High Court Karnataka High Court

M/S Sundaram Motors vs Sri S D Narendra Babu on 25 November, 2008

Karnataka High Court
M/S Sundaram Motors vs Sri S D Narendra Babu on 25 November, 2008
Author: A.S.Bopanna

3»LHECIKD:iS3& ”

MMMA &V1’»iG*§8§%I”‘§ a 23.; “a
mama mvzm

EHQEWT ‘
“a*§mwm’:sr ”

.-IQ ,LumMams::::§::

mmtwaaa w&:zw%m:& «:§:§«ag.L A *

am; 999 -~ ;&*m:;*§*a’%3s§fi’*i * . 1 %

..m¥m &Wé:3;f?$.§«a%:§§«m?§€V.4′

Hmm I2;-zmx”

~i.«fK3fi.VwI

xzmtmw
gm ‘£.’I>:~I;_ m.JaV1=~I%”&’,*%s;{“;f;;r& “€;”3;_”‘£v%.”3 w M
savm a@%J¢m{“,:«*e§”§~*::;”1*a$.;*fiai?% *

nmvez Ammsmam gate: k:a.:w*§:Jm;?g%

i:«mF.w

mm imzrxcxza 2%; mg mi

‘H.I.”&5i’I!«I;?-W£.}’nfFf’* m: V 3%

” _ Q g””i:{F»fifi”N@flm«£

_—-Ma zxuamm WH*a&m%;’3 %.~Iaf:,:«-igm 3%
3;m.¢:.a &::1*a..m;w$m&i’m

. .f”£m 99$ — $?m*”w”+&WE
‘aC;Wv%t:~a£ wamlsw fi»:m~m»;

‘ ” % %m:§’mE fig
mafza g M

&13.I\IOi.1£,L3& ”

‘ :mmmag

%%E&*a-%~aI%§*z)aa§é<;'?ikia.agIt*¢M aamm mam

'§3'a.*';!§:I'*?a4'§:?IIszZ3__8f'$ '6; 3aI..Lsm'am iE"iE.«.%¥£Z'9?§-E ~a*:~:§,.,£.

Q % é wmm
'EDGE aéméfixmmfi mm mm mm mm mm %CEI$."§fi§*'Q

'HHQ"I'€'.3£zIVfi .LV VH"u?iV$§&V}i Iii'; §..¥1'1G3 I~I%"§I«~I fl-LL ME.

'3 Hfillul VVUIHNHUSI an nmn-1 unnz Hmflummnl An I*.\Inl"\"\ usmu Hxn-rnwmsmru Jn nu-an-\ I_l¢'IILl

Uf\I'-lllillllilii _lf\ I\lf\l'\"\ l..l£\ll.£ \ul'|.IInfI\nllt\!\.uI\I ll\

ftlfififi i Ifiil

I kiawvul VII I'In-II\x4wl'lxrI.IVn1- IIISII %1I'h[I1I &I Ifi"'IllnIl"1ll"II'|I1 IEI\iIl EZIIIII 'III IIl'II\I'Il'IIf'lI\l'I IIIIDII $33!': if! IE'Il|'IIl"Ill"$\I"1 IIIIIII '–'7'O'-'

7

‘army; 39 ztxgad Egg; Ivar figmm gm xmmw mg m mm.;:g§ mxfi mg
Jmmm mg 3:11.:-zmfie mam ma-Lg gzmgmmfiamx fig ~”§iT.{‘;§. “ismfigsfidzm

fifig Qflfi 1’I.IQw.Ifid’%.I gag mg fiL

“wt 9&3? 9211 mm; ‘[4:-mmm magma 9%; mg §IJ;.1:;§ev;a«::x==*::;;:;«~§v
*a::.nd’ag’p mam “E-I =39 paxwgmm aq gmmam mmz§é*:;;:: —

ix; aqndegp utmwfi am mat; ‘gnvmmw §>’§1’1:;~s~aa¥t§»*.?’;;j}£f§2::£\wgi§.*::s:§»§e3r«3m;:’

3;} 9%, JG; Eaflaflflfl

‘;m3%i’3’ §?xz:”m:m*; ‘étgfsg *

W -W “Tim
W: m Eurpmmv W M:

mt wt wion-W e$3;#kj&:?§ikx¥r9’§m«%r«$ wgzmgm
amaw mtg ya aazrgmx
93 mm: ‘p{fl0=A§..3.§nc2:3v pamrammwab
9311 0:1 9113!; mm mam .?:.*:1uqwg

am axofiqq .. avg; “apma $3: mmmz

‘pgmmm. {mmmm

am; 5:: 9

wt% was wfiwémgm fig am

” fmimrvvé mvma mgmmmw

*aLvL9F%L%gza-aiégyva mmazqa mmmmm: W» mm
mmrx mm (1% afimil $3 ‘r~’m~1–~aw’&:.L§ wtmm

