High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri K I Haneef vs State Of Karnataka on 8 December, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Sri K I Haneef vs State Of Karnataka on 8 December, 2008
Author: K.Ramanna


&$JMU _____ \
0 J ‘:2wxrpwn

‘$’&’K’D am: ;e 31?; awn um 95;8£s’¢x’a*3’;

my ggggggfg pagap aauaguaa aqq paw ue;;a:ngQ;y_;
gs xuamfipnp aw; fiutmxtguoa *:xaq3gwg*§5*x
‘nfiupo3 ‘afipnp suayssag a -nsgq eqq ;Q»fiqi;§» “‘
331 V0 QQfQE’9N’¥’TJD “F P9599a QOQEIEIXFX
paavp amuaguaa pus uargainuoa ;qH;uamfipnpjaq3 .
39:39 493 an fiugfiexd ‘3*a’I3 fig? pm9g;5gjba3 ~’ .
zapuu pazyg uoxgggea uarggaegé f§u§m¢:3 ” ‘[1 “T

«r~«§r~§~–r«+ _ . ‘

(-g-3-3-3 *u&&ufiyxwq;m§wnu9H’%fi yrs $3)
u_ r %yk «~r:ax:pvu
“‘9I53?QfI313H”3?I9XTP9K
‘amzyofi gm Iwgmafisuggataxyg ‘3

9&N3fifiG&SE§

i ,-~, ___#fi’é1oyefiua§
r%; 4_1g’5¥¥?I1fl3 zines @513
“‘.»$m;nwa§ox$-8TIqfla any 53

. ——– “” » .;fl@¥’KJP§X§3?fl%?fi go eqmzg -1
‘ iflflv
*,:u3g’s3aa$ apfiag :13 Kg}

….. ‘I1.E3§§”Q}I
“.V” *’ a’ ‘xnre; gadfiwmfn
*:q3emTqq@qL egg *IaA;Iq

iaxwax gg qnaqa pafiy

Eafiflfifl ‘I’X F35

ififlfifiiifl

*4 X §fifi3£IEE’Qfl mmxmlmaa mmrszaaa TERIKIK3

*, 7″gvnm&HvH ‘E aazssag ‘um 3§a.NoH mum

Sfififififi
3335 xgqmaflafl £3 Afifi EB 3H$ SIH$ G3$Vfl

Efiflffiflfififl ‘VH¥$VNE€H £0 $3333 HBIE 3HE NI

ML/fgfif
mm gm stmwxp mgr; fiK$’§.’aq xeuomyzafi 292.7: 91;

aqaaptxaaaax 92;; gm amen xaqgxng egg, *pveummg

arm cm Emrfiuwgaq pm: zyammea go &}’:§’§Q aq::__

féq !§f$E*'{“f”§12.. .2″‘C1″£§1}.1{‘Qfi mar: *’*g:wx1;pwyg-pveu.:rnK

pug: ugzwm am; we fggxmgm-mg .5fI”§IEQr(Z{ j”

fiuytteavxz mm:-a suasxaeri pe:m{.’u1;J…;rag*:;5:;<:v'-"éfi"–r§i:a1¥-1 _?

afi :*m a -m*fi c§'a nnwqw aw §s5Ix:t}a*u¢ i7*i'"

:23: uamnsasozaimzuapuadaaz '~;_"§ QEEQA

'§6flZfE$ffiI pe:ep~f§¢éé/sz'5&9H'IIa at

afinmzp s1:;::v.;f%Vgaafs;vc.*~é;':?%§a;r§§i';3*a–euw;- ,V§§g:,,A' gaesmzi aazuaauaa
pm; :z<::*;:;'z.:3 ';t_z;Lt$g xapm payg; E”; u<:v'ga1;..:aax Q"§.'t{,L

'dEIEI'ti0

: 511'§.N&O"f'[€3;

ma aprem zwncea arm ‘flap gym: fiufgmsem; no;

no fiuzmoa r:tac:r;:1’;3a-::I ucmmaa rwugmgxg S1311;

