High Court Karnataka High Court

The New India Assurance Co Ltd vs Gopinath S/O Venugopal on 11 December, 2009

Karnataka High Court
The New India Assurance Co Ltd vs Gopinath S/O Venugopal on 11 December, 2009
Author: S.Abdul Nazeer
  . ::;~<,s?g:,::::gi;;;:~;:::;, ..

 

E3 T'§§§§ §'i§fi*§'§ SQEERY Q? J. 

&'",€:%§@ A'? 3§&§§gkL§&${:f~.  '  

aairggs TE-£8 Tag 33% may 9? aéfigmtagx ff-.  "' "

Efififififi   _

$33 %;;as2~:-mes' gem g§¥.§$*i"'§€E 3.; é,fiE?;'§L:§§§;?;EE§R   '

§e§i$SEfL£&I%;F;$§.'€$ gems': gg§?§;§_g,2§g;§§gé$;2La§§i.g::§¥:;; 

§§§:'.1'§"'%'.:"   ;

"E315 §\§z:mr Emirizi f'a3§§..:.:":iz1<.t-x:'%. {77.s:33f ¥_j,.-§:':'§.;..V  
§"3}'£'.{31{3jh iT.}.i¥"3€-:3 ?2§}:3:;3:'{:, " V '
"E".?:':§*m.:.g.§".: %%§--:g;1§;::'::::.§. ifffiziiifi _  .4   
€91 Kaiingéi Riga» i'€<:a§:::'i;}:j.__-'    4' _  

gag;-;Tg;a;;m~a~::aa§«:;:,Ms"§*

{By 8:33 ii;S'§i§'},'Ei§ii%.§;i'é?§;f;3§2{,35Ei"};:éii.;'5, }'i{;iaa§

§3L?*§§} ::

*i~7:§j an ,"é:;::r;;:;:g%;;;a1,
   7:4;;i3$':s.%.~;$¥}.. }-'€£3£'?%§
' ._ §'s§§:.«;3I3, :§§27é_ {§§2'3 s$,
' 3¥££:§::1j:::::2,1§i:§3 :§;";§g,22_1*:3.;
;£:§mg.;.:'§33~8é§, ii}??? €Z.";mS:'~;,
 fiffiagagii §i':".:az};,

E%a:3.ga£:;>:'<% » :'3s';3{}*G2:3R  fiEv3:§%§;'=I£%?'r.Zi=;?"% §}E3§'§'=:§"§'§%§

$3}? Sfi. E?i'a:§:§;£:§1a_§ 2%.;§'v,§*€::::" §%?--E

 



3
i3i{'s,T"i.E§'§'éTi{§ £35.: §}":.7."¥5 T£€ZL;2i}{}i.§~ "§"§§§:g.':: i$ 1.32:3 s'§'§.ss;;.3's.:'iz.*  'ézis fiié.'

<3<.=<'z::':"£z.:s;.#:=.= 23%" {£36. 2':<;'§;:.. "§'};=::* ce::E},> c:~s:.>;:$;€%.::Ti:2€>:: §,i§'gf;".'{§ '$.33:

iigf Es-ai3*m=s:é, e;:<3':m:*:.€§ $2233: flay 2-;';:3§;::§§;»:::é. 21$ 81.:-gi rim e;p§3a::*..§§va'z;::,?;;a._'

:5::;':am"€:'  not §;§,.z1§*3§é3: is 33-3.}; :i:;.§'% f _§;%:§é:'v

     

'si"iE:ia;'*£ii= ii': £§'é;§~:?§sE}5~:32"3. 21:. §§':a::% £:;%§z::;;;»m': §'.i§:s;é;%.L' :7'

*:'s;§.~: 0f {$163 gyiéiiiziz ;:".*L{i.:*;'.