(III? AVHfl% & 3’} Wk €I “I EPERVQ

-.4. sun.,n’.”4v-nan ‘lflfiili I..l\tLl°!Iulll\£1ul’\I J!’ iflflfi-\ XICXH

‘ ””’V ””””””””””I 0’0’-“‘ –‘l”‘_’!I ‘II iirwiivrniriliru itlhvnl 3&3!!! VI I\l1ll§’l”|sr1l’u’1 -|’ul’$’l’l %€’¥l|I Y! “runny;-uurwu-n IIIIIII 3&1’! ‘VI iII’II’NIVw–

U
I

‘T

mg H1 ‘ya zw mam» aamfisgp {FIE mqg pvarmwmsa mi

Wow 1; ‘Xmap firm: saga pmmyzmxb me; warm mg

31913 9? Blfiflfiyp arm umm “min, umgmgsum mg ssmm

01 waacs mam gm mzxw mg.

my an 138% mm am; “gamma smaxiwg A’
‘mm mm 911;; vs; *gm:fi?m mm E1 *t~15@t1;gr.:s ‘

my 50 A35 mm 933; « ‘#133

fiaxpsmxom amaa mm mg

1-mitt: a_1’q1 axwaqi ttxuggaci 1g’.z,zm zit;

am Kg ucmsanb EM; ‘mama Jsiq

apum mafia: 3:: mpqh gamma
Ia-mum IQ pamuvaz m:fi.;Cé1..«a3; mg; 3%
1aen.wd V ‘1:-tmunmr paspnammmzs

3% modern ;j;w%§V étfimgm rm éilxmmwu

as 1; ‘Wm a%;§:%,;n 2%: W W


V. W
93, ammmgm gfl 1t;’¥§I§&’2fi:W@
% 13% mm wwfiww 3*” am M
j my ‘spam; uwq ssmn; *i5%a”3E$%%..W_§;”§§J

9% “W 1m 1% Wm amW:;.z;m ml

zignanf on, 1q3n«/M mmmpv ~y.’mmu.m*sw_3 gmuaxmaq

Elmer? gm §»:;z~ $..If§:”a:.fg’H’§.n:_

mm

u ‘A g_nn..nu.:nn\n…n1 nI\ l\1l’\J\F\ l..I£\II

c
as

T

mtww ammmzt ma 91:1 W -rwmmuzad mu. mm*m*a

as awwaa meg paemnmyp was :1,uam:::ciam- W: am

am am WW; Pmnmw ma ‘WWW mm:

“swag mg; fitxgugagazzzg paxjgmuf gm mm 1 17”:
am mu; spntmw 4:33 W was xmnciwp Qfwfi . ‘
an Wm Wm mam wax aw; :mmmmw:2?mfi%%
mm atintifiyp am milaqm wk 9% mm
“ti *mmI==m-‘msm1=m at 6,693?

JO emI.rp'a mm aim   
9 0% mm Cu pmm    mrm;

111%-Id W1 ‘mm II; ;#;an:&?a=:’§r swag
W fix 1.’ ‘-Wm Hagmmum mu ‘:t:§5’§:% W N
9;§g3″éj eH ueiswvaub mi}, mgagmwzga mm

W~¢*’;3*% 1: ‘méw rm: mm mm

‘ V V pmpgnnm m mam gagm a;1;wz:gm*r'”L

@333: max; swan; wm axzrw mm ..mg2;§mma« ma
W1 1% Kzarmmtazn W Frmm 1? ‘axmfiwsgw am
% U: may wt; was»: “am am Wmmrg ma Lima
3:65:13;-§ 91:13, ‘ammgm gmmeagd am; :,::aws..@daanx

am .19; gamma”: mumg mafia; Tegazrgtaggsmu “am umgpwp

Illlhlll tJhlI..II§_lLI\II..l\I has nasal’ IIARJII LnlIJuLtA’;I\!ya”Ll Ir\ l\Ir§é’\!\ f-i£.’\|Ki t.l’\ILI’I\.l|l\!|.1\K It’: &\.If!I\’\ {IE5}!

n.nuna\nnuoAn\nl…l|l can .155-nan-n. n u…-1uu_:nu_:gxu:s_rnn :4′ xsnnlutnuh.