=nvq3.S%,:&:xq-‘

pizza anus: ‘M3912: 32:21:; paqanflmrp fifeznagxas :1<::§z~–.__

awn xeueznrnefi aqa *m'fi SQ': punaxm §56Ix;:£§ $ F

rm auapgnmw any; :1"; pa.n;'{mm:*g: men -s_;p»–.i’; ‘

asuapjcna aft}; ~pauwIr2:-ca tmaq wag: 1mg”:;eqnq~g’

…Q.£6. a an sfitzmjaq 3’5IZEiY’fI3’flZ’§I3′?L3¥’§*~v,vh:”:..’£:!Z:2{L’,, .:.x*§;. ‘ ;u;:§n_;’a’g}}..§;ii*;

a”[;7’§t:{aA mm :w:{:; &f£:§3j:3.’§ .i’£?’1;– ‘i”V$§C§;r0 “£23:

mzxtxapzzcadgax aqq__:m;,: :…a};}i§e’a{a A§;u:§fi.ux:’*éi;;a:;3 31:11:23
qfim pumzxuen: gs}; :2°u5a§§x<:j£i;'uI;L;;'a":gv£~2%::£Ieaz{;1, ‘*z;*a~’:;*g’c:I$car.{ am: 2.13: pmgp pun

ga’g::xz*i’§::’; 3r*:<;::}.j.a~"r :5 pauxzegana *&'3'E~.'A"§'{1II§ ;«:: aagvgm

_ T.._m§z'@x:z.zs*#é'a{5:"ajzimg **z*g:.~z aazwmy 92:: 30 man: pun

«: ~s'agj:zIi§".'i:i"gf.A g;;://””””

91/

am, Ertnjxrrp I&’iIG’§:;””[.’2Z’;$§ mm amnam go *aa’a:V:e_.-__

‘I”9II’§.’i3I’§J.’D* 33′ 1!’? fiC3I.1lB;£3″@ ZI,’EI33.9″§$1′.I01′.’flI”:£

£3301′; paziaqap zgmz mgr paanmae Enugrsaq …’=:az:x.en::v;1:’3::~:
umgqnaaaaxd 3’2 113:»; _’e£é ‘pee:

mums sq; ‘(IE3 setamen
am: xaqzm ‘E233’-‘;i11.'{¢D:£S.’£1f”§Z aaagi
mu ng:»m:z.:rc:»o§q ;-:3
pamzz ap’;3 *–.aq:°;: ujr guapxsafe
zmnm sazwajtfsaf; ‘e

zyeqzz pagnziagtp 3&2; $2319 gm; xeuoygggafi am;

: ‘i}.ti3:1E3.”3{IQ:)!.I’§f aw; ‘[E”§Ii’.§, fimrxrtp 1’$U€>”§1″i},’§,”:3,afl aqc;

22:1 uexm; azzmwgey mm -quaxzrgmcm 92;: go aavetfi

asae-Ifi umrm mm; :;u:ap’§.’:::::we 31(1) azaugz-3. ucvgzzma-uh :1′;

was 3:31; zmxm saqwaypuz gfirszeatzx zwfis ;uerp*;:3;n.fe_.._’_’

mm gm qaqazig qflzm: :_;1;..«g*:-:3 pm Iezvaqem

a’£—-a’xa :: 8-Iawzum mm fiS’¥M 93E’.€’I

931: gm paaqxfaggr 3′; gram: agjzz:»;Iaq%;a

:;’qfi’§::..=’ fiuyxwg &'[“§IE{M ziwgsnmgqnwaa 3’§f”

wssgap pram uogzgnmward ;tecIs::f.r~:?’:__ ‘v<"!%.3{'@I1, '»:r;;'ygéxifiifiivfix

saw; axsyqaa aqtx a.n.o:r;::», a*qm,2-;J;§:::i;.':._ mm«_,..,a3fé:q
;c;v uojrzwwgwgdfita mean 345 _T':,xi'n:5i:2i3'e:"L%.i:aVV%'fiazzxgdma

