High Court Karnataka High Court

Shedimane Ganapathiyappa Since … vs Devakamma on 2 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Shedimane Ganapathiyappa Since … vs Devakamma on 2 July, 2009
Author: S.N.Satyanarayana
EN 'r:~.:§'=: gma {,:::2§;%"§* {>9 ;{}5 <;:m:.:§:§A,§€cg;;:;:§s4;=:;;<§{;;g _i_.  3

§{§§A.?€(}.2;§~.'i{§ 2005

 

§3§E§"?"«§v" E'§§:'3E'§
Sizaiimana Cra;1ajg?at£::ifé'a?§a    
Siam {$636 by L:Rs.9.%E:i%;.ap;}.£;:  ' t
Pggcd Ei"§}G'L":'7"£': €32 j__;::'s., 

2, S'{3§E,:5:xmmara§*éf;323'*~ " 
Sf 0 E:§V;':Z§jz=.i3:ap9;%.§1§l§:a§;+§=a'~
gégesi §:"£§'Ié{§1'§,f: 4'-"--?;~.  '

 " ' §:£:§tE:' £%;5é"e ;;f;',s  
 "§'ai'2ag:;§;§3ja. ::e;4b};é, Saga? 'i'ai'uEs:_,
'ghihugtiga v§},"z;$E1:"'1'1<:A¥: :3??? 431'

3, ' ' _ '§'§131E;{_E§"§::éi3f:'§i:E'1a§a
"W; :55 §:§;§é'§ {3E2a:2§ra;s§1eE§a1'
;%gr=;e:i";:<1bou£ 40 yraf

   _ V  ;"E*3n}..i£v$5t.E3a wfg S.E{s§2wé§::{i§21

 figgszi about 48 yzixg

M  'Vvfiszifiz am r] 0 Stfiugségu vifiagsfi
. p "klasaba E~§9bi,:§ $aga:° Taizséi,
' " "f3E3£mz§ga EZ'23i$§:'i€:.'L 59;'? {$83.

Ramaiéziskgzz



3/ :3 Eiizedimams §\§ara§;a11app3. ,
Since cierad by L.R's.,

5,

 

Pailmavatllamma

W] 0 Ramakrishnappa,
iiged about 64 yrs.,
R/0 %-iamsagaru
E03313 village,
Talaguppa Habli,

Saga? mink,

Shimoga Qim, 5??' £01'

Féazayanappa

8/ 0 Nara§=*a1:1appa

Agsé 8.3301}? 5'2§:rs;.,.;""' _   - 
R/0       
Saga:    __   
Shimega gist. '5';?74§:':--[§;'.«_  V'

$zfLtiiéfasa.V  3 E€:3ii'&39aLz.§ag3;3a_ 
Zigfidé3_§f}"£1t'4fi..:y;f'§"%.;'=. 'V-~ ' ~
i2;<3_Ka1;g.aafaa::.;."%«.V'T' f 
Lifigaiiaraakkf Pé;-Sp. 

Sagar *;2:.1m:,V   V

§$i"::iz'r.;<::ga Liisy; V23???" 48};

. V ""v'€:i'§§ata:c§§:a§a
  5%] @.'V4?€::§'e2y§3;nap;3a
 »§sg€€i"£a}3v1ii 3'9 ym, ,
A  0 iiaiaséigamz
'~-Sagjar' Tgihik,

Sfgimgga. Dist. 53?'? 4&1,  2§;§}3E§E:?;é'33:£§

 '  sgg, @0933, my;

fifivakamma
Agfifi aboui; £134 



22 . S. Ranmchandra
Agesi abaui 4?? jg-*I"S.,

3. i~£.8.?=§aga1#aj,
Aged about 3'? yrs,

4. H .&§.Sridha1"
Agaé about 3? jy'I'S.,

R€Sp
Sjo Ra,mac.h;a1i::§,raia§3:_, 
Sincs zisad ?a},s"L=.jE?_1s; 

    =

Agfid éi§,”)”(}”1}’§,§-5′; }«*:1f.:%,_ – V’

V 6. ” ;;§’,{:+.}.vmkamg£:§

. _a£)<:A:ut 42' 3:13; ',V

3%

'5'__fi.ge::i jam £374 yrs. ,

Resgfiadejit' 3":-. is the wéfs and

_ ' 5 azxd 2?' ar6:3_s0n$ Sf
" " = ..§§1'::%: Iii. Gaizapappa

are" 417/ :3 Hamgagaru zriiiagefi

ffaiaigugipa Hsbii,
_ Wiéaggar 'faiuk,
Vfélqémoga {}is"£., E??? 4&1, %%ss;§:g{:zn:%m*:§:;

