High Court Karnataka High Court

Mrs Roochie vs Mr Sumesh Nanda S/O Mr Ranbirkumar … on 10 June, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Mrs Roochie vs Mr Sumesh Nanda S/O Mr Ranbirkumar … on 10 June, 2009
Author: K.L.Manjunath And C.R.Kumaraswamy


ffiaagaiaraw

IN THE HIGH CGURT air-‘ KARNATAKA AT 8.£\F\i§%”33’*;.:«3:§§*’f€5’;-“%: —

amag “mas ‘E’?-“IE 13″‘ am’ :7″-3%”-“‘3~’;.–.§§f’=éE~’_’ i a”.’}§§–‘Iv”

PR£SEE?

we ?-EQWBLE MR, 3a;§Tficaé L’i:;.s_k :~%%s:5x:32;.§’;’;¢§’é§§%§<"k
fiifiéfi " I
ma §"£GN'8LE :43" 3;;$f§f;c§;v%§;;a;%;i;:§~e§gR.asxs::,za:»«Y

:*v:.§..s" $403 V §;_3;-.1é_fS§.2f'58 §3£§.—é;

s«:g?;§;%;L%;s§%. zzmgzaae {PC}

EN svém maA1[3s;:;asé:%% A V
aimgaixi; A

$2253 aasciégga * «

k=3g;’§ %’v§s’,S’:.:mesi2 §*§a:f;§a

3: *1-;;:aa:’::;”€aEa-§;a¥gdj.a ~–»- S3 *****

Qaggef ‘§a;::i,en.%;%pia,rtmants

23;2eé!,; .;_?a’é§: iCJ:e.V”€;F!§AV:*::S¥’:.«5Q.E3ad

Ap$a%%a:”zt

{By S:€’§§:§§’¥”§Z: Ramagéfi P, Kuikarfiégé. §evara}fu

Eayaiakshmi §E”:etty —- fiévaaatesfi

V’

svfigit; Sumesh Mama
‘Sig Ms’, Rafibérxumaf fisafida
“Aged abaasi: 33 years

Nee? Camgiex, Nmwé

Raga Afinamaéaé Raaci

Saéfiaba C$§G§”Ey

Caémbamre «– 641 G1}.

Aim at:

iégasanag !\§a,2%
SR? Nags?

mimbatara _ ‘-

–§_,e$’;;2Qnde:’2t”*~

(By EVE,/5: §~’§,”é”. Nanaéafi’8:,’$§éav{é’¥«{a:f_§g;é%;’§_§égseaiates -~
§3sC¥’xl0Cé?3t@S} =”‘~..V

wig §VEFA_é.s’–..’§§§’;e}f_cff_~_ aagfafiiezj $e:j~:;§m~s “28 sf the Hindu
Marriage Act ei*sga_§-z-‘z+.:;§i:’ ‘i«%:.锑1T’;%;;§§r§3e:2:t’= arm Becrea aatecfi
1C§.3§2G§§ ga%sT12;e*§.,%_’é’:”2’*–:5§f§§ §$d}’e,_2§.”»%;’_2;;Q§£Ei2 an the féée sf the 1
Ada}, ?r’§, {;?u§g5e*,;VvT,L»§’§’as”r’é1é4E*g_Cs:é:.a:*t,. Sarsgamreg, aiowéng the
miizésn fééedg umfiar Sv;ét:EcTfi””iT3′{~–:’}{15} G? tififi Héndu Marriage
£52”; fer §r’a;”2%:’:a;f éjecme’ $5 d3§~:.5_;€:§’s<:*?e wézéz a gzrayer is 3%: aséée
the impugnefi "34a,:figr:':$.:"st'A._Ef2V.;,*v::3 far as it rééates ta grantéfig
éegser §Uf"?_."s' (sf :"r;a'é:':-%:;eE:"*::a?:€e G? §s.5,G§8;'=~ gar manih etc.

