High Court Karnataka High Court

Shivaram S/O Vithoba Chauhan vs Asst.Commissioner on 22 April, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Shivaram S/O Vithoba Chauhan vs Asst.Commissioner on 22 April, 2009
Author: Ravi Malimath

‘A 1., }3;s;s;i.{ji<3%£n?:;3.§:§5;i<3£1t:z;

IN ‘§’}§E§ H{{?;E§ <:9 §Af:*{):*z- APE%;:,. _j2{§5:’;§?:_

‘BEiF{‘3§2}E: :

“E”§%¥:”: H{}§§’E§LE: aziiwz.-.m’e;*:jL::’%.f:§s: R;€¥’E.__MA;:ii%f§£2¥%¥i”
vs??? PE§”i’£”§TEQE€ rs:;r>–;3i§zs85gg0{;§§i,,;£%; V’
E3§:Y§’¥.?§§}§§Z§’%: A’ ” ‘ V A

Séxivaram 3,10 Vitijxgaba {3’5:iés%;}§V;’;~:1i1′,’
Page .333 years, 4 g .’ V’
{)<'%e:s%ii§e*ziE<s;i1:a:; L2';c1}£:::r:€é'{};-}?,, T .

R/<3 Ga&£ega.GB,-)?h'aIi'éia., .. ,

Post Y€kkam~§};?£,' BaS3Vé:}_«:a.iy8:1,

Bis:ri:~2£:r:z

{$3}; Sri. §’§2Hf;§213va§:¥i E3153: ..E%’.’;’;\§a§}};i§aii1, Rziv}

AN ‘ ” _

V x “§%asavé;§§.ai3%é:1:1,’T'<3: B2«:$av'ak'ai3:aJ::,
§}Z;.$'§-3€',é'.?;'.Y"£ Big?-:=:;i

SL2. "~7E':}§:1§3;:id:_g§;§ cum Qffistfir ifl Crhiargfi,

{}Iffé1fii Pa11c:§"1§:«:ya:i1, Ladwanti,
A At. T§.v,:§zii*a=e;'a1mL, tq: 8a.$avaE<a£y::::13
A 'TL—Qisuict Eider.

‘Ii Jj_m€i.i¥f {)i1i;_}§

F Aged {:ib01i’f’. 2:3 §f’€iEiTS,
Gear: ?v1sznbi*:r i.,a{§_Wa1;1:_i: *2}. £53.,
Efc; E.;1{%w:»m{i, Kg: E%z>2s3va}<:aT1j;2:T::,
E_)is'£I'i<;2f §3i(ia&1'x

Ogw.

EV

%. {3E”;.}§%*;i”€{:>a§ xx?! (3 Kalidas Patii,
Agcad 4:73 gears, {‘?ics:”:: ¥%.»’§e:’:3,bm* L:»1c’§i5;’a%”rzii {f;,P.,
R10 Gaiiifigaaix, tq; §§aSava§{2-,==;i3-‘an,,

E’§i3i1″immi$3’si(;:§1, ..
C-1.m::i:’1gh.am Eéaad, fizixzgazigm. V’

{L}!

” A. _ §2:::’¥s§’?gj>v?%.;§..3 Ef%:*1’§;

{By §3§i.A::1z~3r€:si} E39Re_;’a, fxziv fsr

This W)?’ 3.5 iiizéii-.._2§(r..{i:§§§ afld 227 {if E31:

C0″n$%’:it’ut,i:3n of Emfzia prayingLit)?1£311.53;é§}1 j:1é3’iifEcati9:1 data}
:?,2…:2@{}e2 in f’;i:::. §<;3._1_m.g:§§i;§i3?2'::§:~:":R;i:2{}{38~€?§€? issusd 2;-gy am :2'

E'f;"iSpG£iii€E'3,€ xziiiss A§;;:;:-1:;x4;::~e~§3 <:'i<:,_ 3

"§"§*:s,i::;"'§!,§-*. {%s.fi§.:%::§;Pf&3imm.a1y E-{caring 'B' Emup

this; ciayg tjizse £?'.0u.§"t zfizatie %i'fi«":%&W'01E9s,x:iz1g:»

CERBER

_V §?§i4i£'§nd’£:11″€’é§.%1d for a wréi 6%” manéarxzus eiirszirtiiag Em: 5*-E-“E

i=::%sr;3;y:§z§(i?e:*I:i E0 csompifite the éisquaiifici-H3233 precesflitzgg.

