-1- Ir; THE men comm': or KARNATAKA cmcurr amen AT nxmwm Satcd this the 20th day of November, 2003' --% _ BEFORE mm Horrnm am. JUSTICE' H. " Writ Petition No. 4767 o£*--.go_g>7 &tvveen: 1 Son of Shri Madhav Rae) Regs; Aged 75 years " " _ ' Occupation: Business V Resident of Rage B*unga1owA« Behind :H1'abIi_' Toll-i_Na1<a.' " * , . Dharwad '-»':fs-309 % % SmtL.PadVmavfat. " _ ' _. V .Wife: (if Regs ~ Aged 55 V3313 . Qecupzafion: Hausa Hoid Resiaiéetatv of Regs: Bungalow ' N " ' T...§-iiz}:»Ii Toll Naka , sa:+¢ewa,rpm ' Dharwad - 530 001 Ajay . , *' Son of Shri Narayana Regs Aged 32 years Occupation: Business Resident of Reg: Bungalow Behind Hubli To}! Naka Saraswatpur Dharwaxi ~---- 580 001 Shri Sanjay Son of Shri Narayan Rage Aged 30 years Occupation: Business Resident of Regs: Bungalow Behind Hubli Toll Naka Saraswatpur Dhazwad - 580 001 V ' Smt. Anjali T. Wife of Shri Raghunanciaix-Naik V Aged 33 years u Occupation: House Hold Resident of Rage Ra_n1an;z"iéE1'Traedér$ At: Txasi I u Taluk Kundapur _ » « Udupi District V 'Nifc of Manse%$h% Regc A366 64 j % .' Occupafioiz; House---.}_;1oLfl Resident of Regs, Eiuggigalow , H,ubEi"ToE Naka ~ ' Saiaswatpurv H Dhaxwad -- 58b"6<)1 ' S<33:..irJflat£ Mangesh Rage Aged abbut 26 years " Occupafion: Advocate Refiident of Rage Bungalow Béhind Hubli T011 flaka . H Siatpur " Dharwaci - 580 001 Smt Pradnya D/o fate Manges}: Rage Aged 24 years Occupation: House Hoki \\/4 IO 11% Resident of Regs Bungalow Behind Hubli TOR Naka Saraswatpur Dhaxwad ---- 580 001 sma Jagadish Son of Shri Madhav Rag Regeét ' Aged 59 years Occupation: Bufiiness _ Resident of Regs Bungalow'=._ Behind HubliTo11'P§Iaka_«""' - Saraswatpur -_ Dhanvad ~-- 580 901 ' Smt. Wife of V' Aged _E3Cf;r.¢é:s--';'~ __ Occufiafipn: Hdusc "I~io3a;i"' Resi4;lei:1t_6f Rtigc Bimgaiow. '. f3chind~§%I11bIi'fI'oII4 % Diiagwad '--V5'sn*o<;1..___".3G=3 V ~V ' EV€I'€S3liTCI'$éQE:, .351' F}.oorV, ' Tejpa-$1'R0_ad"" ~. V V Near Raria §§3iscmt._Fa¢tox'y"V V (Eugtg, Sm"t;Vijayé;' = 4' J V .'_VJ5life (Sf shz:i._Man--ju.nam Badal V Dfo Shri Sakaram Regs: ....
0c<;u.p'£d:ion: House Hoh
_ Resiéént of No.251
V Son of ShriJaga£1ish Rage
V' Hai15i31Ef'r3ba1ti Colony
' dc1pt2:iVFE'oad, Near Bus-Stand
kc2aL Dist: Rajkot
~~(V}1’ijaIath State – 360 31 1
Shri Smit Jagadish Regs
Aged 26 years T
Occupation: Business
Resident of Rage Bungalow
\\(/
17
Behind Hubli Toll Naka
Saraswatpur
Dhalwad – 580 001
Shri Mayur
Son of Shri Jagadish Regs’
Aged. 22 years
Occupation: Student ..
Resident of Rage Bungalow
Behind Hubli “P011 Naka
Saraswatpur ~ H
Dhazwad – 580 O0. 1] ; ” » Petitioners
(By Sri M S HiI’emat11 for’SI’i.,N “E§’VBh£xt,”Advocatcs)
Shn’ Vasfimf .. .%
Sr.-m-of ‘E3banka1*._Rao
Aged 7i2’§%€=aI”$’«. % 1 %
Occt1paa3’o1’1:.’ fBusin”c:s_.€ ”
Resident of_Rc.gc B’L=;i’g:«1iow
i3chix;.d”H_ub1i_ Toll” Nam
.Sa1~asv$*-ajpux
.. Dhaxwad’ -“-=58_€> 0 01
.. Agviud
” or Shankar Rae Regs
Occupation: Service
Residitig at No.2{)’?, Ganesh Datshan
Mallgalawaxpct
Tiiakwadi
I “~ Be1gaum ~– 590 one
Shri Vasudev
S/o Shri Shanklar Rae Regs
Aged 75 years
(Dec: Business
Resident of Rage Bungaiow
Xx/%
.. 5 –
Behind Hubli Toll Naka
Saraswatpur
Dharwad -~ 580 001
Shri Macihukazr
S/o Shri Shankar Rao Rage
Aged 70 years
Occ: Business
Resident of Reg: Bungalow
Behind Iriubli Toll N.-aka
Saraswathpur .
