fix: mg 2523;; CQEERT 99 K;§RNATA}§g”3 K
czacuzz’ BENCH AT’ BHARWAEB-.4′::”
E}A’§’E{} mzs mg ?m DA?(2%??:{:::«:;IsTi[i;g:3§§: H A
PRESE§?
THE Hcérmw: {VIR.J{§STEGE_§gIOH29;N1&§EiAN’f5A§;%GQ{*E§£§?&’».L’
AN§$>_ _ . __
‘mg _Hmé’BL£»: MRS. J-{§$T¥.@E.’BVr»W. NAs:}ARg*i’HNA
MRA%:~:é*.8%4’§?;f2t)::;:«;{ma
B€’5iZi’€£’€€3Z1I _ ‘
SR1 édfiii-{AN’E’E_S9«E£ E?£i§3AE§iAF’PA B.fi:7;;3E:F3:
23 YEARS, <::;;::c;,%%%€;;s:~ai;1%%E::<:-;:sT-“.,~._”» ~ ~ ¥? APPELLMT
{By Sri Saéigégy gr §4;:§i:*;$;GfEf}:i; :’,§ ‘mv@caf:’E:}
_Ar1§:
V’ 1 ‘ §z{;’5’:’i1_vE:§§?;i.z5¢*e*;i;SE-:E’§{,? 3&3;-E:
‘”.5§;C’r}Z$¥:3’«§{} ‘E”E_’§é§RS, GCC: BEESENESS
..§€;;© §;%’Z;ARPETH, magwz
s;%§’§~:ms§§ ‘3;*{g’T
§5§:§¢C~;;§*{j:s£ 3313*?
“‘E’E*—iffii §E\£§SES§’=¥AL MAN253{‘iER
” EEESEERANCE CG LT?)
” §§¥’.§SZQ§EAL GFFICLE
fsamgaaa CEAMEERS
‘ §{ERLQ§fK..s%§€ RQAE
Bfiififiilifi .’:>?§€} Q92 H, RES?{)E’§§ENT$
($35; $172}, Ev§,E’2§<a':ag*, Advecatc .{"<3r R-2, Rm} served}
This miacailanecsus first appeal is fiiaci 2,}./'S 1'_Z""§3§ E:/EV
Act against Elm judgment and award dataé :2 1.€)S~;~;2{}'G§§_*§:;':1fs3ee:i
if} MVC NO. 180$/' 1999 01': {ha {:16 0? th& E f)§5.{:§_-#::§.E.e '«§i:£igE&
(811011) & EVLA. MAST, Bclgaurn partiy aliO,¥§;fi'§1:g'V.§E1cé f.'.iE&'1iI}fi
peititierx fer compensation arid e€;<::,
This appaai a::{:mi.:1g 0:: far heé:?i1ifg§ f}i§sTT E3
LE4} dvsiivered; the fofiowmg: " ' A . ' %
This apvpeai is Egg 'i; ciaizzaant Sfififikifig
enhancement 9:’ c:}m§en$:.sf.§{}fi the jiidgmexat
::mc1 award _;;;8.{;%$ {Sf datfieri 2138,2004 by $136
MAS’? a%:VE36}g;aunV{;.; f’V-~ “V
:2, ‘§’he2′:*s-:§ %e;ra,:::’é’._f&f:is.§§ 3336 Cast: am $23′; 9:: 38%}. };<}@€E
~:%:.§ abg:-fig: §3.£::";'.%.,E_:§&.c1aim1a.11t was 3:: his Way ifimzzzr": frag}:
;:?=§h<{3;5€:s'?§.. ;9×2,_ hf;s:4._§i:r:ycEs 0:2 A$}3aI}:in«Bi§apu§ Raefi mag? marks:
2=sE:$';i: éa;Vi::*:i§cfl?:%;'Lj§;:%.¥a:"?::":g Eéafisaigé {$3 3%,} ?5£8.§ {§E"§¥€§} in 3 333$": 333$
é gésgfigezfi. $353216? and fiaghazci agaiafii 33$ giaézégant. wha is a
I az%;'§'1?::§:'?L"§:}g@3?. fig 3.. F232;}? he szzsiaézfgaé i:'E}'iiE'§€Sp Cfiiiififiéiiig
___"i:§;"'3a!i.§i*1a haé Sufffiffifié §€§'§.}}&§.'£€}'§'{ disability he fiéaé figfi $23321:
V _ épwziitian $5a§<:i:1g cgmgaxasatien an variaug heaést
5.;
3. E31 raspanse is ma naiice sawed I35; Ehé ‘Zz.”:”ib?§ir;a;, $126
15’? §’€$§0§;{i&n£i ax: :29: appear arafi was piacfiii <:x:»«;:a;«:.$,% '.1i5.f§iil}a
figs: §f§$'iiI'a2"}€€ company apgjeared and fiéézéHi:S~–..s'f;a%gt:21f;<r;;;i€:" Qf
abjectiens dfimiing {ha averrilarzfs .§:;aad€ §_:';T %:§f:é ;C§:a,"é:::'»V;3'é£%T:i;}I3 '*
and sought its disnflsssai.