 

5:3, E;«fi?.';4¥.'.'i.'"§'.';jt'.'ti.§ ::?<:é:  §'€?:§'§IE{Lsii§€jI§i:?§':E :2;:,:E'}.::2i§T.:a;

 

   

§§::«;:§ *§§§.{.'.  :'*::::;=;_§:§:i§'s1:é§;és;.§' %..::e:V§;'::2_§Vé;:":    <Tr'§§:::=.=:é§--:*:'2§;é:3.g

313:6: i:z3'§32;:g::§1:§_V j:,§s:'§'g.;1§;é7~.:':;..i  :%:':{.§  :2£»A'22::z§ :§:%z~:§§é.":'§g

if3'IE'§§i2iI{§iI?:2'§LfE€f2'1i€'iii5:."-{i?2:}§?;3.§}€ii:§E¥;£§§'E§§§:§§'"iii :;'a;'§E35E §'€,fi§'§,{}?'f5%§%$ "§'7§i:';%$

€.77:£};::'E  T "2::;%5;:»::j::'§Aa:.:5§A'  :%:.'§{§§€i§{;::.:».ii s:g;2::<;;:2<::'1gaii';'4i§:.§'§'£$é:{§ {::§{3§2 Sim? ..';;?€;%{}'?=

 2§::'3€:§ €«::»:.:..z3ss:>:¥§ s2g}§>$::»::*é::g §'?;'}:"

  22.;--};§_}--§§E}3::;§'.2§.'  .%':2§}::;;ié'.s; :':E2a:. :.§aé;= zége.-zézi 42339:? %;i='E:i-S $35 iazzi. zezggzcrzm

 §,"s'is_§" Z.2 

 

 é;§.:§a':2§«:.:":§2 is 9:: ;3§':f E;.§::-t» §::*zi2';:§=7a:'§

.€.f§ :';"m'zE ':Tr:3V=g"~:=,:~.:; _ ;%:.§i:&:f';



é

   
 

gfzzzigay zxihérs 7?§:2«1€§ paisgaéai i'§:::~ _ju:_:§g;33:é::::';£ éiifiii 2:§*<:;:.::::§ ..:;.§'I

{}3,{}r:'§. { :_3'?.§.*:}:/':§~}.':_;'S::§§:4:3~?H  " f'*'v'3i§'3"3

Ns;w'%43;{}?j 2{}=£fZi&§ $3 $:,:'::§§e<ri 21:} fizz? <§::<:r:%§§1?¥:}:3. fig}Ti',%--:é§;;3;3§:2t*Vé:3.  

.

:3. E? :25 z-zviiésizé; §:*3:…_j§;”

Ei>:,§%3.E 3113:? 31″‘: %;é;:»:«,.§ mi: ;~”g<:£' §3(}§;§£?}".x"'~._T'§ZiE 'g',sré'::;:'é.::é;: paészi v;*2's4.:~'s

§~?;3¢3?5f – ?;fl'5fl£f£i£'E§fi-E §1?22z§:}:Z;§:i§_.j _g3é_:i'§3§ii7 ';:é;;;3;; Lé':;+:3ij=;, '"§""hz: §;{3§§::%'fg*

féiai 21$? +::{:ev<:;z" ':32:-=. zésigi of 3 ggéiéiggczz ééiiééy, i-323:: -€:;7'E%3;_"i_%:§a1:§ gszizzzéig

$13: 23:3 %R.FE~}S 3: §,:§i*§3;ié;'r«*.3 .

,§’Z}~,§fi§’E§ ‘£33.

$3; 2

§.¥.$§;§.§gg?,;§§2§§€’.§§gi§ fiffiéggggg R.§§G§§”§Z§ »- gfi gszsgg

Si? ‘itzaé; Esgi-‘éE»;:i’_V ihazv a3;:=*§’2<:*.:':;: me <i<3:;.E;':%:{?§. <35 :§,§§:=§§fii"E%.§i{I'€.'

