” ”’§+§:{ié:ré58Es 403
IN THE I’iIGI*I COURT OF KARNATAKA. CIRCUIT
BENCH AT GULBARGA ”
IDATEIJ THIS THE: 111% {my OF F3.BRUA;2;fgf*”2’a¥..1:;;3f: _
PRESENI’
THE HONBLE MR.JUS’I;I4CE:”N.. AA
Al’–? D–..
THE 1»ioN*3LE 1$r1RS§__JHSTI_C,f2_VV. Szfisgggtramg
WRIT APPEAL 3. Q;{¥;»_5£3f.2’O€§€3f{3E&Z-KEB)
TN ‘ ._ ..
2
La;5=:ma.:”2_ R<:a"d§,f," Sf £.f:{.'1'€e;}:"21Tsé'2::. ¥=353ddy
47 yprie1,€>:.f; ._ ” «.
M/s.’F£rurfie1}a. Ei€:’:;t_’r.riCa1:;;
E3£«:ia§.,– R,?o.?’ia3I; E\;?-::«;éS'”.?’;’- ‘
Bra%1§3:ap’u..1″ C{:’i€;v:<:y{_
. . 41%p§)E:§J§fiflN'1'
" V{i%j_»,}" ;~'-'prxéeaéi: Kama: De§shpa37:d<:; f§da7{:»<?21.%:£;é}
T I ' — "E ffhe G':.1§b2:rg22 EEé:<:t:§ic£i.y
V. ' ..fS:;:§3p.§f;; C;§:’:g §}ir:=:<i:i;s:}r g
' ~* {}i;§.'i:z;1:fgga5
2. The }”)€?ti?I.ji()I’1€1′ eni’e1′.<,i imn an E1§§I'€E"fII}€IliT.
with $115: r'x’1d&r11i:s:; 0:’: I5.’i2,,2GG8 for {%2:1:rryi.I1g 0:113.
Shift: dz.13::}; and mimzsg’ n1ain€;eI1ar1c<:% 'A-'{'}1'k in I'E¥$vp€f2'Qf."*Of
33/ H RV ssi:21t:i0r1, B:m..Ea1h2111i Viflage. V.
the E1§.§1″€?f3.fI1€iI1’f. eszlitemd intc) bei’.we€:1 the ;:~:iff:ieS_;:. Cvigizrzsev
4(1) 0f the 21gre,en1<3:'1i;. siip'1.:3ai',e5:s t.h€"~
c::czm,rac'i: is for an.:-:: yf;-"f3.I' 22x1d"niéa§{ be é:<.t.<a:1c_ié<i E':.:§_ir"*v5.¢:<§=::{3fr1d
year if the pé::rf0rme111Ccf_ is se1i:i_s:.i'é§’::§g but 7e1«1t11’€:,1fy at”; the
discretiorx of 2t,h«i%;,.C0rf}0r;11:i’€)n’;” I’f ‘”£h,.c§ contract: is not
exteénded Oné 1fr,1.C:Ifi*3;’i;]Ei__ 1:>>1’i-::j;*:rK f:’.__tf1f1é’::gmpI€tic>’n of one year
the s:%0:’;f_:’:ia;:ii’ V ..%;§jt2t.’:s;;:._ ;.r;*:i:i:fii&:d.., V Ha’j:.¥.,’;%;f:i:}F:l’1E3..t1L§:7E111? fif)§”‘{.h wiéh
and wi€;.h0’:1t :»’1J§:§,f:”‘,§7′;1é<'i.}1't=:–':'_ V'§.1<5i;iite¢ Ciauge 4(ii) pmvides
t:hai; apar€ §1f{}:";f;V bath t:I'1z3 gazrtias am 22:; EEb<:rty
to E,.:%§jii:;_:?:21i:e {'i1<:%V §1;g;r:%<:%:11o3r:I; by giving 3G{€'.}1i:*i::;"} c§aj,rs5
'<;:m:_:;ijm ."'zi{":t;_ic:€:.. A11 €Dffi»::ia.§ M'cmor2m<:i'u.m came to be
:'s:§3:.md_ i:'–'; _ gé::i"s;_z :';iI1<:€;3 cf the Said r:?<;rmra<:€; «:31: 14, '§2.2€}Q8
m'aE%ii–gt1g it *£,ha.i. {E16 awafii 0f ::i;r.21<:€; £3 w.z;":.§.