:5:~m%2§:;xy Ei2?§%¥3_f2GG 6 ":'A

$31,, S:§m1é§hv*-."E'§3:§'7da
~ 'E-'sir. R;.§f2b_%%' ééumar §'§and&
4: .§;gé;a:i aiaagsz 35% years
'–Mafia?' §:_;:3.:f%;§:';§e:<, ?s§a.§.§6
'j-.;j?;a«3;a figmzamafai 253%
'§a%b;;a:'%T§a Caiamy
mmbazm -~ $4: 3::

fiéss at:

Lépasama
:%éa,2§$, SR? Nags:

§aiba§a Ceisny
Qaémbatara -~ $41 $3.:

{By M/g: MT. Nanaiah 8: §§”%8f§§e<(é'Z"V8§:C'..-A:A£'_33 3':
Advacatas} ' – " 3 %

§<§§§i

Mrs, Rocchéee
Wis Sumesh Nanéa
Aged abmst 29 yeaafsg V

Naiarzda — 53

Paiace Ga§"é_%s*;..s.*1+5jg;é2.a:é;'%t;%1*':z§¢:1;€ "
2324; Pa§a <:e Cmsig. R_'.;:*.;¥3s' _ —
Eafigaim-e ~–~!-.S6S §.'2_{';

fisififi at: – V
Mac Mar§<;é€'%:'2g Cmp;»:_.':;:*at§§;"t
3,i.;$-'~;%–'-?%e§_A? Era'§__;}asf_§.a;§ €._.":§L:s't"~– ———-

$321,, Qamnéraggiagkié Raad
8a%”%::;a:’%;3T;’2ie[. – V
W « ?g&§§3@i”:§&i’:t

V ; {8§?”’Sr§*«i §a7’%ne3h R Késékaméf fifixmcaie}

2 . ‘ ‘i’§”z§:.:_ MF;fx Ea flied mafia? fieatien 283;) a? fag Hindu
=. – ‘*?v€’ar:**:-3§–e_.?sé.:t, agaéngt ifie Euégmeiéi: Se. aeireef éatéfi
” V.’:~7§.__§’5C?3V;;Z§§§ gagseé £22 §v’%§C.§’€Qg 2:4[EQG2 ms the féie $5 the E
T;3fQ'<:.€i.;..§}r§r§c§g3a§ Eudge, ?am§E*;»* Csurt; Sangaiareg aiiawésfig iha
.§é'i:.ii§§%"': fiéea améa: fieczésrz :3{§.}{:faj: :3? tééa %-éénéag §%€§rr%a§§
'=,,£ic't ta éissaéve the marmge gaiamrgégad am 1§,}§§.E§§§9 & is

A H ;:fif;f§t;ja"A;'i_%j;fe:;f1'L'*:.V K V' '

gym: a éacree sf aéxsarce, wish a graager :9 get asifis me
émgugnefi Szzfigmervli: m s§ far as it reiaizes ts grarztmg
mamtenargce af R3§S,SQ§f~» gar mgnth etc. ..

"mesa §'*'§§§;Cé§%EiE"?a'EQi.£$ firs: Aggeaés C@§°"?":§E":§

hearing mg day; i\*¥;A§*»33L§£\§,fi\"§"§-i 3., defévareg ihe §§§_§;§m~;2;:§j::v« _

?%%}

Thesa mm aweaést, are flied §32=.A1%the3AAT%jei:§:;*;;«a,§%:§é;é';:';i3:f€%£$

wing aggréeveé by the 3ué;;;é;m_g;*::"'a;*'%::§Vi1:éé:fes,*;..V_d;3*I:eé.. '

13.32093 passes as gsm. :x:a.2z4§2:%:32%A%»by%:ae : mg, M

Euégay %"53{'{':§§y Court, 8ar:"g-§§§_:e,__f{.f A fgaéfa mm the

fiéiitififé §'a:* gra–n: .<3 f 'iii';-:55:-¢é'–T§rs–fi' C§ES§Q§i3E§a¥§ me' the maryéaga
saéemnézad 9r*{"3,§.;§.i9i§9;E_ '5:: ..Eanga§{2:'e' ":'";?":e flaw: wfzéée
gif'-&.rT_§v§%§'°':§_"§?§§__ s:§%f§e*S¥'§§'«?7:§.S< éfiirefizea the msgmgéé ig my a