It

‘i

9:1 lmm ospa warm waamyax am “§¢i§m’€;”–;¢$i%§T§i3’_” ‘V
art; 9: paxapgmm seq xmmzm eaizrifiagp TA

am an mm 0:’; mum» go:

wag mama agqt; tmmm ‘wrxwea!
may 91;; 9119-ayptxg mu aw:-=:§’..’9;¥?.;;~.’gf3i.zé zgrfimmzgz

‘aam rgugzmnfi my r;z§«’:. *f.:xé-5+:>;e:r,::.Ei;z:u mgtrgmaz

pm-w fitrrmxm mam
umwmwea ELI; wmfimfimggj
mmmpuz am EW§~$é%§ mm;

W 9?! 9-ma Wm +39% 39 mass “fimwm

_;e- mm “v–i;:u3§:;?£1es:._’-LV.sa7g:~1:§Am xzmng

‘W3!-I %%e:fiC% J?%W?m mm mm was mmmwwi

‘ mi’: ~$3»§»13iIwdwx mi aw <33 simzm am
" mggmm mm mg; 'pe:–;zaL§%mm%

" " % ma HE Wm 1% W W131 mt

"saws: mgzn 113 amlavs mm my -m:m.';m»w
0:1 Hgng Jag mafia sq 'gm pynmm 1'; 'map nzaem mm:

mm imam aoups: pasta zmgiyzad ngzm. mm 3113; f;-.:*.»«.;,%§:."m:»,;§ £53, afimfi

-_.. -.- an lulu gun can. nnn.-n4’n. : ‘..nru…:nn.1A=I\:L:cI

I\Il\f\I’\ II:-\us |.n.n.::|.tnI1n.a’|I ills l\If’a(\”\ l…t£\ll.I I-l\l\d’f\u€AI\l\-1’6 ..I!’\ I’\£l\f\”\ LIE!”

uuruxuluu-nu:-‘nu-n LUIIIIII Vuwrittnu ‘pi 1:1»:-In-I oauqvuu —–_–..– –.- – —

‘I

an m 6% I10-yam MW gm mfiw M fim§~m§%mm

asggzujan mmm xrwqvay awqg mgpmfaml gum nmgaa ;s1:.mmf'{

an pm; £{Lm uaggafi “ggxm mjqz. gm éggaaazfifipg §w:;

5..-. ‘uuoulsa uni: I snuaiwnluvifi .Il’\ litflfifi Liflll

wt: .10; pergxmq aq gzmam ‘Mme mgtg;»;;vm..4w:.a;§:’3.c:;f.$;”‘:;’i;:3.

fiqlnm ¢:«a-pm}: magmtamu am gm

.:t%et{ vs; -3.; *wm.1m.za1m Jag iésgszgs-gx

win It; Wfinmr mm 31;: zw
wise mm Wm rm 91:3
W3 Wm LIW1 mi £;:;§;’3mW rm
llwwua munm »f?9T«11
mmynw an rm wfi”tfi5 E1:

mm mm ‘mm
W?» W9 ‘WW arm-W “Er:

flfiaxwmpgn aggqm gamma sq},

go wag ‘i;a{ifs*ac$.§’a;i;é3L: gzmmxa mm masqwg am,

3 gang} saqgééig figmg muagz mg ‘g%n§mx mg;

V. Qmfixam 9: .a:’f.r%mmm’3’§ Wm ‘gm: W:

rutuvungo :3 cw-scan nu-nu:-win:-1 uvuruu ‘nun:-nu war-

a ‘flaw; % mm1m_ _ pxnmm smwgsax: ‘gm :;m@ ‘

– –up-run: -.u- .– –.—-u-:-umqnuro uuuquuu

mmam am ga ngmwdaea gym 432:; m”z:::;sj;:::mw

Mm mg ;mL:{; aqpwwmg: pgnmm gyms

souzaxmm 9111 $9 1%? ‘gfigmmga ‘mag fig

Z”;

. . -. nus; ..u.n- unngaun

am 3a ta fi::gm_; sizrq §§a:;;:mm.£
ma gm amclggp mm}

gm Ems’ xnmwg am ‘mm %’r.:e::§ a m;;

Wit 1%!-1 3%?-I3F’Efl?-ma ‘”‘@J.%’~”3%l=
,wp.;¢ c:«:_x.~ zf_:;%*;;;s:§;$ psmawciagp m; r.w;=1;:s;;:e:£ §w:z«a*gm;ammm-

?#uni%w»I3wqa mm? min Wm w:

u.z:~a:p.w my gm

V; megmmqu my _;a1m9§u$v:;{at;:m:; ‘L.I’£’§%3€} ;zszm%t.%{

Kg aq fimrga amxaxagaux §§§ imzsww mgr;

‘MW mm ta ‘mt Ema ? =~ H; 2% 1%; mfiwrmw

.-‘\ untu u-uunmuuuu Jl’\ man-x untu uuuawum-N :n nznn-\ unnn wsiwnnuuusa an i)Iflfi’\ unlu uuuxvzunuu 4n mnrn B-19!!-I \f)l’d’1\’INHV)l JO 13603 149::