High Court Karnataka High Court

Chandrakala vs United India Insurance Co Ltd on 1 February, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Chandrakala vs United India Insurance Co Ltd on 1 February, 2010
Author: N.K.Patil And Gowda


R6 was Efififi $9132′: axe’ KAR2*iz%.’i’API.A’ arr

333333 Tags gem :8′? mm s,?3*+j_§=:E;mL;?::*;§;.g*:2′;}’ 2i::%;1; V

3’9. .-,.-g_ : H
1

E? .11? E :44; E42 ire»,
‘E’§§E §:G:+z**3:s’..>§:. ‘:§;;a§1¢§;’- 2;; %;g. §§;?::’L%vV
$33 §-E:3§2″EE_,.E g3f;;:”:.#e’r::::’;»?:.%V%;a;%;s3»fg§:izf,:1$:.s.’z?;;a;sE «mama

§$T%’$E§: % ‘

&’~.=.’»:3..fs_iA, {:§’1?1;fi{Ti§?§f:§z’%l.§;’§; _ ”

<3. TV§€ag;aE}i'1V¥§?3i;rai
Rgfirmi ~.:»:E3:f):..éfi:. \:'§?;5':':s§"'* -. '
R ,1 (A3,… i%:v3.\z'1:1:;§i'a IS_L1'i3z§3L25g;

‘EN Niixf ”.?(7:” _
§’:fL1I1tTS§E1£féi§’r–3. 3″‘s:::i;.p§§:,
, ._?f=3′<i:za;1~" %:§_%";.a1'£«::i3 §%:'i<:§"::i:~ai;

“Z;a1jg;:g:::2*c:A, B&:’1g’é:;id:’e — .38.

_    Apgizfiiiaat

= A ' '-.§?§j~_.€ :*1ié1?i~é._   ¥~%_ava";:r'§, éhiéazifi

 

V  A 2% §: H 

4

V’ A’ ‘ ».¥_..3::3′”i’.s:%£”i .§:”;:€ii::a §.?1S§f$.¥’i5.iI”if3?: €’P»T.’::§:’§>-5 E.-2’f{E.,

* 17:3}; 12$ E:”aI;zs;:3’3 Iviaxmgegg
?€0.3¥§:€i:/ T32, 3%}?

E3? Biock, Ea_§a}§z1a_gz;::~,
_;’B333g:::§«:3i*t: –~ .;:”‘::.E3f’} 0 3:7)»

2, §§3″.i. ¥fis1i<ai_eE::::h ?#i§1,if"f1f1§;',
3,30, Sri. E2- T. Thizmlxaiaéz, ma;§:, £:€§v.;’ s’.%’f:»?i_,’~ ”

333.2 -~ Nsssiiittt €fiSr§2E}ISfi'{1V sviih :;¥;’.giiait:d ‘V ‘-

‘,¥’3″};§_s aszm mag: 15; s, zw at-:1 éigéinsi: ¥:.h€:

3.j3J£?.g1}1§I1i; and a’.-‘i’Ei?.’E3 rgiaierd 1§3;,._.3 i,2§{}5’§,}3$S€{3} in MVC
Nau8Ci4[‘2fT%£f14, 0:”; ithfi: iii: 03′ fixiitii, ..T¥i:z_Eg@;’ fiiembay
?s»§§1C3′?~3, {1<;=m'i: :3? Szzgéifi afflaazsizétil '»VV%E'£»€£,:t1'::;2p:~::Ei?:a12 Kama,
,Ba*s::gaiQ1'f: :j':"~_§<fi€E'%?i-;?§}, pa3"fi}f3j§€s:é'i:'2g _i"§.':.<:»..£f'§'i:a»i:11 Péfititian fer
Ltompz::11Sa%:i{;:1. and :ac:;i<;§:1.g;'V»€f::1§1a31'}a;::zii€::::13:}? '€:::}1;1p:=:aSatim1. "'

"i"hés ap}Tfé%%aaj}1iss'*:::;aj;i€1g1 E51 f§3:::r' A{§"i':?%.is.séc:n3 this éiajs,
BL K. E-"atii 9.}:',"V{,if';i.%VV;C$2'§::{$i §f}1§,§;}'i§'§i;1g:.V. '

E N 2*
.f3=a%T§'i'§'i'"'§iz " » ' V .

