High Court Karnataka High Court

M/S Sanghvi Cylinders Pvt Ltd vs The Assistant Director on 21 July, 2008

Karnataka High Court
M/S Sanghvi Cylinders Pvt Ltd vs The Assistant Director on 21 July, 2008
Author: S.R.Bannurmath & Gowda


‘ V “?§Aze:> fiS$’?_Q.. ‘f,Z?§§;:§9s§ar,

” V’ ‘ – V E§r:;3§;wgj;3:;_:g E-iafi3§.”§.

?–E:é §§’.&€{}*;£:*§f§; i;I%§.’§;$s@§*,

;fi??§§§K§§$@gR?{fi?xAR&g?aKA,Q§x1£?§§§§af;

. AT!}HAR%fl} _;~:-"J

§££§'EQ 'E'H§i§ mg 2 2% {my €3§f :§§.EL'%', Mgaaéij >  *
PRE$E%T     '' %   

*:*-33$: %§<3E'€'B§,E;'? aria JéES'PE€I3ii' S–.;§€. §gzvz~é§E%:R;;§;%§*§%§-§~%%

g'%§'E;?Z':

T§E§§§§§3MR&§§fifi§&Ef§§§§QE$fi§SW%A

Efiisceiianaaas Firfi .§§;:é;ae3% 39%;; §ESI%

Batwgeai

.3323} S Sa§1g%i’;*§§<§f§._%:§f2ai§€3;"9§¥::§':2§,;" -§".,z%:.;?2._, "
?bi§&4afi§Ka&§&§$$%R%tm

– Eségaiziggzi _ ‘ V’ ”

Rag}. “E53? 3:6 Pmsaci , 3
2′-1§:a::<2:m§$ Eyiafzagyam; V '

" , _ " V H.,§k_§}_§,)fi§8E1§
{}%'f;~ $1? 13323.; E?r9..b§:a%§a:'g——-:'§z:i¥.}

_ '§'hé"'-Efimggicéjséfis Stats: iizzzgurazaarez
' CQ§p§5;{'&£§®fl, Sar'*;9i:E3:;7aa Siycéa,

% Tfiii' §32§::,g::§:3};e€$ Siam 1§;'1:§m'am':a€:

‘”‘§i,
‘ . ‘§€2E§§}€§’:”§{I§.iEE”§?.TS

2 E1:«2¥€ ‘§:a€:{::’.; 3’€§€{:§€é 3351 ms: :§§3§3§:2;{:z;:z’:?, sag-‘a:§ {§i§’€i:§.€f€T§ “?i;5f;-‘.. ..

5:€:§}<}S§{ RsvEG,§é,<'~i<}9;'- :x;:75Gi":§r: .153 {Eras f§"$;%32 iéifs'-«.g_ia§:=§V..é§f

iffgé :"3:*<%€:: figs 3;pp§§%€z§f£;§m"2. wag d§:*e:i:<:€€:_'i; '{:;"'%;»::f%'_:§€=:g,2;l.;~é?;£:§'::{§;,V§Z:§a*

éhs: Saki :2;::%;:’*;%: is €Z§€’§§§{}S§§i3{‘i. $f:’€5§£fi§;};-Q5 {:12 :36’: ‘éhéé «’

méfii’ ggafissid 9:: 133 Na. 3. 323$ é1{;~, ?:;§;§§’€{:t’2:§f;§;»{‘;:02;i;;€. fig
i’€§§’£~’;3i.€§’ ¥{h:’:: case far a{§}u§é’c:3fi<}£: '_'$$'§;"a.',,§:f;_£{'%%:;?;'§.T; ° ésisffiig 5:33
{§fi}}QS§{, iifzés ajggsfiaé $133 E3861} ffiegi,

2. we have; heagiri ziéééai .3;{:;3;3i”:-fizz?’ {“i0_2i::1séEV£'{:s:;*’ {E22 aggsgéfiéané.

afiezi §3{z::us€{i*’ah£«; Féi?;–Ifi, -. .’