'§'h§3 .2-zgpaai is fiiafi 1:; 3575:} {TPC agzziiésgé €316 jiaéégwsgié.
arié d€(:=r:~'.*£3: tiatagi I,8;;T:f{}€}i:"'S gyasgezi 1;}: §€si,§'é,é§f?2j ;»E{}t£}T£ ma, ihgx

flit: sf figs: Qiivii Juiiga {S12 1331}, Saga}; éiisméggitig EEK: a;§:§;§::a;

31:6? .<%:"S'?[ 3;:*5§'§€§ {;"§%~3f83} 9:: the

Ad;€ii.{Zivii ..§udg€~:: iiQ§3'.Df},3 & JMIWZ-, Saga}:

§€Sfix.Pv«Z0;2264 £20553

%-~'-

.iL}t=:s;ai<amma
fiagétii abzimt '?§ 3-":<1:~:.,

S. Eamaaéizagdza
Agsii a§39:,2§. ééfi yr3._,.. .

Q3!

?i.SJ’é’agaraj, T «.

ifiged about :35 §zrs.,

4.
Agsfi

A3} 1356 §’_§?3.E§~§$c”;?.”‘;g_;’¢’.<§.V'§"{"iz'7,.'

ifiosalii vi§__Eag<%:, ' _ V

E':-.::Eagu;};:2€; ..$3ag;2raV71§2;§2?.1§{:b_ b

§h§mg:a E}is1:<_.._V:T3'?.";?' 4&3} é'7:y;;§eE£a§i:iS

~ , '{5}' $3353? §.§;§;'g'zi§?*. A?-§':3,,s,_f§__}_a3::,,:23::€, ;%<i*s1§

" '

Séggaéiéfifiazze {jz%.;:éé§a:E;i}'a;}§}a

V _ SIG S_§'1€ri.-iiiéxiaxiis; Narayargapga
vSi1:<:?c*: e§::s:{§ fijfg E». R3.

~ V ”’E,.g;~:§.1;§§::3;:13::2a

‘ W E 0 {§a::a§a£h.;l}?ap§}2:

figéisi aémui E53 5513.,

u ” V . V E 3;} S, {,1 §,.:::§<:;}ir:sz:"e1}?22;f::.2i

Sf Q S, {}a§1a§:a%:E1iy§::.g3 gm
,1-'§&gf_',€§ a'E."2m£: $3 §_;;:":~;.,

3:: ii: are rfa Hegaiii viiiage,
Taiagzigrpa Hehié, Saga? Taltiié,
$%;.1'3;m3g*a E}:%s£r:Z:::'{ 5?? 4% 1,

is}

E {E}

$m?:.Si1an'{§":aEa
W! <3 S. K. Chancimshekaz'
Aged about 43 §;:"s,,

S:m.€;}5£:'£E;a W} as fi~3.i{'E€avi:1{§z'a

Agaié aiwut 41 3213.,

Est}: 33,! :3 S'LE§§;§,gOé'%3: viiiage,
Kasaba ¥~I=::'i':si3l, Sagan" Taii;tk,
Shimaga Di$t1:fi§a;'.Ei. 33?'? 4351;

2′

23:.

Eéagzzaiiflséana

S; as fihedimaize §’~ie’31#a§,:;;i1§2.;g>§–a, ”

$313.05 iiisad £53; #5

%4’a,::§ma%~%3:§1§1:3; §1 §:«1 ‘V _ _
‘-:2 §<E'22:a,e3Iia:1*i,§;}%;:{:;'5:;g§:52.:[.__ _
fiageii' §3.7z}°Q1:'{
Rig H§:§j2"§;}.i"E§é:igE£§"3,§ A "

E€~:2.s;3;1ii viiiagty *

.. *§j:%£a§:ap§:a §*§::}§} ,
& ” iaigzii,
* .. Ssi:,i:;:@g:2i_§;%igs t, 5??’ 493*

” -?%%’€§:9*€L:r*’3%’:%§.&;%>*:1i3é%
‘ S} 0 E.’*?are;§;s21:appa

4;r%gf::iabz§1:'{, 53 }–‘fS. §
:_e;~.:; Eiaiamanji

~ ; ,§§3g3:”° Taiuiz
V’ Shimaga $135; $17′? 13%}?