J, fi’;f%i§TsLA.a.;;::fsa%%%jE.__;:3r§s<%:s§; fT3¥.3.¥.f <3? ifjiiazti jt2«:_§.g:":1<mt and awarii

' :_rs ":§..A:..,;::*:a?;_;;"s gsaizsaiéd; an rvfigaf: Ni:-;.a;@'<;,: 2:104 £2333. gm 9:"

i}:: <':;._'*s?"E'§_ A£V:§:§§'V."_*z3_11€%:g€'§ §t'i§3:fi§'31€3'} Mates' Acmciani {iiaims '"E':°i§;3z.31*:.3§»

,3, i'.".»«::n._€;:;"i of iffaxisas, fviéirgpfiiiiasz f%E$€af Baiggeivre {:'S'{1i:?'i§~§~

::T§§€%zf€t§:i:§:§"§=r?:r 2°€§%?t:'z*%?':£§ fit) as 'E"":'§i':~:33::§E*' fag' ?{}:':~?: Thfi

_' ::s,§t:§::eé:E'2:-::"':'%?. £333 }L§:'€;-%é3:1":¥i_ Jeri rim: §.nf:':i'a:1E' apjgyfiai an {.3163 ge:.:':_:2:{i

%"he*-5 :::z3§::p6z§:f§:v3:Té€3sf: :3?' 'fRs.?é";5"}i"}<'§,i« 3.W§:i'€§€€i §.73f£»' '§f.§'Zt€f:

'4 "'§"'2:*'£?<32T:_:";;3;§ W*§"£i"': izaifitrési at 6% ;':e€:1* a3::1':z1:.ra f1;T'{"}§§"i %_§?:€: <.ia"§:§': 273%'

"§Tif'i?'§_§§i'"3§'§ fiié iéw :§:~2.t:2 :31?' §;3v32':€:*:E't 9.5:: :~2g:::_%..*§.:$§ iha {ft§:«3;_:?2":f: fa?

L».

RSV ‘§i.§}=,€’}i3_§:

pf’:”§.i”ij§{,’a¥”i 31363. $53331? tip for czazzséiieratégn 3T’!€’;’f€3I’f’._.’€.?€E£Ef

and $33.6: ‘¥”§’é%”3z_:3″f:ai in f’i1§”sE i?i..fi”.{‘3_’ rnR5i{i-srri?’–:g”i–E.§c {31*:’a3– _a11€fi” =

€i%3c1.:”::’;é=::1€”;a:’§»=’ evirientzsé a’§’1,i’,§ «r;é:§.::e:=::’»_ T’if:’fi3:§Ea’:::ie rm 3″f”:€T:<'§'§'<i has a§3_x::=xW;ri ?§fi_%;E r_i'7z::_2§*z11 ;f;§%;_:i"§im'1 Sf 'i.hé'–..

aypfiiwiauf. in 13%;"? :as..irard§1":g C<31ji;§::<?:i"::f<2'§%.§(§:':-Q§f'_:Ré:,i7{};{f§<}{T3/« V'

t..1:3{i€:r <:¥i,'i"§'f'E:'r::";'{ heads w=*iiE'f§"i '§,Z?Vfi?i§§'i'tT:5SnT_§:ff'.'¢3';{""'f"k§r'3I'§.3 §:t§§:"'ea:r1':iL1:n frem
1:336: iiafii ni' §3t:?_,ii:i::’: iii}. tfiaé :”iéi’Ei:€’_,_ §’a=.fiv;*,:é:;f<;*3f:;;.a:%;:'7:»*£M§V '?§*:c*: appfiziiani

