IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
I'")A"l'I£i) Tl {IS THE 15" OF FICBREEAI-'{Y,'2O 10
I PRES E*L§\I"I':
THE HON'BLE MRJUSTICE N.K.PATIAL..__"' .
AN D
THE I{ON'BLE MR..JI;s'rIcE B.s;§$E$zwAsE
M.F.A.No. 7317 OF 2'00"v 131531: ' V V «V
I5-'.S:'iv£-ltsa. V
S/0 C.S.PI"dbhE1K£1§'".. _ 7
Aged about 29 yx-?e1t"s.
Resicfim-E a-,:i.%\1(').50.,~' . V
(;3;.1.:' S1 1'e_<3E.;"L}1Vs.<4)(31'§. I .
Lia r1_;;'e-1I'(_):3¢;r~ E1550 KJO8, '
._ _ Appellami
{EE3y Sri . S11 Na km :':e-Fat.' fxcik-'f)c'i21t<'?)
AND ; ' 'V _
_ 1i)i9N E\rE.1:1:'1irz1i4l1r1a.M.i)., D.M.R.D..
--. V C'<'.)_IV1'SLi'}vT.Ei'£'1E_ Raciiologistz & S0r101()g;is1,
I.'}v<:%j;3:§a_.:9E.;'1jL:;}.t 0? Raciic) Diagnosis.
A K1M.~:;.;j -1<..A'§-Ea. I{0d<i.
.~P_Lzi..<'aIn. Bar'1gaI<)1'e-560 O04.
.«='.\.rV1"c:i Rtzsiding at:
Ifm§:I.0rs Qu.arEe:'s.
AA 4_ Séxrsé. Road. C(')1*p01*a.1'.i0:'1
at' is m ily H():'1'1E*.
H C§"12:1n1211"ag'1')c1.
I~3a.n.gal<)r<~3-- 560 01.8
.. Responciems
[f3y" §\/E/ I-3. M.Shy2,1.m Prasad & Asasociaitts. Advocates)
A ffffffff
é
"l"§'1is EV§I"z.g".1é21:'a1___ {he
JL!(1_L§E1](':1§ z-111d z'\\-\-'21l'(.1 ("l2.1u>c% {J12./(')§3/ 20(')6 1);-£S=if.~3{'.(i1 }1'1f§\)I.X-"C?
s\§0.i3(}11/2('}()3 on the File of zlhv VIII Acid}. Jxlclggc-r. C;:':)_1i'r.1_'Q1"
S11'1aE1 (,',2;u1.=s:*5»'. i\/102111361' MAC'1'w\»" £.:3a-;1r1ga1()z'u CZ_i:*;'._\;'..ja1.)a1'§.Ey'
a11()\.x-'in;;' the ctaim pe:.i1ion ibr ('m'111)c*a'":sa11ion=X31 .
cl:11121:1(''<~mc1''11. 01' <.'mpc>1'1s'sz~11'ion.
'i'§'1é.~a M.I'.:'\. c1"1; ii-'ms. Vc"12sy.V
PATIL J. ciu'Eiv(?1'('=(§ 211:? f0"E1()w'i1"1g:
uuDG@£fifi '
'l']'1c insmmt £§})})("f'l} is ('Sf 'jVAl_.1:§("Eg;§1'I1(i*2'1{
and z':wz1rd ciezuecl V :i:3e1,."#'-'Nxci in MVC
N030}!/2003 byjhelééfififilvujgufifiufihfildudgu Conn
of Small (:L3"x'E'§':'-:(.'fr-§A_ -'.1161_'M€2'}11'3£:r.;'Mo1,1' Ac*(?i«::lc1'"11 Clailns-3
f1'i'iI;')[.iI]E1v].",',\.»i',,.V 'Vi'-'-}:,:;>.i"':_<_5_5'a1'--.",;g_)2Vfe " (Ak1_¢;f¢i§1'121i'fcér :*efc1*1*ed to as
"I'1'1'b1.11:}'V'r,-'1.I' 'for H'
2. 1'%y "1'1j1(* _i£"l1'}.)l"Ii.'.,{i:"}."';'.if'} _j1a(1g1'11(%1'11 arm} E:1WE.1l'd. the
'i':'*ib~%.:.;:1a1.i 112.15 é1'~u.$t:: at 6% p.a.. from the clatc-3
(517 Efiié? }3érii'§(_):11": 1111 10 me date of deposit. 21:; 2.1gai;'1st the
o..1e1i1'1'a.. <.§1".:.t,11ve.* a};ape11a111£ for Rs.45.00.000/«~ on ac.:<::(.}Lmt' of
tvI"1V<¥"=.i1':wjmic--e:~; SllS1'E}.ii"]€'('i by him in the I"(}Ei.(11 m1I""i"ic
z'=1;eI.I2»uIl has 1')1'0sc:m.c=r(i 1.}'1:'s appcéal. 53ec'?k1'ng
filed :1 (*}z.m'11 pc=;'1'.it:i()1'1 unck*.1' scc{.i()11 166 01' M.\-"._.._A(..*.E:.
