High Court Karnataka High Court

Smt Omana Rajan vs Ashwatha S/O Chellaiah on 17 August, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Smt Omana Rajan vs Ashwatha S/O Chellaiah on 17 August, 2009
Author: K.L.Manjunath & B.V.Nagarathna


ibé “i’§'”£E=’} Hiéjrfi {_”i{}i}§{‘E’ {M9 IriAi{NA’E’fli’£A EYE’ BAN €jz!3g£g{§%_f_’§*§§

§>.fi~:§*-11:23 “FEES ma 1′:mi BAY 022* AU<;:;s3T_,_ A'

PR t}§§i:?N'°£'

1'-ma: H{)£'é'BL&§ M%{.JU$5'l'i{jE;: K. 1,:{.A£w:r;.é*:*szg::;~:«,as:";'H'V ' _

gzxiij
'i"H!:: H{}N'BLi:é: :v:s<s.JL:S£"';.£;&; B.V.N'A,GA£€§£'i'§§'NA

1 35%;' ()I¥'§.z"x'Nf!"RA¢3Al'%.

as ,i {J L;;’-ifffii ;:<;;ag.:;.;<M' _, V
A’.ss;;;;.:a:>’£;’?”:*?’s3-0 ‘;’.E.,.%.i.ia%3,”_
§;’,é3{i”‘ –Efv§C.:=…z§;i3:3, ‘ ._
S1~§’€;g1mzva”;»2. 12s::>1;::3vv–¥-ééwtaw,
:5:AM;u~=:s’A§;1_.VPAi,v*a%, . ‘
§§;:a;\;’»:5-A:,<3m%;' ~'?f<.J; _ "

KUM.m.;EE._ ”

. — :,:2;<3 m':f&:':<AvsieM
9;G:§i£:= AB{::U;'I' "'fE3;3sRS;

§,§’:A::2,

– ?P;L’r’A,

– B.i%;§~%’i3<i%{s;:(_§§€;i:: ":39.

£19.)’

3 ” wz.§:S’;*’:s;:< SKEEEQAJ 55:: m;:*::; s<;_Aw<A…z
"§,;;'iE§ $3913? 16 YBRQS,
:?.~:§N<::§; Mi?-ESE REPRESERTED BY' 3:3 i~ai<;2"'EH*£:R
A§~e:§ Na';'u;<Ag, 2;L:A:<;.)1M~s £%§'i~3§::Zi»Fa§%'i'€5 Ni}. L
' R,'A'§' ?~EO.4E§8§ MAHAQESH'&£ARA "§'E§.2EPLE
Rags}, §~;:.aMA;«;$H; ?ALVfis., BPgN{";%.§–'iL€.f}RE $79

A}:'§'tZLL:3§§H'i'S

{E}? Sm: 'E' N 'V'§§5WP:f~§A'i'H§&, §£i}'é.;§

&?§§§

1 ASHWA'£'Hz'~% aim <::i»u«;:,L;uAt~;

.:’§{}ED ABOUT 4:3: YERAS,
T’.§%IG.§ié4′;3,9TH BEPOVT, 2
Bfv’1′,Ef'{3- 5:, i<;:~m«:<:. ptzgrsz YA :zNi3{§5'i'Afji:3,'V V' 1-
Bz'§i"-EGALORE. A

2 'THE; MANAGING ;;;;e:::<_:m;< ' _
BEV.-'i'i"'C&,Es1Si<?'£'{2S1%i<1{..§i:;-'SHAV:'i§\l; .
KH. £2033, SHANTHEI'€;%'£3;§;E:,BA%€G;%L€}§E

;- :_<;5:5§'?:.%:<;~£);;:::4~é'£*:s

{By Sri; :5 1"' ;".*'§{}i~£§¥P€§ 5:5's;«*_: — ;:«*<;;L_ggf':–§§;;