E1355 p:*:::s.en%§}::ij.L'V_.. £3115 a;;§g:«:-:;_aE_ _-«art: the: gm1::3::ci that th&

<"::13;_)€%§”3fi«.*f=:;iT.Vi;s’?$;;’:AAa€a;g:4¢:is%:::3 ‘sj:§.<i "?*:"°ii:31T:'{*:a3; is §_'£"i:1§{3€§q1iEi"{'.€': and

Vigéz §"€:<:;u_§.:*~r?.s ff'§'i'%"i%'?;,'£f1f3.{i'$'§a'.§2?3E;.'i§7,

-.4′. ~1Rf§;._,4§*;g§’:: “2f%.~:?%22a3*{i é:’z1§: %<__=:am.€:r£ rfT'.f'}§E§§§€§ a.};:}_i::i~.":;a_ri1f;g <31":

¥?:{?s%fi.§:": §s;%:"§as: §% :é'.:jf €::%3an;.5:é:'§fi:'a?:%e §e;z3g'%:E'": 69%' fézziia

V "§3a7¥:'3?,&?§' {f2é§1°'f?.?3.i§ §_:€:§**::§?:_§ :3?' i%:3:=%. :g§,'l;€§g§EX€*:§"'}f agxéi azésayri Qi'

__ "":T.h€;; "i'1'§.%3%..::f:a.§ azzci a:fif.:"::' <t::r;"'fi:::a.3 fi¥§3é;.§21ai'i{3!f"i 213%' rm ':'€'..§€"i;V3§"§f

r:"§::aii€;3"ia§ avaéiaiisifi Q1': £316: 133% =a:'§";a?: €:mr3:'g€:$ E5: 'thai. "$16:

'?:*i'%::u,:';a§ E135 r:'%::":*ec2 $5.": awa:*<i§ng ésrgijs §<s_~;,'2f:,,{§£.")i};'»- *si:3war-§$

A

i"

£9

‘paéza émarji s”-::1%’%}%*:’s*ing::~’a’ UiZ§”§§ff§.”i. is; iilfifififgtiaifi f1:$’:;.,Vi’ir’:§%’V.r£%:a%.§m*;_ ”

that, it :97. ms? ‘=33 d’§Sp1i1’I:€: i:3;1;>:.2? thee sé>;;’>§j>飒§:.f«,:._:”:?:. has V_2″:;?1gf§.§é:*:g7<;:z%é.

trz'?;a€:i:."z<=:;:"::' iii)? i'§"1€.?1i'f?: ifhars 5:3 €§4a}«':%:». Viz: mt:,.";3ié:)s;isi?fT.fa.§ ":a$j=L

éizpatficzrrré. a;r1<:i_ :.1:f:<;i:3r1x:<i:2f:1' V.=.a?'o§3:'1{i -ti:;¥;:§§§V<.*iI}1a:§i:.
was Gena. "§'ii:e::::"€ is €ii.9:§Eg:11*3iVié§§§ an': 13:3 §.h.f:’; 3;::::§_€.i§::1i.a§ Chflfi? harzi
59041 ami icy:-:2? 33;?’-‘;?:”:a£jaV j'<.–:*§' -:;%:i:-a_:';f;"2%::'L»é§":'::»:?§._..§§:€3§",:33f;-i.a.i,1i:sz of tzack
gain, Thif': ';i§asi'.i.c stzrgczrjv w3'1§»::§":

r{1s2g%3§y*’:V:V:§§f§;§éV%%§;’ K?§T’§..iL”!.’V’t”;’sVvv.:”‘Vi’€’.§»;§”3s”‘:!I’.”*14f mi’ Eihfi ::1a2%i:t=::’ has
11:3? ifi:€:ez;:A’« éfg€_:»{_:E:<;:é<'i_ ':;~."%.3§r*.:"; fhi: r:n:'3s:f§€::'*af§Cs2': 2353131

a_Wz§.§e'§"E.::<: 5533?} ;;?:é€1*;.e.é§;%:'§:3's": €a1v:~t§3'£Es 'E33331 am'? 8::§'%%t1"i§":gS"i