éférinévasa S; 0 ;§’§a1’a}Fa::2″:g;pa
figsé a’:::s:n::: 3&3 }'”I’S5§

$1′; :3 Kaéamazzjgl
Lingaziamakki E393′;

Eagar ‘i’§.:§u1:,

{J}

Cf:

$31′

55:}:

E§i1}L1:10ga i}i3:’€’, 5?’? 483′

Véiaxkaiachaia

3,13 .Na12,}-‘a:1a;3§)a

Aged 313011: 43 }*rs.:,

Rf :3 fiamsagaxu

fiagar Taiuk,

Shimaga ffzégi. 5?’? -@913

Eiazzzzapgsa Ganagjaapgéa,
S; 0 Ramachaaizémiah,
f’§i33.<3€ zziéaii by 1.3?

}7’a:2133aVa’:_”E1:amma

ztrge Gajaiéaggpgga

Agcéi about 41.35 yrs. ,1

}§,<:,va=:;_;;a:a'g_i:-i " ' V _
2 ,7 =:;—-i—§-.v€§aja11ai:22:;)}::a_ .

figsii ab0u%’._6;§ jg<::$,,–

%§§<;;§2a;~;ga;ga:::.{g;~V_"v«
age E~§".v–i}a;'§anaf;7;.a§I;yp:;;– V
Agaéé a%m,',£'s;'='~%.:3 };:i'$;*.,_ ' '

.~ . :~2;;§}3.%.€j Q ' 'i*§3'r§ g}ségf*a:":,;__§{i§iz:g&,

"§':;:E:a g*:;:jQ}:s%;i 'E-E

W _Sag%51;." ..'§'a;%:a_E<;~,A ' é "

Eiizimaga .,}§}:”L.§t; 3 511%} 1.

gas?” ii ~§%::<.,z for 5:; E25}

. "t";?h.i:~,A§§§sa: is am 22,23 ?§<:§e:}

'z:.;::«:i ii.€<cL';'§';:=:'i- giaiaé §.$.2€}€§E3 _g;:a$Sm:i ii: §«€:'§a?é;ET{}§.f2€¥§} <31:

tiikfi .§"::§£%/”:§3,?§?’*:Ea;’i””_« 321$ Caniirmiiig fiaéé ja{§Tgm€:::i magi {§€’€Z’f’:€i ziézaéségi

__ *_E’§§..3;2’€.§@§ gagged in E}S.’§*%{:.4’%:”§?,I §E?§’%’% {i'”3’E7%;’8:’%:,: mi; {E716 i-52%: <3?
w§T§}f_' §2'3§£i€§§,C§*e?i§ :..?mZg€ {=3r.E'3:':} & §3§v€§%'{3, Sagzzzi

YIV §£:ts§;a;:§:§};{~:z:E;3

'*<

,- gagziigzisé E E6 jaziigmazéi

Titasfiéi flppeais s;','0§3;i3Z.3.g an £331' Hif'E:i§'"i§.'ig {E323 :%a}é':a '::§j:i:
:C}{£I'i 2:it:i3ivs:*r<2d ihfi fcsliawing;

&E§E}{}E’g€£§E’€’?

‘?’;%z@se two €i§pf.’:£iIS arisrf: east: ;§fmé3;”:1-g::m:%,;::;::.:1 .«.,??ua’i_§;:;:ii::;f”;?;

arm E}c<::°:::é passfici in f52.,%,8é;'5»~;'{'3E <:.$2:3__1i£:c€€:{i ~3:i;'*$ f;'éi'} '

Whsiyzzig}. the e.}2.1dg:%:1£:z1% .1-md {}€-C'§'@§"}:&ESSif{:: 311:3 ,3}?
93:1. £:§?:<3 £316 of 1126 ;%:ici§..;{Z%v'éE. ;Ez3§§g::– {;_,%:j. isms;
{'.%?:z:§,E§%E:g€{2 E3}? the j;}§Eifiifi'€§S,'8$' , é,S'vv:"€:§.§3'f€.?¥1€§E¥§}T§§~3 E0 E3

uzziésr $e::pz:r3:.€: agggfiéégis. '

2. 7i%Z’S§?s::3::§;;3£ fa Efiéiszééizzg $3 éiiésfi 2i§3§;;:”::a}$ emzz
‘§’E7:éé1 _§i,2:i::,:i%§”§a«.’V”:2;’i:E, Z–§;.3§:~:=;;zi.a::é$ ‘fE”Cs,€§?z ::>z;:::::m::::.2

é3§’},{2{fE§ii1′{»§,§_ ;’;:*§%’§;%§:»s§%.;:$’_._ {7s–i:’::i’~–?§a:”zz}?a2′:ap§3€«: j%::2»:.{§ €:.a; 5;;:’:%jg>a smd 5?}? {%§§:é2i:<§::.m': §§2:';::31z=:§3§;§;:

{':'séE_.?;.'.';%j,§'i'§f*;'j3;",}Lé"ij;,'s;I}$"A:'éiiifi .%":”{2a £3?” ¥3a:::a{t§§:m:i2:”aia§2 azjzaé {is7:i%::§{§;2§;s’:E’.

