Karnataka High Court
B N Ramesh vs Chandrashekar N on 9 March, 2009
{','?;."§..? 222:. 3S€Eé.*Z?;€éé_§§§
ifiifi? ' "
T%.:fi2;a:--. GEE, E ?:fl?.€(:'i§f<}
gm 'm:=: E-'§§{§ié é::<:z::%";' m'§::£3 '§"'E~§§;'E§ *€':~--§§<: ::«2':"%% 212%-* <;§':%f fl 'A
V ' V' 'V .
'§'§~£E z~mzé*s££ E §£§$Ti€E .¥g§':~:.§§i?i§~§;:%z;§}§s.:;é;;LA
::_?:%z:a.§§:~é;a;... §'s:i:.:ff;:f*:*§{::'_%; ?§§i}1.S~%fiéE.;;".LE{3§{}¥3
§%£§E_S{3, ::§§€.L. ;-;;%%::£::%::'~~V».'-~
B Efiaxzzaaéé; _ _.
iiéfcs §{:°i$Emap});:z,..._ _ ' "
fags: 4&5 f§'€i8§'S§ ~ _
§€f£;{ 'z;'"i;2.'bha §*€ag::;.1:*:.~1,. V'
E§T%:s'im<';ga. ' . « V ._ ._ --. ¢
@592? w53§*§<:3Z::g as: §'r;;uz}%;"r%; §=;?§&:?£;~:::_§::::¢
Eiazfiaziaka Baihkg " VV
'§'§;i1*t.E:aha1}£i,{ " ~ §3i;%E'§%:;.'im3s:2*
g§§,:r..$:~§"? .8 gas gas :<:::;:aa:;: saw, 35:33: E3; 3,
Lang/gfiyza §'£'f;€T_,;§ --. " V "
V'£L":T:7:2:§1;:%:V;:*a$E3§i{z2i'
' L2? f 2")' '?€ai':«:s§m11a 1' W23 <§<:;;:*{i";§;g
xigfi: »j;e&*:';=--:~.$
-. 42§ai§a?g;;:e: '';<'%.*'7_i:t;3:r;, :
~
_ V '§'§:%f§:7:§a§}1§¢;iii. %€s};§:::{§§§'a€
"§.'hi$ ikimézzai §3"€i:?€§23:: ii; ffisé 'i"£§E{i€I Sséiéfin *='%$12 {ii {E25 {Emits af
C:'°§.m§_n:a:3 §3ms:5:<i§1i3'€, p:*:5sfg15::g is 38: zasifie €315 gmifig" giazacé 1%é.E"§,2§{}{é
cagnizaxxce of the «::fi"€3:2<:23s aiiegesi in fhéi C€}fl}§:i;E§i'§§f. mgisifiziazg are?
{7'é'§»§*' l'€@. i%8é.53{}€§§
.-';"3'sa'
};§%$<;,{.'f:*E£'aE2:7s,§': _3._{3{}1'%
3
am: <%:'"i:?,::§:3.:a§3: {mass é§,%;"1{i. §:.$§-§Z§€i§3.€i'z'3' :1)? :;1;:::9;:1:{:m$ §t;.:--'ss;$€;§?.i?. if} 'VV¥':.:fl-'§."':§_'&'
Na}. 2.{3?:2;;;5£s{}£: 9:2 E12153: fiita 6:" {;':.£v§£ Jtiéigzé {J31 :}§;:::;..; ;::i_:'::é 3§v§«:i'«3;::§
'E'T%':§':*i§.:§:%}_a§E; zmai igzzasié {E35 :3:3'%':3L;*s:* §;~:*{;z:?:?:::{§;iz2g§;V ii}. {ft
Wiha: file cf i:i;iv:{.§. Jucige {JEZ E.'3£v':1,} :32 JE'¢i§v%'iZZ, !§:[;3;if'3:ETl?A§-fE{".§,Eii.<
' .T?2f'£«:;{1%{"§é?s <.§§--; F'
Miss. {fir}. 91%}? ,4 239*} is fi§€a'iv'1iI;;;?:§§a=.:~ E§%e:f.?'§}«:,'-,3': %§E.i§j"§Vi= .::f'7;€3-:'§.:::: ~§}§
ifirimigzal §3I"€}C€'{§,L1I€, ggrayizig 31:: 332%}? a§'§':.:§V$}2<~'::" ;:i§';§::;a:§;:_£Z31::Ag;-SE1pu.i"s'z:a:2": Er;
18.1%: aszfiszz' {£32521 3%. E LEQEEEE §}3;SS'a€{§. E33; 3.31:: ifiiarié d%L';<;§g§: {;§3':§i §}§v;*2,} zmii.
