High Court Karnataka High Court

Smt B M Tulasi vs Syndicate Bank on 20 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Smt B M Tulasi vs Syndicate Bank on 20 July, 2009
Author: K.L.Manjunath And Malimath


SETv’v’EE?~i:__

,~’-“«.§7SéQ

, 1.1,

23:: THE ‘IGH coma?’ OF KARNATAKA
UATED THIS THE ZIET” DAY 0? JUQ’
PRESf.’?ii’T:_ Q %
T’r~§E Howms MR5 3US;f’EVx§!f.A_E’x’.’:L..i§fi?3§f$’i§,N$’i;§§’~: ‘i .
we HGN’$L§ rr:R,%3fié’r:’ce%_s§Av:’ rv;;aL;r§1A’m

WA. m’.%T%14Lcsk k[ke F RES)

95:; at; :v2o’a:HA’:fi’A ‘
Agaskaé 53
Rf’3’A’ §*’5i’1.3..’5’3i~.–‘|’i’ 4WL3-»5«<3*_'¥

TALUK 's=4;as'_f»:§<1,1L3'R.:%%' '-

" :'?fr§STRI£T {;G€'_.}?iG' "

V. ._ fi’xPPEi..i.A?\iT
(E3? ‘¥*?.B.ETHANDRA C?-EOODA, A9V.)

»,A1,s¥?v’£A§’iCATE BANK
” %IaaszO%r4%zaL amaze

iiiiic’-E%v1PU?6An3AR %
Wseae-5?o 023

Z aa? 5′; AssT.eENEaAL MAfiAGER

? 3i~’§GM’§f%iATHA RAG

$53 NGT i(i’\iG’v’v’i¥i THE }3t?PEi..3…;5\£’~£T
AEEQ M.fia..3{)R

ENQUERT”v’ O?FICER,I R CELL
GENERAL I’4£AP«¥AGER QFFICE
EAYANAGAR BANGALSRE

E’-D

smsazcmve BANK

‘siiGEi.Ai’éCE DEPARTMENT

ceapoaare csmce, 151’ FLGGR

2:49 moss, GANESHINAGAR.

BANGALORE-560 099
REP ax’ ASS”i”.GEN§RAi. MMAGER %

in

4. svwazmre BANK
CHETTALLI BRAi’wiCfi
cooae axsraz-2′? V %
§¥’IT8?v1ANAfiER.

roa€oNaENTs

(av W8 9aAa:4u._& ErAVE,~-5_’:DV5g)

__

‘;*i.§;§*, .*g%E.:.=’V¥:aV *;;=::,z’; :: VTHE KARNATAKA HIGH

COURT AcT,,ps-y3;v:sa.G’ TC}. SET 5!-.$jIfiE”‘1″‘§~§E QRBER PASSED IN
THE war? §ETITi£?N Fé.<j3,i'1.§'§1!§7.«DATED .'.:',?:'7i2£s§'2', ETC,

T'réESv§a'§}?';§'f }\£§§?'E§:f$;'L- IS"CGfv1ING are ma HEARING on

ENTERi§3CUTO.RY-..V"§sF'F'i,I€'.*.€i'¥"IGi'xi "ms DA3', MAmuNATH,3.
EJELIVERED Ti-;E._FQ_LLQwIPsiG: –

3U£'2GEME?aE":"

‘. “e?,;§:’:$V§EVsa:r§:3i;1§ the Eégaiity anti ccrrectfiess ef the Gffiéi’

A§!4:€3:S§;E.§}’:!i%3AV.?\”‘J!.F’. fie. 1155132967 dateé 2}’~€37–2{}{}?’ the

AA Tprégafit apgzeaé ig fiied by the aapeiiaiwtc

2. Er: tffis appeai at the time cf admissicr; an

T ihtérira erfier £3 granted. In arias’ ta vacaté the aaéd intérim

créer fviisczéiianamxs petitierg in fie. MISC. W fécz. 5fi44;’€:e§ ié

K’

fiéeé, Tfiauah the matter is iésterzi far ccsnfiideration 6%
mésceiiaraeeus petiiiczrr”: éy ihe cafiserzt af the

afipeai is fseanj’ on meritf. ané §iS*,iitZ¥S$€i ef.