"f'i-HS; MFA :;«"';';,.ga:;m,:s a:;s';s'13f::sg1_3…:;:.;a~ ;mi.;:;z: DATFjE*é:2–{}}v¥§é-/ 2906 PASSEB 53¢
mic: :\¥€i},i.;2.’3*é€v_{£if§f§}(J¥ <:;:-5:? étmz 4:25?' 1*m:;- Vi ;:;:)::L, :§<::J,
MEMBER 3%s»'iA~;'{', '§aiErI*iR§:s:3'm;*:'2;.:~:"' AREA, BAN<:3~A:..QRE:,
gS<:;$H»__:i3; , F'§fs§€""1"'£;?{_"_.s'xE_;,i;{}fiEi£'EE\5€§._I'_i:~?E;7 CLAIM P'E3'£"i'?i{3N mini
{::33;ap§::4&:A?:s;:N 1'35; "-$'§3§.1:<:r«~:s:;– E§*JHANC1E§MENT –:~;.~«».__»V ‘ — –

;:*§’:;;s«._.:§.é:;+:%A <:_0:i:_ii1g.,~70n £0: %~i§:}?sir€i£'=é{§ 0:1 aims dag,
§«E:'%.E'~L;fE,fE$EA'§"%%§ :*}L'€Eiv53'a<E {E13 f033£r'.3;'i11g:»

.. ….. mgiflwfiflgifiwfimif

" . *:'*§§".::-L;:3::fnénts in give, Fm. 1293 {man 911 mg {fie a:2fi:i1e

iii {£33363 dudigja, fkeisméjer, £E§ii{§:'§'3 étfiangaicxrs 31%:

'€§:g}..g;}p§:§££aI:t.s 1m':fT::;r€ us, '§'h:"g am "$25 iégai Z'€§}:"€S€I1?,E1'{i'S.¥'€S

é:s§§e:s.:f:é £~'»;av'i3"'3j wfia djifid if: 3 raagi iI"af§(3 a<::<:'.:ic:i€m.,

A<.%1:’£. *?},€}{}p.mg

¥3s*’§.1€:3″: éé .§’€:a<?E§::§§ {E36 £<;.EM%LI1€} }1§E'§€§i{}I§ ms. fig': 'Wéi§' '$9

_. -s, ._.

Vijayazzagar, {ha tirivar of tilt: bus suddténky task a rigizfi 3Zl1Z’I3′,

in a higjg speecz, which resuiicd in mmwing a:.::gi3:_’_T~:_g;e

deceased wing was a passenger in the bus to t.i:§:: ‘ .

was shifted to hospital aingi succumbsd to ‘

‘§_’ir1e }:5M’l'(} co:1te1:€£E£:i’ ma: {fie a§;f:£§iai€’:;t,

9:: aceaani. of iphc: rash and xlégiigani-. gift-Ewing C%f.[E.fi€ £i”1″iié*.ef’».’>f”‘V.

the Ems and {he bus was “:nv0iveI£i_ 1:1 . ii1e.’1 aie3*i.

4’ ‘£’i:1锑–i’:i’ij;’:1.11éi;”-20″i;si€£@rifi’g’:*iir3 avidsnct: E6: in E1); me
‘p22ri:é€S”‘.§::€”i;§ éhaf .’£*V1*:$Vt:£¢£.*:::+.ja’$§§’:;<i3 died an a<%=:::1m: Q5 {£15 rash

gmxi ‘:1€g§j;V2;::-:s:_ “i. £§1’§:v.}iJ_.;g’.g>§\’!:§{€: €.§.I”_iEf€I” 23f tize E3118. E~£mv€v~::r, {E13

~ , n€§;ié.g€§:%;'”.s? was “e?:§’3.§:2gg;:g_:f;1”.,i.a}::s;£ at “E89/o 011 1316 driver =:>f ma iyiiisa

:”3§}’?€:2′ ‘::3i:”–. me ziaireasad 0:: the gfomnd ma’: E26 §x;«’a:”5

H §¢;:=e:§§~bart£, {j0fisi,d€:’iz1g ‘{.i’:1€: €ViCi€:1}.€’E3 iii? in

iwsggarté {G 331;: magma 5%: {Em dt:<:r.$ast:§§£$ Eha 'ifibtiizai {fame

_' §..::2;,:he '"s:{;I1e§us;:i<m that aim ciaimants am enisitéad fin'