33333383 C'<;2:;:':3€§' f§§;S§L3;:%'.3Ei_?3}}*{€§'}{§€§: 323%., ':%::<: ifauzé. is
zaQi".j:z8€",§;i7»":z:§:§i ii: a:*<1é2"':%:'3_,gj_____§j3;s: a:E@p@$i*: <3? fE}{3% 9%' ms iaéaé

aIz:'<?§2;*:.f£"{§§€:{,%::3:::'::§{siv i.€,, Ea figs SXESEEE sf RS1 E{},飧,4%9"§%,?¥,

__Az'§C{38§°{§§;ET3.9£f'*V'::jG mi CGEHESSE, sha Cam': hag $€i:i'i%§S§$§},-'

" $z°r£:z3{§§.§;, 23$ C»<:'::";;%".@md€é iérzai figs': ?<3$§;3<;:2<§@:':§$ am $33:

jasgéféfzaii ii': {%&z€:m::§.::§§.":g {E23 E33 %z3E

\/

a§:1:>u§3;§ §:>§:?z2 $15: the {:G§}iE’3CE{}§’S 353:” §;’_%3:::ir 2=mz’j§:<;.,__'

Sagrfigaiizag €135: Zaéaazzr chargfis.

:3. ‘}3}§§.”€§§fg-‘, he Caniengisd ma: i£:éf:rV €:’i€;:§;: §:;’:g§ii’:%::.ta;

Zaken 1.25:6 sf ms: fact {baa 61:512..éE~~%~:i’iifi”s;a.£$§;}=33:3
is heid; Eiabia :5: pay 33,5:”V<%c§z1iJ"i'3:;V§;€E§<§éf:;L.gfget é€:3?'g§"' i;Za§3i3.§:j¢
'§%E0§}l{§ 133?: fixfiffifiéfzii Rafi the
aupgeiéami is V' §§vi§§-233: afiy
raééafiaié. A[ L ' '

%. 'E"& e:*:%€f?,a_ :5'; ,E.3¥;v3£"3. &"';}v'J' §"_;%i?:!éfé…E;.§,;"§§$E' Sefiticzg 82 52} $2" {$5.25
2518?, Elias 2:pp€a§"$E3f;:§§{:§-. Eiézséaéé subséiesxfiéai {p_2.$s%:§®;": Sf 33%;.
I€:;'2;{f;_$%£§-=;%§;%:':g..%VA 23:15 :::é§:;:"0§%a;:';&::1:2 <3? &;5;f::e;%:a§ am: 5236

{_:G'::s§:é;e:2:§l{;::$'–v.,_ 0*f ffiifif iearnaé Cam':-.$eE,, "ézéla _§;0§:1t fer

' VV sf:<3:2si:§:':;~é;téEicam?§Qm §E}’§{}§’¥§’£f35§ am»-= gazhstamiiai tgzmgtiasis of £335;

{Gr cs::zi:$i:%s::’a€§az2?

” §’§ia.zz3; E1336 rsczygzi, ii: c::suE::} bf: S8231} S3153: that W

é*<:~3§;;<3:'::§§s::§:;€. has ;3a.$S&:% an <3I'{§€3'§' ziaiaé :339.2'2{}€%8 u§2:;:’§T. E’12″§,§~::g<fi:$§:f%

jz.§§%§<:é32,,:3§§g" $35: gasgézag $326: 31:: ggaiggzzsd <:2*d$§'?