Ji*vf§?{'Z-, '§'§'1ir"thahai§i. .. =
'E'E;€5;5 arasm itemzlzzg an f8§"VA/3}{',ii.§'§}§if;§f';'J;§'}T£L§ fé§§':;.:%.:§s»..;{§':e;~};s {ha €i<;m"':, maaaét
the fafimxzrirzg: V ' ' ' --- "
~
Tim peii€ig}s:§§"{':::¢{t}z::;§:gi 133.2 {Li "§'§§%.,E.V{}?;Tf}?:;{?{§€§ mi: figs fit: {'35 ifézzfi
gfiud 6 J2". §}i£§'am. 5;3'?z'E¥'{§.'i:a}; *1',§.14:;:%*%{A';*:z*.:.%§,é~:;§:%.% ix §}€§Q1'fi Eéizzia f.I...7Iei';=%a:::"--£. :m:§.5:;:*
Seaiéeiz 482 0%" 's}."2sz3"§f;z;z:§;e:é 5:3V§'€:i;.;3=:fi'}.é§:§.e€§:-~§}t}:'i}5:f€3{g..§§f{:; mi-;:§3'§"" fix' <:*::;;':v:$.§':§A:71 %§;;:5;?.
2 . _ ' '. .~ " i "
iéfi. };.;;,i2%{}%E3-.:a;%{:':';g <:9g;<:%3:»1:1{:$ agzazé §:~:s~:,2.:::i_:":g §;:*<,»::{-:85; :5; :§'.:a=::
Qififir iiaiifiii '
;3efi'ai;~:::§1éi'«.f;sE: %_i':§;,_ itzfffiziéta umsfieg 82692391: §,:3a:% 0%' {E25 ?§€:ge§.:'-'r:.%;3Ea:
%}::.$§"r:1fi§:%:2§:$ :§::<:i;v
" §,aaz"§_"m<§...5J:<;1:z:S&E fay 'flit? §2€i§,ZiGE1fi§' 8'{i§3fi1§{.S flag? 33:6 ::'}:if§§§.i€3§1€Z'.3'
"r '-iizéas ':':::e;*fi£ -isigézsaii any Chaqua much Ems $35: 333;? E31: qéséitaiészz £31 §a¥<:sa§° fif
'r<a;<;;;g§zf:§;€z:%f:cm3:p§:i§;i;a§:': fig: :52 $1221: 5;? R$.<§-,3;;',{}i}{':_}~, §'-£5 fuziégaz
:3}§:ii§'3~»::%:1é.§$ éfliaé': :36 has aw': '::2a::.w.s,:'€{§ 3:23? :§:;~:":%:§; Ersam 332%: ::{;z3,:§3§;%_%§2.::§3:§,
§<:";ver: if 23:25: {saga of 3:6 €{}§E3§}§,&§f3;$}}§ is 'é:a.%{£:":g Emaségrzg }§:¥f*;§%€Z§;i,€;':{3£ '%:E":<3
' ""'iziv%3§:{m{:é::.:*r:{§* 7? .
5f,72"%.E3' §'f~€@..E8é.4-'2§Ei?--'9
;"'- 3
\../5
. {f:§*E,Z'{{:2 , é? E. ?;'Zi-Csfééé
'=s
3
" gzészaya zmai
chezgmi 3:": {gus$%:.i<m 22:"; §'{é'&'i}éi§2':%.}{é1 Efiiizzii, ;¥:%[};;i'§z3<}g2*:3 fa}: 5:"
{E38 Séiiiéffi *s¢'e§$ €§_§S§l{}§'k{}E3E'€{§§ w§*':§':: £23: €i}3.!_§£)i'fi{:§':1:3§2I§ "§j:;j'j.£*m€.A3i:é,"
:,%2"2§a5:~::"; '€315: {?G1fi§3§§E,§EEaiE§ §;E*;€,:§'{:%€% %':aV€: "€33-f;'.{§ 1;;;?iA.':1Zé{.§_"§'§E£;5§.§€§::i€7"V%;.:'
€§g.:1i;t§;»:§:{?:i €02' '£31126 <;§s3:3%: afiagégi aggalégzggi ?_?:';,é:é:' §.";§?'é;§?:i§:;*;s:%:*;'.._""'
3: 2?; 115: {E16 aragé £3? '$.15?I":3:S'g§=3§::&§:ii:.:a?;:f':;?{3i;2.7;3E&2L:':é:;é'?i €;%:;s<:§: %:fE':.:=: E'i{f€;i%}.S€:€.'§;
is %?{'E§. §:3;;:§z%:3Z::;é3siL~--;:;:{§ €313