2i<~%;g:.a:§T%¢ N; 2'E:2éfmi'ar:m {sf t'_§'z€: €';E-iE'~*iiFt as: :_*t'::i§3:m*€<ti aémess:
é:3::€:'§._%:h§: v.3f::e:«ii.::'€':-?i::1:i cixzfafian 62*?' ?:*:%:ai:'":2e<?:::1; i"3;"§e: 333:3} .:%:3<f_§

3.g<3:*:§,:t__f9:2f§'?§%i.zi&€f%; WE fjiftfiiél if f:E_?;* in awa.:*<fi :§:–3;3€};if§iE{§,1_ 'L1}_7"1€§fi':3'

K §n&a}:iv.:a:s; againgin Rag; §;f.73€'§:i"[3 ,1' -.

“?hc7: ‘3T’:*i§%:m”::_:-13 had :’ig?_r_:.*£:§§; &’§§?8E'{T§.f’t€.”3; <:»:;§"n;:_«e;2,$a:i€::1 (sf

'V.?;@<E$,E_33,é'3€f}€}f- m:m1'€E$ 'CQ'fiV€i}£3R{';f; :":€;m'i3§::_§:n.g fetid anci

§?s1E.i§,f;si3f};';~ ?:r:s%;3:a._i*£:i'§=s 'lirssss {sf 3."£"§}€ii"3§?§f.':$; «:"i_§.sa%3§1i§}«' 331:1

a:i'§%:%:<:terr;;§?:f*;%'»::»T:;"'s:fi5'.& is :":0?, in <iis§3s._nf.:: that this: a§§::@§lza.:f:i: vent-as

:§_;:” r:i’::;:”:’1{:§: rzf ‘§1″:§§T}§f’O’£f€§’£E€fEf in he?
~..é>;s::;”i’::’sf§E%.T§::;’:.’ §<'§?::-2 513%? psm": in ms: i:~':%'% Ciéfittég, "€_".?:€"E"fi is 1/zgifi

'S<:ai§ €33"; §'im;" €135:/: a.:3{_'§ :<a§.:€: E5; ,€':»a.{:i:::g rii§'%'§::i,3E€.'ie:$ $3": $i%5["§§;":g,

ai'§f:I1<:§23_rH. chargés' and iI;.t.€::"§lt=,1*€%r:::e E72}: "%:t?}f{3:?§' .

im{taii<%"~:r"_'i fizz".

?, ‘.’:’hr3 “‘:”r€i;§3zA::”;.a_’§ Ems aza?a;”€ie<1'_E; 'ii.

zzzadicaé z$?:’;v:;:»<'=:3'::f~*sé=i:,-*. ii:-"§3i{?fi"1 is: %:';;:esj§4 ::<;1:.4é1f'i:j%;V_"??f::"
Téfifi a§:s;:ze:%§a_:";? 313$. }"3§"{':f"3_i_'ii";t°Z€"§, '§'a§_§.§':~i-_,/*
ass 53:33' '§*'§§~:§7uZ5'~5§¢ :3;?if€~:r 45?? "Z§"1ff:'A}A*'f?;iT)€T11'{"i€'1f, we

I

t;a_rr(~:mi:s:'- the: saséze ami a:=.a§a:*'a'2;.. E€'5g.j.£,€f},;'%'i%v;:§ $41, '–::is rim' mfiréficai

ijzééis: "3f€':2i.¥.rT~?Ca"*<7'f§'*5T ~.§_§'§VAi:':i1{.§ -:::~&.ip;?i':?: ' ' V

The .;'"§'§'ié*:~s=;;"';& 4' %::*:°a<:§ in aw-'ar<:ii::g 91133;'

%..:1§fe;aE*§i:::'§$i."'*%Ef::t_ ;#[%;'::;'§4fi {E1331 5: (333553 ix": {T335 haspiiai arm?

