EN 'F'Ir~§E HIGH coum or KARNATAKA AT BAi~;§.';*¢§:.}'V0'f:~é'g--.""A« _
Bateci: }.{}th. day 0f August V '
Presenf
HON BLE: Mr.JUSTICE v;.QC%mmf
}~£GN'"BLE Dr.JUS'l'I()E§"';3Es§'1%"3;E-iAI{'FE:~iAVATS;3LA
51.5.5
Between:
1.
:v1.Lai_~itha, : §
W/o.P.Chan:iVr;;m.r3g£1li, . U ‘
Agassi ab0uӣ=i28 b
2, P.Nav};:is}Ifi:*§ir:,.: ‘ :5fV _
D] Q. I..a7»*_-.’g P.f$ha11si*amI;Iit.,_T __ —
fiaged abcfiut 8 3-*c:.ars«.. ” V.
. P,E{9’Ere3h, ‘«. _
8/ 0. igateg Chain drameuli,
LG
‘~ ‘}:1b§’:;1’TL y€a3:*S’.~– ———- –« *
?5;;;);:it:}.Ea32.: «*3 am mmars 311:1
‘Rap: byvvfiéxt f14;§§:r:id afld maturai Guazdizm
A§3p€’fl3I3§> ,E.{ j
A33 aria E§§0..§;é.3ddasiddavanaI1ai§i,
fl Chiiraiifiiiga Taiuisz. APPELLAN’?$
“gag: 3::.i>.:%.;4agam;:a, agar.)
;~%:”:6::§
. ‘ A ” §é;s.z5:;;;:e& §;1§:LaE:2s.{Z”.5.Li§,,
3}; its Eéivigizmai Manager,
Raj . E:X{€£R$i{}fl§ Davangare,
2. Evif:::.Jaj;aiai<si1mi'I'1'&31sp9.r*t C9,
By its; partner R.C.Gwner of Larry
Bfiariixg I\§'0.E{A.O4.A.4-(3228,
Yashwanthapum, Bangalara, …RE3SPQ%'¥'DE§f§"F§3:" _
(By Sz:i..S.V.Hegde MuH<£1a11{i, Adv. ferg '
R'-2 netics dispensed wifil}– & '
MRA is flerd u11<:'£er 7S€=_;<i'f;i;0:3 £"?3{§} Qf "i:¥_3?<:-~M.V Act
against the Judgment arid AWQEQ' dated~.1'?;'–1/26904 passeci
by the H Adciiilivil Judge (Sr.D§:}_.,'"ffihifgradufirga, MW": N0.
3342/200:. .
This }_’vE’.F’.A wxfrzing cm.’ibr’A:£I1j:is’9ia:3.”?:Ief0re the Court
this day, upon h<=.aring, -1Z);+..BvTE1a£s;t;£f1axi2;t,S;é1;1éi, J delivered the
fC}HOWifigi»~ _.
T -72 .:I;.t:’fl%./K film; ..H 2′
The E’-.;€p;)é1};afité}~{§1a.§fi;.s$rits B31116}? wiié ami n1§.n{:1°
c’i3fici1~a:f:_ Qf’ti’:é%’~€i§é:::i.’aL’:§<:§:i;?. C E'¥<;, 585; EFBQQ 0:} {has fiie 0f
'viifigiiii-iiiazizai ::;, a::;;:raam~ga, am beffirfi mis
S%E:*<:§.i1f_:;;1": 373(1) af?v1at.r Vahicies Act s;=25:€}{iI:g far
V ‘ ‘ . ani1a:2.gaI;_2:%z3.§ fgzai; C0131 perzsatien.
” v.V__§’irst; yespazzdent igisurazace aampany’ is
“–réfir€S€§fi§aé by cmgrssei Sri Sf§.!2E%€g<§6 .?vEuikha3:z{i;.
3. Efiiiih ¥:;§f1@ Canaan? 0.?’ ieafliéé e39%_:.1″1S€§. far ‘£122:
A ‘*g:€a.s*£i:?:s§ heard argumegzzs ibr final d§3g;:s:3§_.
F
:\W,,m.
4. Leaniiaii ézounsei far the app1;.€1 ami €aI’I1i1f:g’E>I?uS.i”%;€;’3{37€}/T4~ –§331*’—-._
manfii and in that regard. the g;’ap ?1-.o f ‘Q16 :€:’i1:}.{i as
per E:«:s.P»-8, 9 and I0, respe¢t3é?€3L1§,»b§1i} Ef1€V_ Hlias fzxéé
irzcome Qf 1:136 deceased’:%i”-Rs.i;黣€§iZfl»?,.f i11e’;v*;V’If;f3″%*11i::I1 is on
the iexwgx side. ‘F1″; ereforé.V,V_§¢.;9,rfi¢§:far the agvpeiiants
prajm far
E5. ‘«£:§éa7r’3:1ed C{)’£3.E”IiS€3 far firsi;
resperidéfif, V subniiis that this ‘}.’i’ibu:1a}
has :’ea$c: i’:»r:;gb3§;v’ V .im:0′::;:ze <3? E316 deceasfid at
V}€$$:3,;§£§"£)}'«..'g)$r: :i;2;*fi§.§1 §§V1§L1é..'de<§1:cte{§ €}Ii€3-~iih3:I'{i sf the eamings
{':Xj)fi1'1St'i38 0f the {ieceaseci and appiied
__ awaréeci acieqiiate cornpeizsaiion in 3.131
V :3111<}u f:":$ I€é.3,55,{}{}{}/– and the ijmpugned j"Li{§$I1€fl£ mad
K x ' Qaés Hi}: caii far §m.:eri'€z'€I1Ce by this Caurt.
We haw: parused the iifipligllfid _}iE;€§§}}€':f3.?;. Tim
V '4"v%?:EV;i:'§}E§I18l has figs-ieii the age {)ei1.¥&c:z1 i28«32' years 31163;
L
appizkzzd I'm1E.I:i;3iier 16. Kesping View thai 3
was running .ho%;ei as per docunlents at ExS'.P:~8;A_T9VL'.a_%:jf »E{vs.-2,;1’§_,€:Lé'{}:f ___a3m1g with interfist as awaréeci by $316
V T’fl§u§a.i’. the i1ngz1g16d_iz3dgn::er;€ 331$ awazfi era
:;;f;:0dii’i€ €i… V ‘§’h é’ enhaficsci cempemsaiian S1331} be ap§}03″‘:iz1eC1
“‘£:.he fclaimants equaéijg, Thfi sham 0? {£16 m§11e3r$ shag
kép: in §%”‘§;xe& ikpasit in any N’at§ona}i$ed Bafik “amtii 318$
V’ ‘é;i:?£;ai3″; majazéiyk 3:”; 30 far as Appsflané: 2’«§{:s.§ is cancérzxefi, 339%
9? enhargzeafi caxzxpezasaiiaii shat} ha keg: in fixeci dapeséi. fer a
L
p<':ri:c}(i 0%' {Eva js,fea3f'$ with iiberty to ciraw {ha pcri_0<iica£..i:';:erest..
Appeilant Na} being Ixxother, is emifled to <1:f':L.-iw
izlttjrest that a(:cr*u»:~::s on the miller clep9si.tVsa;'Raéjpaifiieni §'¥I; 1
irzsuxmzce 8011193113? is grantad a :§’1V011t;h’s[v .’i:aé~..tCs <f§i§j;;::}3'i§;T_A'€31+::
enfianczeii c0I11pe11sation i.9géii<:.¢1' 9:3-th i;7.t::#1fééé1″e ‘z-ha
Tribtifzai. N0 (:{:>st.s.