bc*1'()n-=.> the "1"rii3u11a1. (tIz1in'1i1'ag-5 c'ompcns211"._iam"-._<01'
R.~..+.41i3.(.)().(')(')('.)/--. T}'}c=-* said (.*}:;'2iin1 })(:'li1'.i(')l'1 i'1'(.E(1
('O11Sid('1"2.1{.i(,)n i:)c{ore the' 'E'1'ib1,m211. which .i;__'a "m,V.11"1:1'_;"~a1'i+:§r~--.
11«.'z11'i11g' b(j)I}"1 sides and af{.er z;-1s.:«;Am+.s'i1'1;"__f.' E11b'<.)r:1i' .E' 1'iflCi"._V
dc)c?u1T1'1t.'mmy cvi(im'1<.'c. h2:1.<s e',11}c.)\\-'e.d...i;1'}t+_'$aVi'd £..':V}"(r.1_l'I"1T1 '
pc;~.Ei1.i()r1 in part and 21xxr2:1rcicj.€.E_ a si.1--:11"Rs.2.9-9.2'OO/ ais
(.:(')mpc?11sal'i011 urlder dif'f'c1'c1"1I'~li1E";1(isa v¢1{i}"1 ' i.l'A'7lVt.(_:;'1"(:"'{'I~v3{V2&3". 6%
;.).a.. f1"on'1 the date of__peE:ii,i(')1'1. {ivi1' i:'I:.1<3 ciaitTet--.()f _€iep(T)sit:.
i:5ei1'1g;§ a.xg2jg.§1'ic4r\~'c*<Ti by t.hc:«_S'a_iCi'.__§11;dg1fi--€:%'ivi1f."Q1161 axvard. the
e1}')})<.?l1aj'1£ "i'1w:».1.é."a_ :j§.)1*e5{=};.:;.i".mi'ci .1.his dp;)C2.l}, seeking
Q.' 11 h -(.1 1': ("tel 11 E? 111 1. 0 f (r()'nj' p er; .5j£f1~t is) 1'1 .
S. VVc"}'jl.'1..m.s'c*1 2:i1J¥§ea1'i13§3§ for
°é=E"1c "*z;'ipj;5Le11é1:':1'. :;'§£I'1(H1W}€&1I'IT1('(i o()1.ms(;rl a.p13c;;1ring for
A r:cVS.;:;-011d121.
_.r31.f':'c§13--' ('e'11'('i'"u} pc1'us~;;1} ()1'E.11c i111p1,:g_§1}c?(.i _jL1Olgn1em'.
Vii.1;A1d 1:)y Em': a}')}'3c}!a11i. and t:.1"11'z1 Exakcn by him. has aw.2':u'cied a
...~.a1..:1'1'1 of Rs..e.l'.30.()()()/-- I'.(,)w211'(:1..~; pew") and St..1ff('?I'iI'1g;;'S zmci a
.s:.11'n oi" R..<:s.1.I:3(,),()()O/» 1.()we'1r(.f$a n1cdi(*al
1:\'e_vz;111c1'1sd1ion 2»1wa1'dc=:(.i by the TIfi'111}'i'.i~].'fi§'i.l>iV5§, _j«:,A,1st_
21nd l'€.'.&E1S"a'()11'(ib1L' anti it d(")('.'S not tied} f(:'>.:=- Ti; itCiitk:1*«:t=i11<"€";
7. Hwcw:1'. U10 '1"a'ilm=:'1 1:j~..1__ l'1a1Vs:é'-..c.='1V*m:j<T1
only at SLIH1 of Rs.9.000'/ M during
1.