i_,_'E_2';«2G{}%E%§ .:;-::':':<:i E:E"2.<% <:{.§:z1€:ra<é"é' p:3:z'§<;ze:£ E53 Ezafiigi Lzpté}
' _i"§f€ .§%.i?;{}{§–33 {J}? ii}: 2:rr2i:':§§g:%:3':e2'i:E.s; 2.«m:* znzezégz whizth €f'2-'"f3§' is
'p:"iv'a_.:ié éi'i;*-z1£';–ri;2<%i; 21::'f;'%:iM:3:<)'{' 2:: sa%?:2:t.:1'£,<)1*y €Etf}I"if,E"a{3ii feiiiiug fizyr
'1:.i_E§V"}V.=:.'}{*r:* sf tbs? €<3r":s;E.§mff£<}:1 5:? India. 'E"h{;2
;;"2.:;'s€.; pmgrser eimd Eegai is m21i:€.€:r w'h§<i%.h. mi': bet:
H'€}{,2'3i"if'u'€%}_'T1.§€EE'}iii?' ;1<§jazcii:?2sé.e:2 in 2:2 <:1§*s.::;§ pr<){?€e*,{§.£r;gi
V' :'-3E:""é~. i,E2.e:% §€~.m1:>; £3? E.§”Ei’f z’:<s2"1§.:°:.@<%:. :*&%{:§z:§::. ii; ‘I§;}:f:% §:’1€’.§3:”;>:°@§:<:{§
4
ezlrlicéz”. By .A:’111ex1.2:’s:,–“13”, ‘(ZE”1€:’. EXE?{E1,iiiiV€% E1’1g;fi1’1<;%€::'.,
repo'r*"i:€rci iihzzié e1é3<%t.'1*_ic:re1._1 2I1(?<r2;d.:%:'1i': <.:a<:c:urre«:i on 11 KV
I~i21ih211ii frgeciczz' <:*::ne:1.3'1at.i1'1g_§ £§':1h2>..I1.i on 20.6.2009 due to s;s1,:dci<:'-:rs infl_w sf ~
poxver smppiy, which w2?:.::~: undcxr Eine c:i&%e1::—,4’§,:;?}1,i4y€’ci—-}3}j
ix) 210%. fw’i.r2g ihfif s;2:1£h=:i:}j r*:;:i=::;s;:’.–‘.A_V ‘
SL1p1s*’ci<21*
dated V".§;*.:"
:}.in£11$,i2§ci 4i:I7i_锑~'{1%(>niira.<7t with csffecft
from .i_.9V21QV§)9i,_" »'_ Ii' "'i.<%f:jhina1i:i0n, which was
{?h_21li<:anV'féEi' '=':3}L9%.t"1*: 011 Ehfi’. grecmrid
iiiaeii: figs: :i:i;és1§:»L_:;*;:<-fi..'§::~:;";, pa:"i;';:'=;~.::e :«.i.;"iS<:*:~i~:z {JE/-'1-£9' :3? a
5536;?-:":f§i.§”;.~e»::~;. §jf’:;§W§1<-itheér i'}."::=. §..s:::*:":1inaE:f£{§I": of HEEL'? ()(}E1.§i£".'?_':€Tft is
E:
4, in 1′;h_’1s3 View <)ft:1'1c% 1i:'.1.21t.t<3:r, we dismis;s–3_.=f:__his
appeai
E3. Tifze i<;':arm:<:1 <i:<::m-sci far thf.-3, v "-21;j}?$;é:E?].;;11's.i:'~
S3'..1b1'I}i'{,$ fiaat, the: c<3:1tr;1c?%:', is: e:-.*.:x::t:<5.;bmi(A§_(i,' j.Wt:{dc}-._t1:3t..V_Jsé.§:_T j
any subst:aI1;1ter:”::i;0r1-_. ‘