High Court Karnataka High Court

D Bhagavan S/O. Doddegouda vs The Director Departmetn Of Mines on 17 June, 2009

Karnataka High Court
D Bhagavan S/O. Doddegouda vs The Director Departmetn Of Mines on 17 June, 2009
Author: P.D.Dinakaran(Cj) & V.G.Sabhahit


WE” KEMNREMRK Hfifiafi mam” W2″ Kflfiflflfififlfl ?’fi§JE”‘l M-KJWKE

uwwmn WE’ mmmmmsmmm NEW” MWUKE $.,x3?””,_’§W%KNfi%#§§%fi» WEMW mmmw W? KIKKNKEAKK %”H%€””‘f<

:2»: $213 EEEGE fifififi? 532* magma £3 ~ T %
§&1'«'%§&E.Q§.E ,

aam 'mg mg 32% my T ,

p§,§s§::;%':* ;

ms gcgmaa 32:3. RE %3E§A§§%§§’»§§€, * %

“gm I-m:*a;.§ W1: ._§;é§}+§é;E-ifi’

WRIT E$f§gi§%_{§gg”””§??§ .3a3g2;§L3e@§és’2§§§ Qsmmgs ;

BE’§”§<$'%E<§:%* % *

D. ahgaam-g'$;e L

Aged*43,.Qe:2::: E?;z,:zI.n23;s;–..

R19 '§§3i$€:f);"7£§*s'»%5&3'§é!L3:;§ Eaiukg

– ”

— §§’§’§§’§€§§’€§R

” ….. .. y

……~.we».=»-u-..p-.4:

ammmx as? éaéingg m
” fiwgfiamg

-“:3 sf kfffififi azé

Gagmgahmxhi y Eaégssm.
Swine: Gselegifi,

– — — .- ef égiirmfi fiié
Sxmghigum Efigéggara.
H R§S?$§$§EE*§T$

3

‘vm’|w*wwmUa« awe-wmmuws-wnaruawr-n wumwaw wwwwnu ‘MW lF’wW&K%~E%£f”‘©.MP°'<tfi"M"'§- __-fm;a:*g"*g; gwqvgaggggqgfi

msgsrzéani 323$ 37 ' ;

ms%;k5 9&;ég %m:,A§+g%§ ;.;;.§>§ mg Km

but

a 1- ‘4’ ‘6

$8 @%%a$?1%%i§i§+..M& %£a:f&?en

W émé mz gm’ arr: gsfizggag, 5&5.

msa my ?§’§’§’§§§:$ s%és3§;::;\.:«g; fj 3:33

Mam ms mLL§w::-.:§; K

.. are

1, 13% ‘sy ésaecmass

ax: :ega:g:yg:%;:;e §§§E,2§§§ gamé by

af Eviimg ma

Mz’§.@§33 Eéysasfi 12%. 2 _.;;:

mm”m’z aim safmi fififiéé aha pgiiamfl :22 335.. Ea

fig 33% 332?? Eat

;%2s:2 mf°’£*f..a7§&k:éé:$ £22 Egg Em ma $5 maagmii

V .-

z§s,;$2′;2§§§’

::- $3: $522: §%?§§§.$§§;§§C’ as gvgfifié ie: fiw ‘§s§;i:

gefifimxaz kw ham gmziéifi za £6 ajgmy ef

22$’ 2 5%: iim §§’%’*$f fifié af

Va

53%: *§~::fs*:i§Aé%,$;éE%£ég£:i”§ :%:;%

SE
3
Q
as
m
E?

m
3
§
2
X
§
513»
@
§”””

E
3
s
u
3
3?

E
§
§
5%
g
§
§
£3.-

f9
E
3
:33

ma. W éreaugmg as age

Vfiii-i’.*5?*’3″i§3-»*3?i”3§”§1’3§7{§§ by

“‘””””””””‘”‘””‘ W” W”‘*”‘WmW””M “WWW WWW”! VE”._’%&%KN#-kifiiflfifik WEHH méwm U? %J~’?’sKNfi¥&fifik M

Rififef 95 §2:1′ Licénafi

esmms my 3 3:’ mm 3953; in 3g%ik%I*%%3:§;%i%%;g%j

Eicense ‘viée Lifififlfifi N3; Yfifi ‘

ef ens yam: in Sy. fie. 25? ‘éfi?

Bmnfiaflzzx vfilfifies Eésuict. The

$33 in wfiich $1: §fi;i£ie2:§.§g 522% film rim: flaws a

fan speezd gig ma» gsszgg Sim am. qwzyizzg H

aom in gag 1?§’«s§§j%%§;fi:%&:e’ §efifi$§§fi $5 me in ma.

c:>;*:&§in’9__n§{ ‘§:.*v§§.V}§3ghi*3«f:V§:;:;§:ce$$,i’h1e far Eéia gefizimmz is stars the

sarié 533. ‘iii: %.§ fisaéim E2″: the said

is in amawta pime

sf raga.

mg aw paaém g m: fig fa:

‘ fikm gmfi $31 gmraa iaég asf

am vixmm mi mam sgma gm 3; 3;; Ea, gaesg gm

6

.’ viiigs, gmzzwfipg; *?§’1a3;11:;: j.

