

*i:;:1e" t3Eéé$pa;§aa:* is in agtizai pasgessimzz 9f the

V' * .<:;:rs{§'¥e:°t"§g, he img as ha eviateé anly by feliawing'

K_ "fz:%ée @z°@§.&§::re §res¢m'.h?+&d, in law"

-§§..

33* 3e hag farther reiied am a jgéfimaat af

tgig smart gepartafi in £LR;w»§§§§f¢WE%

325:? whéxain it is heid that xmagagéfi-es r:;1%i;e:a*:>5g– ¢3é.:;_._

regfirt ta gemaiitianf [it “has: fim_”xe¢éS$af1l§2”

fmilww the §rQcefiareVpreé¢:$béd u§§§$~Sé¢;%§£x§f
tha Ka:fi&taKa Muniai§a%R§¢§?§raéi@fi$u§%£§J:Snléés
aaé unfixi the $a%fi.§fiQ$%&$%égiS’%$§3f$%§ to it 13
fiat pexmi$s1bié f0fi i§n%fmE$&_ to aaage the
éamaiiiiegvgg a§iaw§§§ g§g§%:fi%%%$n$ fifi its awn,
and §§h%§fi%§t~£$§%4:ig :$%e% m§f tha a§0va, thg

appeal §a$1@Q b§”a§zaw§§u f

; i§,’¢§ibg§3$£ §f fihfi éfiffifidfififmfififi, iaarnaé

s§u§$é;!$mb§:t§gfig§h&t the appeal £3 liafiig ta fié

.S§jecteé far $39 raaaafi that tag plaintiff as net

A’v,thg awnér sf the iaxfi in qmafitima. She purchasefi

‘5:hé”é;fi&Qméa5uriag ?9′ x 83’ 13 the year l§83,

af%er’ifi wag aaqairefi by tha §fi$ anfi thezafara it

AA_wa$V§$t ogen far her ta chaiiemge tha acquisztian

“»p£ac§@d;nqas 5ec@m$1y§ fiha canaapt cf afivexse

§$5$§£SiGfi has not fiegm tfiiefi as a camtentiéfi ané

4.)”.-

gr’?

$6 fifiat extent $5 @¥:fienaa :3 alga iéfi $fi7b&kaif

GE the plaigtlff,

2%, ffia iearnefi. saunas; fmr£hgrf $$fl%:§§é&

that tge Gafifiéfitififi af t§éW§i&i§:i§f %ifii”fiegaxfi.

fi& §@m~§§mi1$nae fif $ect§§§§} §n %;§”par§:¢§ §$§
:3 fififififiiaififibie ;§»l%§eb é§$a’a§ }i$é””f$§ fhé
rfifififififi tfiat $$c,3é§3}»§%§% :§z$ éfffifii by fiirimé
sf tag fiafigmfitubg-tfi;£ fi%§§§5i§Vtfie yeay 2$$§§

the gaifi p@31::§m”w$$ fiai_§3e§é:;:n§ an tag éaie

af*ié$§afi§e fif $@¢”1é{2§ n@tif:c§t:mfi, fiance ffifi
saifi £@n%enté&§’i$H§§fi a¥&:§&b;9 :3 the piai§i2§§
aaé itx £3 gfiébaifiiafi that §&i;g’ zagigmg afi

ggjufifitiafihagggfigi tfie 33%, tax pr$£e&di§§s mafia:

“w§&$,2§{2§a_a£ tfia Lamfi, g$q§i$:ti$mT éct $33 fiat

Z: ig fgztfiar $mbmt:$@ fifiat ihg

;’~4_ V’:

«S; “3.

;amt:§igat;$§3 $33 ha ahaliangefi ani§* by fziing

=w:;t §%ti§i$fi$ afi&.nwt E? wgy gf Ezizfig a gait,

23, it :3 aiga aufiitfiafi. tfiai it 3% age
fi$fit$Ei§@fi Qf ifia piaifitiff thafi fig is gm

aantififiefig yagsegsian far maze ifian :2 yaazs, bat

flé 9¥;§@§a& is tfiat affefit has bean §§$§fi$§§ fig

him,

23, Ex gayyazfi sf h:§_ aasé;’»%hé’ ;§ax§éé.

aaansai fa: tha éefa§d&at;ze;;é§1a§<fih%u§m£§fifit'

a§[ the $fi§§a§% fiafirg ,§&§¢%téfiT in %§§w%§§§5 fififi
§23f wfieraié ii 13 Efiédgtfiattfihéfié fiha §azzi@s
hgga ta £&aii$§§% fine ggééfig $5 ihé éétf iika iha
33$ éQt§ tag j§z;$i$$§§% 5§ $§§L$iv:i Gauxt ta

takfi 5@§fii?%%¢e"_$f*Vt§aA fiafief xiii fiave :3 3%

as£éz€%:§@fi.,§a§§§é",f:;;a§' the Sfiii. Tha fii?iL
c@gzi_ '§ya=, $§¥§i§ '"§§ fifixifiéifitififi. ié give