8. Ex psmsai, 9%’ ‘E:.E’3{§%z.%:?::$ g:§:f€;::§%’ <3?

§i;a§:;3";€§:i 'isgézzg masié: {$§»¥8E'€§.S aria'; fhgai. E:

§$ .2304: éiéaéfie s::sz* p8.j_\;:2":€z*g%";'- (:5 H c§s'faéii+§31:i.ia2': @5531" {$353

saiarfgr paézé Ea} ihasa i;*;::§3§f%,=§:<%§f:;{:i;?:%,€<,% "Sf; 33$
{:<}i1t3:-a{:4:s:**s. V' :"'::¥§pa:*'f:*:::'2§a*:§,r', 'aha
afipsfiakma/'¢ ;:€;3§.§§}§?;§fi_; {Em <i::;cm:.T:s§:';".§ and
2:9 I:292%,eié*§a§ __ Si:a€}'as; 13:3: EELS §€%:§3§§’:fiff’ S u€;”:gag1?faé_V 33$ s<:c:::"§%,3? 333:3? :3? {E26 aggpeiiazzéf

A'-i::3€$;i;:§.%$§:::£::=.:;§ »"»../, Elvézz she agi"€i"i§§};€EE§ b€'{%:§s'€f3.E"§ 3:213

agsgészégéggsgiz£}'€'$:3fQ%ié§3fi:£:1: &§,"§{?; EELS <§{§Z1'{f§§3;€:?,{3Z€'S was iii}:

p;r§d::é1€»rZ, .§f§é§§é:.{: E5: wag Eaeid iézai, Eiifim 33 1'35; $33123 féifiifi

–, ‘;Z?;}g’é%..’5{:f3£”i£%,f§& fiffiéiifififi as 33932:: {hag ‘£313 ap;32%:,*a21:;’£é:::§3§$s§;%’3.§§§,~2 ;3aé.s:%

Es}; {E35 saszzriiy 533%’. E2″: View 9? ram”: g;::'{2{%2,2=::%i;Z<':fi sf

::'3azs§".§aE§, ihs: 8313:": has a3':"§v::{§ git €325 <":@:1s§:3;3§0s'3 fihai,

{here £3 FEE} grimsa faséé f3£%S€:. 2%: the Saki zfiezas :3?' E333 2';':aif€,$;"

mm}

hag 'as-362": hag: i.i';;af: EA 3259. 2 azzd 2 :§;;:§;;:a 35; E33

2:zE.::;s:2 itaiaéiérsg 8333:; %}f:a%i, E341 zrggsfs that: é:3:p:2g:3§:<é._éi€:2:;::;sé%i

Eaiiéié £1) ':36 ééiegai 9:' if {E16 <:;2:§€s.,zEa:::%;::s§': '2;2«::§;§'__§c: _; %;:=::' "§;:¥1.;<:<':5:;'*:§"'<::{:~§".

$16 {§€§}GS§.'§",£Eé ammim: 53;: %:}<: Q;'{Eiir€ér{§£é :”{:au3€;;2V:s;”v-v;§’::%, ‘:$ ;« ‘V r&§;1g ‘$9
{ha §E”§§’a{,{3 to Eaw arid 110%:

v;’h§3;§1s§£3E3§;VjV gr iira;”§;, vagug: zmézi

2-§?%;3§z;:si{:9;§,’–.§3::£ s;::;,m§;:;:% gas: Eéigaé, :2 is wgaiziézztiai

fzazzciiezs, _éé;§:§{:§”2 is a_1:”;:attz9′:-fgfiéd Es}; E§}:e<§ Riiififi <1»? E3253 E33: ":0

bi":-«t3;;é;?:-*{;€$f{:*:1's:§ é§":._%f§'3;:”

3:3′ ‘$.75-EE’=§$i.%;’§:é:§§.S%?3::*~::E grizzcégésg :2? ffififiifiéfi §£?;”?{§ ;:_;s::§::<:

' anii :'2<:.:.; ar}:i'::i:§:'iE§«f. $238}: Gfdfiii' gaggfifi $3; 33:6: 352%' m”:::*

njjiistazzfé is f{}3;§§’}§ :9 fiaafa sezziizziiisci a gfitezzé a§*:*{;2″, ya-“:$:.,;§%::§:1g

31:’: 8. ,§:f:;2m.%;§::=S£ §§’?i§E}S€§€€ %3€%_::g caszaeé Ea §:E:1z;3

apgaéésézfzzjafzgasziéazai. €3§'<%%na:*%E_§?, ah:-3 _g:2z'i*;1<:§§ {'33E2§}§{}fgz'{i§."'