?'%"§é§.:f'%*i:é.fié;-3~:".ii'..'§..4:C}§: §%§;5§§§f- fie?" €%'°§G€":'E§"s. $239 wifa has flied

a%§eg§:*:g thai the maémtgnaztcé awarfied

–4.T.T’_;$.?:,»v’i._tV?3sa £ea3;ft”:.b§§{2w %5 as’: me Emma: Sgfifi. Sémééargz, the

flies §v”:§§a. ?*é®§:Z9$;3f2Q§§ aaaééafigéng the

“3’s”2~z5%§}”2§§.§:as””:§§ aa»%;a§*aé§ 3:: mg §?§L§§’§$ that tééé $a:”:*se ig Q3″;

V”4..”:’:§”:%~ E2ég?2&:* gifie, we husbané gasézs fiag guffemé a déiféé

-:’v

Q? fiévsrse has ma: cfiaééengafi the erdasr of d§’s.r$:’:t;¢:.-‘*;._’4’g *9:§§§;x’-:;e}’l<.?%."V.

€13 {fie wife. Er: othe? wsrég, %.:§:% dévaraa gj;*a:§}%':.$§?i.'_1%.'fs:;{ tfié

Csurt bemw has became Cmcéuséve agfié "

{2} Qéxing the CQi.é%’$% ggf §§”£§;§%.§’.u;T;§ff§§i’f;:$; “5{‘§’§;{&T§§ga§”%§gfiS ézazse
camg fswgaré fa: settie:’i*2é§’%s.§”G:§_ $3; afififipramések
They hava flied 5 cgsnfgprfim§é:”:g:2é~i:§%§§}%.”vs}§z:§%::v£%§ is signed by
339 fififliéfifi 53 parties afimét
2% é.:><§cu%:i;as"z…$§?'A":é'e The respesstéve
games :§?:':eér aémcateg. fiaccarfiéng
':3 the £Qm§rG%":':iS§'»§'3§V':§£EA§:=.V{*é;'«':§?f'??& husfiazéd ms agrees Ea gay
af'"3:_.s_;r"§'*: ?;}.:L*:;f§;E..A€§§',g§%i;%'§–;—'?—=-««'§§*: §m':§§:;m tazsgawés gérrfigaergi

a§:.é"¥r2§:*':'*,%"_'1e:r:3:v–;:rf;:;*' mm :a.:2.2§§§ ms 2% wéfé am fie hag

V7 "A~…a.§$s agE:i_g:€ed.*i:.$5éL"%;::es'$gz mginiemamca as avgagfieé by the iréaé

::~':q:_";~a:a Q? as,s;;§§;«~ $8? manth am :m"2§2a@§§

V»._'"=&£:§¢:i€E':::§.'§'§r§ me mmpsramise getéiém ég éfiiififiififia 'Em

§:%j§'"s:,.%V.e.;:f..%a3' the E§am§§~;' Cmsri %:a3 21% be mméféeé %n §"§§3§'°§ 'Ea

mairzigrzarzgg awaraefiy

c'K/

e
"{3} er teée eeeee, tee éeer-nee eeeeeei fer the eueeeee

enemies eeet the ieeker was eeeeee in Syee;ee:e..V'ee:eee;

Meteaeeieyem Breeeh, Ceémeeeere jeietéy in

the wife eee ee eeeteer fie}: eéeeéeeee§eee1e'"e"eefeféeipeee

eeée §ee%<e§' eeeeeé: ee eéesee eeieeeiieeeA~eeeee'e%:" Eeé%fe–e.":'éej

given ey eee wife. Sireéieriy E€e_ e~e_emét'e :§°%e: v-§'f:Ae':.__:§'"§eee "eiee * L'

eerceeeee eeree eeeree free"; the:.'$–eeeA§eete'*e.ee.§§ $5': the

eeree ef tee eefe eee eeet ee"§e'f:e"gee tee eeeree

treesferredviee Tess'e'eV€%:e"e,e'ee.e:_?er'zeeiee the wife has te give
her eeeeee: ieetee .

“«j{.e§’~%,e’e4§’eee;’eeeeee% eeeeeeeg fer zee eefe eeeeeéee

‘ =…i:v.’e;2et e§*:e_ §’:ee .e’e1’i.ee§eetiee fer ieeueeee e?’ ieetee me eeeg ee

–fj’_;e,§e_se, the §ee:1;e:’ bet eiee fie eeeefee eee eheeeef éf eesg

7.,44’~-.eé:’eee__§eg_ fie ee? eeeee ée eeeeeee ef fisgeeéeeee eeee ee eee

“5e’::e:e;e;€e,

3/