“the vietixéf —-
read with Section 51}, of I.P.€1 and Sentenced the
aecusefi to undergo five years rigorous imprisonment
with fine of Rs. 2,000] — in ciefault one mormh rigorous
imprisonment giving; set off éetention undergone by
the a.c<:used.
6. Sri, Ravi B. Naik, learned senior -foounge}-“A
appeariizg for the appeiiam; submj.tted–.tha*$ ,
eonsidering the €;:;.:.feCQ£d§ eharge sheet
inter aha under Section 354
of Vioaving satisfied with
the seiid ” the case to learned
Magistra{e”–«as’vThe-__offei:oe»LV alleged i311 the charge sheet
byA fi1e…_.i.e«axned lviagistrate oniyg Learned
‘ VVMagis11fé£.e’~ei’1*oneously interpreting the statement of
~22}
Eoived the application of the prosecution
f;1e&i..13;§:;dé1x~. Section 322 of Cr.P.{3. and referreci the
” “1}1’eajtnt.6rNt.o the Sessions Court, by observing that, the
collected by the prosecution reveals the
‘ offe3r1ee punishable under Section 376 (2) (f) and not
354. He submitted that the statement of the victim
oonsiéered as it is, it (“ices not make out an offence
gr-‘é..::z.%:aE’;;:–‘iE§§€: 1.31’l{.§.iE§” f:§e{7ti<::n 3"?%fé {Z2} {fig 'a§:é<fi:£:x T§':2;:s__a;::T2E§-'
:<;EaE£:a._i f§"s£«§.§i. sfiiae W'f3I'1Z'. :0 £32,251 5%'1<::=p é,::'z:'i ihif _.;~:':s;?;.?:3:_:;Te:<v'2Vi
;"zi*:::{;ve:i hat: :2:1{i€.:r gam3{::.:1::<; z;m.(§ <5'-£iiZ§g}Ti'§ E-191:1' 3:';-;§.L"'-ss:MVE":{::…
airmiaii. '?'i3§:4:+ ai 233$: "Ems: .m;;»::}; a;mf{_}ai1':§' as";::=a;'§;a:"a-1%;:;;, in
§.f{.t;;:;’:::: £’.’3’i” 2:11 3;:?;”%:<:rz:_i;.i.:;::e3 '$2.3 '<;:.%{:é':31:*'§":i:f{=-.
::§§T?%:.n;:’:3:;::3L:
raps: E
7: fi.§f;%c3;§%;i.:g?(é¢é;€:£ci 5′:.’§}~”——%:i,.:,u*: 3}:'<;:s{3:::1i'.£r: :1′:
$T:1};3;.::::i:”i:’V V. v.:i£§}.%:§”»€53§fi:SSi€§E}$ {I?:a:;1.2ri’ Liar; :’2T£
iii3§i«’:’§'<.Z'€i'4 Va.".3?(.:AiA_:iif'€i<li .-:–2i.:e:fi::a;;i ta) :"21p<=:. .§'~§a
§3:;;§3}'2'é%;i_ a':{z.:.f, §i.;0fmiA'x'a:§.i<:7§.i:::2': in 'ah;-3 §;§;i£€mé?:3,i
{sf €§I'1€E~..%Z§;(f"§'§§;'§.§§3',_ §.:1 é::»; '_.:§.1{.:e::E: am; iii; :33 €4?€»iéi?;I.;'=;%;};§:€'?i"§"ii gi22*€::':
..'.§:%i3§V%Z§1"'€f fizé "§='::':&i§<%:-=2 (33: ;Z§}:E{f;3. E32-?9:€}3 vitfizém ésizéja; azéiirgzis
, 's':\E2;_,;'i'.'$:;E;-:3 éf2~<:%:'§S€{_§ éraiiaii Eéifi" éiizizéiaiézz :~:::;2":i§ E'{'f"§'§.§{'}'?s'€'i€§ s;a::32:'§§:.§"
g_é;:;:='§:';:j;':-2*:::%é;:.V.T%;"§:::-5:;i i%§,},ii .iF€E':. 332311 zajzai {:-:zL.i{E{§x '§\s'§2i-:.H:za3 %;a::.§.%:a.z'::
«,_'i§}.s_.~§2:3:ft's.z;i:§ .?2§.22g§iS11':3i{3, :<;E';«:3 siéaiiiiés '€LE'§E§'{ 212:6 §e::fC'::&*a*:s.§
z"::~:s23<}«%z:-:*{§ §}a.':' u3:{§€*:' g.::::".}::.::%:2'§S am} Ergti éiifiifi 1":é;;;:<<.;2fc% §,'1i;'§
* ;:.;a.m;§ai' g2v::':':.::::.::t::§ gzmi E22373? §"i€'fE' {§o':zs.:: <32: iigéa §E:” ;=.:::a’§
” §:§.€i’?::§;>€. <;§z<;:;' E.§f'?Z', =::%{::::m:.:1.1é«3€éo:1, 2-«éégié é5;1e::i§’:”1§%;.%f’.}; éizat. E,E1}é:% _§;:§as::::
‘~aV§}.€E§;’€’.’ *£.§”2:: {}§f:E’i1:{if§f 2+s.EEsig=€:{‘§ iii: E;aV::=: §§<:£:[:': <3z12.z:::,i%: i.2::r{% $.53
63%
.§ . §–3 LIL
héfiif. r<":é'm"n::°z:'i 'é'i3_€.*. <'.~E*1a;:'°gt: Shiffii' E-is zi}é:;2__ s';:%:;2i3ZEié:c%{§
33:21:, '{i:2.£ie:: haai éfifii) .z’igE’2V.§i1f«,?’§i§1:%a:’i 233:5? §si§f£e;”::”:?;”‘.