?’€®s. E. z ii; 31$ <:h§€i:'€:3: <9? fiizefiizgéagzs §'*e§€§§°3}*E§33€%§I}§)€:§

;'§E::~.€<:£%;;I:={3i.{3::§.§é ffészzs .§{:'§3§?:.aaiaTE":'$ '%*:"z«':4r:<:'%";.

3; '§"'§'2:3 mi? §.3;}.'§'§f€?'€'§ £3973 Eifé? 1:335 iéamii ?:::a=a:'é,;.';:g; §;j»;,:":<:aii%§%

"-4_:;é%Z%5:'zz;;i.:;*r:j}§ 3%. §§:3§;:.'z..;" viifiezzgzfg §§é,%g:%Ii§." %;::§r;:E«: §{.}'€£i§§_'§' :;:2€:::«z:5;"a§€éz3g 5%

'W:

E

z:az3:*$$ E9 g’z1:1t3§ is tin’: Eaiiaii ifiréezzgizlg 21:3 31:: 331$ é’:%_:f:::’§f§j§»’ ~ : V

par §§;3=:.§3’~ E, E{<':§.?haw.:~:r §§:':gi3%.;t:a1; fikicl $3; ;3'E:§§:{:'§.'i1§"%",T'

5%{&<:{;rc:§§:1g '(£3 E318 zieiiimzfi-11:8 réfiieti ugzédifi frjjg jiéiagi §;Eaié.1fé;§ 'i;I';é&

élaméfiy :23' E"§'{;:.ma;§;3a_*;':a ;'%ama=;:*7::an£§:'a'*'v«;*a'::_ <:;$§s.;~*:1:33?';-ggv 'egg:

:;;f E acms E3 gzméiag iii $}~2.:1,:§§§;*–.§35: 3. §Z”:az”€.’§?i;i(3:i _i§’:=..i§}v%?.

1§~’%{} §3{3iT%’£=”€€’i.’} piaiizfifi? 311$ 53*’ {f§’;’f’V§%’i§.:7g§§a§%,T{fa§. E213
Saki ti’t.X’€<':i'i}? :3? E é§{?I'€i'. Ti? ':i§§.':§.«."IVi€,'z;.3i;'f"i'{i%..fiiiiiééégéfg' V3;:§€:*'£'w<:€:*:2
fiifim zézmi tzacéfg 9:15: 54:?" %"v'2<;::{::4:* 25.2 gz.1::{23:.<L
iiavaszsxzéiig in flags: 2§§E;%{.i.€€E K; sszzzéh 5 3%’;
gaiiziask “§%’:;x’*f£E1:;2″‘ ¢:§:%fi%1}§,’i§£:*,:%’VM’fi%:é§ 13$; fifiéfi €33-3″: déifiizzaiézzzi. 3s::s§£§ £353

€::><:§:é:::.E Isa? ii? g':§;:'a:,:"§S _i::{.¥;§':~:: sariéséiiaii :%~§'a:3;*%::':jg :'3a:§."::;§{::: Ea '£1%3;§:

£:a§é.:<:::?«_é.';§ <§L:i§"€§a;-@243 232%: :’:<*;':'::":. :t';'%;:§i§i%2' §..E':.:<:::2; Eséis

* <:€sa.:s:~;;:i.3:;.<; ,%.if_§'::'~: fi§::'«2:¢?£:i;'3{E:f::'2€é; 6}? 3.313%: S:"sé:i1,YE€3 §:–':.'§;:3i}j-g: *{§'.::':;::g.§'::

Eié; "iS§":.::g:é;§3§.':'V1;:,«' *§'.:z_2*a§;'%éé§’i 2′)? 322.5: §.}§:3.§_::i37f§ :§$ %f%’.2.::;§ 2,z7:3.€§:::;2: ifitzéz :g;;a_*:’i:éE:’é9:3

§§x(§*4*–1£; 252.3”: i’:%.x§€fié: (33? ‘ii’: gz’12:1§a:»; arr-,:2<.?.§:: $5:/33.5; :%;i§:::::§,§:<% K'; M21:

" azzgé *E:§.:§ %}::::§%2£i2', {rL?'3"= :%i«:§%:';2:§a_:1E:, Es: }{'ifS'§'}f3é1'.'§ :12? 1.2% §§?_§f§{Ei–":":;

w:%§..§;<::91i'§;;::::§ E} {$331 {?§:§%::§;:§:~1::.::, _§1s:: 721% §;;"%..mE2"2:s 'ii: fizz? §é§."§'.§'}.€i§' <2?