;::a }'.)'C:tfl:T.{'§{&$"§£'{ BT[3 arfilaffii" 'f;'£:$'iI7%éI'§§3.v_'2}'§I€a*,S'°3%;?I'{5$;I1 pme

tzsrazx Q "§.I*;;_."-Y.Ixi;aj'. '§€1éf;¥'§:?§5fi'F;"«i'x*¥iI;:tT€.3″V%i ..E?T,$”§.”I.;£’I;$§’vifjfvjj 33:12:, liq paxedazd qzzsgaagra

‘qf>:’;:*£ *’w:z:.”._ s’*g:;’§fffi+-=5-zsza ‘3A.”.I’EI.Q rsmgmamxzs sea-a ‘pee:

<.__ a*z.f{:; €;;?5s"*c;'z«1V*{:r.é7:;_3f.§:V$i'eaa :13: peat.-«:2 aim, rm fiumaaoaxd

_ =…_$vzéz~; ue'g:;:..s§am5n my m::s"g°:.:;ax.g am, wmgs 'pesn;:r::m

f_"=§s':a'V.f?§A;=%,tk:.;;ap am ;BS(3;I(3 vaqrx, :0; 5’; 1.1 ‘sars£au:;1:m pexnfiugz

aaaeauajmafia pargwrrs ma sq; em mmjcqaafifina

quaxaggtp and am; uogtzmtrgrmaxa-sscaxa

h V //v

£3? 0?} 831′? 33.021 am»; Z’;’LIG’§J’:I23C3’Q’ QQQ Z;,E’i’.{:), $§EC?'[C§$’§’Q_-=__

xx-a*xg zxmdax xanaafiaux afvgqaa :o:§wf fiW

sq; ‘a3%{fl xmmn guapzmaa sq; iqfnaax & e§’pu§ ‘c

zsxnq fieai em; gm enfig em: paw pa&é$ @$f§ §»fVH

H: fiuramm aaa £333 3&3 neg; L.§;a:ffi p§fiaéfi§u3[‘

awq amuagmp aw; ‘paz;sfihbu:€3ap.”aq:,:;Ifi#§:’

9 aw ‘axwxq pa$T&fi¢s pas§$fi§ fin; ;6tarfiea
fiuywaafin aqa on Ann §§§fi -$fi3 %#pfi¢V my pug
3fiI3’§’WI5 may :W:?§%?:i%§§%§::V::: ‘.i.A\\’/.”‘;”..¥a~{7i #2:: Izmir.
saaugxm aqg Qi:§a$§é§$fl§ §3:#_%§_fiI *4uap$a3u
av Q1?m Qfim”pfifiwé§fi$ é§;§§é§¢w%mx; finxmum uug
am: an £é@ é§$fiTfi§ @%§fi# #j p$0I an: 30 apxa
aw; an zgamifiaafi %qi ;#§fi g’fi’fi gm uaggaugmaxe
fsgg:3§§q§Lt:_u§fguaquam aqa uagea seq aauagap

aitgz’ “?W?”i’§’F::v”‘ mt: liq deer em :9 f>u’a:m.=m

“_ ;uafif{fiau @fifi1§é3x aqq pug amapymwe 33 xauuwm

M_§§;ufin§§xé§a: peqvxg eawq fiaafi aux gm manwmut

5 *§u3fx@ér§ fixn mum L pug g*sgfa ‘sn¢?3nua

»§wéA$cf3 Ewan aq pfnwqa aafmyqaa aq; Eugnxzp

VV”a_¢3a§¢xp $q: guagpfixfidn sum pwcx sq; an fiuyaow

Imam azayqan aqg axagm aamyfl aq; *3ua;paxfidn

.’1au nnq zuetpezfiug Mat paw enxna zwqmammg Q:

alfi}, I1′; @%3’$’:§.8 BQE Eflxkfi QEQM ‘2’;'{“LC’1 3″{‘fC1;$<53?.[ glfifllfll

$q1w3wqg~9'm*g asxnoa gfi -pazyséwa awn s1myqe4w_

awn xaazxv am: Ra ataruaa aux :0 fiuI§?iP Lf-

nuefiyzfiau paw qamx gm esnvaaq new; '5sau:fm9£§

an: axe mu& g Paw E 'a*miaW";nar&afié§?¢é 7qn§m x3é§fi 5is

aaauqgm naaq aqq ex gaaaa?%&K@flgé:n£u: my éqm
t’m*§; $S?D 3umq$u§’ egg ;rpV$fi33&gfif “{a3ue;ep