11:? pcri(.)d of Emat111L%VI1’t… i1:)1f .’i’ii1 ‘(:?i::’1»’T,1’1&’3. takirlg {he
in(‘*.01’1’1e of the e1;3;.)§él121r}t”:1{§S;*i3::'()d5V;f mo1’1th. ‘£’h.e
ssaid (‘.()111]T)’c.I..’13.-:«?211’§’§5j’}_’_ ~2i\x_fa’i’.§ic?d«– [by /the ‘l’ribu1″1a1
:’11e.1(.1é=:qué31t’.c ‘:1’1Ai1.tfi_Vit. §’j} be c=r11}”1a1’1Cc.(i. T116-.*. ‘I’:’ibu112:1
11215 m’1*c§’a’:1 in I2-2Ij;i1’a_u§__.’__>’w. t:1’1g?”~i:’ico11’1c of rh:–r dcc:<:2,1s::s&~c1 2:11'
l-'{sa.13.()0.(')/- phi, mLI1:A {:0 be 1’1l’1211″1c.mrd. it is t:1’1e case of 1:119
Aéi–.j{)})I;?!l£fi_1’vH:. “u.Iv1;1Et}’t-_.i”1t’ is working 2215; an ‘*3xt:cut:ive arxd
c:1a’21xx;s=i.n5_.§__:.’t’1::V}’s;21.ia=..:’y’ of Rs.?’.()00/» per month “‘I’}1e1’efore,
VI”éJJ.<'1}1g i.'a"1—-"1'.(') Consic1c1'z5:t.io11 the age. ().%}A:11”1t amci SiI’}(‘.(? E”i1c=> 2-1.c?<"'i1’1 at
” Rs.4.0(){)/– per m01’1i’h it. would hue just 2.=:1″:(i 1″cr2:1s(‘)1’1ab}e
AM»
9
Rs.25.()()()/-. tmdc-.r this hezlri il1S1(‘E1(1 of Rs.}5.0_(__)_O/W
2–1\v2==11’c£e<'i by tile 'i':'i1i)1mal.
9. ‘]’he ‘1’1*ii:)u1’1ai has (.'<.)mmE11e(;1 an .~«1″.’1_f”o.1’_f’o’ i:11 ‘
a.1wa;11′(ii:1g :21. 511111 of I’~'{s.I.1ff3.2(‘)0/– t<m'z'11'(;is_.i(1)§$,Qi ~.Kf.:iii1.4_L.E.'é'£f"'
im':. by 1.2-1k’:1’1g the: i1’1ci__1i»i’yVA.21t. .,a1:’1€i-; b.V\;;*
21(‘.i0p{.i1:;g MulI’.ipiiE~1* 01′ 1E>’]._’i71’o_1c séisigi V{tom13§§?’t’1*:321t’ic)11
a;1wa}*cic(:1 by the ‘1’1’ibu n.;11 is gi-madeqL:a£,e ai’1’c£..,it.”requires
to be c=-.*:11’1a.nc:oc’i. \?V€ i’121Vt;* .oL1lrL:,2-1(i%y’
the a1.)peli2;1s’1i. 211V Rs.4.QQQ/.3 rrir=)§’1’1’§:1:,._–}rlcé xvas atgc~t1
211710111 13:14.1: Ii1’11eW 01′ 21c(:idcnt’. zimd t.hle is ’17” in \-‘iC\-\~’ of 1110
law ig.’.–ir_:1 (i()w’11._ by {i1c”-Afjctx Court’ in the c2.1:’sc:% of Sarla
.”VVoVrvihVé1 A~othervs”W”Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation
AaoéoFihotho1′.AV.T’Vré}.3z1d of
3\/I1.Ih”§’L)}.i’.si:_’.”.}’.(2.1% I 6 ad(.)pt.<:d by the '1'rib1,:1m.l. We 21c.:cept: t:.he
~_EIi~J9"€;I~i_E_j}iliI }~'" lzlkcn by the 'E'1'ibu:1z..1.i at. 20% E0 fhcr whoit'
_ E5c.a<.1'y;' 'I'1"1e:1*c;éI'/~ (125.4. 00/« x 12 x 17 x :20/100)
j”‘_’»’,.nka”-‘1.”
