High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri B S Lakshminarayana vs The Divisional Controller Ksrtc on 19 February, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri B S Lakshminarayana vs The Divisional Controller Ksrtc on 19 February, 2009
Author: H N Das


.§L%=’flG£¥§£3’sE'”T

This gezzgnd appea§ is difccted against Elie Eudgmmt anc§. f}1ecr€:}a.–.’..:

éatad :a1.@3,39a§ in ,s, an 25253992 passeé by the _

hadge {Easier ¥f}ia2*i§i<m} ané 3"§aE?f;f Cfouri K, _ j

the Fast Track Cam E at Ezsssan ii': R..%; 2$4,5Z§$§'@4 %:ifl§.§'i:é;g méni. .

éaifié '£i5.{!1'§.2€}€é3.

I2.” Tiée a:3p€:§§afiE: is £313 gglsténféifgg az1é’ :é3§§$naf§_é;it {Q2 éefendant
befcra Trig} Camfi. fir: j::dg1;2:a2;€,..;§:°’aéifignisnsgi, the gmrties are

zfeférmai is fizséz’ ;”ié;§;§3f’.:::§i’3:”?, V
3′ it is {if §i1eE.”&szd3,ni we Kamataka Stair:

Rfimé ‘f§a::3pe:2″€ {fi>§’§g%rai%a}:é -¥_::~sA’:;e§aEééf§.+.’ia%%z3:a éaied “:3;i33.?%§9′: c§i§:2.££ fa:

Ztstgdgzrs i§e§;i is $16 cenéiiétm af

&::§%:fi€i:%n%’ §%a§g}E}*i§:g “s-agate? fie ma éhs. vggsiazfiam :2::f§”ashmsn§ {mm and it

sfiefég ‘:z:Cl::£§;aE@§ $3; EEK: é~:2§tc”:’:éat2L Sigma ‘fin efiafsfiéani iaiéesé ‘éfi gamséds waféai’

§§::§:.é%%§_*§=” ii”? 2m’: $325 2-“cfrsghmzzzgé :%::a-:’::? $3: géaézaiifi amid Ezcéé gigs: his»

§»:3§;§:3:g.s;, iéas asihéf Emma? :32: éézfiizszdaizi wiimzszzé §§§.’-§’§iT.}§.”§§;’i§E’%g_ §§}$§E’ gm’: :2?

:5;>§:E§§a§§<3z2. amé §:s§s *af§§3§g§:%§2.g §%::: a:{mé%%§i::§:g af ieaégég &fi€%§'§§}€€{§. is} ?fi'€{}§€.€

§\M7l\\"/\~'¥\'

$25 bag}; §.§'§.;m°a:2%e;§:. §a%;".'i%§§E%::d 125: {E26 ;3§;2§:;Eé1fi :33: '£323: iiinéfi Ehi: gxiaigitiff

fflcé 'QS. 2'.?€i:" 3991?; agaizzst $16 flefméani 631% the $6 Sf Tréak C9231": f0:' –.

32 é::a::"aa 22:-§e?;;;:§§:i;ag €235: €§€§:;'§§é€§§"Ei'£; frazm irwééeiing the bank g§1;;§*3§;t§¥3;+ "

éaésmzi {?§.$:é.§§9§ éssaiaai 133%' the C<3z'g§<}rat%.9r1 Bank, f§apadé"«':._1%;'a§c%§§VL"'

Eéaagidapur iaiézig. 33%;: d4$f:3'§E€§£§§E€ mieraé ;z§3pea:'an;:éA§$'€mfe E316 §}".iz:AE.'{7'f:_;:;a§'§'

