IN '1'E~'1'I?Z- E--I.IG}*i' COUf{'F OF KARi\é'ATAKz'X AT I:"3AN'G-AL-O'R__I§
i§)a'i:e-ad: This film 10?" day ~:>f}}2;11'}'L:e'1:*y 20}
B EFO RE
THE E~iON'BLE MR.JUS'I'ICE: \f_J;AGANN,%X"£TZ*i_:XN %
c:R.:L,.P.No.322a
1L3p:'Iw13E;;\z: V' 1
1.
H RAMAKR1SPiNAPPA
8/0. S [3 ITTMTNUMAIAH _
AGED ABOUT 45 EH:-;A:2S=””‘ =
R/A NCL869, 5% ‘MAIN I-‘::orfi’), ” ‘
CH.OWD'[-ESHWARI £3;-..;_1’:»Av–.:¢;1\:;1a:, ‘ v_
MARAT1»~1AL’L:, £aAN.s;-ALoRE:Au37; 1, ~ ”
3/0″L;A*1’¥:gfr 3’EzYEAfRs” ”
R”/A 132′-‘xf!;AGP3F§’I§; V1 LLAG E3
ri:_cn>.7:>AB’_» POS”E’__ ‘ – V… _ –
‘r1~31yAMAa0N:13:,Uvz%ITe.:3a.j1
NPZLA.MANG;A'[ *.i’AI;:_.1K.
Z-J
_ a . _ V. ._ I>Is:T1’rE0N E-IRS
[113Y4:sRm2:Av:’1-;,…N,A1:~<,, SSR LJN$£:;_,
” _ E’OR’:SEfi-E., V-:%;1\;}e:,sx’1.*1%::3*i=–E 1:2. EE3i~{r-‘-‘x(}A’1’. Aif3V()(7A”1’££}
“‘ 3’2″-A.f;*£:” ‘m§,:3:~::\:”1*§§,I;> E3355′ 11»-1’1: S’i’A’.I’I%Z _PU:331_,I:::
,, § . E”{E?3SI30 NE} ElE\E”i’
“W52afg«*’.”;g;~1,;*»:1K E-‘?’.T%’I, NAXUAZ5 ,AI3:;>:’r:oN;x:., -E3-PP}
3..J
THIS CRLP I’I1_.EI”) U /S. 439 C?R.I~’.(“I BY THE:
AEf)V’OCA’i’EE§ FOR ‘I’I’~EE*-3 PEETIWONEIRS .PR.3\YI.NC} ‘E’I”1:’¥i.’ fE”H_}S
i~~i{)?~J’E3E.,E€ COURT Evim’ B 1:; i»>I1+:ASi~:::> TO ‘i3E\ILAi?2{}§&3. .f’:1.-“zj.;I I«:._
§vE,*’r1’1’£oNE;Izs ON” BAH. IN CRNO.16/2jO”I’E}.. ~
T1—:YAzxmc;0N1>I,L; :>.s., iBA.NGzX£,O§{i3:£ F’ m
c:.i’§:£§§:~3._,,ir;1«§13A
£i)AY, T1–iI~: COURT MA1)::«: “I’i~EIE i%*@_i;;,<:)w'zNcg: – "
Heard leazfned :3'e::1viQr €iC)1'1'Z}_S€iV'_Sa1z"1V';v" Ravi B. Naik
for the"[)'e:t;iT£iij')11eVi*E5 Sri. :P§'?v'{. Nawewz 1<-3ar_n.eci Acid}.
