High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Ravi S/O Shantappa Desai vs Sri Harish A Asnotikar on 10 February, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri Ravi S/O Shantappa Desai vs Sri Harish A Asnotikar on 10 February, 2009
Author: A.S.Bopanna
mfa.12495.{)6

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAK.A._""  : "

CIRCUIT BENCH AT DHARw_Ap "-...  '  %

DATED THIS Tan 10%! DAYv'Om§"'P"EBRUfs'R'f"_ 

BE§F()RE 1__  .

THE HPAri'1-{AM %

MISCELLANEOUS FERST AP§f9iA L "g495}20 <36 (MW

BETWEEN:    '

Sri Ravi, S/o2_Sh¢;;'tap15a lfigéai, " . " 
Aged 39    "  '    
Occ: Bendeixf  M] s. Vklkshezéfiaa Steel 
§I1{:"z{1Si;I7i'fi5,  P'i:i1::;;1i_3;1x;1r_c'::'*,-,_ " v.  .  
Iii Present N'ii;3R/0:3.4Ci1i1i1aku1a,--
Taiuk: ?KarWar,  Kmmada.

(By Sri. T;'M4.Nad'gg_ Adv;). %

V  1 ..  I:ia#ri:§Ii'~.A.A3nofikar,

" ,' ofiiiaxidu 'Asnofikar,
._ "'Ageé:.M.ajc1f,"Regd. Owner of
A ?Au:.o Rickshaw No.KA--30/1744,
Fr.'-«h/:v-._'I'Z)c:"a'.Ii\zvad3., Asnoti, Kaxwar,
Utmrei Kannada.

V' '~ Tbs Qfisrztai Insurance Co..{.1;d.,

 ' Branch 0&3, Rept, By its
'E Branch Mamager,
7 Kitifur Chambers, Kanvar.

(By Sri. A.G.Ja§hav, Adv. for R2
R. 1 served}

. . . Appellant

.. . Respondents

znfa.12495.C)6

This MFA is filed under Section 2:r3(1)_:’_:;5r’i~21;-2;%,j7 21¢:
against the judgment and award dated 29.9.2095. passed
MVC.N0.84~/ 2003 on the file of the Pr}. Civil’.J1Jn:’!ge=.{Sr.D1;1.)”

and Member I Adél. MACT, Ka1wa:1*,'”part1y ;3iiQwifig_tI;e’–Clai1n
petition for compensation and é’.I111ai1CéII1fl3~ltvi.;1V0f
compensation. ‘ ” ‘~ « V * ”

This MFA c0m1'ng on     V

delivened the foiiowingz
J  D   

The is. :f.’§3efo.1;eVV this Court seeking
enhaueeggefit the sum awarded
in No;8?}V/”i2OQ3′.~ _

~.2.u fiiie .1ea;*f1ed counsel for the parties and

‘S V. – ipehfieeiie:fl1e..ap§3ee1″j5epers.

‘ of the injuxies suffered by the Claimant in

:11é”eace–ideu’£, which occurred on 92.92.2902, ihe Tiibunai

V. }:::;:;.s4’a1i?ér<:'£ed the feta} cempensaticm sf Rs.S1,(){}0/«= under

diffemnt heaés,

mfa. 12495.06

4. While seeking enhancement of c0mpc:I2S;a.fi.é31:”;V;* Vtvifzfr

learixed 00111136} for the aygcllafit V V’

Tribuna} apart fmm awarding :’£:1’éV bmeagre .; ‘cz5 nip33;}.séifioh

under the heads in which it has €i£:3né;*.ffl11c

awarded any compensatitm “t;h€V mésespiteVV

{here being medical evis},¢nce. .V””‘ =

5. The” ” 213°’ I’€S§=OI.ldf:I1i,
however, :§{§;§’a;fd””V#:entendi.:1g that the
perusal. of by the Tribunal would
ilxdicziigg th2:a.’t f.Lh t: “has; “aypreciated the Inaterial and
avidfincfi”-:« V. thereafter, has come to its

cenggfiltisisu with to the cempensatiozx payable and tbs’:

” dais _z1″<:.1; <:.-aii for int:-zrfemnce.

fig i11 :*£1A1e light of what has been contended by the

' 1ea111e€iv.,’ éiJ:2£i…*é11~ event,
since the doctcar, Whovfiagifl had stated
with Jregazfi to j:,?::e vgiisability limb and raven
if the samfi: e;;;.§;g§:f$ted, the disability,
CGHSfl§jigg ” couid at least be
mckoigfid _ ‘ amount is calculated. in that
premiség be ezntitied to a sum sf

Rs;3}:$,’fiQ0/~.Vun¢:§é:r”thé’ sajc: head, That apart, it is seen that

” ésfifipefiaatéon awarded ttéwards ‘pain and sufiefing’,

:t3J§i§}%(‘§13%;fS and filtllrfi meéical expezxzses’ is siightly on

thA¢:—..}0w§.*.r axzé to compensate the sajci heads, a sum of

RsT.1s§a:}%>/~ is awarded. Themfare, the ciaszmam, in all, is

v.”V’.,v:121:’it§’s;:d to enhances} compensafien of Rs,5§,{}0O/~ wiih

wi;i1:eres’: at 6% fznm the data of petifion. iii} realisatiefi in

aédiéien to the campensatieztz awaxfied by fihe MAST. The

J:

mfa.124§5.G6

enhanced amount shail be cieposited by

Company within a period of six weeks

rccaipt of 3 copy of this order. On?

shall be disbursed to the claimant. A.

In tarms of the above, ciffsposed of.

No order as to Costs. V A
Sfi/’9
Judge

K1113″