3. The Shfiff aua$tég3n -..ifiaf_”I4a”r’i$é’VV’:vV.L§§:%r.» i’au?’—-, j

Céfifiiééféiiéfi £11 this again:-éa-5..__.i3 9*-flxéiher %:fié_:

Bank, Whé :3 the em:3l¢yer’vL’b~§’ihe a;’§;,’;»,.r;r:1i’:ié?:’*:ut, i:ras paié the
Stibfiifitéficé EiiéW3?n’fi_é; _A::$vaé§’é’~–..i:d'”~a;:peiiant, éurirza ihe

ccurse cf ii’ICiLi§_i”y’ in tetzfss. a’f.1ti§r%e”é’r.d e%’%4i.’e’f suspension, which

is prcducgciaé§A:rméx.u%a4A ithékwreé izaetitiofi éatefi 23-o2-

2oo er.$ r ‘§sa%.%;A&%V %

Thé {sunset fvii’. Pfrabhu, appearing fer’

fie efés§§sn§ié’r2t.v__’§?§?¥k fairiy submits that in terms cf the

‘ ‘*e:«.:%aar_%”:’§atéc%.__23-C22–20f:6 suhsistenée aiiawance has been

H * .::a’ié t;é”.{§f;iie§Epgaeiiarit. Hewever, in terms 9f the birmfiita

aqrféernent as there ‘rm «:o~operaiion by the aapeiiarzt in

A’ ‘C*;’g§”1″:VI5’iE:iii1§ the enmity as eariy as possibie, afi she was

aéekifisz adjeumments far we 6?’ the ether reasans, the

ssfssistencé aiiewances are mat paid in terms cf Afinexure-A.

i-irsmsever, it is paié ifi terms 9% we bipartite agreement. it is

.2».

ithe case of ihé resacfident bank that 50% cvf the saiary is
‘paw as fiflbfiifiéfifié aiicrwarzce. V

5. But, the grievance ef Mr. f{Ziiéfi d’raj:__V”.€:!fif:s9d,

iaarfueé ceimsei for appeiiant isumthatf a=i'”‘:e:*1 l§ja_V.:::iexi=i(:§

1,

manths the appeiiarzt i$ e:r*:j£i£fEsZ::*c’.’i’..
aéiowance, Siflfié the Earn? 316$ ‘fits: fie fias

amzraacfieé the Lawn? .

3fér_ % run subs;Ls:ence%%%A V

6. on hea?i–:éfi h§aivlé”~–n& t.i’c~@s_é that the ixrticies ef I

1′

charge was furfiish::«i~{q::v.thveA’:§§’§e_i’¥§’%%t’* ‘$5 per Annexufe-B

dat§’fi”13»Q.jé.3-2£VC:i’-3′? :ti1éfféa’fii’:er the matter was iisted for
afiqii-if? am;t’h%é%%§:1i:§;irg%’ Vgvas set fimarr: to 25-05-2997. Gr:

iha: fié¥;.~ E?’fi Vé§s,:::éa;’:_%”1*i;~.~”‘£f:f fhé féfifléfif cf téwa amiaeiiant, the

3zsrasAAV’ai§j—-:’;m”i’:rad ta G54}?-280? and thereafier ta

‘ irrzmediateiy, thereafter the writ fiétitiéfi is

” X ffiéé. L’ % L j

~~ Gr: tomideratian if the periefi cf adjsarfiments

x. §c:_a:§ht by thé apbéiéant, we are 6f the cpinion that in the

interest a?’ féfifififiééfii hank; it is far as ta issue directisfi tc

the f’$S§éF’§fiéi’i§ fiafik ta comawsé tfie enquiry as eafiy 33

wsséfiie, Siiifia urmecasariiy the ‘{‘éSDG£1de’r’it bank has ta

6’/.

“~31

“pay the subsistence eiiewamie at 180% from 255%}?-2307.

The matter is eendiee from that date and ape.eji_§e}14§”VAe:e’r;eet
hag: “‘5/j{>'”r:«s;1bLe ‘%z>>/ca… _

‘ee he said fieiay.

8. in” the tircumstencgiee; :tf;é.s”‘:_a;;,;,.,2,§eL§._VVEe:}”‘eVii_ei5eec£.___ ‘-.

eireciiee the ‘reepersfient eergk te”p_e3; sueeeéetefsce e5j§es§esa.cpe
at 196% in ierms ef dafee’:’2§¥'{§é§2sG85 efid
eerfiifiiete the efiQuir5f”1*:ithie”;§ef feii%”ni’efit?as. If the
enquiry is ereiongefi_ee”‘eee§_{§r§t r3§ eAeje_fi.rnmente seught by

the e;:reeiie;;*:t'”,”j§;:af§?”s:1s::%%: an -:evee£§,”‘it«!s.__§.%§éh fer the responcient

‘ee:”:i<:"'t"ts"eiz'sx.r§'r,<e V'e%£m:'ie£eAfi-5 ef"'e%ee:i*tite eereemerat and reduce
tee sisbeésienrze~eiieW.e:fieee' gaeiiehie te tee ermeiient

_ 9. W§th'v.ifi'e_»'e'e~7eve observaeiene em directiefie the

* _ e§::=ee.i.:i::..ed§eeeeee..e3'.

_ iiietfview ef this ereez' the Miee. W. Ne. 6644/r'fi9 ie

6/

7a_i§;e c¥§_$:*§421i':@:ieve as it deee net eurvivegfer ceeeieeretierz.

55/-9
Itzdgé

3%}

Va hdgé