for {‘2fi’hn1{-: m’2,<'§:21" -.S::«}5::§'”L.§7*; E–»{§3″
<:",t{}%;'1i;£':E.3{§€?{f§, i§;::.::,1§:, Em: '§3§aZ'E15iT?.; .31E,;f;¥.E:? :i1Téi€'§C'T§;%§1§}§T€};%':f;¥iii{5Z1i in
Easy 3ta§.:::::€:";[% f1"<3:::;.; 3*:,2:zgs: -§::~.$%',:e1g"¢:. _ {<3 i%?;'§:}'g_3:Z'31"is'f}.f%..€i {tags
€}ffi'3.€ §."¥§'0S€€"fi'u{i®§£l. '
£3. £1? 'f':;"7'£.<§§:';%}:.',*G§'.?Z_ <:3§'§.E;:;§:é {§3e3z1':c:%:i:i:r:;t:~;, 31:: :’§:i:Lr::<3 <32: Egiim
j11{§g131§:',1ii.'§;€b§§¢ilvi"§'€{i :7'ii';-.:""}}i¥39°*—"E,..€ri;31éi:.:ai i.,.2m.? s§x:}'z':2':::.aE pagei
}'3'3{' :{z'.f:;€f£..ég?s.:§311:}§§f§:%§:E'féiiezi in i€'§%%;,1£is;':5:§ a2T§;§'{f'.E.1£§}$:§'§.£i_§'1(?{%E§ 'éézé
?*«'i'2éi§.&l'2§;'2a :~'ré:<§%:",s;.i1 €iZ–:m}'"ts iéas Eiaiaizi §§§'1a.?; E13325?
mgusézrgg §'1–=:.g %;§3:;=. ::7.:<;:1":§–, :i2§"~~–§f}z:§.1'.<ra;é::. 333.1% :-:;«;'::.:ussfi}o::€ ii} :~;:éi’
‘s:r-:§;§:;’§.g ‘%3;=’a.:§:£ :’:{>’E. c:mi1§§.:i§;U.f:.$ {3}} s:,»:%’€’::t,::;§2%’
V’ ” fig <.::n§3; :m:'i:::' E§::<':{'i<3:;: :§;.;"§4 9%' £13, Eff. Hz: égissizts
j:;:..£g:m:;'2E .:'€p<;r:.'{sz:l in iii}? ;§;{}{}I«§ Stapraxna
u"%\:s;;;;g<;.. :;~:-fig? 3%}: iizi: mm-m sf mg Kvmm mam
VS. S'?&TE $9 I-¥A%YA?iTA., r£t§?<%:':"i:3g E0
.'§:s:.2;t:{§ xmia, E15: :*:-;.z:§:32:z::;%iit=:<i iizaé, £3.26 aviiimzxzte Qf
pres:-::"*::€;"ix zmé EEK: ii::’i’e:” air; §’:=:}€. suggtsigi fig
pi:z1ct§:’.2;E,§1€:i{;:.3. in £162″ s;%:2z’£;:3.:1′:€::aé shiréxgg 33::
c
53.31:} rm»: ‘m:’:<3t-1' $:3<*.£i;:3.§1 i§'?@ {:2} if} z::§.'__§;f_'§'7'1.<:'f'; L.4;i';::'zai% V.
E
' §E"A.'?}fi}:;'f,_ §:2'2,:?;. ":1?
ii}
‘:0 c?0m3;z:aii 23,13 <)§§::.:1€f.€. $213: ;}:E%§z=:z':::'é;i{;~:jz _€si«=§._§§.'-._1'i{:a's
<::3.§;£im:c gm {>fi%:=::<7i is ::’fi:’>:’:::§.1;.;§i_ :’:%:§i>=é.§:é%1*_’;.’;:.{E_;gI:1£é’:s_é :”:ip%:>:’i’é:£’§
in {iZ{}{}€§} 1’3 $:2;3z*:%::1aé {.T:s.:::22:”*é’«VfV-‘€mt 3;”é’ig.i11g
m{::§§.s9.tfg,, “flat: £”£fiEi{;,§i§T31″§”:Z_}.f:Vi’»’§f,§1i;f “§.?\>~’a,f’:}§3fViE”‘i£”:V “£3 Vffffi-‘ :’5?§&?*».I2:«:13.§’
‘s;E:<}'ug§T:»;' é':i'i;_,-iii; ii::_=:}€=i :i%é<'tié%'i'§€:;'-.' 'E§'~w.::1 27;': {i'EiS{":', if ffém
§}1'<}§f:(,?ii?Ef'§X. =23 £%.:;'é:= 'taiéazig 2:3}; the: acmzssci wiiié. sag';
*i:}:ié2"§;€:i.0i3: ii<;V1";c§(§:t_:i;:.§ni3 §§_§€;"'ifH£};1i{i1"€:i)1iI'i%€i amié <35: .E:{°:a3"it";g
.逧a;'m :"2iais€:'d '.Efighéizij ,.}}§.'€}E§€('.E_Z2'i"i".§X *«.?i§}ag§:1' :~1S5;€:3:':.E'3E§_i'2g
:"r::$;:?%%;.:'§.g§' E35-":1'g, *.§'–f;:.3§E:i 39:)?' <}:i§3'{:i€::'%_:%,s §§€§'.£'§I£E§}§. Ea; :::::::mZ%?
E3
1:
:fi*% <3? LE3"',{fi.