4. G3: the above ;.pl€ac£i:1g t;h.€’~-.Tribtii1aE .fi*am&& the
faiiowing issum for its Ce:’isi:i*e:’£;a:i,?I;1f;; I %’
“E. Whémar :_ii’ié V’p::*-dées mat he
S§.iS178;§;E}€i_ ii’ “-..iz1§}3i._;§i€$ in £33351′ .r0a€i accifiszgi 9:1
8.9_;9<;@ iééa he:;;:;.~s 5::;"';ég:han:~3i3apur Raad
rxeaiy "}2§jf;'a11i, 51:5 :0 rash and
:1egiig' f:1::ig' ::§.ri%.:%;;"§g"'s§f.-%}i§%"4€fi1€k ?€s.MEL§3 19 by its
ii?
%;,£’h€V%§*:es”””V?,he aiaimam. $5 enéifiad fax”
‘ V: {:L.§}1§§f§::;g’V§3.%§;§.{§fi!? if Sfi, what is 131$ qmanium arzé
“‘ . _ V’ %T §?:Q;”:§~;§’ ‘
__:”§; mag? 93* awarfi?”
” AV ;’3.'”-.323 suppafi 3%’ his (3336 the claimant: €;’X§.§”fi§,E”§=fi3?{§ fzimseif
_ Fifi} 35151 3:: Satish }3;Pat%.E, G:r”thapafidic Surgeefi aé §3′?é’2
4′ gs: marked :3X}”;i’%3i’:s-P1 Ea Pffifi, whfie the mspcnésizts {iid
£2
V./*””‘
{mi E6: E1: 2;”:f§}’ €’§i€i€3E?;{3€ éixaegiri geiténg a mfg}; :}f ‘:§1€.§;’:~$233t§;31}C¢:
pahxzy :113:”%§€<ri as €xE*.:i?3i'::«§?3.. 9:} the hagis :3? ¥;t}2§§é"3:iéa'ie:f:§aE_.ész";
recorzi, the '.§"ri%m§;a§ grafitaé. €:0mp§::j;$a:i9::*'Gf"
with irzteresgt at tha rate ef 6% pa. Vf:"o:?g1' Tt.?;1eé'd.é:%e:"t:f
pefition {iii {ha date cf :*$aiis&«%i:;§{1. E¥E0*E:– Aségiisfied wiézh'
'E136 said awarfl, the dajmaglt I1a§$__1§}'§fi5§:£fZ_f€{i.;{hiS_3;}3}§}§8}¢
5). We fzave heard Iaazfxgd L’;r’:-*;”;~»t:i3″1::~,$:}V”1v’L”~2.’:j:’V_;:*. __f,_%.,._:€ a_pp€Ii}ant afld
the iearrjaed <:Q¥_1;=:??:s':=:§ _€*a1' %__he_ :<'és_paf:é.€;1t.:%.}1suranc€ campmzjg.