$;3§~';'§E§{.}€3i}f ~ and 012%. ef whis:*:3§3 3i_;% WES d<:<i'uC.=i€:s;i 012

" " ~–3;}:%s:?{m.m, 91:" ihfi c<::::1f.:i%31i'E<;:j§? ::sg£§g:=:I:c::. in aiji §{§;,;%§E:'j§?{}€}_f»

is fl"§3§?'"E%§'{i€{7§.w {.Zh;–3,ii€r:gir:g; Q36 éagaiify 811%-'.".§ eatmrecmesg 3% 'me

§;a::1z'; E_§':{': §_m::%§;:::1.§.a:9_p£:3i 12$ fiiiE<ii :33: two grimmis:

5/

'E'. {in fiehaif {sf this x't:SpQ:1de1:ri: tilfi drivar' has.§:°-$36513

exaznitxsd as Rwy}. The accident has taken p£a<V:§_§*ziifi-,%i'v?.§i16:

deceased was Sifiliiig -am the rear side of the

§€I'SOI1 is give €Vi€i€3_'i{',€ to Show a¥;%'éiéii;us?r {£1113 _.d.t%}::*:§z;s€& f:s£s:¢

alga azronfributatfi fior 'aha causa of E;'i1@A'a<:£%§Le;§$.:117,V:.§ra3".:jj§s:3:.

csnzizicigr. Que E0 iion-exautjiiafien V€2f__ i;§.'3.¢. we "

have ice draw an aciwsjrsfi i:1fefm§1ce"ragainsLt -f.";1Tfi};.u§ £11 '£116:

C*iI"C1jE££1$t8I1C€S we §:e1v€"i:f§i:Qis+i §it§i1ix::?;ic=11 of Bi)"/o of

me tatai comp:tmsaii011;1wazfiasd'*§$"»:Q bi; :fév.a%:rsed by us.

8. bf :£fit7::5:x:s%. ifs; c0nc@m€d.§ we do 1103:

S652′ a1′:§?”._§;1i::i:it:a€i@i*1~:6»igittsffitre with the awarding s::f mtfitrest

33:. 7%» ilat’=,:§;i{}§?s?€;§if§f;’.X§§§:’…%’§€€i that’ ma ‘i’1’ib:1:1a;i Wifi}Gi.1’i £111}?

E’fiEi;Eéi€;’.§I1v.:’i§RS aia%ar<i;j;j,_vi:1t&rasi {mi}? il3:::;m 23.5.2005 32:51:

»f§1Q:;gy%, v'£im§;;E:5':';§'¥;i(31: was flied in ma year 2800. Tilfiffiibffi we

'.§:a{%.;;:=:,'tfi» £§%,~':;ir;_i {$16 'i'::ibm1ai has committed an error in

awéifsiizs-§.i::%:::Ifisi only 30%} mg C§&'£'{€3 Bf récerdiéflg r:vi(i7r::11s::e

g:..*'1s$..4::s.a::sf"fz'am the date of prfrsszntaiign.

44 in '(Jim reguii £526 appeai is aiieuaetik 'F215 ofiiiii' of {hit

'i'z:ii:"::;::1ai is mmiifieari by hgikiing $133: 13:6 appfiiianis am

afliifiéd 3232:' teiai {T{}§11p€£1S3?i€3I3 eff i~€$£%,51,{}{}{§/«« £533 1? Qifib {Ff

Xgvf

a. ;e=,:'= rag,' : "3" ' g.=:';;-2"

.=’E;ri.;’~s=u;. ;_4,’a;’S5s . all-..1’\1{E’l\_/5r”‘i4′(

£112 a1:<10u:':'6; already paid with interest at 63/0 13,3. {ham €115';

date of pctitian paymeni. i'a1"t:ias 'as $3631' their ::mm <:q::;i.'s'.< -: 'T »

J1:d9*e*J.% ff

KVIW'