€ffE.'.§*'».5'{.'Kff£"§. fgéaéig »:§§" '–%1:%':é:'::i _§§:=;«.12"§'.§; E323: §3.:'s£ 3£§'.§:~".§§I, §:::§' :iSié-::w”‘:>s2:ag £235: z;-§:’%.;::’:z::§s::=.::§ iii} a §§i.§L’§{?§% :.*§s;’i{:3,: E? ;:_§§;

§*;?E.:;”::” :7é;;z:£V”;%;»i§;§s:gf3:;%:; $1? §;§,:2:”§::séE%:i§=* :35 “$.32? §:’::+;m”::2_:::;:s’;* {f.A:’3:”§:§}.2,2.::jaf

E

4′ ‘ — %:%%:.::”:’:s 3325333 L’aEE{§§f.§’:

iwrrs {E153 cgriiréiifi {sf 3i:1$m;*:»z33.€«:ié gt€;sar::3’s.z;i
zigiér {sf *{hT?;.:”e:§ ‘p:c}3°:’j; %:su§: ::<:3£.. Eéfaai, ef {3"2x';33€":' €31'

§:a;é}i§s::z zigiar efjfif §'éEEl"!L'§ §'° :35 $25

ix

5:3? §;§’::§§.:’§’:r%.;’;§7::. .

“:*é:;§cL:%. g”§.’–§;:7$ ;fl=.~§.”.iai’*..,’2*’~;’::’v”:”.,:’,;f’::’f,§V:3:;{‘ $3’: ‘:§’.:é;: e:x::»;:~:a€ 23%;’

:5. $3: $3 {:33 s:is;;2:.1’%2§ “£:§2;::a:: Ehzaé. %:§3s:*. <'*§:i2im:»:£:§~ 13

;"§:gjg;<s:':':£;§£%3';%' issagi §E§€e:"§ gm. a:g':»g:vz~?a§ 31:1 §1m§T .~i-3§~”*§’é}£§”{.§ ”

ifI}§3:€i.E§.iI_T€;i’§.’i€f;fi”E’ crzf i?€}§’_i.1§3s£’.1″3§”-3é?i§:72%:.’é-EL E5; iééiié 3:é:’i-ii :a:;3§:s¢_f’

€ji<mz"i' %':;"es:,3g ;a;wa1"s.i:E:;§ z§i%:%é§i:3z:.£2E {','i'3EIi§}s3§§é»§E:1§f;{}'§IE'_ éf_"%f ?§"~?§$.T§–:igi§,,3{'f%{Li§'*~ ' .

'§=;=i'§'_E': i:1i£<;'e:s§ 22.: {*%*1Z'¢%: '§}=:%;' 2;'z3"::':s.:::: :i.’; 515*».:A2.:e;;’2<§'z;%::';i§'… "A.

§§»;1§i;='g%.:s€:', i:Ea.;” %’:;::-=’.é:1g; :3.

‘2?-‘-‘%.€}€i:¢i}€% magi 91;; §E’:;e::’ «:.ia}’g ‘{§i2§:~2 {T:s::21:z”§ i’;.::g;§a <:j'§;»&"%;'"5"§§:%.:_'i._ t.:§2§i:é.':':

_' "am ?'_é;{?§ 15221;' i:';::a1,;;%':».;':::{?:?

” .§”§%7é:1’E”{‘§ .§i’,”‘.rII=’§fg”§’§§f:*¢–i’:’1§-

arszgizzz gri’/v§,E2.f§x”‘V :3:’3.:’§I.

‘ £§%ss:._§;:;»§§é:?st:E «:3? fm’

§.:2:e§.a;’2<2 .§%:;:..i"

V' .§;.%3%;- é§f:::%;é§.':::::wy:°i:. s;7m'§.1§,7§22§4:_§,' $334211 éézx? €:::s:,m¢::::z;'.?=::=

"'e_f=;:§::;;;':é2': – afiééé} §:»:"z:§7:::';*:=3.:.i 22:5: ::2'g;;§€:::~3§
":§hi:és=S?é'i£§§:;:::::;; §:§2§§'£§..%E'§-= :;"s_":'§i.§ %;.§':::»3E. figs: :?g§’§::;a:’3: is
;;;é:’méé;::?g’ 311:? EYE §’%3{>..<'%-§§€};:"§§ Eiéiéél ;+:§::.i i§E€I'sif§:€}§'€.~E5

