High Court Karnataka High Court

Sharanappa S/O Balappa Kumbar vs The State Of Karnataka on 6 January, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sharanappa S/O Balappa Kumbar vs The State Of Karnataka on 6 January, 2009
Author: V.Jagannathan
as: THE HIGH COURT <31? i{ARNATAl{£§""' 5   

CIRCUYI' BENCE AT DHARWA9.  ' 

DATED THIS THE 673 13AY1»A0F,j;9;;s:U~s§RY'2%2s0<;  -- 

asmaa '

THE HOWBLE MR.JUs?fi{§E» V. JAGAN'PlfiTF15NVV

CRIMINAL ~I5'£+?If1'r--?:o}§; t§m..?S6~1%1200s

BHFWEEN;

1 Sharanavéa; Eiaiarifiéi K:réiba1%§

Age: 2? iyeas-'sV,_ Ode:  

2. Smt. I5?-I  
Age: :35 yaaits,  f{'m.:,_$éhoid§vQr}c. _'

3. Cham;irasheka,r._@ Chanfihi' _ "'
@ Chandrappagg _ .
S] 0 Balagppa iiumbarg " "
Ag~z=;_; 28  (Jc:c: C<50}j.<§:_,___« ;

Afl..;a:»§R;c Eiumhaffini,
Gajend;tfagéui.,'f}TgE Rem; Dist: Gaczlag.

 »_:(B§r Sri. Bgaav.)

-- V .» '  ':Kar11a3:a.ka,
A " -  VGaje:13.ci2:'agaé Police

33; "State ?P11¥:3Ziic Prosecutor

  V ' » . _ _{3ir€;1§ifBench, Dhaxwad.

 éiri. P.i~i.Getkhindi, Heep)

. . . Petitioners

. . . Respondent

:2:

This cximizlal petition is filed under Section; of
Cr.P.C. praying to reiease the accused] petitioners -?.>jaj1’vv:§11

Gajendragaé RS. Crime No.13?/2008 u:1dfc5i*”-«%<;ticu;S« _

498(A), 302, :304~B r/W Sections 3 anei 4 Of}:);P."AC1C, V" T. "

This criminal petition c{:ming"'c«n. «fer: tf1Vis'_:'«f1a'j;-*.., u

the Ctzurt made the fellowitag:

ofimgg

…………………..«

Heard both sides and pc§:i::s;¢{i’V..the gbjecggfig filed by

‘the: State.

2. Thii Lxsefl xffhavitzg czmczmitted

L1f1d§§r seéfjbixs 498A and 307 sf {PC
reaé seétiqxi ~ sectitms 3 and Q» of Dowry

ProhVi’¥:,§iti0Ii””a*’;§it on section 302 §P’C came £0 be

cas.xéfGf’*fl:e pznsecution in brief is it} the effect

“:’}ii9.$; was lodged by mother of the deceased

Séiafljig . p€tit:i(>:13.er no. 1 had married compla:ina1:1t’s

éafighfég Gangamma. There afterwards there was demand

» foffiowfy and gala ornaments anti though the pamnts ef the

were sending new and than some amount, yet dowry

u fzarassmcnt contixlucci and ultimately as per the compiaint

avcxmentss, 0:1 1.11.2008 the accused viz., Sharanappa

_}

‘ I

husband of deceased anfi Sharaliamma, 1_}:ȣ

deceased waxed kerosene on deceased and

ané the vietjna died in the hospital.
place within five years of the i it

3. Learned Counsel’ wetgle argue
that complaint is soleilyiffiil ” heatsay and the
petitioners W€}’Iél 1Z10t in A aflgged incident
took place. submitted that so

far as petitio13.er_,Vno’.”3 “:10 allegations are made

againat ham ‘

4.’ L’ ‘§’hei”3eétz§;1ec§:..”‘*G{)tremment Advocate would argue

that ‘death within seven years ef marriage and

pxjeeumption arises in respect of dowry death and

A fietifioners are not entitled for bail.

* ‘”iHavin.g negaxtl to the above submissions made

na:3._.d en’ ti perusal of the papers placed on Ieeezti, at this

I find force in: the submission made by the

‘V – petifioners’ Counsel so far as petitioner no.3 is concerned,

who happens to he the brother of husband of deeeaseei. The

y

I U

complainant makes no allegations against ‘ tiU’;:3 V’

and the only persons who hav£;”¥:$ée1:. ;€.spon§§ib ¥c

zieath of. deceased have heen

husband of deceazaed and of

deceased. So far as 3*? goncéI&1ed,.-1:16 can be
granted baii and pefitiéiisérs ‘.1 Eriet entitied for bail

in Vi€W of serious <;}fl'cnc*éS"a11;:g€éd..V:aga§zé1s.;j iihem.

6. péétitiorx is partly allowed
only “13c:ftifi;6’ne1′ is concerned and it is
Ivejectefl 1 and 2.

‘f’ht: 33-‘3 *;f>;:ti§.ién€§r’~.–§ha}} be mleascd on bail on his

V. «_ exfiériufinig 5; bozid’ for..a’sum of Rs.5(),O{)0/ – with two sureties

‘ ‘the of the trig} court.

‘– ‘lx’.I1£=y«–‘V.’I3f’iA'[ifiéfifioner shall mark his attendance before

Ga_]:4é£;a.§if§~t;gé1d: Police Stafion on every Saturday between 10

” ” AM ..gnci”s PM.

The 3″ pcfitioner shall not tamgxtr with the

“”pro$ecution witnesses in any manner nor shall he hamper

the investigation.

9%”?

:1″):

In the event {pf violation 01″ any of M

conditions the prosecution is at liberty mafia {Qt –« ..

canceliatitm of bail.

17. The criminal pefiti§§fa,_Msta1’1tis_ z*E:j§c§e£i é1svVVi”2ir asV

petitioners 1 and 2 is cencemfid;

an