High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Sridhar R vs Sri Gangadhar on 2 December, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Sri Sridhar R vs Sri Gangadhar on 2 December, 2010
Author: B.Sreenivase Gowda


93 mg FEQH $011353′ 3?’ Ké2R§A’§’§.I{e%. 2%’?

mma ms Em, mm mm’ (:3? §EcE§»*53f:Em§:;€_s’:”t3T%.’ff

BEE’§§§§;’

mm E-EQFELE E’$.’R.$§3’I*£i;’:E B§:s.§iE::a3§%:*Jg%;£§3′

Mfia. :~m.23a%§f:2sf;L0 9%

E ER

33: samam 3
am fifiggggzé” j ‘

A&E:32 u
Rifi

«rm fi£fl%,_E&¥:.3E§E$£E¥£fiF’V – 325$:
k£a:%AIre%K$E€%sma¥{>:;~:%% A
%:§€m§R§:+%asa 3 %

A % ,”fi.??E§.»&§’E”

(3? $33: 5333333 g_1:.g,2_f§3′.g§..~3§¥,;

_14?:–§_i% I%’iT};;§Ei$, IQ’I”§§ craarsa
. am-*;s$%;:é;r§§:§§A
* §§§%;§’ié?%§§ESE§§¥fi.,.?;
§F_;.AE§é;§$KS§£fi mm
.,EfiJ;§§%QRE–8§

VA T:-{E awmismg

§EI§:§”T&}:« ms

m§,._:§@.a 5&5

‘€fi;’I:%» raasgas gam
yaw: mmémsxg smzm
mmgsaaaasa 1

§§£§?$§?§E§€?$
3%? SEE’ : I $HI¥ FQR R? Aiéfi
RE-E§G’§’§fi§ EES-?E%Z$§2EI3 flffi

2

ma Ffl..E§ figs rzsgzg 6%’ mi 152$’?
giznasmm mg awfigm §fis.’i.’Efi: ?.m.2sca §.A*.$;$:»£:%;t:% 3%

mg Em 1%’9i2fi$’? mi mg mg :35? TEE
$13332? cgtgm 8? 3%; @3333? m§5fi53Ez=;-..m.a{3*§;
wmmsmm mm, EAI%’§.§s§§i£E,,0 ” “§$fi’_t:;’iE§’;§¥t3., 14:, ” ~

FAREFL?’ Aiiflfiffifir THE €’:éLA$1x EE’FE?§€3E. “‘FG§%

G{}£EPEE*”é”$¢%'”§’E®1’% Am ssmimm ;fE%T2%”§m§c:::%1ga.u;1s’t§A—-.,.”i::ss

(?%§&EE¥8fis.’?EQH ‘%%’fi’§§ sass §5€’3.’_fE§E$’–%;”,_.

“ram mm Germ-%<$=.:5{:»*:.%a: F'fl*7§..V_§'¢"IF.;é%xI.; '~;E:1VV§§Fs@GrVV

TI-IE3 D9312 figs mam EEL-I§{ER:A;LfEI"§ffiE mL;Q$;?ma:-
.3 a%nagg;;xT'% k

'§'h§Zs am 4' éaé .<.§3;aamV:'v'«.V._r;.é£1E:.V'€{§§r eixhancamarfi

sf $a§.fl§$;i%%§":§§i§f:-ggzvémvéiéé 'fribzgnalfl
31;: V' * §'&':*._i'§i{<?: ".<t'::£;"m:'iv&:1§e31'1m§ gm gsmfiw are.

t'fif€"}3";';'¢§:j§ iiemsfcfarrari 3:9 in iha aiaim fififltiiififi

" ibgfifiré-351% Eibuiééié.

V – ‘ ” Erigi iagig as? aha €333:

<::;éL*:km 2..§€;:%, meg: téw .; wag

as & yiilign rider if: & maigmyale -*

" §$m,§{&:fi2»~E&»83§2 may fiatéwriya,

— Eifigavragfzaita mag} fififiihfif maiarcycia

bflméng mgatzafiafl féaflfifiwfifi-E’E3-$??§ mme £31 a.

3

rash arid smgligent mama: and dashgé

mamtmsmycie. As 3. rwuit, ‘€113

ingzzriaam fiemzag ha filaé a. ciai:ffi’A%pé*£i:’.$fi-n »

Bamaime 35:16:13 ¢&m§e:ma.i§.@:fi§f

The zfibumal awardad a ‘c:§;m;;engEaé:§n $f

§s.1§$S,€}8§;’- «mm

4, mgarding
accarraztzfifi and af Eh:

3′.:};s*s.,:.::*§é§’°”V:§*.E’V’. 1:133 QI’I§§” paint aha:
a;:’*;3a§’%’§:*~ 3131 {ha aggeai £3:

: _ ” ?f’5?e§1é+;fiié§VA§i;1a aamgmaafian awarfleé
~%’;1a is ;?t.z$’£ §fl§ ‘£’$$$G§Ea§E§ $2’

‘ ” _ ~ sail fer fizfiafiaamcniw

{ha Efififlfifi muxmei

$3 * L f_ fifififi’ 11%;. ‘ .. 3-ifs:

far’ 122% pmtifi aria §€E”¥.E,§2’§§ aha sfiudmezfzé

A &§=§md Qf aha Trmanal, I am; af the vigw timi: the

h __’?cz::m§&::§&*§:isfi. awfifiad by she Triffiugafi; is mt just ané

ffi&SQ£’1&§}.fi§ it Ea mi ikm Eéfifiif’ fiéfik 33% hang: it is

regmirad ta Em axzhazzmfig

4

5. ‘§h:: giaimnf: hm sustainsé. ma fafimgéfi

i::_§2.::::*i%:~

3} Fragstuxfi arf iefi ciavicia L”

frastmre mi’ 2% &d Sfériba ” ~ .