.«m». nwwwwwn vw-Iwv-svrtlbvn wu l’€’~W”votv’IH1’|1HP'”0k9il”‘W..l”§.&f”‘% wwmwxw ‘MaVm#’WM’&.l WV $’Va;fi”‘?;xE’§x.fiW:5F'”*&a§.Wh§.?-*’i…~’- §E5″;§§§k$§'”§

‘M.

V
_I£;€a;;b1& as §a fig asgég mg éémztfiifigg

h

4812; 3; 4, $5 0f the 3.35233?

xawea: vilisge mm 33;; 2%. 3:52 fif %

ma &t§s sitnmfi figs; mm 3;

6111 $3 tbs gefiiimzezs “Eh: 535% mgifi .

t}1emm’ maci. § t§$ ;’ng

my jfuzisdicglazz to @331 the

seized rim Sfiiéf fig? zigzag: challw
mm g fer Q WES fi an

35.§2¥29e;§ W”-:35 §2:b1i5§:e§ an the smrta

day fig aw

Ear 5&1} £315

fif iitfi gmié fifiifiw Ehfi

é Ema fiifi iizflgfsza émgugzefi wéfi is

be isgwé ia the

fix xmzé fieffi gig ahersie

mzé fizwafaszg fiénii Fsiiama $13 fiigé fer aha amva

% X % .. i:efma§ mzasfx

U’

fiié g3: $3. 2%

u u

%;3UUR”E” W? %fia§%Wfi.’E”&K& Eéfifiéfi Cmififi” Q? %A%NA?WKfia Hfififi CQUR?

…- “IIMV W »m w wen” we

énrzcmé» Tm

nwmanwwrmumuww um-Wm mgigwwmw wfimamwmsmmm Nwmm mwwm U?” Mmwmfiflm 5%:

3. We hm? he-wé Emeé @§§fi$i:ig_j_ $118

4,, Lemied cczmgai flégtisigg §:<;:ié§;:§;j:

chm thmigh §3'£1§u§1£§3I3fi Rfifififi Em

hem imsa. :3: zaspacégefi 3:; by ?,}'m

Tim is 31:: avf £:»:1mn" "'3-éfiwji S23 mzfi azmtim mm' :5

Wlfi M-i%'ha¥%§l%$mM%%j;¥$*a¢fi ma szmé by :21:

pw5Li:31'mf.§iA"£;i' €§ié:;~°:'sg§: is ififififii 32$ §a§§@é in gmfi

flaf gm. " fififiififlg

V .. z " has': giwfi fiaiéfifi §$§§fi:§§3"§ififi $3 iize '

eé figs izmmais

$$'fi3§..:§£31 far :13: Epfifififi fifi

aim}? Sfififi? E-11$ thfi

mfi wifich fifi ham fifigzgé fifam 331$

$3 Eéa ma 5%,

48%, E? 433 §§ 3? fix Kwnr in 3;: Ea E52 czf
\)~

Aéwssgg

.ww..»m-"gnu: -uwrawu-I ww-mun: -mu twnmavmammxm nnwn MMM5.fi WP mMgE£N'm{:_.:'%;f<*'g;m gag-vgmgem ggggggg

Kaiekadi vinaga ma in 3;»; as, 2252 af §aé&$§§ _§._ 'm

favnsm: ef the mama. aeaaréitg $5 $325 i.g_::~;{a

W3§ fiamé 33?' fix 3"

mid amié fiié

md fine mm af thg $$}.d Jjmad
the absence {if any w;;Lfi§§%5g!§:’€:.£9&;é§9 ‘§3g$eé; §§,~»z§:é: rewmdem.

fitae fifi msaimz cmfié ” n ‘

?’ wzmztéafi mass: maid.
net $32 ymac:-eéazre aef iaw in
$5 mm: jagiee a§ 131$ fight ef
fix; afigézgé by 233$ Szzfigagnad wiim

– ‘gitgxgzzgaré az;€$§{:s:;: Zfififiéfi is Eiafisia £23 & 3:2:

31% was 5:3 5% is mg ma rmmzgm

fififizi ifi Q13 mfifig’ ifi fifiéh Eaw ifi

3%: 233% %@§§ §§ aim ssgéfl.

\.J>

‘4 Ema ég ma ”§é%::§§§¢>é_zéé_zzg._§3:¢’ . x

Qf J

KZQURE” 5?’ KfiKNA”i”£§¥€&. Hififi C-Qififi”? OF KARNAEKKA Hifili CWWRY

~.. mm. w mnaumanm mam m.mm- w!’f_mMmm’mmmm wmm m;aa:x:’wr KAKN&’W&%§’=?:«¢

Aamrdirgy we gsga thg

Qrégs
‘tr’

, i_ , .. are
‘$12: Peifimmgf aiiawsé; é

Aucfien zzaiiae Qgeei -gr: %§”:i§2:;2$§§’

rgsfinéeng is gifi filfl iflifé
zaspmxdsrzi fag gagsfig Wiziz. 23%
u I Sd/-

Sd/-:2
L _ _ Iudgfi

Istdagx:

Vfififit Z 

-" '~  _    _____ _. v