2. E.{°:3§’I.’§_€f.§}; {k}i,:3′;:~’s€:E far {he ps€~:*€;it§{“3::m§’ submim ‘aha? ?%}€’€§

ééf” {E36 fl1f3E{£§”3€::”fi £3? fix: %,,a<i§;v§:i:i¥.i Gram §';2m£th:~a3;a€§;. ;ez:':~: faifriflg

§.§Z'€){'.(i€i"h_§i§3;S far €%i$<;%;:&§éfia?aé§(}n $73? §?§§°ii.E{'E ai' §'}f§.E~. :"1<}'£,i{;*£* ésaxzgaficii

Q/A"

E33? ‘fiiiff 33*; ;”<:%.s:p§”1i§&%:”:’é: giinii Ehzztt €223 :’3th- 3?-::s§€>:§.v.:%:~.=:g1fl€’~.§;§*::3’ug§:

‘3§{‘.iZ€i{.3: sf ‘§f%}€%* ma£*£.er is gs? ‘tic: pass :’€3<3I*s 2&7§§E),§ £4é{g2:é*':i§;._ }E{:i.~_*{§2=€:

i§.i8€}i.i3.§if§€.'f:€if§(}3},, Hf: i-zgtmszriizzgiy cromemis ~V'£–E:.a'f£:~,':"3ti:{aa:'={i:;%;' " 11:; a

bus: parxsegi by 'ihfii 3:11 }°f5Sp-O3fi{ié:}'_if §:§_i h}=?:x" –,;i§:»;§.§:1z§£§i§y1::c$1xz1’fi€:€KL*i” An§i<::s<ii:':: $f:%. H6 §i'iI?.'f.§},$}"
sazhmits $132. if 1:}:-5' "t:;_2vG "..2«j1"6 diéqfialifieé, {E25
aiigquafifisafiezz xxmulié I'e;1£§' }§a'v:§:;E*:V 9:}, which the

i1.iS{§1'{£2}3:{§Ca{§{3ii',V{ii?C'1E§?i'€{i§ W.'*'ii<'ié:: ;§S~:_E$1§i(7}{"i prém" ix} ihi': f:l€£.'%.'E9i"i

£769'; :.§L<?{}"?_ig§;i'§L'«§1L';'sE}C hiéisi. {:25 ifiiflflfi sf An:1€x:u~:~z~B,
J13 L{3;2:§'f:¢:§iV ~*i."§:';'I):z%%%i::__<=:"i'1″ ‘ihéi ::i~:s;p£)3;”:d§t.:1t $30.3 =:ia:>r§’a’t:ne:.§$

“$32233, ..:,:;:§;ii sigsii. ‘i’§’§1.’§€§S§4§’ 213”: r:f§::*.r cf {i’§s{g::33}?f§<::;::?éiC:'§: is-; p:i.s$$£:ii ix:

, t":;:-§""§é:§f'{3°f 2T~j§{;':;';?':i<.3§:2 [E.f.%{2§ 52.'? the §«';:+2m3ai3E«:3 ?§:§I}{)h::'ij§«'§,i%,§_E Ra} é'§<:%.,

i:.§_§?::– Sé";.§{,§ – i'X3.€§};f:§)€':i"&§ %..§.’§ théa ifmzzzsei, E am of fizz: (.°.i)§”18§(§€I’€{“§

“%:_i.i_fji%; %E”:z»1.£: 3: if’. §;:%i.§£*ir§ m{;_:§,i1″€-:5: is bf’; 1’€:jeCtc{i £0? $25 %7{}Ei<:vL§='i:1g

rgtzagmm: –~

W

'§'ha §f{'§€fI' §3¢é1*tai:13Z::;ag K} 'zhéé {Ei$c§_T::aZiii<:$2.t"i=::::1 {if the