1: ES gubméitcsiié .#expij::I3ézni that in the insfsgm;
cage aha 1:}"§§3'};{_)i" ..éie3g£0ss§:3g* 3:331:13: sf {ha 139%: {high
far which s1{i;}éér.'as_é§s:}nea and Erie '£}.I1{§€i§"W€;I};§; ;"*a§€3:{::»:§
.§fperaii<}%§5$. "i'hé§it' had gpifieé that {hare was 45%
‘ j%V.;9’.§;i”;¢ “i:3ft iawer limb amzi there was 3%” sharteiaéng
Qf was Séiilitiififi ii}. {W3 ta éhrefi Ewspzimig
323$ i’143r.§.éV;$%pE§e.z1: casnsiaiarabie sums zawgrdg maetiiegi
‘;g;§;:;:;@§1{3;:%?::§w:i*é’ hm £115: ‘Fr;%§un3i faiiazi is appreaiaie the €’¥§533IZi€€
£3: re;-§:ré, _§}af’Ei€i§§8Fi3r’ {he mefiicai €3’£iC§€§iC€ 311$ £233 awayéeé
V ‘ A améaga camyansatiazx 02′”; {ha bead sf 133%}: and $iiff€EZ’i§”2g émé
5/,J
meciica} exgaamscs and an lass cf ameraiiias 335% £<:$s =:2;f"§'_fa%.2.zr€
ézarnirig capaeity mid has met awardsd am.-=' C{}1f1.S;1Lf..:='-§'3T1"}w'V'?$;f:§;§ iT9£.??:7l%__ 6::
the 111336 sf 1053 cf zziarriags prr:;§p:'–:c":ts_–'*—«'}"§;ei'€f01'g5, ihe
€<}r3ipe11sa%ti@:": 31:13 'ta ha fj}T}h€£I1{1'fid £31} E}?_;;%+=,:..é§pf::<::éi.
*2. Per cantra, $;1ppor'§zig*R"i}1e .iu;<:§g:1i1{:;*§':t ' awar'cV;1V,
C0¥_1I1$€"3} far the i13sura11cfC~.§'Om'péi:}; .:-s;1':31;ziiff€& tha£ in the
irzgtaxaé, case, the apgaeflfixfi' L'V;:;§i§;s0§:_:'b;<%§51§§{'giespitéz gievoug
injurées c0n:i§12;@&':§il~3 his SSLC. Thai
he was. a §10§i-ea:=*:j.§i: g*'~- 'iE}é1§}béf 2.116;: aha 'E':{*:§bunaSi has Iéghtiy
COI1Si{L§€:%{_} {Z{}'ffiVi"f:€3;"£S$'i§Qfi._ 'C5§1' {ha head of £9283 sf fu§u1*:3
aarnimg ,i}{§{§j–
<:::_"z ané that me award madfi an the whey §1ea;:3.s
5re:'b;'*:§;'$*%:,;*~a;:}'.131§;§,»=’
‘j§+;}i;;:f§ that: arises far am’ cafisidsmfiazz is 33 is §%=’§’1€E’€§’;€E’ tfza
” ‘z;ppe}E3:a”;§ is arztiéieti ‘£9 aaiaééiiiarzai C€>z11pe:}*:;aiiQz”2,
9. E-%’:’e:n the matefiai {ESE .I’ecs:>rd, ii; 3% eV.i{i::._§i§~.._ E12231;
dis<:harg£: <::~1:'ci~E:KE"zié3§i»«E'i2 gfzaws ':.i[2a{', the §~'.?;§}a;¥
Sllfiifiiilfifi degiaviilg ifijfjifjf :0 me 1€f§_IQWs:r.'1i§.*i::h:'a§ii}w f'i'a<:?:;;i'T€;» 1
of tibia and fibzraia Gf 33%": thizfi anti 'a;tI1:;3.r*é;;1°§2.§:%_i:3':~s» ' ii: ii}:-:;'§§%E3f ta
:«3u§3§0r{ E"1i:~:. ezziaicrzccrz ?Vv"-2', 33a-"2a::*£,::ti{' '-§§2a:»*{_"'–:i%2<t.2:;?£33;i3;}es:¥;.'
E3:»~:hib§:4P3:2 is 13.3% giisabagzy ;i1ib§ts~E3’§ “ms PE’?