S.P.P. fQ1* 11hr: .1"€&§p4:)t1d¢131;§St:at:e in respi-3c:t, of the bail
pet1i:i01'1 fi1é:d." V
f»§.. T'}_1. H ‘png E1116 ‘:.h.1’ee
_ c:;:’1:séi*x’:¥,_ ‘p(’33:s5Vc§z§.S £igé1iI’1Si’. wh (3211. 2:1 <'r21,s;c is; 1'€g{i:i$'[,t:';:"1:r1.i_ss}121bI.e a.11’1<ier sse:<::t:i<,m 302 };° /' 'W 84
(if IPQ "€311 t;h<: e1iieg§eai:i(}'1'1 i:ir1.a.1:., in c()1'1m:<:t4i<)11 with
g::jutcx the W pi:-:t1’i.ic>m%1” he;*ein ‘being:,{ 1:116:
VA ‘E’t,%u:’:aE)z=1§1.{i Gf Smli. ?§’r*.2m1i§21 is ::~.3ai<i 1'10 héikfé? 5:-?r2sL,m*::<E §'v'i§)}'1
{the 2?tff3Si§§E£}.I.'}€_'.€'3 Of ::.E’1_c:.:’ 1.x>v«:;s .2;1:7::j:us«5c:c§ per-e;r:.3:1$ ‘tic: do
35?:
DJ
21wz1§_: with the life of 111$ wflké Pr2m’1.i.I.21 and .21(3<?<)1'di1'Ig1y,
:31': 62.2010 at abc):,3t, 10.00 pm. when 'é;i"1§’C}v_v
had. (101116: to the pet1″o1. bunk of the 1-*1
a1(:cused no.3 axlorxg with a::~c1.1sed_ ..1:a0_s.1 z_i:’1<':1"' ..'c:}€if(.4V',"ifVl'_'e.-'.(v;1
to kill her anti a<;:(:ordi1'1g1y 131$} <, 9iz2'ti_é§.I:'xr1:€%':'_'cf
d(')Cf3£1Sf3d was sent away tt3.1.h~:: w'iI1:15;je aififigJ[lYifi5§*(fE1fE:€?1"
ac(:used_ 110.2 21ssa1L.:ii_ed i;}3<:.€Er:Akf:€.ase*;ci w.ii:h-2:1 clhb on
the head and she rari' 'to'v.r'é1:jcll::3 v t,1'2é–v : 1"oVé1'd_ zmd at thai,
t1'm.e, the o1:h<?:r.__ z1<g{?,L1S€'cI _4p'e.ts_c)n's 'i'.i1c1L:cfiI1gg the
petitiorleiig éi]i'asé;i1–':V-}'1ér. –ai1'dV t;h(-":,_' 3%" pe'tit:i0.ner 11erei1'1
made. he:r _f'2113TV5~§1()x\f::– b.y 'p1}1i,ti1':.g his Ieg across her pzltlq
and \AfI1e1*1._s}r;e Vf(:.'1i~.VcIL;wEr1,, ;;:r:CL1sed no.1 told aC<:L1se..d
110.2 to "a;;saL.:]'€; _t}1.e " Lfl:t§-mi-321.s<2ci and immzscliately" 1'16.'
z1sSégu.1t:&?ri ageii1=1.wit}1V a. chib cm the head of Premzila.
'£'hé:"s;%aiI;£'£{i:::1f; 'zalfi the ti}11_"<::e3 3"-1c':c':uss<;*,ci §:.o<i2k.: fj.E1€:= ciitzcttzzxsaeci in
_ sjzirj.i:'3,_Pf;a§*:3{£i2:. h<}spit.22:.1 ai: Nei:1113.211'1.g21.i12z_ .21.n«:i gg"2:1ve::=. Hm
iii}.:f.E)':%'%r121i:i<5:1 f'€;E1at. ii}1<3: i.:1_§u.:"i<:%:+; xxzme s11f°fh%r<;é<i on
z:a<:(T: (m 21%; of "mz:3t'r e1.<:<::icien L
2%»
2/2
8. if was; 21.1530 tint creme of the p1′(i)S€’.(‘1,1fii()I’} ‘éthai.
to prvzéveni. i”}”.E€Z* evicie:’1; u1″1c.211’t:h€-sci, 21(§.<:p.:':s¢tlV_
1103.1 2-mci 2 t'}in'E-rw t,}":<~:' cr1(31'11es be1'1i:'1<.i {he pe_.t§;%(5":' "1:V~.'1j;r:1_}.<;-'-1
dlld t,I:"1ey were bumt.