V”-‘;.fs\:-tcl t”.1’1e irlcome of
i}1:3’i(“2E-id of R:s.].1E3.2(‘)O/– a1wz~11’cie(1 by the? ‘E.’1’i1:n.1m1l zmd
‘d(‘.(‘.{)1’di1}§_§i}-‘. it is axwarck-;*.c1.
E0. Fu1″1}’1m’. Elhc “I”:’ii3Lm2_1i E’1a=15’s c’rrc.°C;i”‘*:’:1’~..__ii{:§.”n
21wa~11*(:ii11g_{ amy (‘T(‘)l’I1p€’1’lS£1Ii011 [.()W’dI’dS I’u~*.v–‘.«[1.1’__L’f”, 11116-.}.:ci£(“.’c:z1v ”
€:’x1.)ensc?s e:u”1(l il’1(>1’Cf():'(;’. if 1’1c:e.ds ézc) be;iwé;:1′(.it§d; ‘f0V1’~.L_f_’.11v’;’; A’
rc*z.2sc:):’1’I.hzi’1i.. in View of 1l’1c7E-1..1_jLariL;s;_ §LISE&.1′.i’1’i'(f§’.iv__1f)}’ _i§1’1C
a2ppci§a1’1i he has L11′:cierg011e Opt-:ra.1:i()1’1..”i1f171p12miis were
i1’1s£>.1’1’ed zmd t’l’1e:’c:2¢11’te1*«._:i’e11’1.ov«:;c.! éiajid he: has i}’1f_’)L£1″1’€d
czxpcxascis towards t.}’1cj.A:se;m’c*. FL:1r1.hE:_1flmi-‘ has to iakc?
f0l1(,)w up tf’e21i_:ii.”1;:r1:113’l’!4i(%:1fe?’§I’>rt:?..’ ‘1j1z1Vir1g 1’ega1rd to the
facis zuici (“i1″‘(‘.’L_.1/F31-.’I’~’sIEéi,1’i(?€.fft§”()-r the (.’E’1S€. we awarci 2’-1 sum of
Rs. 5. O00 ‘/ f E.1I’1d(‘1.”_ t’2’1j;”s;a }*1 ugitl;
13. 3–I’m_4=i1″1;;{ 1″te;__§2-zi=f.I ” iVQ_..”‘[i1e ums ami (‘tir(;:un1s1,a11(\cs of
£110 (‘t.z?1:.§c. its Sieatccfi”e;1b§.wc:,. the iI1}pi.lgI1Cd jL1dg111tr1’1i. anci au.»*211’d
132a§s’sa-aid b’y\-‘ i’1’1″{1′._’ f’lf1″iE’)Lli}.{-1] is iiabicf {.0 be m()di1″i’n1;.’Jr:*1′:se-,i1i’k’g:’1 §=)é=1y22-iblc mmc.reak1.: as §'()11(‘J’.-‘FBI
-EU-
rL?:1cwz;11:)Iv for 2″11’1<:')1'1'1e*r five yc2:11'.=; wi£.I1 Ii}.3c.*1"i'j\,-* I10 him in
wit' §"1purt’i(.)1″12.1iL2
s;§”1z=111 E38 rc1cassc(i inf:-w(>1.11′ 01′ the 21ppt.’.I1a1’a1,
on (‘1L.’]”)():~’siE. 3.)}: the I”t:’h’1.)(.)l1(1CI’1l.
E..)1’e;1\\:’ ihe zlward. a.1v(?()1*c1i1’1giy.1,
*§,.£%.,,3:Awé
tsn*