IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT
DATED 11113 THE 28"' DAY 01:' JAnUA1ai*'"z£>0$;--i .
PRESENTM
THE HDIPBLE MR. 9.13. nlnmigkgm, Tick:-z:i:s";:ii1e*:*1§:i?:VT_A*
AND
THE I~ION'BLE MR.JUé*£:'¢Ev'v.d.s§3riA1¥1f;T
Writ Appeal'
ma. 322/2095;-325[2;ooa. sa%3;?.s;2oo5
In Wm' APPE£_;:!.:;;.&'*e'.§;*5._21@,.€3;€fe."': AA
Between: VV M 2 " V
Eflasgvery" "Né'E1'8.V§3gl'i i}';i::::j'ziekfi V
New re}5rase11.ted v§3y..V_it5A " _ -- '
General Manag&r_Fi21'a::1(':e, " _
491 Floor, Cgfikrfi Bdani. ii?-"ufliiiixg,
N0. 1, Q1". Amhfidkar .\_1'ei:d"h§_,,_
Bangakarej A' : Aypeflant
«.5
{£3}? 3.Swe'€J:1a AI;ésV:ii:1'A,' }'&civ0ca1;e)
1.
Statt’i’P.(a3*11ataka,
Re’§:re:3¢nie”re.
_’ – 2 ‘.3 _ ‘V}”‘i_1-E {)i2’tZCt0}i”,
iDepa.:’tmen.’£ of Mines &. Gacslogy,
.–7§<iha:1i§a Bhavan, Bangalore.
" V3. The EX¢C1.3fiV€ Engineer,
Public Works Bepafiment,
Manclya Division, Mandya.
4. ‘¥”.he Ckzvmmissionar,
City Municipal Council,
Maxadya.
The Execguirgive Engineer,
Zilla Panchayath Division,
Mandya District, Mandya.
«U1
6. $3iddaram11,
S]-0. Saidegouda, Major,
C}.21ss»iCcsntract0r,
1*’ Cross, Ramamandira Read, V _ *
Hasahafli, Mandya. _ = :”§£a’s-yondents.
(By Suit, Nilonfer Ak1:a1′,’ AGA” 55 R3, Sri. A.
Narayanappa, Advocate fo1fHRj4v,._§ofi1:.g=; :3oa;d”‘:2;’u:admg,
V. A *1′? 0.. L. Dr. Ambadkar Veedhi,
Banga:1£)::,c5.V’–v.»_« % .. * ; Apyelialzt.
(By ‘s;ag;’t;’swla{i:g;’§I§1§and,Acivocatgg
_ Jami:
v»’¥;;¥:ti?:*;”Stat’:§: of Karxzataka,
.’ it
‘ Represented 153; its S{§’.C}:’€i1″fl1″}’,
{L’;epar¥::1:1eni: of Clommerce & Industries
Building, Bangalore.
The {)iI’€<::t0r,
Department of Iviintes 8:. Geaiegy,
Khantija Bhavan, Bangalore.
3. The Executive Eilgfilliifil”,
Public Works Department,
Mandya Division, Mandya.
4. Tht: Execlltive Engineer,
‘ Irrigation Degartment, ._
MUӤ)A, Mandya District. 1
ES. The Exccutivrz: Engizleer,
Zilla Pa.n.c]:;_ayath Diviszion,
Mandya District, Mandya,
6. Ramesh, *
S/0. Laie I{.B. Tammv —-.’é:vgGu*r}a,;V– VV ” _
Aged abcut 31 years, Clas_$~’2 ‘C’x.3ntracf£:i*,… ” *
i3«.Nc>.159;’100, Maxigouda Layauz, ‘
3″‘ Grass, Maxadya ‘ : Resgnondents.