§:z1:#Efi:%;rm:'zf§:' 3.-V :2*g:i=:":*j..: z§3"_:e:i s3"':9g_.«' i"€if'§¥.§,."§}."'f?: 3. ;:iasv%:§s.:: $m'g€rj,:.

AM

:5

sé:.3.:"a<ii_zf:.g, ifiiinzhézzg aim; s«:t7y:ai:'t;'.i:2g ifhi" :3 inng t"im<:.."~Tha3f-6' is

pair: in iizrt §"s18€7§<.' and. $3339. és faciiig :f"iif'§'§<t1:Et}*'-is": *

"'*s7'?:€ :f§"g<":'s.r€=:zfs";f%::.'::'sa «:3? ::"~:;:aiU{: :'»':3'fi 1"é%3t3?és':§.§%:i "»'3.":*2.Vi;1:"1_S.:.3_ 2.?! V'

ri€:g:'e¢s§ s«z::";.:’i i’3*z£iéi”:-:<:<:'a~–ZfliI%.§3€::j*

W:rt:=:%Ta.'a amri f3£"~':'{'§"§i.:€i§"ifiEif r%*;é;:.:3':i":.€i.§'§tjsf «fi:;"V §{T}"??»*&?5 v~?_r3""..§3?'§§',:i1*ae5 a.ns:i"

18% fa t.%,?::=: wE"';:.".:3{: ?}i'3:."§.}j" :a*?:i::§V';….s%%:a 3'-33$ id sa,z§'I'£:2"'5 €"__.§"%,?::°<::n.:g,33
91:? $163.22' iifft. '£'a_kié*:'g _'Af"i";§,§*',v»"';fl fi"az:'é;.,i’,}{}{T§/–

?ftf}R$*L7§:i1’d§3 ‘i,%1%%”§.:*” wi1:.§”:{u2é:. azxsarding

“?~%:.~;;%s:.r;:3′:_’§.$ §’2::§.:_”2’:fr%: Ezfzaa :1? §Z”§C{‘:’§1;¥€*:, Eavimg

:”e7::ga€.*–sf%. in .é’..=?%”%.%:.j’.V’§;*§a__.:_’:’%f_s:«::_§ as :?s?.§1si’.:%:€§ 8%>f.’L%’%i?’:,, aw. {tam 5;a:§’f:i}.f assfiss

K ‘”,i’%::§: %n:::{§m,:€ 9%’ %’%’;£'”: ;3§3§2:=:§Ea,:;? 4%? ‘§<? <,;f§,:_"}:"}é7T§ja 3353' i1";.i33::3§f§,"a ',€'%_:§

T::Aii§z::v.<7i'i7f<*:s?.A'An:~3s;s?. :é:s.S€:'5'ss;:ft€i €§§S€§<§ij§r,

V.§~§a.?éi:1g rfizgazfd is 33%;? age? tééfi '§3.3'§1§"i"§§:s§i5iz' a_§3§s§.§:i:a%::§f: is; E8.

" " ".s'1'a{t{::33'ii%1T:gi}' we <7§<*.§:=:;'_:':':'z"i~;«=::”~; :3?” fiifiare i:”:s

?-21$’ 3%.

E%$js,£*sé§,é§€}i3′;’– §”T~€a,;%,<:§_.}£'},!« X. 3£:.s<E.§-3% X i£'3%'£a:2…::1f_::*§.Vi]=§¥:1*§i' aa%;:§5;:*::1_

?3I"1fi $3.33. 1::