‘]_§A;E.? A1 L53’£§%:r sings Eszagztzmi ;3::%ari:’:§; {by
..§§:::§_ z:a;}g:3{:’2:i2mi:. <:.%§*£s:e:§ zmz:;E.E1<t;:"§L::%gg.§:;}¢:.s:.2"é: z':3§m:'§;€<a§ £13 2{}{§$
I :"%;'fa'rz:: ?£a,:'z.1a§';ak2: 332 E, ii': Eh: 1":aa€.t.z2: sf JAF.§R $§LEfi¥Q
$8. '$33 $'i'.&'E'E 8!?' §{&%$"I'&I5{A 331:1 ;~=s'L:°5i';z3;ré::t.$::':i
that, in znzgntistz' Ks {.Z'€)'E3SiT.i.€.'Ei'§f3 ii ';{}E'f":_§.f}é§1§"é§'{'f§§)1'},
z:a1*;":;z.2.1;§i':::zi::.:§$ af ;r;m:22:.;v;; zmai i':1t.'3é'§,SEiI'Ei8 z'1<:<:;%$s&:"}; €232"
é._'_?i'.}fi'1i"i'§iSSif§§:%1;<:té:, P:'r:i;}.:».i:'2s.€é:: :i,§i駧:3§’§; §:”é3::::: 223::
E
(,4;
;iI”‘fi’f:
‘V ‘ xi »{z.::’€E?:£ _ .
:;£m’£.2:::i*§ <.:*zj§Fm§ "diT;_€: E:3%i'.?C%éS€'i€§ £35"? Egiaéii".
%.I.2m; r€:<:o:*sfza°:r;£ §;2}=' %'.§1::: §3%:3E§c£:* :3': a':'3<;::':§ Liliii Eiei i'r:._ ..'§2«;f2§i§'a 31%;}.
om: E1«::«:.::r <;i"i}@.e': izzarizfé «$312., Ei3ji('f is': £3.61' s;;:'i:ai:e;.:1%:::2'€?V:r._Ef:.a: 'Ems;
ésiszii-2%; tiiaf :«;E';£: Ezaci. g of “ijizizi ::3;:<I%-2.§;~,:'-%ci""%£<$ V-
im}: 2: :;;:E.2c:wr>§a§e _p€?§3§i}(3I”iLi3iE’},'{A,A>V WE::{::’;’ ” ‘;<;3'.i.'zz~?=.i%ié:§'12§3:z::€§eg.§
<':.E*:ar:::;'e;)§::2i:€:3 $115 ;%:z:;?a;*5;€::<i <'2a£}e:j§. §ilB"Tii"– §3§;sfE'a;%§:: 'é'iE'itf§ :"<"{iz::{)*é*a:g:1
fizz: 1::1<i{:r garm::I;:i::»§ £:'iE14E§ Egizzi §"Zéi7v_§.I§C§'E'f3, ;a;:i'{Z.,A':~r.?i€? i}:::_ L
§f;%é:§.ii'3 in me ::–'i%i;<is3m5§~7§£I+ii”?€E{1 <%z*§,*:z;g[,' "£?.§:1:*::j:::::§t<=:s'; E13:
Eefi. 121::-:3: E%Z'{«:§jg,'iz'2.§g, a;e:; :5.:§1é;5 V §£':'EE,_i'§f$'§.,}Z€f§E'€I., :~sT§";.z5 s1z%:z'§;3:;éfc§€:3<i
31523,; !'4b%::V £::i§;i%:§Tiia:?:'§fi"s3 ?:'*:v3:,;?L:.__i:e"-£j:E. f3:).1f§:£§i :a1:.§,:i:33§3t. éai'; ::ta:3zi.:ms.é*i
f
:'::%.3:3£ a:.§z:~5'§%: s*é3._?:s<:é:i "§,§j_:='~ %:.§__:«:"– Viiériizxz 33% iiza {um i.::<:'?:t~:;}%.2i1’:.
:}is;£:2{_§._ §5£: £3 -‘§’L;E:’~€hEE:}é:;«%u§:’:F::4E€«,§.£:}.§.}.§ 3323 ii, is :31:
:3..%:§..£:.;;3§3§.. ;’§.§}.§’:”~f;s’:%E§”3!§;}:¥_§’§i§i§{f3: §’;,%;;§.E :’ra}.§}12g ihié vicifzm. ‘§;.2s:’:?.cE§:
, –:::3.A<:§ :"e§i:'y::v3:.'::g' {Em zmdsz' ggzimtézzfigg, if :3 1:5; gm i;;.'i€.r:§'.€s;;:1:
'§.é."e:r::}i§"1.mi"£ EéiI3.'§":§§:?1§f}{".?€, %iEt;ft:'$ $3 ::3.{_;:":% iEé;»§.3'3 ;:;:'§?p2'«1raf_i€;z1,
':_§;.:1:r2;12_”:.:%’E 3;}; {}’§f%?’.E§{.?€,
V iézfz :2§«:1i”–€f:’z:.fa was laid arm ma fiagor amé s:>’:1;I’£fi:1ipi vszsg ;m~::€:i<:é
333:3; <::22E.j;; 'i;'é:"E':(3i} six: E£"i3.fi§€'E'<':{§ ;3aéé,1:s,, a.r::"E $21531"; 253:6:
Tixéa :%":a€':::3;::z: 2::
i: be u.:’:{§€:”s§:::£i £9 mézzm (}.’§”i§f%:” f);i”€f§}£3’§i£”§3,€.§{}3i’§.3 25: ‘”i€t§’.}
air: air: “£23. §’i.:2″§h€z’:e2,:;C{-6 <1? §§';.€.{:§:E:ézi§.:': Eizars. E3.;’i::;,
£1h{m.g§.z $29: §1§§.)§1:’;?_'{if£i5 SE16 a’?1.§§§€3 $ui’31’:.1i’€.*%'<::g§ tékzifi,
z?.§":.{mg%: $2315: <*§.;:%2"°g{=. :§i'.2é%::ei: :2-':».:s: 3:'i§i:rs{-:{;m::':fi?; filzéii §£:;:: $313:
4' 32::
’33
€}f§§:’fI’}€””fi ;n:::1,t;:~:%:;zsz::>i<: '11.:'2d::r E§:é:{:E.iw::;'a iiifréfé» {sf §.§i'-".{[l'.._»-.23}; iézgé
§'{3ii<:{:, E';02zé<:v::::g. pmsem:t.i<;2r; m3i'i<*§_:§g %'I:m "::::.:§iz.;<:ji'é:¢:E,
'i2:n.a::d. t}1:»i2i. it :5; mi: 0,7§{€fE2(?€? :,:,z:;<§m* E§::1i E”3′?’€é_ M.