3:35: 2%-='?%i§sr: Siaifimzifii égiez' 3%; éaniezéiiégég t.§aaf that?" %3 a2»f:::V 333% n

s;%g.:§a§:';::1 :.:c;:':':§1f*:%£%:£:.?:::§ %:«s°:;:as';-2°: 3:? :e3z°§z:::1_: a:f ii:-gzltiég'. {E 55% %%_:z"¥.§3§:' :.;:{3:é.§:~.:§éf{§:<:<3s

ihgt; §§:£§§§§§$ :'::p€:a%se§i :'e:;;:2¢s:g. damamgés aiéé,–E€??iA§';"-%?,'§'§1§ §:»%a%§éiiff.f3iE.a§ £9
aazamsme 3;:':a% rm: gm ragiaézragzi am! 3:: is :;.';.ia§§:";§:V}éf§f ¥;s:%;<2 a:s:}'mmi%ie&

bzmaia :35 '£Ei'§'i'§§é Gf iezadaajz" {:2 :5r::2:'§s"'i:sf.':%:a3' '.€h.$ "vélafezzézmi has

§:':v{;%i§;d Em 'a:z:"%::§€€.'m£ I}{Vé:.$1.,{}£}§;'» ans. <2? the {ma}

hagaia g"ié3§°E§.'i'§§sZ?€:§{S'.2;§i}5§'{}i§é';'<',V{_§3§f§.;{}§'£€§$§iV_g'§'G{Ei}.dS iii: éafsndatai egapasazé

'éhai aégém {:5 §3!:;1.i:":fi%?§I'~ .,

~ , 4. {iifijg §§2:;%"53;:,§;:i;s ';:»?;::3;§%s'2§;-La, $2: 'E:é3.3 Cgretiri framcd ihe féééizswing

isms $3?' -éég x:x:§§§:3s:1fi:t€ai'§~e:&§§..

i p§§.§n$%.fi9 §3rm:§:$ iéaat 31$ fififeziéazzzi £3 maészifig
‘ .. Ea »’:’:§§f§}%’C:& ‘Size ‘:%a§’:_%«; gasaratiées iléegafijss 3% .aE§egeé=’?

" ~    32¢ gskzéméfi" ix miéfisé £9? gegmaxzsfii figjanczigz:
as seaigfi. fa???'

' iii E-'s~"'i§;:i aszéw'?

§?*V'""



ii Bizfeze ms Trig} Cam’: ihit géiaiaziéff cxamineé himself 33

azmi gez marksé E1′-4:3} is Ei:*a’?. E3. “§’%:a écfandarzi: axazninefi am: w§§;3¢_é:§,.3};” Q’ ‘2

§}T_E%-“‘.§ gmé gm -magézsé ‘EL:~.;§f}.}. 1% Tyiafi. Cfififi afiar imaging ” ‘M

331$ 93*; &§§§’£’€£§;§%§€§fi £2? the maé ;-3:33 Q{}£§1},£’£’:€1{¥.§3:§”f¢’V %s;’s~’.i~§i§::1::_[}€’::a:_4:=s-;;’;’

passed {ha émpugzsé judgmeazz clisgigigsizxg the suiffjf” ‘§31;§§nEif£.’:’1gg’:’ie’asaé, ~ V

by this gudgitaeat cf the ‘§’r§aE Semi, tbs 3.3:: apgfiéi

N5′ ?.£s1f2%{}4 bcfmra ms §.,,$’§”€6I’ :§§%p¢:l§a§e ‘$213: S;-atxié ‘<s.;;zzt1r.°se.~'£§e:*.: he
dismésgad uncim iha impugwé _§udg'e%:é2;:'d3€$i%'»"~3.:;d canfigmad

€315 jaégmeni sf Txiafi C–§:.:-3% Eiencaj,' sé§;@;é3é«é§§:~§§ea£V-bgxféwiiéé §3}ain%i£"£

6. Haazé &rg2:§’s:::};a%§;:’Vg:_3:: tifi’ gédiéisf 33$ pemsssi the sméra
3§§€3§ pagsarsf;

3? $33!: a:1::%?s’V–§3a’§é3i*q {ha fag: $231: figs égfegéam E3}-*

§§;a%%* ieiisrgsiaai. {F85 3,§}:~E§1%_; $92. ~19 E333 raqaacséeé ‘$115 filaalzziifl 2:3 remit:

€:=n¢ 3%é’¥:i§*§::a ffifif? exeaaie the ésasé :3? 3333:2233″? wiihifi mas

2>s.;e>&i§i$%2r::s3:xi at file §§r§ié§:€ féhr the Q{}i’}.’v’€5’§’£i6f?.§€ af

‘VVé;a%:3E§§§ag—.p2;b§§«s;; _f’$e%%%é:g which aa€§.<:«:: Wiié be iaksfi is eazzcei ihaz:

" if'§:;f,e:;:*:3::$a .§;s;_{%§' $9 ;'§cm;::z' 'me éimncs fee aqua; ta fem" msgihg %y

' figs 'mafia gaafzsnteg Eessiésg ffifffiééifig BEE} 3I"fiCt¥.i§'i§. §;:»~;F.é is

§€'€§€%' 23%' éafsgzéaazi '£9 {ha Manager af C%Z}E}§{}f&$§€§f§ 333%} Ctagaadi

_§§%;2.§z=:§:, Eiizzzaéaggg iaésaégz £33 '§?%é"§T§%C§E §§'i$"}' rsagisgisd 5:2: bank ii} r$E'£i.Z&S§"£ {$193

E5333»; §"££fi§€{3 is $2': eximé <3? {£3325 mmzfigs' Zésaace Em": amfiuéziing Essa

§{Eé.='i{}§£§{3$§."?~ aéué. af i:';€'2.% §3E%%'§}«i §;}:a§';m§::<: £3? R.%;2§Q{Z§€"%{§i}.r"~. ¥a:§'§%':£:" ii Si."-<Z':"'i

‘k\:v-~

ifizm gtéaisziiff §:: his griséné §pe::%.f:a:a§%§,-‘ pisadcd aha: dfiffifldfifii has farfséied

iize and =::tn.ca.$h$§i the ham; gmmniee. “fhczrsfezars this prayar sf

giaéntéfi far 3 gxmhibiiery infizzaggiiegz ‘aagtrainizitg £h€:: §efe:}5.an§;'”fr5:§1§_~ -.

emagézizag Eh: Eafik guarantee iszzd bewma énfmciuims. }3€}tE1.i§1::%f,T.Qa:§*£é%’ .

§}€E{}'<fi§ has': C{':fi£¥.:E'§.'!:.:§}fi'§£ halé that the séuié byffihfi. §§1;:iii42_§ff"–..:%ia-.:l" _

Eascama i;:'§f:':zct:3ss3s ma iiabiés: ta be éismisssfi, "fisis C€}I1Ci§I'i'€.*«E'1'§ ;fE:i;§i:1g éf "

hath iiaa Csuzég baiew? is facts 311$ cirefifiagiances 9f§%:iS"'<;;:V:i;e, in

aacaréagee with éaixz 333$ I fnd :20 _§€1§£i3§iab§_a:V géméfi; i:;z3 éz°;te:'f$1*s éiééii the

sama,

S§3;£b§'§'§§§§¢€§ Etsg' 'aim gtzbjasasé' z:As€%:§§ziV'.;;é:3d2i%§n.$ Eznpessd bf: hizxa. it is

f§.2:°%;hs:" §;<m§e2':éa:§ £.§§:-g; E352: d&;f:e:i%g§:éx:'%V::E€5:s4cammétted brerach sf {arms :3?
Eagzésy F:£’.:¢A.E”5§§?fE§. 13% fax’ hrsaczh af ienéer cmdiiiens hy the

éefméiafié ‘%.=§.’j 333 is .§aE%:§}t:e€;f

9. ‘ Vfizaé _ acs’ $:2f:i3;§%,az:€%:a%. qussfim 9%” §aw $13: 3i”§S€$ far my

_ ‘_*a:;>z;s%‘as’s:*%-‘l;a:%§}:::,” ‘zfiig agspegé £2 §’2§§*€’§§; éégmisseé.

3&3
jgégé

333.3,