/

3
i3 :'<:<:;é;.2%§'*{":§§ ii: {§é':E§{Zi$§'{Z :3? 3%-::–: ifiaiiéé 3;z'_:a<;%i: 13}; %'£":i:~

C{§E"§;3:3§'§;%.'%"i£'§:E., :¥E"':§%§: §;}E£:'é§{§E%1g ma &§§;'s§§ T?§:':§§{}§'i amié $2":

Ci§:2z§iE%:z'i§:';g 33%": diimafiéé, 'figs wzaéafer 3%' E'§f{§%_%;'iC{Z§{3.i'i z':::'»';"%ss:

0:133' 33 exazapiiagi aria} far €§':::;*: rsssagexag {£3 E::::~: ;*a;;::z;;:;%ii§:< §__' A'

*:a*:*i€i§'1g,¢

9. Frsgfi a “isrmgal 9.?’ 335-: £231 32;; “;e’éi€§iHé3″aé’§,::};3-:, §it'{:3§;.3’s_!;ii”?;é$

Said Ehai fiéere is azijg fi:a?E<:~ria..% <=:_:*:"3?:’._€$:*<._a:*%;*;§'€~§f2:s?*}{,:J:::'3:,:'=-3:': V

fix: }3é8}'°§'. 3%" {$33 Cfiiifii, iii} rej€s:?r3§}.*:gg_§§% @S;3__ S§§;.<:<:,

i".§€S§E§§'.;"'f <:2;;:§3®:'%;:.13:§.%i:;;' b{:§;:a{g'~~..g;'a§_:§a:§, §;_::f% ?;:;z§, ;§:»s_:*.i{5 %z2a'iié:;r%2:§;

'i}'J&$ maé ;;§:{:é:,::::i:;:i''''%;)%g*- ;: észugggjszzvtrfiafii, fizz: Cami: 32:33 §}&$${"Ti{§

{ha E331: §32;:gis§:?:4;?:7._<u:=;?,*{§¢;w:i' '_%£§:%c'.§: 1133:3153: a;:"7::é'§::'a:"3: 13:32' ééiagzaai'

4.37319 £f:;é;rt% L' 'E133 iéii;-3 __§§§;;;:<% amfgi 3=€a§;:2:": fiza !f:'I?§€f§"§3I§$€ its

»

615% s£::f;@1%ti*3*§."1s:%11"§:.%v'; m**§3.{§iz:t§G:"§, Eiflfifii' éixae _;:s1'<;'ar3;$::2? :6 iaraéarze 2:}?

_ V :§€:<§;:.3;::3 'iéée a;;::;ag'[:§;;: is '£25: €§€§O$§.'§";€€3:. 'E7126 £f{;:::*?£ has acésaté

§§';:. ézarmsx a:§s"s§1:§§~$aa£;ia:2 {EB} af $363931 ':35 sf fiie fiat.

E-$31.2 AA';?'%;;:%:A ssafazzaé arzfi :§":"::*{§ {:@:z:€£*:;§;;§:::s§ {Ea :’;s::aa’é a;-1&5: .’§%’:2£”

_§t’€:=-;’:;;;<32?:};§€z'a'€";i§:': if}. éhfis ag3;3€aE§ at 'iézég Eségzgfi (sf §;%'3<:

_ ;§£<;<:<:€=:'E§::g§§, "'?§1{T:§<' 3:? §:':é§§'%.{éé"$ 1%-"'.§"l§{?§E 223:: :'a~:e:;:.:é:?s:<i is 1&3

sfizzaiiiaizi fizrjzg {ha E?'f£é§ ;%::z5′:;.i{;:: E5

\/

Szzbgéisz $0 ihaé saéii §§§;>§:’t__s; 8.§”E{§ 31%;: <';%3§:2'2-*z3;§…é,_::§';":':23;j _

aggpszai s5§3:':s:;{s ;:€:§€c§:€<iw

3-%.5«