LE4′, ;<.i;r:.::;§ féiisfi em é3§4}';'}§i{:€?1'£_i(I.i1'.1_?.13.'1{§{f3" $€*.::z'fi»:3;). 3:22 "#9?
{ 1;: §?'.${T:. :»::'z*;c§_, i:~:.i+:3"n.é:'=r;i §JEa§'gis;i';§?£»1£«s:';' {t:r;1':';e:i2§r:1*i.1:xf§gT—_E33:
s%1si:;2:'::'3<::se emrii '£3216: .s::;'if,2z*'a€'":1::':;-1;: ciaf 'z;'E1¢:: ziiciiégzi v;%;»"E}v:ir::ri;} :<;h<:w. '
r€%.§'i@1"a'::€:{§T Eégzcé ir:Cicie:1€i 3;;;,:i,:e3Ess::; :«;–1<2i's.:$'E.§'3.?:f:' 2:ig}}.?;ij; gza:~;3e«:":};
4"'w
an -»:3:':_1ti–.:° uziiirjz" Séctizraza 3_f£;Z'{f<7f' £','.§§."P.£_i.
V …. 5:¥§3;r:,}£':,;–:*f:{V%2;:ji* :%:f::3.it:f:f:§: {<12 fizz": {';?*af7§{§E5Ii'i<;?€ 3?" E'E3£~i;§f
éfizr: «xsi<*t,i11%'r.:4z{ié:§'a:§:ée:¥_ §3'S?.f<')i'¥:: fin: ltéamzéii S~§:~:3sic:::;.s §_}22<ég::
331$.s:.:eE.)2:;3i'i='%.aei% fi::;:2; .i"%:1:r3:*:: is, 339 §1:%};€e;*§.a2.§ 9:121:E':"a:;iés::i;é.{:s:'3,5
'ix-*i}:€2§ s~;E'3%:;.-:. fiizéis :§:<a:m'.;:1::a§. §.';£:§?<::}::3 ?.§'},fi E<is~:rt1€:i.% FE-ea?-s§§;i01;i:«;
s\.§:éf€i;g;€£.'*«&_. She was ii} 3?:-:zar':s 015$ éssavizxg iifctk: §{}'i€3'2¥§{f{1g{3
VAsk:7/-§._§}:€.iE-..g:V3€':'§:;.'V":'§'.€X£_}§£ié}'§fi{:i 313$ %1'3<..=i:3€':':'i'. '§""§;a€. :%£$»;::r§.*Ef§";a:1cf?}-* if
a§:j;=; 21%. §r&I'jg' 2';:a}1;::a<3z' in 3.3.;3%::,:r<~?. gmii vsgéii ;':<3% :%i}J{§3:'
é.Et;§;ca$€ ::3f'£:1":s.:–% §"}I'f)S€<.?i£'{i§.{}i1, "i§"%:§ S{'=f:§;{§"E1'i;E€i.i}!. of '?'§€-L»? 'Tm
zirzzzszs~«€:<:a:1:i:3:§.§§.z”3 {.%:2a§5, fafzm _;:2§;Ei{?€f wézg sag}?
E:t:2€§i{7%ém £62″ $e;§§.€p:é.:3g ziazés .m’::1 mezssgzé t.}?;:e§'{ £,’3§§€;¥§{?€? o€.::u§::’§
gm? .§3.é3″€.=”€i §”}€§f3’E’E. _§><,ase;:%?i¥::=?;::.
E5. E3″: §u§};}r:.§:”§’ :11? .%i:{=3§’ {T?€’;33;’;§’;€E’1§”.i{‘>’E}.9 .:’=;.§:z’: fi’::*§§:11.::é;’
§’°§?Eés;’::..E cm 2’E’;{i ‘:2:-‘<:«:,:;':z§. a?{':§'€ii'E<.:*:a§€.$ :-maé p<;s'%.}:;E,€::§; iééfii %ha'§.
Z5
1?', 811:? 2'–5.:Ei<:=:,§ am {.216 h§:::§§g:::;éé:}.E_…<.*_i§;.zés;'§'~
§a::2m:':,<~?::i Sfiiliiiééfi' <:::s1ms:€:i %'.%;t§ $.E':«:: éi§:'§§.3{i§l£?§,i:'§'§._u3:"%} 7'a.i:§3:;-5 :7a':[:'-3-ii..€{?2"'
sf "fazzzaza §{1.u:z:~:m"'$" z;:::£$:£:
;=;i;;2i'<:12;:a":::i. «:3? :fé<7§i:.:;: {%{';<3.s 335;: :;€?{.}ZEi§'if if;:via1":*:;:%§_}%:}:"£:;=TEi{::1s
mi.) {i<.::';E'3i: <.t:-m Ex: €i'.X§'}'12i: f E225.5;éiszrhf'_s:':i:'cf:.z:§%.$Eaz.;<;':?:;.,.