£&@iazafii$%'*¢fi "fifie imVai£fi§t§= éf tha grficafiuré

"3$mEem§$a:efi fifiéar tfie aangtitutiagai égfism

._§é:Vg:Q fihe ifigtafica mafia? tag giaimtiffm

fgfiyeiigétf hag Exam Zhfi mafiteatien that tfie

graégfiura canamiatgfi finder §&¢'3§{2§ $5 tha

;fimé ;§@q:§iii@n =A§:. hag amt. fifiéfi ffiififiwflfi, Kg

via Sf thfi fififigment af ifia Sayxame fiaurtf tfia
§i&1§t:E§ afiamlfi have 3§%¥$&Cfi%fi tkig maaxt Efifi

gai tag fiivii $$ur€,

"E4,

3%, flange E Wm 35 the véaw i§&€_%§é=§x§ax

paggéfi %§ tfie await b@i@§m§§$$ fiéif$a§§iEe3gay2

intérfaxéfifia.

2%. The iéar§ec ‘¢§unéei f§r J€fi§w,gméafifi&§fi
zeiiaé. $3 zgggggg s$% g§x\ %fié #fifi%itt&d. t&at
gait ltfifiif wag é§®’m;n§%ia&§éa:

2?. ggaazv-:ef:.;:_ an by am
l@&fifi§£ fié§§%§§ $3 fig? §§§3»E§ iééfi wfieraifi tha

fiugxgg §$§§fi fi$iéffifiat ggfififiqaaat purchafiax fiaa

fi§K _xi§fifi,a Vi$x_”gc£ai;efi§& fifie agquisitiaa
yxeaégagmggg

L2$§vEn”vi%w the amntentianfi taxefi by aim &§fi

“%§g?t$é:i$i$n$’ referxefi. ta aficve, 33$ ieargefi

‘ ,éQafi3eixf§£ tfia fififenfiant prayfi far dismissal $5

_i§i$_&§§&éi°

V 2§, E gave haazfi the iearnfié afiumfiai far tha

Vvyarfiieg afi&Tpa§m$$é tfie matgrzai $m racarfi.

3%. Exam tée fifiiériai am zeaaxfi it :3 gaen
tag: $$a§§’2i§: %ma§§:&$ 3 §fi§$S :2 guniag, Exvfié

§§§%$ t%at 3G £33 ag Sygga EEK: Ag fiflfififirfiéfif thg

mg

Mr’:

9

a$q§ig:tg$§ :3 G33? fig she axteafi GE 2 éfiza 2%

gumtag, fiat it 13 mat giear firmfi §E,§¢§;3§§i$§

§@ri:§n fif syv§®.23;: has b&§am.&$§$;r§é, *?§§

é§mam&at&r§’ fifiififififié gzséfiaéa’ E? fihé*_§:éfia%if§

have 3m: $a$&.’§§@§%$;y $§§£&$§atéé,”= *?$’*§kw§$
ifiai tha §i%i§tif§ wag_i§ p§y$i$a;_§§gsé§$:$a afi

the fififiéfifiifi §§$§ari§gamfi*tfi% §§$’§fi$liSfi§@ ihe

$fi:u$ture wfizafi @a5 f? }tfia 2§$@3e$$i$§ af tha

giazmtzff Qfi_i3w£§Q;§§?.§if@;5 $fibS&§fi§fi? ta tfié

fififigzfilmfiéfi@fi,%%é@afimfiEEm$pmfim%é
§§$é§§§a§§$’%§£ gage: autixags fiéffiffi ifiis aamrt.

3:, =%he_ txifii amgri fiafi fié ¢fiaa$i&& fig

&®fi$i§ar ififififimfifififimfifiié gg ihfi¥ waza $E$%§§Q§§

V~t$.i§&*§§§m:$5ai $5 fihé gait» En Qxfiar fig afiafile

z”%§$’c§az§”beiw ta gaagifiaz ifiase £msumfint& fiflfi

§§3$A’g§§§m§r:at& axééz witg xagaxfi fig thg

,§@$$é§§:@m Qf zfia §;aimtifE, Z paag tag fsiiawifig

V”QEfl%¥i

§h;$ agyaa; :3 &ii&w$fig $§& matfiar is
ramgmagfi ta tfié caart bfiggw ta §&”&fifi$i§&K tha

evifienaé aéfiacaé. by tha paxtiag and aisa fig

»~§{7:–~

aazmicigez.’ “£315 a;%::§::i&:i.,’i;:..§ gfirapsged ta §§3’~. :fL,%«;.3w§Efi £23;

25% fiiaizztiff. 23:39 piaintiff 35.3

aaafiézae a::f5;1i.%;2;.a3::a.i évifience %s;:i.;.%;**.:::f=._ §.§;§»g§a:’%, ” –..$§~.__

dwmiitizyza . Exaarzaéfi <:@=;;z3.§e_;. ' ':,€§;',':;7 "I Atézé' -..;;.:;_'a§9;;;§i.T.3A.'ar3."fi:' Q

prays *%:;°§2£t iifiagty 3§e:r~,"..;;,éfg=.mz:2 ifié. 2ii£:2 §f;¢ fi:3;,$
azmisxfiwzzt afifiiiaatifizz§'-. "=.§ie %é~.«""~"'% €§;,,5f 3?..,€? Em as

perizzittefi, in };.ax§*';

  ;     xuage