IN THE HIGH COURT OF' KARNATAKA AT BAN
DA'I'I£1') THIS THE; 6"?" DAY OF JANUARY _2'_©'1'0 -'C _
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICECS. A31 )j:Ui.--. 7
WRET PETITION No.13971/2009'{EDNJ..;é:i;s'i'_V_' .
BETWEEN:
Mr. C.P. Mohammedali Shihezb R_ K }
S/0. Sri Abcfurahirnan C.P. " '
Aged about 19 years V -
R0. C.P. Manzik;
Kannamangalam V365-ii. (PO) ._ I .
Via AR. Ne1gi§1r. M"a1éi}3'pur3L'H:I'nDi::1.rict'~
Kerala Stat? 6'?6"3@_;'§_ PETITIONER
{By Sri. A.P.__ sas1e:1a.--a_fan» w.AdV.;
AND:
. .1 . '*~;rhc: ,Q:a.%ai;~;1m'n %%%%% M «
_ "'Fhé' f}\d1_'i'm;1is1.;'211'ive Me1nager1';en.'t. College
C arnf3us: 8"'? Km. Barmerghatia Road
. "i'§a1keré[f_
'~.Bang£ii0r'e - 560 083
A The=F'i'in(_:i.p21l Sectreialy
I 'Cgovi. of Kxamaiaka
" E£ducatio11 Department
Vidhan Soudha
Bangalore -- 560 001
3. The Regional Director
All India Council for Technical
Elciucation [AlCTE)
South Regional Office ».
Health Centre Building '_
Bangalore University Campus :
Bangalore ---- 560 009 '
-4-. The Vice Chancellor
Bangalore Universi__t'y
Bangalore -- 560 O{)'3~.__ _ A .__ ,.,"RESPONDENTS
Sri. B. Manohar. AGA for.:R'~'2--
Sr1'.N.B. Bhat, R23 1: . 1
Smt. Sujatha.'_Adv.§ior_ R4}
[By Sri. VA. Mohan Rangaml-.l
Thisi'iN"rit'ii>eii'£fiA:o'n i's._iiied i'i_'haér Articles 226 & 227 of
the Constitution:oi: Iindiae. "-pra-yiiig to issue the migration
certificate._and t'1'ansfei1certificate afresh and etc.
'Fl1~is_Writ. Petit'i'on coming on for preliminary hearing 'B'
.---.§3rot,1_;)5t;l1is'day. the C..r_).i.i.1'i made the following:
ORDER
.ll})€.l:E’:”Li0I1€?ET was admitted to the l-‘*1 respondent –
ll lllC()1’1eige.&f”orllt.he study of Post Graduate Course in M.Sc. {Bio-
for the academic: session 2008~2009.
F
2. It is contended that at the time of his adniissioii. he
had submitted his SSLC. PUC and degree certiI’icat,es:/’1=fia.rIts
Card. niigratioii Certificrate and transfer c.:ertiI’ica-fie”togollegefe M
It is further contended that he had 5;;
Rs.78.000/- at the time of his a’d’rI1i:ssion ii>wit1;._the”
college. Since his admissioh._V'”wfas rit,-t appVro_v’e.d””‘by’ the ”
Competent authority. hereqtiested”ther.Co11ege-to return the
aforesaid doeumerits a’i1d.. the§,V;1ni’oti:1t.i in a sum of
Rs.78.000/~ deposited by”‘i’iind1″ the t.ii”:1cjToi’ his admission.
However. the4..CiQ11€?::§e_._i_did’:not__1’et._tihr;. theiieertificates and the
aforesaid’aii”iod;f1t’. “f;§’1?iei*€t'{fg§i'(=. heuhas fiied this writ petition
seeking 23.’ di.rect.io11«.»”to :th_é”rCcr11ege to return the aforesaid
documents and ” a Vst1rii–._oi’=i§s.78.OOO/– deposited by him at:
‘”~,_1l1e t°in1F3._ £11’ hisV’~–a–d1hissioh and also for award of
7.,c§os1sipe.r1sz1A1’eioiVi”.~ xi ‘ ~–
V__i;earfr1ed Counsel for the petitioner submits that he
does not.’up”1’ess the writ petiti.on in so far as i’:}1e award of
_eompe.iAisatioi1 concrerried. It is further submitted t’hat the
§
iii
College has illegally admitted the pei.ii’i0ner to eou’r’s–e in
question. The University did not approve his aidVm,iss.ion;V;~
he was not eligible for admission to the ”saidjfeol’urse..l_ ”
Therefore. he has requested t.he””Coil-ege”–, to
eertificaies submitted by him at the i’in’1:e_0i” hisadfnissionas’r
they are necessary to get adn’.1iss.i:’o”nt:o shomehlotehjexr It
is ftlrther submitted t’aha,t…the reft1nd’ed””a sum of
Rs.28,000/~ during the writ petition.
Therefore, the College of Rs.50,000/–
in the petitio_n*e§i’e.Q”. l I
rnjei ist.VTV”ms’poViid,:eii.tCollege has not filed any
objections wrii The 4″‘ respondent has filed
Obj€Cti3’t)l1fS_xlCQIII€lld’ii’l;g…lfl}’al the petitioner was not eligible ior
l”.’Va.:iifii’iss.iovn i~o’t.h°e’ course in question.
A _i~t~ isje\.lrider1t’. from the materials on record that the
~’«.___lpetit.ionei*.V__Was admitted to the College for the study of
it VPl.t3;Co’iJrse in M.Sc. (Bio–eheri’1istry) for the academic session
The assertion of the peiit:i.oner ihat: he had
‘i
-at
submiited the aio1’esaid doemnents and had de~.posiieV(iVa_ s1iz1’1
of Rs.78.000/- with the 1*’ respondeni.wCollege _
admission has not’ been denied by the Coilege……A(*}rfii’i-{ed_ly, 2:” ‘
sum of Rs.28.000/– has been re1L13;:11ed_:A’t5y. the”:
filing of this writ peiition. TE’h_e1″eI’or”-fr. “the ‘hers ute
retum the aforesaid d()c:L1n1e’rii”:e:V”1-ind aE2§sun’1 of
Rs.5O,OO0/W to the petit,io1’1.e1’. i
6. in the result. and it is
accordingly aliciWeeiVL.:o:”} direeii to return the
SSLC. PUC cards. migration
CerE’ii’icei–i_io11.-irei1i$f7e>_:r’«1et<i.ii2i'e.:3.1.e -'SUbI"l1iH€d by the petitiorler
211 the time._LoI7 his a1tki1i.sé'i–c)ri and also to refund 2} sum of
Rs.5O;.jOOQ/V period of four weeks from the date of
recap: r;:_o"p._y of this order. No Costs.
éfiflfm
Eudge