§<;s:;e§<'i:";.g .z:~:°§ hm" §,t;=.:t.£:::;2&iI;.€; i_'z;m5,fi'L._t§::,a=: €:i?i{3'é:1'}i{?€é g§,'ef{?§"} ii:
f7';'{i§."§£é€:?€.'f§.'E€Ej§"i'§. siagé ci{;:'L._Vs§i§:1;;3:$' '?:i'iEi {F{)§18iS§.f:*Ei(?}='= -Eiéim
:I2
v:35_;:’s£’>’= .g§}:;:€i’;V–fi;}ie3i. ;éV$_z2s~i:1g <}§'f érifgér viaziésn acaught Ea
333V £12.:-1%ié'1–i;;:3_2$_ 5513"; é:§%:<:::2§}{.. $23 mgsssar. E"? is in 1.33:5;
'{:aa;.=.E{;{1*{§é::':z:.§' "<g::3.§:'-~5:51:z:~;s;_:ii<.2:;§.cm £32235; cm':s:%:§5:§¥:{£ Egg flit:
iéi§:}€X Vii3<:a:V:*;*£ ;:z);_a.a§.»– ;1£:i'=-»§': 2-: iliaiéii sfmziiezi' {<2 i}:.:.E§; Célifiii.
38;'-VES}:{j?M ;iiiS(} 3°v::'i3i<:v:i. an ::1:.1<::t}?:.a*r j:;:&g1}::a:~:%:2%. Q5 33%:
, £11353 ?:Z;7.a:;1z3"'§ ii": §.§:.::*: fiiéitiiééi" af §{<}};::§_3.:~::i"z.2 'i£'»::;:£<a:%m"a.<} 95:53
'fs;:é'§;«;z;:::?:;f£rj':%:§ §.},'E,3,§. :3}:-: A}_':»{3x €_T.'l<3:':;"§' has; :’:gir:§s:°:’:;’:sa::i'{u€;e, 2zt*{.<=:11;:;:}fi. ssizii 11.3% <;§'}$$5"v£<'§ ?':hai,
€i1z:az.1g.E1 fl}EiE'€ is rm <'§<:§E2}i§i::a::z :3? za.?te::.:1pL ':.E.:a7: {§E'€§§3'E£Ei,§'f€
§3':€;2m.i.:1g z:';i'é§1.'£.{:zI;;:':% 'W8S arm"; sT§§:<§ z"-111:2 (3233-;£:::1;:E{'i £3133,
ii :"€.qT:T22?:'z–:s Si'.€f§'3E§2 §,§:}%%:':4iI'{§S {Em s;:<3::m:é$3i0:s. {sgf <3§'§'7{a:':<7€:; if
gm. z»:z<:<:'2.:s;<*::§ xzzakag :9: {§i}.'°i'i{.'§ Iilifsvfiiiifiiiii '£;::;.1:;.z;3.i:~’;:~,=.is3:”: 2;:.§§,z:::” p3*::f§3.::.m;:§.ii>z:.s am: f}i;$:§€.§{: ii-‘§§,§(i’,§}
Z~»J:i'{.’§.’g S;’:’;i.’>;::£.’:_:<::§"' " §'§"{:;:§., '
E5)
2-m':m;::i.5: in .:'»§i§€:';:;:}L ;*%~§':":£: €u:":E'3:.':;:1 §"{?§f.'.{§. _..:_m 232::
_j:.:<'§g,§';3::.§';%' :'€*.§:;<';:"t.{iti in }@5%é;%%? €§'Tz'i;:,mZ::z~:.§ Law J;{):’,%
fag’: {hf 3-2.122;:-2.22:” <3? fifibfifi
$T'2§f§'E, $1315: (:i€<:is;'ie:;::§.'§ 01.' §ffi1..2§:;:ja':'t"m_" »f'7'b';.:V§1_*E;V £«1{§a{'§;
s;'::E}::;u?,t€.::a:§ tfiasai ii}.1:'i1'f.*. is :1<)"':.z'~:*:;':,§?55:::;'i §E:i[:*.t'E:f? I E?'3"i'35T"?:i:§{i§i-X
5;: 'iiféfff 47:3,:;:3§.}§:–3§.::2::3i ?';:;:?%:E+:E;§~.:»f:-fig i1:1v§3Ei<;.::<;.%€-3 T' "§..°§'.1€tf;:s.:;*;*«r'<.*;::s~::é3=:i§ 'I'Eii§$". '
€%;;<: €=.;§{i:":";'2.g":z: 3;'1gg€:s;i: __E;%§i=;%:_"é3'.._é§;z2.s; ' i:'§::::1'z%£<}§:. H:
§}3;§.3'ii<:z–i:§:::.:' éL.3}.§: siaféégtaxssiéii. §§""i}:;:a;i :5; ~j£§::i€ {*z:3s£;-1, ':',§':§::"ié ,i?;~:. 13:}
3'fZ'&§«:§I';?,£fT{" j;&*'§'é,}-?.'f.i.§"§:f._: :;_<;%¥§z.:'g2§;+%.iz:§2z4§3i »§3§,i'1€i§ €,E:Ts:2% siiciiigi 1-;E::<";u..§.<:.§.