"€§.fi§%?§'E€§£1.E}.§I'E$*§. 'is'; ':4'a;'1s:.§:;?,§' §€;X.§*"–E;, :":?:::z:ia':é:'3g :":x§:'~::':%: $3" 23

32%

gzmias is in §}t::ws;ss-":ss:Zs::§;§;2; $3353 <_t22.E2'i%:aE;i:}:§ {gsf §::}iai:'.;'i:§.%' :=:zi.%;é::f:§i=1–;é::~.'

figs 'ziiis 9:" 5391 ::§;ef::::;:i8;:2f. amt: aisea éfiizézgsg Whig atzféi <f:§:;::§_:;2'§i;g ""T

F.

Km

Eéfis is that Saki fixéiézzt in this ;}:”$::*::;:§<:§»;::%

2 2:2. €};:€:'* id .s:;;é:

$5: €§€’.§ffi’}{i€i3′.1’L’S 2; :0 5 :§.:.’1i:€:”£i:i ££?;}}_;;}§?831″‘é?£’fi{i::.é’?f’i’VSéf’:§.§i§§§ ‘:33: §7’§ié.”£EI;E ‘

am am: sixtaéi. sf mm: .:::’:;>;: ‘_” {W
§%?:%.ma{>:}.i:am:§:*;:si.2i2f’§: smii §{r:; s§3§::z::;z,§’;;__j§§%f2s:§§ 2v.§i?:31:::«E:”:
E, :;’s.a:.:’:% E4 g;’E.1:’2%iz«2s 335$,-13 a}}%;§:?Eéii. }_3ra§;2{?§: 211311;}. 25:)?
gm.’:i:~?:s Ea} E{a1:2a.::§12?,3.:g§.y:$:{;fi1:;%;3:;, :.i:4.:.’E’é;i:Vi,.f.?.§A’:§E”_}’_’x’ {sf gaié 26

gunigsg €233′-1 {i5f;r:i_r,f;zi2§§§:’;a’*:_. :s«;:El:;% Eaég ss}f:.3:”;”:’ 5:? gzzmas as 333$

‘fé§§’3_€I’ QiTVV§§é:§”é::::’§V:é%.§::¢2.V’is .:”§ “a1§fi{i§€iE”~F§.3§€ éfisezi 22:” £35 ?~3?”i.E iizsizziaé

-éjfig’ ‘?§; ‘~;’£§L’a%;: ?%1′:§.§ %I::i}’_?€§§’;3. “L§x:’E:’:2;’:’ {:>%::’;::££ 7if}j§z’ §%.:§_}.i:e?::’ :2?

{i€f<::'::fia::;i. ?*=:5§a%ingE}=-3

§19;€fz:c: %3§ §i€£%.;:g:iéé::T:E::§ E” 1:23 5 #533 {;1″§7€};}f;”§ £31 ;:,2§:s3s:§s~sém’: ?:§_’§Ei”§

‘ }$;1j<:a}*mé:=§.2.€ e;::_%' 2 251$'-§°f§S¢ E': is fE"Ef{§'i€?;' a:'f.':2.Sii :35 :'§€§€§3.€£2mE.::§ 'Z1 Es"; 52$

' 333$: $%;:Ea;$€qa,:s:'3éf§§; fzézsréi' fa?§:€.:' §:;*2:§:m:%s.~:w:% 2»: "§v':§E§ %::<é{;'z:{a*2":§_%:..é4s2g E.