:m*.mb€r§; wiii bf: maéz: by thti Stag: E1:icr'{;i.§:’:§§._: ;’:;:.;g,_£”« _

‘:;1.:1}:’é§:”:: an azfieiti’ is; p£?£SS€”.d ‘:3?’ {Ext St:-:*:»:% E3}:tCf,%v:;:: ,.§§cs;1I2:3:;:1s3«sai<:::;

fiat: EE}{fP£i§}€i'S <:{):1f:i.1'::.2.€:<%. ta E35? zm::m'if;ei'–3 .'£_"3_f '-'§',§i§".~'."v;:§}"a',F£_',1

¥}:cu3::.%.:.a¢33:'at%: and mésre pt:::1t:§a:z_1{r}: <§f 'éhs 35):".-:){*'a?:$5:Vt4.§3.1g$; "fer

<i§§<g::a'§:s?fi:rz9:$.23': iJ*§€';i'a}l{i :30': aiiaéiiififgiéz 1Z}1t?§.E'i"%:')} é§<,T:–':' 8S ;;IE1€i£1§;é{i§"§§
ax}? that gram pa:T:<:§f;a§s:4é:'{f£1,'_ _1?§&azéj{a,,; '§*h'€;"'…'(T,'f£i}I1'{f3I;i:"€f}'.Vf}I'§ of {ha

E::.;«:z*§";£'::"§ (Ti-:1:’3s;e§. fez’ ‘£1/3:3 §};€?§7fEtit%}¥”i}V{i’§; ftizaiv pr0€:.e£:e:}§r1g8 of

{iii3q:.i&i%;%§§<;%;=:iéa:)f:'5';**'ss3_i:;§<r% ':1; -the €}€€7fi{)i'i. sciiaziuled £0 bf:
Eaéfid $3: §..é::;:;:::a ef 2'5\m;t4::x;":1f%:::VE%Vis theraférc 1ii1S1iSf}"i?iE181§'}};i3¢ As

gem'? "'35-"3if3_§'i Ufif? fiiaié Eiisézttioii C'n1mi.§;SiG.1.3. 11333333 an Qatiez’ sf

‘<§<is;{}[iz:;L§§§i(:%i{.%:::;:: éiihe S:-2:116 shaii 1}.a\?€f {E126 itifeci. an {$36

A "-.<::'?{zv§I_§?f'f%;'i1iiiffig).'ii:€i%:Z§§T%€?i"$ 3.5:; zwié 27:3 fhtt gran g::a.::§:?h33:'a.t%?z.

" f§'§i;.:;7 §;~§t";(?{I3};'}iT§. §;:'2:}?::z* maiké 23:: {E15 Et:arI;.5<?§ {3:3un$€:£ §:;1*

" V"§§;€;§F§€E.ifi{)fi€i3;" 31$; is'; §i%z-€:{.r$. fi'E€: E711 zzisgsentieni *'§i.:3 »:':a::u::1p3€t.i? €336

53-§::~§€;'§:a}.ifi{7atic3z.2 §3r0{%€:é€%%::gs;. §'i {ram 33:: $5623 éhai E315:

V' ""§§m:3 iizai €,.§:.€: 5’53’

§’a%§”g}<';:::"E<3:§'2'f 11.'-firfizzfiifé tafiiéi 2i{.'£a%{;'uat:§ E§~§{":§%S§ is {=::»{g}f:{,i.¥;i.£ {ha

fl:/%¥'"°"

s:.§i:gq:1:a;1i§E€ze2i_ic§2 §3i”0{?€.E%3{§ii.”£gS as ézarijgr as _p0s;;:,”A.

‘£’}1t’::”€i is :20 m::~’:I1ti€m. far f£.h»?:_ ‘}3i7{:’£’~i:Cf’i’§,’ – ‘

F’r t%3.€: afarttgaziiii f’€3Ei§{)I}S, mi: p€ii’¥;is:>:3._iS-I

Ski’