4. S1,2bm.issior1 of the 1e%’;>_11’11–§»__iti’~ “E-:se:’ia~1′.(i’1” _(§o;L11:5{s=21″~f.A
Sn’. Ravi B. Naik for t}1c~._”p.¢tiii,i_r:jn¢m _ fih’:5£tt.’he
injuries suff<~31*ed by the deg::<32hs*t%r:1"'\»xfe1s c)i'1'-21;:c:p:fu:1i of
motnr accident and t.he' pc–:*é,itic§.n}2ré§'1:1()t:hir1g to do
with the deat,}:: Qf d§:'(:e23{se.§:1._IV1i;1:_:’1_e1_’ bCVi1§g;”‘f,:h'(? ‘h:V1_é’:9.;113d, had no grievarlcc at all
and 1ih(‘fi3f€f{)1’€’i’h€:~.;€11fi1fi锑p’i”()S€3(3L1€’,i()I’} cexsca Ca:n1’1.oéi be
b€1i€??J’€3d. Pie Z11f:;3V().v~.1.’€’:,’;’.fi€IV”1*u”_’;f(i to ihe irxjmws suffered by
t4I”1e:«3-gie2.r:’eci “m thcsé ci0€.:tr”‘.<.:-: evicience: in
= ?Lj.%*:{?};;:~i~5 rt'? A
_ Ei'~f1VL1'.»;$'r11i3:e;i():'1 01' the §e23:.r:'1e(:i Acid}. SP»? an
'£2136 0t'.E'2:;:*:1" §'.1;g1r1€1 is that, i:h~<3:1"'€: are: 6:359 xvii:11€ss£%:3 to t,h<;?
i:1c:'i(i<:tz'i'é;._ 2:-mti CW5 2 to 4 are the s-':y<:é wii.1':esssc:?s 2im(1
" V. i:E_'1:=:jy s«1§pe£:a}<; iii} 'i':.E'1z:% i:'1<':§<ie1'11' oi' <'1.c*¢::;:.::~.:<;:t:i b€*i?.".1§j
54':
W
Sgrw”
W/” ., ,
e’1ss21L.1i1′.é;:<:i by the 2.1CC:1.1s€td Baaxbu anal the p@titi011<31's
herein having 101:1 Babu £10 -see H1212: the (ic?gié<é.2_i&~:.§3(E._
(ices mat: $z11w='i\re zmci fi1'1issI1 her ()ff anal ti1c:*c2.:1.f;'i.'c5é3;–.
eye w'ii.1'1esse$ 31-se did net 3.11}; ve'f1"i}:i1€+'~'_;;21é§si4:i;.g;
'Lhrough the said piacc of i3'1(§id€Fi'«1{._ 'vfiéw. O§'"_ t'.I1«(3
wit1'1esses <1-,vide:'1c.*.e emci <3i' "xx-='i';t:1"z
the <;*x=*_icie11<:<3 being i:h¢1'e, r1iac§.::3 t.hat,
§I'a11t ofbaii is zmi: xn*aii*1'?;F§t.{%£1C» }
6. and after
going ti11’Q£ig}f;«._ st_::1te:11e11ts. cause: of
c1eatl1V’v..be:E1ig.§3i3%£1+:Ld .Tzi$.j.1″+3–21CE’injury. I am of the \—-‘i€\V
that g1’:aif’1LtT._4 bf 1§’a.i1 ::;tf stage is likeiy to ieaci {.0
i:21,r1’2£’p<:%v1"i'n§.§ with -t,1__'Ii__¢« 63'vid<:«:1":<:c:-3. 2.-md. wit:1'1<-3se=;s<;":s bcéirag
' t_;E§_3:<;:21i:F,-;.1*:xiii?_;aifis;x.c;:.~ Ce111n0':: be miasd out
'.E"1':<;=€fj<2i§;:s:r%3 pn rejc(‘.i;<:r.'L H{)'%-'€')'=«"'€'E1.", the "maxi
:,1_’1’i di1″<::et,eci to <;:xpe;dit,e the: ixriai as the a(:cL.1sse:d
» é1fs:?«.ssa1.ici 110 be in <:L1stT;0(iy £51' 0:'1:*3 yeiar. 'I'I':<=.* ¥::ria.I c<3'L:ri:
..«=
w\g*~«"
(1.
ska}? e1″3(.ic?2»1v(,)u1* E113 (‘.()m}’31r;:E:e the M1211 \.:&:’ii”1’1.i§i “f1’1i:1’1S.
D V ‘1’ :