Dhanvad —- 580 001
Smt. Savitri
Wlo Shri Gafl3P=a”h=..46°3¢e%V”‘\’ –.
Aged 45 years
Occ: House Hold
Resident of.Rege Bungalow ”
Behind }:!t=.bIi_’To1i;_Na}r..af
unmade .\
c;¢e:c.-gh ” A’
. S] o fiegc
.» gages: 23
Gee: Business
Resiohexiii. of Rage Bungalow
a’£–_I1 1jbIi Ton Naka
2 ‘ Sarvisfivaihpur
‘ Dhaxwgad —- 530 001
Shti Rites}:
Sic Shri Ganapati Rage
. “Aged 21 years
” One: Business
Resident of Rage Bungalow
Behind I-Iubli Toll Naka
Saraswathpur
Dhazwad — 580 001
10
Shri Jayant
S/0 Shri Shankar R30 Regs
Aged 59 years
Occ: Business
Residing at N’o.402/ 206
Neclakanta Tower
Gasodia Nagar
(izhatkopar {East}
Mumbai
Shri Dccpak Vasauth R636′ % 2.
S/o Shri Vasanth._Rfiege 3. . ~ V ‘
Aged 27 ycars
Occ: Service
Resident offlcge VV
Behind ‘Tali-.N&ka’
S31asw&th§i:V_1r’;’. ‘ _: ‘ V
Dhar;ya¢;_4_,580—-eQ_1—.’j;A ”
Suit. _ —
W/0* Shri VV”T._D”iwadkar
Aged 29
Occf’ mas: ‘Head ” .
A. -Residiiigat No.99, 23*’ Main
.. 6fl*~B1ock, ‘BSK 3??! Stage
‘Bangalore —
” Regs
‘ _ Agfid! years
Occ: ‘Student
Resiriing at No.26’?
Ganesh Darshan
A_ ; L H ‘g Mangalwaxpet
‘ °’I’ilakwadi
‘I2
Be-lgaum — 599005
Shri Mandar
S/o Shri Madhukar Regs
Aged 26 years
13
14
‘A D/o’Sj_hriJayanth Regs
Occ: Service
Residing at No. 1381
1″ Floor, 39*?” Main F’ Cross
Sarakki Main Road
J P Nags}: 13* Phase
Kanakapura Road
Bangalore
Smt. Manisha
W/o Shri Rajesh Dalal _
D/o Shri Madhukgr S Rzjage: _ ”
Aged 29 years E _ L’
Occz House Hold ” ‘ Z
Rcs1dentofKotag mpofund ” ”
Mrutunjayfia 3: _.
Bclganmx ~– 001 _V
3/0 Shri;_–!ay’azath.<Rege _ —
Aged 2?'
OCC} Student ' _
Rcsid.1ng_at N;o.40'2/2,06
X . 'FaWeI'S*.
,, Gasodia Raga:
C%1;j&tkopkoIv{–Ea3t)
Mumbai
s:¢t%J.-masna
A.ged.Q6 years
” Service
Residing at No.402/ 206
Neclkath Towers
Gasodia Nagar
Ghatkopkol (East)
Mumbai Respondents
15/
– 9 ‘M
(By Sn’ Maliikaxjun C. Basareddy, Advocate
for REA, 8,9,11–13;
R6, 7, 10, 14 8:. 15 are dispensed)
This Writ Penfion is filed under articles 226 and??? of
the Constitution of indie, praying to set aside the oxt1ei=_d.:ited
r’3«3-200? passed iay the Cotzrt of the Civil Judge. »i{S:f;.Dn.)
Dhazwad on E.A.I No. in 0.3. I\Eo.274/ 2006 _
This Writ Petition coming on for orders. –« ..
Court made the following: V ‘ ‘i
annex
The petitioners have chaiie.nged}:1_ this ;
ozfler passed, the defend.ants~35 to
39 ané 53 tents xeeeived by them from the
suit schediiie ”
relationship between the parties is not in
contend that aii the suit soheeiule
V V’ _ pro;;iertie.s joint family properties. ‘i’I1eie is no paztifion
$;ei:abers of the joint family. The contesting defendant
oontend that properties which are yielding tent are all
~ self acquisition and thexefoie the rent derived fiom the
said pzoperty exclusively belongs to him. Therefoze, the
k/
kg
_ 1; _
of judiciai process. In that View of the matter, the order
requires to be modified:
Writ petition. is allowed. Defendants–3S to 39.ané 44
to 53 are directed 1:0 pay the rents as they were doing’:
to 9th defendant 9th defendant in turn shall –:f1:epQei:1′;’:.Q)’ :35
share of the aforesaid rem in the
depositing 2/ I 1th sham he shall .
remaining amount shail be defresiged p m;;1pt_1y1.b.. AI§._e11y..defau1t V L’
is committed by the 9’31V_defenda13VfA’£11_ depositingfiheiisaid rent,
the g.§VA3V£ibefiy_’_to _1:1frove the Court for vacation of
this ordép – % % A ”
Sd/-»
…..