High Court Karnataka High Court

The Managing Director vs Sri M B Prabhakar Reddy on 17 March, 2008

Karnataka High Court
The Managing Director vs Sri M B Prabhakar Reddy on 17 March, 2008
Author: Mohan Shantanagoudar


Efi.!:£ALs::;??..E $1 s’r3«::r 51’3″” ‘

i’§§$¥’-I COURT 0? KARNATAKA COURT OF I(oWiNE.5aTAKA HEGH (SOUR! 02- KAKNHIHBR ruwn uvun: \JE nnm».n..r…,.

1
EN THE Ififiifl SEOURT €313′ KAMETMM AT BAHGAIAGRE

};’fiflTEfi ‘THEE THE 177*’ EFCEOF MARC}! 2908

BEFGRE

“gm wwamm hm. msmca Mmm

M.F…A.:~zQ.1459a OF %

ma mmazeaa azammaa

F: E E. T 23

K H R£¥}”:.’§i., 3HP:{*}THT.Z’L’kE}&R VA ‘ K
m»mL::¢::.%r2>.:a-ma”? ‘ 5 ” , ‘~ …AP9ELLAl’i’

amf SR.I:K 3 ,f;

I-Ea}-IE4:

ER: 32 I-33 zzfimafizhzca-fi.’_..mEs~a¥ ;
Ms M BP£’§’.’i§’?;»i;f.’iV!’§.’.”5£V._ V ‘– *
mm :aBr.:m :34″ ~:nms ”

mm A. :4 mix -REI)’§;t’.:~’~.._
3-rEm..aMm’:’5E.R _ ‘ .

mmw: “Ei”I:L”a»E~.§ 3i’:E§{?tGL'” ‘ »
Afiifififiifi x:a3z§*?:§14.V:4EI4:fi;}5Ar:i.3Au..n;’ ‘£’2M;L3K
‘ .. . azsmunzxr

._ ‘*:<§+m%i_"~r%;?t.§§v.._E:LED UJE 1'33-.£1: 93' me' Am,
E*sff:Efi&I*§t"~::'3? mm AWARD Emma
;3é:'.r.'E:fi';.E€.'sr'3 f '3333i.SSED 11»: we m.2a3:3:'mea on Tim

2 FILE '~-!;.._L3E7 u-.'I2§ }'.Ps.l3BIT1C*1@s.L SCJ 5: §-ELCT; B!'sNGPs3'.»DRE,

Sflfli-§* if? ,, _ ' AWAEHING .33; CQMFENSATIGN OF

7.l’:,»-V’~.E.’:§.A11.2t:%’,VV:–?’4*;aa»9;»**- ::m*E9.E=sT M are 9.3;. mm»: ‘mm
‘ >:g.:’:.;:*E”s’;ii;E” PETITIGN 3:21.; nmasm.

Iofiifi GGLHKG SN FOR nrmmsimn THIS HAY,

C«{?¥T.§E’§’ 1:3mL.m’Em::n mm muowma:

-_.–.»..-…….. .. nu:\l\F\ un.-uu 1-tuwtumlltnl an Inn!

2

JUDGMEHT

flaim appeal fl fififi by Em 11.3%

mfluamfima. azzxf

w

:2; mm In the
tlzw amtmant Tma aufi’e.w§1– ;£z’1*aa.¢::t;3rsui.€§gf5EhLA.&.6§h’vriT9%+Eanfi
b§wd51¥..1’3g fmm aw ma. that
ma fllflixxiflfilflé ‘m::aum1
in 332% km WRa..1,?2C3,.$Q”9]–

umfim

:3», it ‘rErs;._ a@ % Kumar; Iwrxaci

_mm19»«:’g1_;faéz fize thmh firm age 915 the 0 t fa

is. avfient fiam. the wnunzzi

F3’, hm. ‘fifim trfmzml ma wmngly

‘V fiégmt “iaga at’ that: $ t an 24 yeam; that

mzlfigpfiiar of “B3?” adapted by the tziizrunal

.i.~f§.– E1: 5% fxlrthm” aubmfit’ .:.=s>c1 that thsa mnmplicf tn be

A %ag¢ms by flan mtmm ia “:5″ and rm’: ”1”?”‘”‘.