{;:ai:,%:é;é:3_:§; :::f§:§2§§=1::€.::% 5:3? £335? {;'Ii§"i£:1iT§£,'-€i'§§_ g%,z;:{:s%.§::§ Iii:
V§2;'zL%?"~«m;$;u3:'*-zigiriigi. fééfifi fig: zzzazifisé :=:§:.::§'3=3§§is;,=3' 33;} aka? {§§§§',i'fs:fé§.§§if

éfifi: :§::%a:%§s:'é::»:} ix; i.'§1:': :':s':h§r::" :,=.':§3p~3::2:§ fiisizif E;:,=' €,§:::*

.f§;§'2.§«3g,'§_2§':v'i:::{.%z–:-; :'..'%:}EE};§};';§.s §éa§L:2’£.§i:j§: ix

{%:};€:<;t§-::i:3.:*.<:§;. '§'2r:z: :«;;~::§:§ §s:.a%§:::.%§;$'i::: is; éA.é”_?{7’§i§_}i’£*3i’§ 323:3.
s;;:§*a:§.s::”{%< i m:<t:3'§:§.:é.:§'1g.§j«;'.

ix

a

“W3

85 §:.: ifiéisz ‘§3.i’::5;::;:1€’ .a;p§,”;::*;.z§E, E §;::»;a:§-:- izgsiéii i§2a=.£ 3

é1§§”§}é:*–§§€E3§£§’*3:E33:Z1’i’i1″é§,E}.{‘§f {,’€}’23_E_§3?c};Hfg’ £3 112:3: E’§a.E::Ee- §{}_….§}é:?:j’gi ‘

<::3z:';_§:z:3I2:'§2:'i;%e;;:1¢ ix: §a§_%'E§ §¥§a:2~.<'§ E{}?';'2{}{3€s, E?' 313235 Ti::§"5:3; :?§;:4:t:"§§ia%%;E{'

SE33? £33:-3 E;ia§}fi3"ii}2 9,? 231;": é;.;s§u;*a':3{?E.§€}££;?’§’E3i'<1f{' .;§.;3 V V%:§::€

ézzihgzzzcziai :é0:n;:::::23a{é:'3£3 £3 3-'%:,ziV;«g?§:=i?;'-._ 3;: {£265 £§V€3;é'_."_*§S§_£;%§'}L:.i;i5;i.'

€3.85 .:e:'§3*;;}::ai, '?.§::e:*€s.{{:::'z;g '§'i'.§f;' é'3'<=;75.«-"§1%';i1f"t'C';é.§ 233:: '¥'cE':ié::§é::j :{§":V1§5sE,é£:e:':,
;:ams:%§§g, $33.5: Sii€'{3E1{.T§. I€ff'i'*'s}:;2i}I.'§.€i{iIiv§'»-'§ifi§*€2§EEV"-£3: Eéa:'i:§é:"~$:;sV;§213* '§:}:€:

Séfiififi 3

'5}}._ in _»§£g;'};:'?"~w.;:;§f".. {E223 2§§:3:cz:%a¢:a:%:§ :§_§3:::":s3::%é<3::1g 3
;:e:'~:2T:«2;:s;:;+s:.§ 'E:T'§§:Te:*: ':§é;:§§mz;.='i;Vig; '

Qfifififig

2.} a§§€3:~’¢§::’E’ “Rig: 3i::3;§3£2g::€::7E §:§:;§g:::;aE:;%i
1 $13 $53 .§z–u” 21:3 {£§:’§:%<.*-éténg %§z::i g§§_::_§§%,E;2§:§:~
' §.§§.:$€:§3g:::€ ::?:::§"g;:§':s:=§§§§° E-:3: ff}:-3}5' $;*}§:~:% é:i:;=s§::§;:{éi:$.;§%§{}1; 3:;'i-§

1 i::{~::'z*::§}§;' .;§e':fs aséaifi.

* ._ ‘fizz: 211*’-3 §”{f%§«2’§3§i:{§::;§:§;i .i:~: iéigéfistéarjsgi 3:’; gssggx figs? :’-:§:’:§;z”%”:
{23mfg3€é:s3$2é.E’§0§: £:”§§3§5″2?§E’i§’€i’€E 53:}; 1:23;: ‘?:é.%m’:;a’§ zizmi, €;E’s

R;

»