‘bi 1%hr&$im1 ever iafi e1§=,>..%;ic_iTe’ -3

“§’h§ i’.§’§j?;§..E”§.fi’§ sazstgingd ;§§’ ‘§’ht;’§ L?

mam: mm the Wcmnd §g;;»*é§,%m$k cam

Ex?-1&3, K-my .ag.{:. d:« by ma};

cfifiams :3?'    W115 Wat
emmiried    ?W»2§ 'aim

has asaéasasd thfi

 

*§%>*’1*1$. é .. sq; as.-=: .;

$3: $5 wasfind cefiéfigaic axixé

& Eée: MMMM famé gm issizgsssezxag finfiiizgs

– ‘ E”s§s4v%a$:§§.ramimt§:3ns;:~

‘ fig’ ‘j_ mm? icf: siafgiaia
‘ » ~”§fi11sfi$§°§:%$$ mist’ Efifi esiaviisia
~~ t. §€S§”5I{3’£i§}§3 fif mavemanz sf Eefi: simzfider”

2 W-2, the daafimr rm assfigefi 2223 §§m§:ty ta

mm: sf 25% E3 Emit uppar limb and, 1-5r% ta wkmia

%@§:;, $2

*3′, Gafisédariw rim zzatzzre at’ injufim;

R.§.$3,@W.~’- awazfiazi by the ffihunal

and; gufiarizig’ 1% gigs’: 531$ pmger azxfi ihem. _

far eflhancament iliififil’ thia £1ga,;;i,5

3. As as.:z,me;+, mma% by T 2;m§

tswams ‘mgéisiai fiF§§3*%23$$’* V.*’«§’%I§’:E.:.v’:t.,-t3V..£§;§ §ed§t::a1

biflg praaduatafi $3: c§a£m”§.’Va1AEns: — and
than is. :10 aassgm fsz%A:§1′:§!h;§;fi§:V£f:a;°é?s.c’i:§:.”a§;.%i§:§:£rt* iflfi hwfi,

: ‘ was tmaéefi as in§ati@nt far £3;

periaé flfff4._3E £3;;fi,jiV?’$_ Ieiggggitafié Baz1g.a1{3m.

iiésizséaifierégzagl’ “th$..___§1:ir&fi%sn {:15 tmatmarzt, Rs.3,fi®i~

% g«a.=~.m;;:: hy am ‘§’ri’m,2z:al smazag ‘iI1sid;er:§ai

iéegch $3 mégzwyagmag fiagfighmagzt azié

‘ ‘ aitgfifiaat if’

fig gust md fimmr and éimfa is 31$:

fa? gnézafisament under éhia Rafi,

3,33. ‘Ema aiaimani ia Ea xmrldgg 3.3 a

Tailar 9:: Mia. Trazmpari Fzivaia §fi§1;3$’§£’iflS Liméiafi

peg’ m:3::t;h..z R3 13%

é
grcfiziesd ms aeiasy (*::&fiifiC:&’E’:fi air; Elxpi”-3—&, §13.%”»I;1as

z1cit§’m:* fiX fi ‘Ehfi nmpieyer 1:13;: the a.1_;i;fE:s;’§:£iV’ ~a:’§_; 3_’.”’11’:r:_}_i;f¢.

saié aafiifiafiei 133; am ahaenca afi’ yrmf zrsf t3r;Te~ V.

‘E’x’iburm1 assfigirzg 33 ifiizzaizm 3

¢.

manih 323% mrzsiderim zréatxfi-eat $3 §–. ‘

manihgfi has xiglagig $1’: –

tamrscifi ‘lama 9:’

3. ;. C@’.;c:.:i;§$i,I1§:?:’f:5zitg5’_ gm statfié $3: {ha

&.t3€%fi.é*”§iifi’ d’§’s£§fmfG1t and ?;.EI1I3.a.§§S’§I1%S
me aéaizgxaxgt AZf§s;:{T%;:::=;:{é;:*:*3:~fge in his fiztzzra éifeg it is just

~§::1*fap$ z3′ sum cf E333, tawaxéa

% am it is

:%1%ks};{,%g 9 igasgardafi “bf ‘aéze Tgibzxnal.

” ., 35$ R3:-iivégfififi fi§ by 232% Tfihmaai

€i;::;*é§ég?.§6.$ ‘Ems gf fiztzzra ififiasxmé ia bwizi an fins

‘ fiiatad by ‘Ehg éwfiarg fix game is 313.3: afifi

:3; &c£:m’§3’§1g1y§ fix figs} is _

Ehaé §::§mé§1$.; amfi wxarfi pasagfi the’ $75 ” u

mediflaai tan the mtzna

clam’ am ifi gntitlaé fm’ $3″ ”

R:-J.Q,W8i =~ with iI”.£§§§’fi%t gz..t« p.45… dam ef

claim. peatgm 12$: me Icf

3%», fig ciiratteé; is
ciepasgig §h$’ . ammsni sgathar
wim éfi@E§§h§ fiam aha daze Q1′

recaigt éi’, .;:’:fi;;*{5} 2*’:;f iudgmmié 333$ 121$ aamg is

:53 in ffififiéif af {Em 21

L’ afia? ma siagagiti

» :”§§§ Gffifif 33 m s

Sflii
iuflqfi

‘§E*~é’E