":»2s;:3%:; f§é§;{J:§'.i in &;fg.;29i.i-3?; E: §as;{,m:" 0:' €§i:§€i§TE€§§&'£i3f§ ?€:;a;E é.%.."§"§i§

u '*:jEi=:,§%3:::;§a:2 $1 §'\%s:m;"'§, 32$; :a:%_2:'r%': '{.§'};::'i}-' 7?§_é:_¥§' ':::=:i:é<'2:"§2:': %f§E§f§1;€'.i"$ 05 ii ;i»2:::'€

§.:'::a:CE'3 E3: ':.irr::»: E~f~22.§¥:§_ §§'é'i{"i.?'f3',J m..m§'§;%':;*: §%§%',§.: ?h.<:*.${*: zéigzai {?=f}§fi'.{'E';§§O.§§
V 3

""1

ms: ?:r§:22.§ {3<;2'i:z"i' p2;*s;:<'{ts:{i{-iii 13:2 .§E"am:: izimé i$:'§1§f:'i=': {mi af x-%;'-E-':;_§.<.€1

§3s:::t,:§: ER; 7% 3'3 §3a;'{if.,* afiizznfiié, Egsme .§'*~§a.5é 325:0 a;§§°é:*:3'éLt§§,~.<

wE"1::~::'"<5:as $35115 R03 2 {<3 mad ? '%¥f€:'E'€§ :::z23w:*;';fé'5{§v .i:é*-* V'

m:gaté2e*&: in 13:26 rssaiti €116 {fig} {f0:m=%..ga¥€¥ 3 ';;'§_:e;:j%£

wékzzi %.%.:'a$ avaééabiz: 13:2: €116 §afi3ljy* {)fRa§macE:é111§£ra§;§§:?$"'–.

bamzciz was am}-' 26 guzitas V'{}1:§gf' €.':A¢'i'"'*»:-;V:'a;{1;¢,;:;1§;
having mid E3 gmltaa wjgai waSV_g_zi§§ié'iabi§ 13; E3
gimias which was a.iE0ti§%:i;« ééidszzcfid in Exfix

2. E: was aise iicifiazfd aileéifizi

E0 63% d€f€§1{£e1:;%1.»v1x?é§s’ ;{“.2′:.’2V:*’:=i:}1a:1L:’-;é<i 6;? zfiefsmiasxi.

Nag. 1. $295, s1i<;=§§"-.§}3:::, éézaiizi 'of a+:i'%.:€3"s& §€}SS€fS5$ii(L':5'f1 :35 E3

g'z:;1:s'£2s:$ sf §;ai1s*:E E33: *;.E'§.i::_ §£3i:2:i§?§ in aware}-* :"€{}.£§8 W225; §'g§?.€:g£34i'.§'i;€:i:§~3

,_..

_ ‘£233 sfiaim széf s§.efé::a7¥”.:,§_:§%: $395.: to 3 %:.£::afii 31:53: 52:3 in §3;{§’EffZ§’S§:t

p;0s?£;5Ss:’:0::.§3€ EEEV gfifiiafi 831€}’E”E§{§ is 3:318 shat: sf ;_}§aé::%f§§§f is;

a3;%s;{“; é;T:%.;aga%£”:zé{E, 2 ”

:3? said jiifigflifiiii aim? €§€€E’%E’.€ “emzs chaééttzzgaé E33:

ans? iiiiffifiiiaiiifi ?aj; fislag f:§{f.§}8E’E'{E€ zzzguéaz’ agggéaaji;

“”…,’W§;?§E£2ZV§f}fm%. are .§%,fi.§*${;,}.{}7£§{}E fgifiii ‘:33: $15: pfaiifiiif 313% EA

V _ §i’i;’0.86;'{}E is ffiféi E33’ iifiiifzmiazai %\§€;$.} :0 5: TEES i”‘;:’i3’§- cisfaziaiaaza

wigs: is the §:«§°:}fl3s:’ :31″ jpiaizzfiiii” asscspiitéi €315 J:.2{§gmf:::é; azad

“*7

,…..e

=:.£€::>r€@ }}{–iSi;’3€{i it; éhcé észégizzal. :~;’;:i%,, siiié 3:252? {:9::§€sE.,iE.”s.$_’ s;§§,::%;%::,.

‘%¥E”a€:”e21S “£325: 19*’: a_pp@E;{afifi {:{}1E3″t dismisssai E3@i’h. %;’ir.3e ‘:é;;}}§ea2§§’–«

azné z:;::3f2:r::.2ad the jucigmsm Eiflii ds?é%éé’pe3_s$.::{3-:’E3–§{_’V21r12;:*.Vv

(2013:: big ifs; itamzzxmi jucigmtfifi a.”E1{i ‘fi{:’:€:I:€ffi e:i&:._c_:;;} ‘ E8 V

‘”E’i”:€: szaiiii comman ju§.gmf::’2f is mfgpéinir <:§::é§T14?:;ig's':T{2_?: 't '§:°{:$é 21%;
appsals ikikfi res;§:»€cfiVe1y $3.}; §3iai2V:'€if§ ._1'_§s': §¥§{};2Z26=5i'}{}i§ 311:3

2% siafméanzp 23253 232;}; 35%."