';__z:§::€:{§ é"i§§_'.§i"'€}f«"§{?§?fE€€i§. ?;§i:.§%
fiamyiaéézzagit am §«{}fé§..j;§{§-£35 2:3: §%a_E ;agé..7§§?ré§f;=:§;>' $}%:{'.'§}§§:E£§§I€fZ"£E, '§'I:*2i':"i§'7;:-f§:aE;Eé,
__ §%~%;xi%';3iZ;a§;%;§j ~» :'§:.s_":::'::. §::i§;s §}t'.I'S{)§18.§_
zmé §:a€;u&s'éi5{E 1.-1' 'afzai s:.::_:f._
&:3m::::%:{mi:r:éi 3.2:;-rfi. f:§ée--"a¥§.:i:'p§a%,'§:::5é§2.: :;'a{§vz=.:§::'€::%. 2,2 Sf §*3S;5§,3:£§}{}§{:3; ~
areas}: smé ma: é'%;ifs:T'\§;'2I'i~'»€i{i§. :f:::;?':":%§?.{§"'*§?;::3 23337.15 :32"; $2.:-": $33232': ézazjey, '§'.Ea{: 2%<;re:::%,:§s€:§§
éssuaé a :::E:2::r5§j;:.§,i?{';€}€; far 21 gum 01? §€§,=¢'§;_i%2j;§{}{}§ v» :§..:":a1*':: GEE
§%E:%f:;§{§~::<'§.; 9:" '§§<::a:{%n Qfficé: {:7€}fi}§)§€X §3::*e:2::{'r§2} §e%a::ga;%s;;:*€:, €332.
favaéassf 055 §a§§,s.:a::;'%:, észfi ?_5£"§E€.'."£§ {£223 £'§"§;€f{'%1:'3' zgas :*E3{r:2":i€<i ii 2,3533
_ é . « n _ . E3
L' 33:73 sf $33 camyiaizzgimfi ES 313% fizz: "§m::$ac::iz3:: taak
§_sE,f_s€7;:.:+. at "E" 'Z1uT;iir;3:,§%;:§3?:.a§1&1}3'.¢ it is far €313 zicsugafi :9 {aka s;'ucE€:: 3 {:<;:»:::€m'::ia:;
4'~«.VVV';3s3fé:ir'§é%; v%%§;:é .'i:'§ai {1et:v:.;;r'L 53$. fizig séagm ${3§€§}£' an the greazzgé i:%:at ms
Ti:-%:j::5§u€§":§-as prsgexaéeii fifg-" thaér s:<}m_§3§.?;§;z.":an'£ far :"«::%a§§3a'£3?0:: 3%": ;3§1%f;.%.::::'2:ga, 3?:
s:a:i';30€ bf: aaid that $33 crsgnizazgcé aka}: aha Eaar;:m{§ éaiagégtrazs 522$
agaizlst E233 presfizxt psiiiécazaarfaccufiéii fer {ha affexzca ':::§3.§.%:§ S-€{L"§fiQfi
E5; 'z:,%E<:i;',A
53%;? Z'*§a'Js. $36.-'3{'§{%9
if-2%
Eiéésc, Cfi. 9 E '}',="Z{%I39»
és
13$ sf {E16 E'é5::g<:}iiab1€- §I{i$L"§§£1i?'.1}€S Aw: is Efiaii ix; Eaw. '§'"§':{--:'. :§'€{:iiafaV{:V':=§
E3}? the }u'38};"i1€{i 6912:1353 fm' fiéfi §;€'£ii:3;a:3x3§* §'t'p{"}I'3€%E€§L~§;f;} 249%)?' :':§{3'i%§.~'%VLiéV--9
ggiggviawg <gI§E}'{U'? gaggasggzxré ?é_%GA%'v§ _§_:';."é}.:":§'"tiE:a». §¢:j§:,%:¢:;§:':a-Vv.:. gm '
geaai g.;$:>*:?a:;§.a:% $5: quazzgh flag impzigfiitii {3§*s:1z:_3::_ '
5%, {:3 {E16 mgait, "$2.5 ?"'€§E§§{}Ei: §'fli§:=§ 1;:;,1€§; _§:%".ifi: §é%};";§E{E is %t:é§TA3;§; §3€'%é§zji::a::"'.ia':"?>£§:%:§::§'"€f§':<1:<} '§."?°',f 223$??? $3; 1i'€E}}3£T§.é3€".g 25:3 ii
éiass :3::s.z:.Séa:§%:§é:§§;Z<;:§, " __ \
sa/-4
.....