\«/>

awmflad by % 3 1 V

3

-*~f’.«, ‘§mmgh ma a;s~}:eEmx1t’3 mammal Em

m’m.ix’3g mesa: amw, ma mmmfl mmgmnaamn ”

the tri2:2m’w:§ apgmm ta” fiejmi mmfi 3 — ” V V’

1:, Fm mm ‘t.t1a’£.t}:m wmun:;3; g¢:Am:t&®;t:4e. %au..m¢

age :3? $ t ma. ;__i3»% 24.:

..§:::ix”fi, thm pmyer i3 “15”

ma “”1*}7″. E.u4%, if.§m- by 2113
fiffihfliwi aim. Asa
mum he awn the ciagbmant
has ” Jfr5*a.at1.::.m but hag amt:

wmfiermd m«@.§mg mkgym iefl. em:-. am 1:r::Zbu-nal has

WW: mi’ fim Whale body. ‘rm

we E3.3€},fi)C’!}- under the head

mfimxg and 1=es..3<3,o0fl;~ mum tlm

'%m&$ ':.@f fixtmm amemtiesa mi' Effi", man wtmt

' » mm Rm.5,C%,f — rwmmively aawarded hr 1:113

The claimnt hag yrnd':.mm:i mefiiml hiiia tn the

mm af Es.$3,fiW;~, miy tltmat much <31' amcsum. £3

S~/5

nave-rap nu-r

WQR £933? 6? KAQNAYAKA i-!:!AG§'!_: 391.3%? QF !€ARNA'I'm£& 2-min fiuum ur nfizmtmnrxa nuan yuan; «W nun…-.w….. .

-4

awarfimsfi Ems; tlm ttfiunal balsam. He: must haw spent

mam aka, Ehin Com-t mxmnt low efight aftlm fact

the azmmm. its mt. mpescteatl tn mainmin the
mifiia mewmloufib’ dllfiflg the mum: of ”
must fimw: taluen the aaaiatance

amm am am. arm: in mapW’3~

awn be awmed
the }m& ‘medimal mpve.*ws§&.*§.j’A_ .eI.r;§;i”‘I?’€’a ;3;iF.}f,\{}i;fi:4Oi!-‘ me
hamd “mmendant, &

irzmidmafial mpm@aé?T:fiVL*

213.. can ha when
aa fiméae. thc v::Mmaz1t shall be

‘ ¢*.:sc.:ié1:,:¢§§aa:*;;afi*£:a’;;¥r4i.:e:_a.§€::_Rfi.§i:flflfl{- towards ‘has 91:’

V ~ rm: ~::z.y__ pmrimd.’.

§:.§m:r$.pemaat.ion so ar;-am fifty by trim Court

axe mnsidemtiwn, than the $13.1″ t ‘m
..*£?e*:>= Lmoarc mmamusafien tlrxan. what is alrmdy
by the $111.31. Twufiare the amnunt of

V

.o.u€?m 3%»: fiwfifimfiwmmpfimwmfi «$33 flifikfiwfim mum: mrfifiwfiwfimfiwrx 3.53 mnrmfifim mww wwwfiwmfiwwmwfig

Wmmfiwfl waqfimmm WE’ fimfimfimflmamwmw fimfifim ffwwmwwm «aw mgmwwmfixukwmg fimfifi mufwfiflm

5
wmmmtiszzan awardmby tha txriburxal cazmot be said he
beon’r.}1e:h$g@afle.

3. a.mm1:ug13,-,Am1ia atmmama. The gf
in fiepmit bafiare rm czmn: ahafi be f
tribunaihakxw. ‘ % k V %
“II111}-$4 (33