W133? is c;E1é:£§;i§:’g€d”._éz:€ ziiffsgé’ ajijgfféilfiis {7{)1’1″€’?C§;i’1€ii’3S cf
{E36 fézaigmené a;r:g{§:i’_»g§.e§:’;’*:%:–é4§_:«$é1s$€«;:§,r§;i79§9igi:”:a.§ gzzéig ax-*%1iC§’7f;§’j? ‘%.;%3.55. F’: €%{::i_1’iT;:;’:igz:z;’I%\é:2g a{§v»5::”${~: zriszim

by bafij 8§1{iv{§~$f6I3:§’§é&?3%’ ?€s.2:;,E :9 if} is: E”f3f;’E:§}€'<.'?. 13
gaizzigas £3? Ezmii" in '§E}«:§ figs, ' "

V_ ‘E: I ) – . . . . . .. I
A E? {.3251 g;n’:’2g ?£.§m:::”a’:g2: $12: a_§iE{§_g?;E}€i’Y1′{. zgzrgzé E}€::z°::§~: 53%” %}s:s’i:_if:
EEK: :?{::2% 5;?’ 1 acrés E} g:.:::3″ia.s; is:

S§;§}i¥’§? _j?;:{: zszfgiicr €21.§’é37§;ai;7<:3:: sf f;%':{% iaiizéis' Sf 22%: Qgégémai

am? %'é?«?i ziiefsméiazgi; viz', E€am&€§::iI1é:"ai3}1. Bzmfiii {:31

~ .iE.::a.i %£:}.& §§éi§§2§i§ 3:38 §:t:E::{£ £9 semi 23;; $3136 <;tEa:.:,:'? ; $33? the :=s§3s-:~:I::

;z§€;'i."E.:::i Ea} E22312 Emtifir parfiiiazg iiéziéi <3? 1<}zfE{} 125% g':::2::§,::::3 as
WV;

E

r-Q:

againsi E3 guéziag meizfizmaii in ii/m wad pszriétiafi {iz3s_:*:{‘i.4_ “7%7_ifs::*:V

cmxteniéarz 0f the piéiizfiifi”, that $316: Esta} haidigg Qf:.:h’i-S”

is 1. acre 11 gixzitag priar {(2 {E26 dag 93′? E:x:;’:’:s’-1«:’:;’_«::’:’;¢:%; ‘1E’;£;§ZifI;{.”:a’~3?’.§.~}f’€.}iAi:’.’:£33£,’ “£§;:sV’pé§.».:’§i§i:3z2 géfiszi, wiaéch has

take}: p1.§§z;<;.a -§4"ii:¥£4S%3.§f'"':a:}{i 531 €§€ff.'1"if§&fl?;x iifizfizg the

ozigiziai pafiéfiofiviiécci 3Z::':a::"£, $%:@wi§:g £316 {:§<°i:;*.:1*i, Sf

Eanzi giiéiiczi ii: anti 63'? €;§€f§i:Ei{§83.'i%: Eifi 33 gE'ifl'{aS,

§},'3;€:'€_'fL§'c'::3;a;31. g:§é§2;§2:iifi' that whai ghauéé have "étwsfizz 8;§5"£"£{'Z{§. in

€:§i'::_ :L;'.éjiETii';";§€;f§.~v.,_§f5< guzxias ¥:2as.€{§ an §§;<:.P«3, Carma: bf:

_a$i:epi'1x§.. .-Ti;-e.:;*éf:s:*5, figs ma} Efimgré; E1:-is righfij; 2°€_§fiC'§fi€§ figws

.4 Sf ilfis,-:..§3}a:?:2_i§fiZ Sazzseagusniégfi éihfi ciaim 9? £16 ;3Eaiz:.té§§'

" £;?:ai 'E15315 in a{§%%'€E"'E§€ §<2sse?":3si{::: {sf E3 gimfas af Eajiii 731

azxaififi, wE":1?{:§1 :3 ma exiezié. ffimajjfiiflg after 32:3: 'E:rg2§h§r:* has

«$325 31% gamias mi': af 2?} guzétaa '=a:%:1?€:%: was aiésiiéeii ':9 Ezzémg

V:

x

5’0 Elafiilwr t:3}’;'{ji€f§£i’Z1§”£–3If{S; 1 $0 5 aisa zimzs 210% survivsz “§.’}§’

cmzgiiieratiozi, Tim Ciaim 0f f3.€f6IidE_*{;{S 3; in A’

adiiiiiam :0 I €i{3}.”€I E-4 gzmtas aligned to their é1sr§ ‘ ”