3ua3e;auQmu$ ;Q~t$5?#fi@#§@ a§$?4V’$0fi PIHQW9

1? ‘pm? sfiwr-7#%@i3@3? §é”§fi%i% 9: panaedxa
ax ma;qu§gg¢;fiVT§fi§D’@§§§ éa0n an quaujazad
$1 31 ~3a$§§y¢9?~%§;7:§0; fiuxqtnsax zaegep
gayyuyfifiafi my $éh»a:aq; pue zauumm auafixtfiau

9&3’.qg§;»_§%ffi§=_aIa;weA aux eaezm an awn:

7V_M$$3e3:pu: Kfigéys qatqm izapza my snag ayayqan

_ §q;.;w’fiqigfivfiugugmmax paw uaxuzq qqfigt pnaq

»§p§gi1;51 quoxg ‘augfiua sq; wax; fluyxaet sum

4″xt§¢ égyfiua fpafiumap gpxa ggaj anal; paw qauuaq

‘ *._§$fi§mwp powq db; may awmxg Amoq 69: *m$xo:q

*:fa2£’£’Q&II€§§’Q’ $211′; It};

aux uyzmgauea &qexaq3 paw zxnag z§;:§’.$q” ”

§aue@;Aa fiawxuemnamp pun I930 §qi”%mgjQ§§é§éd§’C;E

my fiagfmfieggr :0 9a9uadaz:c5u§’¥.*Xun *V

pay; now mg : ‘exa;exau& ‘fi§?W? V? xviniééfi’

my fiugzfngax yum aazznigg fiufafifin paz§ad§$ gem

e:a$qan4 $§:méfi§§§§@m ‘§$fiu%§”wp%;zd§p uezanna
paw axaa :afi@xfirfi&%xé§ §§§fi:§m pm? quaxpexfi

-WMQE 3? 9%W$K@$$ §q§’i%m¢a§ww my quefigtfieu
Ffifi, q¢%”:C9%fi iéao?aIaaa sq: awn: 5u¥@Ieu

m:1;: ., t;;’.,:V;C§€~f§.fi __-/¢:;A<f1{§"<;;""§'%i

go 93$; 19 Karel cm, pm ({¢*}'I:r;*;§;f.:;ag
zxarpmm etqmqmgund em: 3::

pogxafi m :1:-C2»; *:vfl,<3, 'c;_.'fixa:§i:5.:}'.':«§:V.:p§a§%;%$:t1;#%'xatmxng
5'; §e!SE1a":h3'é;:""~ *§:, gt: puyzed
1a sea; hffljmiqa sq 'aux; 33¢:

zgtxamzfiwfi gs: -m90*’1:*s’a J’? “FF;

….. .335-nag japan azqmgamztmsi

e§.4:t:.Aaai;§¢-V.TAarq4i;*~;’.1=§§;,c«–_ sxmfl em, gt: purged we 1:);

V”1’g i::.§;71f&a’g.’::1£i1’i j_*€>,;I§L pamuaguaa .”I$’f.{:3,;1’I’1;_I 9′; paanszm

vlggigg-mag, xeptxn axqarqmuud eouaggto

«: ~zj;4’x;’.. :r%;:§”«-..q:+u<au;e anzm gm» pmgztad 9 :m; *:'s 69.6

xfiqaxng <32: fang"; gm quamfiwfi 3:0 :;1gme;aep

..;'ggg*ség gm em"; zimi «:21 mm sqzguem

_'::~:*m 3&5: '1:-3 afixapun. G2; mm 51233391113 :35:

{V} fiflfi 3 SEE 'LEE 'fi£Z"97~»'*$'3 3I5'P'{»?T1 59C'V5'§$9

' \
4 /.i'
,/

azvua SKIES BR} 21 Bflfifvfiflfi ' pmxzz T311313 fififiélf BI}:

81? *$aI ;¢ ¥~%a£ §w% ass '£€E '6¢z'R0aSj .

xapun axqwqsgnnfi gaauagga an: IQ; fi§{§q H x

szxnoa ea; 4%; aau¢;3:3afi aqq :su;@fiHw§ég$wfi«

uefgagnuoa ge zapxa aw; 'gi§d:~uj 3pég¢{fQfi_w»

Q; ucyqyqefi uoygynex aux ,'£:Eujp:¢au§} wM E

-paggzpcfi mg fin 53$ $§€¢q sgxnvg
eqg fig paeavfl aamaqua$,;§§z%fiig’§%§53§a3ua;;c
zeqqe ammg JO Q§$@%§;§ ;& §aé£% fifihé no zeqaya
mxq xauyefia gx¥fi§§ ‘§§$f§§§fi figfiq gq panama
uerzaxauoé §§” ;g%%é’L$fi§Ixy%H on smm exam:
awn; gum; éqfififi$%$@g§fi§§”§s{a pm? xwuapzxqed
an: ;m 59%? §qfi_ £fi;§a§fiauos pug Qflfiffi xaoa
gg§§?Qé@a§fi§Tfig§qmH§%’xauuvm am; ‘@393 sq; go

aaé§Eggmfimx§§V.§n@ exam; aqg fiuzxapxauag

*3&1 v~va£’szn etqwwsrufid

fifaéfiéigdaaqn gm; sqquaw 9 :0; *1-3 ufixepun an

A” 34:fia;9p H? ~zaca’s*su go av:; 52% 0: paw wxvafl

V “»A: Ed; *1-3 ofixapun 93 xeu¢;;;;e& ea; psaueques

fizaqazng -aqguom 3 gm; -1*3 zaqnxng ofixapnn

an ant: I9 Auemfivd 30 atnugap H: m;QQQ’1’Qfi

CI!

1%

§§P”£
‘-/PS

“W*4uawuosj:dw;’W:n

ga aauaxuaa Qfizapun'<m3 qqjmqqifig ¢§no§ f@xxg .

aqg emwgeq aapuazxnm {x9q$Vx§fig§3@:a& a§gR}W""§

"Ana ;; panxsmdep quucwg au;;=§gé5x§ ;% yun§ez
48% an ?3'{iL',E%':w 9:

‘$W3u?W«§$3 i§§ 5%’$ $§3§b@fi tIwus aw
Qunoma any; §b gfi%$$%$ g§,3ffi§;ap at pue 3&1
g-933 uaggn&£fi§%§fifi atfi§fié%vfifl~émuegge eq; :0;
wfggozg-gfi ;Q:sfij§ $@d_$fi§_éfi3ucm 313 3a; ‘1’g
Qfixepum gq ;§aq3:fi3i?qifi§m $u¢ 30; ;*s xaqgang
?5J@P§f’§{fiqg fiq«%!xunQwv any; 39 guamfied

36 zzfiégap ué fit? sax 8£a*aes wanna atquwgrunfi

i ghaaua;;§”‘a¢£Tg§§; -;ggg*{‘ag gm aux; Kafi

_t;$;,puw’9q$$¢m aaxq; xv; *1-5 efixapufi an pm?

j*%;fiGw &um :9; “z-3 ofimapun zrnqg an *3Inw;9p

A }§$ ?fiaj gs ggg -wag zepun afqwqsrund aauagga

*» flu: :0; –gQQgz’s3 :0 aug; .£a& ax; paauanuas

.”VE£qa:aq Q? xauotqrnad sq; *pa§;:pom Eqgxaq ay

MQIEQ sauna: em; fig gauaygggsd egg um pesadm;

11