>

‘iii Thfi “i’z*i.%”n_zt’:éa;i has <%ti*:*<%=:c?Z7i:1_ ax=W£3*.(ii':1g szmiiféA.Vf§3.s:5,if3ii}i.f%,i

tw.:a::'t7i$ 'f'::;m.:*f: mfitiicai (':X}'_}w'.?13:f.%'€?%_-.';'u:"', 3": {$3 «.3:1%3'€. ii": ziisptife
Thai? 5P'W2 —- 11):: «Rabi: E}'§1§§1"1§"z§_a2" ;Vj§;a$"V-aaiifiagci ha? :53. §:zlast.i::r
szargary' at a s:f= {:13 .éE~’f’s.’?§€,3;,i3?i}{3/-, A sum 0:’

E§?s,€§,f}{3i’§f- a1};%a§*%E¥;<%:{i .33}; _ tawamis piasiic

3-ua'"ge:3'jx_«:' i.a {fé%if§ €¥§§§I§?§:§:iii '?.§;7;{%:§"fi":}"(31'€i, Km (£66,-:13; it fit ta azvard
3{),€)<3€.-if -*%"ai:w'?v*:ffi*§=§V'*fi.i%?~":§%*€%. 'fis?§§i€§"§€"i§:3§ <T~:xp:':i:z*;S€$' {<7} 3"s":€:::3f. {ha

fifids c§§°j:.:zf~:%f§{%€a__.

}¥a3;%4′:”:g«.;%Iga3*:i ix’: iirgéi fg<7:E';s a:":z?§ <:%3*ef7:1.n"::§a:a:1i:&ts séafeii

r:i%i.:é»3fz%;f:;,.7%.§':%;% %§j3s«2'§§s2Ti§i a.§::}3%::as,§, féifzzi €23; ?..§.'3§:': agig:-e%;E;'ia.':":'i?: ES; a,iE0"§%.?€:£.i2_:’,3 pa.$S&::§

Aé’x£§’%E.§E: }#¥<3«3§44:' Eiiifiér on $13: iiifi zzzi' '€i'1€: Vii flfififix Liaigigas

Meier fieztcicimzt {iiaims 'T1"fi3u1:xai-3§ {Zm1r*€. crsf Smaii

" –« {f};ii13cs; §¥§€i::Upr0ii1';8×3 Away Bmigaiors s:SC1C¥%~3}_, its hfiraijja

fi.Ei"){§}:f§ff€§. "'?'%';€. §i::;*6:::cE< 123:: E8 " §.3..'fl{ifi'::':
{W

Gui: ef the &n.§za1"::ta€i C0§.i3.}T3fi?:i"£5%3§"i€3§1 i’},€’§i..’Ii’};’~ vssitfa p:’a33:3§”f’§:>11at<% i:":'5<::.:%s?. ss'naE1j'%ii'€: fi.f:_*2?&..?%:'§:'2ii.§f:{}

in ffhff; riagne mi' TiA_'n€–:*: a}"}§i§{"":3§?i}f1.? $2"? 'EH75. in a:"1}»'~ :2s%T?§1ir:»§i:i}i.;ie<.3 V.

$r_7:h::%:{§n1<é: '%7a.1":k im'' 5?: ;3es"in<"i rt»? :::¥?:a.:?s9 x:~5:.:1%::.? 'rf:'i*;:ezéz*?§.7§.;é.£€:'V:.#§'§:';§

S

a1T:QE.%':€:' 3-fie:-3:2*s;m T§'E

;:ae:+::’7:.:_§’.§§–: 3f.’>,?{“}{_} f– witi”;
pr<3;)Grf.i033a.§e ;%fi'£'{::ff~i:st '=$hai3~';bé= :9%:i%;a.S€:é3 in fam3m* {sf 'the

a;§1f3€:E_§a::i'= %§m:::'éi:3§é1§§:§j« é "*sti.c:;3{7:»:aE% by me E::$s_1ra:':ce

<I1m11g_}:21: : '

4§'.}"§"€"§si:€ is; <.i'§?:§£2%f£:{.i iii) €:§i:"'a.iA: §'3;"1f't a.za:~':3;'{E, :a€:<i»:::r£.'§§..§1gij;,

Sd/-5
EUDGE

Sd/.

JUDGE