gT3¥;}.,1:.1'i'! '~.,gi?;.'f"§§§S§;§:'i'~._£§Vi'.__§i};f:{i'–2'T%€f§fEiS£1*:£i, SE15 zzzisaa 1"i;'i§§€;'.{§ cm
a:.::;:'i§:;:{:.:3::§ in MR ‘§%;§§E%’? $E}§}1’€I1£€_.* {.f.’.:;»:.1:”‘§
:§*’=fi;i§:§f€é «:4; §:;_:»;_ $*r:.as:m $3?’ §§§AE~§AR&$E~IT§%§ ‘figs,
‘ ” Rggafiéaygg §§§§A1*€?§1A£ eaymzx 311$} s;:.:%}1}3.§Eim% ma:
“4L:*.’,’§.€.i.;’§’_§«_.”i§fi§; Cm'”£’ £21 C3186 w§;.:*:.z’€ E315: §r1l:»fi %Jé;3U;E”i’ §,”E£?éV§.§fl§§
“‘:*%}’:::;§:: z.i”;€< <"?:;:'sE’a:::.:: §.§z.a%;,§ aim: :’«:c:<:*:;$é:%:E 213$
..§'§.(§Li'£'%,Efi?i'£.i'€ii'§ £3f§E:i1£?£: p':§I'1i::;§3.:4z%31.s:: :.::':{§::§ §f.§§3f.'f§§iZ"5EE i;§'?{é
{1} :*€:~.:{§ $3-'i§ii} Stéctiéasm SE1 :3? E.%~?{T.1, 351:3 z:':{}§1§;i:ti::::"?1:':g
?;§§£713'.§ {ix} §:2.<*§s:%a"<:":'£. <2? 1'-:a;;s:% :%§.m’;’:pt ii} m.;j3{% vg*(;:i:§{§
{f’E3.’i§;E§f? .23: h£’:i,§’i1i {.6 ihti mam-3. gezaii i’1,*:;i:§£::’*%.ng %:%.2.:?=
§::a2:’.’.§§,g3:::%_12z.{:§ §’.”:é§E§ §::i;:}:;3i<s{%£::§ .;"§ger:a.2'{'m:&; i::':;3:fi§;{;§:§ja:{i:}'i. szjéf
w I
§.:2;&:? }'€'.",§3i,E"§%. 5:ga'%,:1.a./W
L;
Ejé, Efiztz iiiiféii} ‘%3§§fi§§. GI”: :?n’§.{.>!;.i’:mf ; ;..’;:__§’;;’;::.:<.::':€'
:'::§;:{3.1*::£{§ :33 Fifi? }.98f;} S32.z_;_31'€:%m£:* {'L'<3's'_:;*€f" .g§s;c;.2;?z._L ‘f<:s:zj1_ :;'}:€:
v.§<3§'im {:3 §'::.:w§: aim »%§:_j::;'§* '.:?;.m'Zs– ai:s;v– A.:’2§2’ ‘a%:;.~2é§<;:i:~ E%:;
§:3':§§3:i€.'%:aE:': {hit Eii(..'{Z'f{.}.f.~§z{'.{'.i.
-20; En i}1:锑iiig*§}1%;é;:”£’€.i3;§:V :~§’s=:§;i ;<.'{";:j:f;£::::{;§<;:i3.§;, '%…E":T€ §f;{)i1.£{
2.33.591? a,1"is:;;’;s§5.é£i.:駒:~saE§;;::;;»_iéa;
____ 5i.;§g’%£§;3.::€:_§i’a3.:”V’ViEi:: ..”_f§.V;_i:f;§Vg;1¥__z’:’;=:::zi:.i mi’ <:ns:§::*§i::;z.: 0%”
‘:§*Ejié!if.._{“i:.%_z;;”£ z”€~:quir€$ .?z:’.:{s;’§ztr£’:§::w
;i:32::i2′::_:1é:é;’;i,%;é:”2 of aiferxzts ;::_111é:-.;:E:a%}§e~3
” ~ :.;3;_1;;{,_£r3.;~ ;”§::{:€:i;<;;:: :3"f{:§ {:2} {E} §"%?£%{i vs;-':i§§::
S€;£.-%}.0;:A: 3"} TE E. sf §.P.C-T3
" 'i"'h€: .§I.1(?3:£§€'::"§§; Saw; mi{€;}, p3i{~i'£{?£Z 55%. .':;2.i_§{} P?'-{Z 53:;
';;§%A{L'a":.i"f.3:,E<}{,;3%§. '§'};£: “‘§%§ {>51 ‘$.21:-:
é§zm’1€ {§a}.f iii: vi:fi’£.fi§..§i3€}. (}i’1€’f §::a:i’ E:}z:f2>1′<:: {Em ':'a:;§g}Z;' §.:-:'£}E%{:'-{:4-Ex
'§"§1<: sE'at.s:zn€':1iT of mi: ia§:’ia;1:,, ms: L:3.:<:f}.::: 0f 'Elsa:
vi.2z:§.»s:.§.2$§§:’:i:2:'<:{.%.