532:} P2} :0 P39′ _a1″e;”‘Et}*:€: ; 3:,’-%:}.”ij.AV’8»V3”:ii11g Ea n1::é{§§€a§
séxprmciiture. £1Cv»QQi”l{3i;?1gi 1;::}_A_ ~12, 5f:;”E*:§ »Q:*ihGpae{iic Surgeon,
he ibund:,’V:11aiii:’;§§§:{§ ifiagzfiirfii sf fiibia and fibuia with é3<3wé_z1g
and {;st.é:o};'rc:::gf<}';=3-is 5.116% -«ffic "§:appe1E31'1E C'8;E"i}"iO€ Sianci or kvafik
fm: 3; Efifigv aims: '§?eit§'ze:* gay; 31% sit {3I'<}$S~§figg€(i am} §§."}€§'€
' %S&":":3s€i**i<:':%%;%é:; 5§~.§_Ei€)¥€I?{};€}.}ii in firm laft hip, Egnee Stfld SEEKE6. in
viévé %§?8;S 4Ef:% aiisabiiity 0f {£16 Eef: Eawsz' Eémbfi
"E'ai<i;i§g'~.. i:"::_=;'}' 2:f:éi";$i:i&:*a'iiia;:': the Saiai €'i£'§d{':1EC€ {ha "?':'i§u:"1aE
H :éss9§f"&:'{§€é:{% ::<5:::p€:1sai§_031 sf Rs, .3, f§:"3£EC*§f– in tha feiiavszizig
';5f11;3;:3::%¢:*:" –
Lass of f1..?:z3:r€ earrzirxg capacity 1%$.45,{}.€}{}_} }g
pain. and sziiferézzg Rs.:2G,%{}f3;’~, 111ee:i3Z§ai3,__”:”::;.~§<;pa:§f;f:s.V;=’….'{;fV ” Q}? % fiilé
appeliami am: the fag: tfggt heVAVi?zxé§Li:.st:.%fer:e;}d” ‘g:i.ev<3:us i3:}§L'"'i_€$
far which he had fakefi ijanzpazzsaéion an
the head ~::f paifxé :9 be mcraasad.
Sinzfiazgiy, in §.I;’;é;£*2§% iz%Q:§I:€r1t iakam as an
inpatisznt _a::1d t:”*ea%memi, there has is
be e::h3.nQ<:e23*;¢'r;éiVVd§§"* on me _h€a{3 0:' zzisiiécai gm
i;1'}.eid€:1t.a} ciiéiifgeéfig V' "§h::%:'é'.§%s' aim {fig facf; $131 an acasmmé cf
_:Ej:€z'€ 'r::,Vstr;Zc?i:§:331;___1Z:?: me mavamerzts Sf the 36$': Eimb anci
ii~:f§; ..,G{iv 8L£3€Ii<3E.{i0E1S {he caingansatiezi ig I’€3{iS §€§’S’S€j5{i–.’ in vf0E§0′;¥”:Er:g
mariner:
Pain aemci suf£’er’i:’1g Rs. ‘”i§i¢ i§€n:fiaV}
sharges Rs,¢6Cr,€}QQ/–, f’»~,fi &E’Vés”€;V=4f ameziitias
Rs,5{},G€}€}/~«, ism erf :11a1afiaa_¢gi’e”‘;:s;f0:Sp%*;§fii€.:’V_~}%§;$a25,£}{}8f», ii: ail
§s.2,5z},o0e;.. at the rate af
6% pa. frcrff “‘:§i’f. €ié:33;:1i”‘*v_peé;£€:ic;:1 tiii U36 dam of
rcalisatiafi _ _’ D __ zérzhaziced campazxsaticzz with
pmpa;:ti0z1:é;£,~:.::tL4§:’::é;».gé§ $;”:;é@ii::§é. dépasited 1:: 23:13; mtionaéigezi
vbank an cf five }ffj.&E’S and the apgaiiarzi shafi
4{;§.«3f’§a§§? pfiriaéimi ii”F€€E’€Sf; 912 the Said fiepesét.
.:é§z%i'”;3séi:§§§3:§i0§: she}: ha reieafisd is {ha a§p6fiafi’£.
sd/-
JUDGE
Sd/-