23 gunias pu:*::ha:;e(3 is}? them tzzidsi; saffié ‘:%:::*gdT

651 defendant in E39031″ sf fiisir faihéz; ihaiz’ faf§;s§§’§€’as:’. iiéé

a€§%1€§”’35 }f~*€3’E=2S€$3:io11 sf zizéditimzai”g;iz1§zas’W§:i€}:= isfifiaimezi
by ‘abs piaiaztiff 213 ‘£316 £.%a;”£,€:§1E: :sf }é:’;:;§ gxxiéiith i§=aSV’A3″‘:i§;;,}§§.€€§ is

him uizzkt? Ex?-2 amd iftiai 211% §’a’ii3;:75:§f 5.1:? ,.:=e.%:%=:;’af:m: ‘:”%{;s.1 :9 E:

ami ::%¢:>:2sequ€:§1fi}’.–%;:3′–wag§:i”:.: _,ig,V.’;*:~;a?r4$$~27&%?;::isVVV{;§§’ acrfis in 31% grim};

‘ ‘ch 2&3 };73§«:.i.’2-1 1211:1252: wézrésh :21:

<:=.§':'3.,§ :=:.cr:"::V::zé:isLA. 3; {Q E”: ” szmgwi ha? €:’E€.'(T’$§}’§.€{§, ‘§’E:§$

<:'mfi;.':e;7;i~:§:Ta:a;3,L'~ of th3e::" =.::?;ef5::a"éa1:fi3 §'.%.gE':iE_"j_; ::eg'g;i~;ve{§ igy $323

€Z?;t;:;1;71:. Efifiifiéfij". ;%,;f:'<% zgafgégfisfigii E}? {ha 1%'? a§3pe:EE:«"3:i'.:: $9211? in Eéés

2»2'%§§.::.5é'i::§%. {:5}? 1§;%:sz:r<2:;.'i}€.é§3g iiaarézmcizt ':0 jasiifés 121$ z'i.%i:;' fatimr Ea figs exifini ('2? '£43

~~gjé:i:;'£;3,$ 2i;*§'5;ii:§; W223 aéiaéiezi in ':%:v0:'§r <3? g:3E§z!§31":§§? 13:13:35: §fZX,P~i2;.

i§'§':¢:9*£§f::–::*5E fixes $23131 iifiemé has rigifiifi rsgeatigési SE3? ma; (TE?-:i}E33'i

'$§.a.{§;v€rsg: _"§;<::$:~;t:3si{;:3 §3§"£}{3"§,§?.'; $23 g§§§1E%E'i{?§}€,fié%3 'a.¥E.2..§<'t%: réglézififgs

" " "<;n.§§fi§';':2f:::'3: %}§; EE:3;e:~: Em" z-«§p§:}::};§za.'£e <:*::}é;::'E" §f:':v.:"i«:?::' '§.§".i{:

L4?

2 vi

{“:i§'{.”1,iiE£Siié’EE_§E{T€5§§ *:.’i’,°a:;*.z”{c’: £3 12:; §u$:§§§z,–:E3.E{-: ;’:;:.2:’2:T§T Es; é::§:éi::’£é;r::=.
3 w z. . ., ” V

w§%T§::. “Ema <?:m2<:a2:*zz:::*:'§. §E:.1:%%Z2:2.g £3?' é:j%f::=.= iréaé <7z:r:'::"% 2;é.$=é%;éE§" *5'.

é.i1}}pEf§Z%'{.{": ::%:é§i:§§.i;”§7 ‘5~::g:§__

,5»

€%a:.§%-:.z2:’§2:s:z:2;3 E :9 -if’: Siiéiizizgg :<2<;§%;{:r$a pG:=§;si€:~:-<%;§:;%: $3 E3-:::=V"{:xéi:'*§'::_=: T5'

13 g*":m€..as agamsz. r::;~r:r}.: zazléei" ':.i;§{%
.:7:f..§i;*m3'f£y' ax' %3E{:*§r;a§i.%:§; $3 p:};iz'1'£;§{E: £;:z,;fg iv%;<:
{°IO§}{Z'Ei}.i"}_"€.'§§?. §?;:1di:": gg, Elf} §;a;v véfii-36$ {:12
E35: f§'?3_}3_':$§{i $3.'; ihitsg *ssc0z:.§§ éi§j!§;_}€éi3;S aw

{?§§.sm:§aS::(§,, :\§:2 §:{é._{t::::$'§:s'f A V 'V

3d/'2
Itlddé