':8
£3, iii:-:-2 zzga {)5 £336 vi<:;r'£3Lm, 533% {he iiazicz 0%.' 'fix: <;2i"i%T::V:'9s.,-'.%,4::;*._gi"afi3
zasas; {mijg S€'3'v"€E'1. _?{ii€'i7i'S €~z:1€;'} 22?. 81:: Ewsst. §j.'::;:¢§'3£:{3A:; E:2:&%§1::::_9:~:
i.f%1«:é §'§3Ei<':{:31″{.at;:;. & ‘§32%;%;:, vs,}’IEi€,§: $E*2s:f?;’:z§aii,
gam: is E’; 1:}; a <::'i2{'x:=:3ie:a.i:s:_. £116: é'z§:<?;–2$é3:i{§. <;~:§eii§';:{i. izsjr
;:_i<3; .
ziaiiii hi: ‘2 -<ms;;av€:d }:';s:'1' :13{;é*§;:=;;" gz':§z":§,1f::'3?:V$ 'iaizizi E:§:':'"
ticxwzg. ::éz:3.:":. shit §%j:.f§§: ;32'«3i1;.—-i:.t_.31:6'–».;"3:?::::1€}}f:1iz:*:i::" 3311:} $t.a,a"*:<-id
zrijsgimg. 'ffiiaezz 321%,' }c;::j§3*iz§§g, E5-:5: .E";s':'. '§§:.iS
:i«;*:,2:?.§=:.::3fi:1ii_"'¢.i§;§<: 3§2'é§i£*' ' -iiiff " ;§:r¢:§}z'§.i?a£:§<_%2': is “w’;2..__;.%I1:E? W.h.§:-:1: aim has s’z’;fiTz3:’:’:%{§
V_’§f;2:.i.1-‘_*: ‘£112, ‘%;i;;::’=¢_3;§§:?§T5::iz3_€91§;z-__ zgzraii i,¥.2’}”:€~:n. ééitgti <:;"'i€(§ he Efifii 31:51'.
'?§;:}I;s3 s<;E.ai€:é:'m§'é.€.' ifi fl"giv'6:§'3 1'3; fi1§: %'§.Cf.§i§i 'ea;/};c::r: SE56 vs-'2::$
;'I§i'~1§};' seiéag'; V zimtzi ii: 'was ;im§:'2§3:§.éaEeEf; aE'ft.é:<:* Efliiét
1 $53 ., 3;
ii;é;i:i€::*;§ ami ‘$2si:”{%af’i:;*:.1″ §_i:»:~:1’ €f¥§%Z§_if’i3§T€% E5:-‘i’:§.$ :”:i{r<'3§":'§,«:逧 %::jg
2-;'§{§, ?*~e"i§:gi$§'1"aE.::, :xIE'1a%:'ié?::1 331:3 §T2.:a:-5 $'i:e3%';t::c£ iéiafz
tf?;_i:€_% gaiéféfiifififli ::1:i.2:2;}::.:v5<E 531:3: §m:'.1£::" g€53;1'}3{1{i1E?;§S sizgzi Fm: aisse
z€::*é3aI:i:{§ hiss m-:2.:i<é1' g:~;ai:'m:é':':t.s; arm? iasiii §3,§i'1"§§f.;%'s3y"'§i aazzi 33$
ragga} 3a.:i.<§ £3113. }i:<z§* {}f3SE,}ii",{E she :a,&§%<:£:z:§ Eaim 'Kg: Eéavtt }::s:::'* :«§.:2{.§.
:t:"££::"§. ':33: :*a."§:}:3 33:3' §%:2:*<i.é§';–%§g; émsgi. vs;§':é::1 s:=;%1{:% £331? ;::=a3's": amt}
&.;':.:§°§ér6{§ !';E£::5{i%3':g ."§EI§j'i,1i"}" aha S"§§i§.i"'i,€{i a_%:;}=':i3'}g, §§"z§::'&;%f€:3:'
Eifzri-r E:-:~§'£ %':{:r. H61" {:v§<£s:z.:<.::*: was; :=~<%¢%r£r.i;2 size is <::<ami:';:'::§ gas;
jgifé
§:§:::":%:':: b<:=12:<'3 :3? 213;: 1I.i::::i§3;a::::§, §.,§'§%,*f=,=° 25:13.23 Emg' ;t?:sé{.i:::A
c::()r:'<}i:z::’2’i’é.§: €jf2’i{“.§’2 €:’:E;;.€i:’, ?%{; 5;<i§*,ii;z.2.3 :::§. .§§:"{:§§:«=:s3.s;?§.? "<;;–:r'_&
<'*::'s§:§§'z2:i:§.i;é,’i+?:3f:a’;_i}i.Vé%:”:i5:.:}:§«
havca ‘:’;*a{%:{:§’.3 §I}i”:锑&f)};§;}.€. <'*{;:~:':::z:é$si::%2:*. __<;?;' .311: a';§7%§:~%V3;v:':.'§:E'v:i.vE" E"§'"§;§..}€.':'5, iii.'