(By Smt. Nilo1;fef’ fcxxf Iivto R-6 served}
in Q
Between!’-.– V ”
Cauvery Nceréivmi Liixlited Mysore,
New mp1wés::nted’b§§’Vits
” ‘~Gcne;’a}i.Mana.ger Fin’ ‘
4th Floor, <:*;:fi'ea.Baa:~d Building,
*:.sz<:…1,' "Br. 'A;txIjedi{9r Veedhi,
Batggaioftt.-. 2 : Appcliant
(BY TAna31d, Advocatzz)
V' i;V'.A'I'hc:Siat¢ of Kaznaiaka,
'Reprwentfid by its Secmtary,
Eicparment of Crnnmerce ('Se mdtlstzies
'"M.S. Building, Bangalore.
V £2. T216 Director,
Dcpartzmmt 0? Mines 6:; Geology;
Khanija Bhavan, Bangalozt.
3. The Executive Engineer,
Public Works fmpartmem,
Mandya Division, Mandya. ._
4. The Ifiixecutive Enginecx”,
Z.P. Engineer Wcrks,
Mandya.
5. City Municipal Council,
Mu.c1dur’I’a}uk, rs/iand§:’£2..§)istrict. ”
6. The Supeliintcudent of __ _ q
PWD., Mysore: C§irc:1e, N.s2gar’ab’ar1,=.} ”
Mysore. V’
7. RM. Subh§égo1_idé;””‘~.._ b
S/0. N12g1’egQuda;. — _
Aged about ,5}: }~’ea”i:-5; {“f:cs1im’a<:ttijf,""V
R/0. I~(fati"11 S:i.A.–vVN.i3aya,=..%V '
K31'. 134; 44¢» cmss, ' V'
Marégowda Badavamjzg ¥_Via1_1dya.
8. B.
S} m$&:.}301*cgoWda,”” « _____ H ;
‘ V. -. Agbrl 33E)i2~L1f’§3 years, C:::ntra.ctor,
. R/..<:-. }é'.,.'f .€:i§-31'; . €_3hamu11deshWari:1aga1'a,
___ 4 €12 Manciggra.
9. £1,
8/ :5; S&t3né:gO1:d.a, Aged about 45 years,
C0nt:ra;:tr;f>r, R/0. 1871,19,
‘ Lawers Eloiony, Subhas Nagara,
V A :1’ ” hgiaiidya.
Venkatesh,
WS/0. Vaenkatai,
Aged about 51 years, Contractor,
R/0. G–835, Guttai Colony,
Mandya,
Z1. M. Ramakrishna,
S/0. Mucldaiah,
Aged about 59 years, {3<)11traci:m:,
R/0. D. No.5–800, I<;';.'§'. Street,
SE. Patna, Mandya. M
12. Razlzaiizlgu,
S/0. Mramgayya, V
Aged about 37 years, contractor,
Rfcr. Haleblldanur,
Taluk 8:. Dist. Mandya. ‘ ‘ t ‘: Rc:gspond.e1’1ts.
(By Scmt. Nflotlfer Az<bar.:GA 12519 R4 an. R6, Sri. TM.
Anil Kuniar, Advocate for 'R4 .T.;w€..1,"I_"xj'v–}$.~3z, 6 sclyétl)
Writ appea1_E'~!g:.36f3i2I 4 of the Karnataka
High Court Act 1: ._j;'ing"._to§ set a$ide"'fhc..~o1d.er passed in W33.
983122005 datficé. .
W:if…apf>3.féii :2 o0’51»s.s,..;r;ied 0/3. 4 of the Karnataka
High. {hurt Actf p2″aj,ting_ set aside the (mder passed in WP.
1:23 1 / 2:295 –.d’ated Q’:#’..2eQ5.–. ‘ ‘
Writ’ appeal is filed UfS. 4 of the Karnataka
High {hurt fact })Vrayi11g to set aside the order passed in
_ w.P.9§33′;2oo5 dated 14.62.2005.
No. 32812005 is fiicxci U13. 4 or-the Kamazaka
‘afiigh C9t1zjt’E¥.{3’t.Vp1’aying to set aside {he antler paased. in W.P’.Nos.
A Q’burt dalivfgred the following-
4ajz9Q–4-6.3′:2:3_/ 2:34;.-.4 dated 20.1 1.2003.
“‘~Al1writ a§pca}s coming on for timiizztrs this day, fhe