?_.h::?:;:"z-7: *2-%31i%i§.'§ ::3.<"; i:T::t<~:3v:%.:':E.%:;:: 5%': '–ig.é{?§;%.::§':: "§"}':.5:Wv2Z.<:::i:1:
{'-§'if'i{I§ azgzi ii" 'W33 z'3:;s§;3:': T§.12V;;f'3"%.§i;'3d."'§;3:3i::g ;~s;E3s:.3§;i2 §;:":';:i.:£:.i:§ija:
€_§fi.€3' £:'E{'€fE.3..£*%€i(} a§3}:1§"€%hJ<i_7:::'{§iz;:§§u5'€V}:1;.:: _;3€i€)f'g2§€% j5;'.–.%£§;1<::.:'; Eléis
Etjtff: Em? 1?i:$_ii1:;,
2' '2f,,2.;' i.1": €."i§1§$<; s::1:i1aAs?§§!::,&'{T3%;.£' %'§i:}2f:3$;t:S fixazxiiimréi 2':;éi£:'::if;
z;i:*r3 E-33.«%£'«V i%; g:§:£j,p§z-zégizzgié.2, ‘£§1<~: égzzzsia {;:.€f iifiiii %?ié'i.i3:§3 W311} '§'3.::"a§s
gcizé: ii'; :E;£i:* :_%**:;»§:aV ~f'§*;;:a§.3§{3§; w.éfé.E':§:2. 527:: 'izamr 523:" iégat
_.§1'::?'i:§i;§;%: éi'§::f;i:§ *.i*'_éi%'if" victiéizz, {En am-: s§.<;%§?:–::.:::?é: Eéiiififfi E}
V "~<.§z;'}:5:&; .z1.=:?’:<i €5:,33.f»f f5'1EE1§'§'if§-'. E~'§§«'»~§2 is; ';;:3;<.;:§::<*u%3,"'é:*f§ _é:i”–:3::g> 3
2.:;:m§ 1;? é;:;:’£%:>§;s::* g§:H’i’§’}{“”fE’§%.S:1; i5§§’}’3:{fh é;;e:’ra :aa:71:z£:{% as ;;&r Eéjx’ R2;
‘.1093, §-?”x?s£w5 is é’sSsis;:::¢3’1%’ S1:§’:>–§.z1$pc:{:%'<;§' {sf §':'€}}i£':€:' whai;
E'{%gi$.§§'fi§'€'£f§ 2% :;%:*i;r.§;:€:, P%};f~%3$ ix 5: €'.'i;}i'E§?£?1§'}§i? z,¥;§'3e:3 <:z;2.%;':.':é::d.
§*"i§§m. r9;'}:;;a:**;, §3*s§s"'»~? is; 1.31:? §:'2v:':s;f:,igz;a€i:':g {'}.§E7.}<:re:' fig-i';'.:::; §"":£::::§
<':'*<:;:T1{§12:m’ ‘:’J3 Pi«’§!~}i'[:’% £3 ;::.§1()’€%7:€..:’ :}Qa”..i’=:3i’ §%;’§’2§£3 §?§i.f=§}Ji’i.§.’£’E.{‘fE”§
fizz»: afigtféiiz gmré ;g;r:*2;*::% 3:’; :;’,a§:>i§.}§::m i=.;i’;2;%?’§:;g €:§’3.:::% “€;§€:.’§’;.”:'”:.iE.<:*
~. ' §"I
.°-:;of'L'::}!£)1i1§tf1ii..¢it warrant for cozrmboration in
,.o:f'£?3IiC2:* _:_§'f;"é£pfe:%_
K : higher pedesta}. The ctontradiction poimteci
" €;i1t.bf§ Etzaxtrzed senior Cotmsé} (10 1101:. altar the case of
VM .. pI'GS(1'CI1'£iO3i1, thtzy are 3101: maieziiai contraéicfion
wa1T3;1i to disbeijrave her siatement. 'I"I1e3;"e is 8.
1″»)
En}
nczi c’£c;uE;2tfu}. Stili thtiscz exzidemres do support.
cf the pw-*.2 victim. The {:o:1£radic?ti::m do
material, tlxey alfimfizor ix} I1:51t1.11’e,1:.eJa!’¥’_¥€i§:%fi(.»§f;«_nC§t’X
811}? é0uE:;$:. in thfi Case: sf pr::3se»r:”.z1tki0:;J;L’..A . . V
2:3, The mafia arg11m6I1£’Vj @1f%:’ih.§ sefiier
szrounseti was fizat, {sf _rapeH11;;rr it
ammmts to an ofiencs 1:’i1§¢:i:;f:V._’§;<£§bti0n 3'?6
(2) (1; mati. w,i~é}§ .5 had mainly
reliezi on 1:11.? Qatement of the
vi<:i:::11n.i_: AV {he iearmsd senior
c021nsel''1;n,_t'i1(: ' Kumar's" case. itself, it
is heid. tL.11af.,uwl:e:1 fhé' efiidexace of the prosecutrix is
265; ' Tiie testimony and statemézm. sf victim
{.'.'.(3flSiST511C:y* in the: statement of the victim fmm "£116
éizats: of ma §_:2€:ie:£€:1E.a Cf"
adult women vmuld have explained. Her .s§;3e5E:<e'B
immcdiataiy after the incident and
€Vid€}C1C'.'€ before the Court, 1€»'3§i'ém£i11j:' giguht £33:
sf the Court. Still}. has ‘;§–;T1 he1»*” {iwém
making out a cigar cash ..§f¢..atte1iipt. ‘ be ‘V
treated as (31113? 3, .pz’ep.a:”at.i(§n. CE 33:: ifiiiczntién. The
lealuxeci 601111361 has” theLT (ia¢1:3.i0n of this court
in me mat1}€:r__ Qf géfsr “#008 Kanzataka
E321), §i$v;3″§i1v{é”Vf:1ecision of Koppaiu
” court has obsérvcd
{hat line between the preparation
‘=afE.t£mp’t .-1;as’44c$bserved that the attempt is a
4; &§1″€3Ct magfémeni: towards tha commission after
fgféffixagémtgon, as (2311 be seen fmm the evidence czf PW-2
her statemfint befom the ?o1ice: and wound
cej;’tifi§:fait£: and the blood stain which categoricaiiy
$1::»:.i.%:s the case of an attemgyt, not a preparation.
36. Sector only state-,3 that, opinion of rape
cannot be given ha has not stated that the attempt has
not bear}. made; Wound certificate mid the biood stain
fourad by -ihe: ciocter do suggest tbs attampi: to Commit