Rukmanna S/O Tippanna Sagarkar vs The State Of Karnataka on 23 March, 2009

‘m;::ss~zN;:;&:«:( * n
*:m;: E-§;3.

.. V . ,§_;.PE’E’§TEONEE€
{B}; S1’i.Amc:::t ffizzziar Eie3E:x_g:§a11d-:,’:L1%.:EV}_ «V ” ” ”

AI\éL}; ”

1 , ‘§”,E;x§ .Stajtc: V of . ‘t:b:1’0ug§3
De};2ut§.: iiammissiczaef-,.L. Gulbarga.

2. _};’}X&(;u’iiY%fVE:ngi’jl1€€r, FWD,
‘i?fl¢:1E __;}e.;v§;argi ?30as:!—-, ‘Gulbazga. RESPOI’éDEN’F$

‘ Vgisy. 51-;.,s;s~;fv; <;;«A}

'§_'};i:=;_ is flied un.dm:* A1"?iies 22%: amd 12:2? (2? the

Cic>:1$1:it1;;?i<):1 of Emiia pxasrzzxg :0 ifiiafiii the: r:ié:r (iaiea?

_passs€ci in §vm.N<;.44j2{}E3? by the i{":é"11"i},€(i E

;§.c;1'–;i–§'. €;'f;:ivi§ Judge{S1:ijj3z1) at Guii)arga_, 'ihfé cerruiied c:Qp}? of

u v%k1i<:§.1 rig ai fin.3.1.€X1ne~i4' c<;11f3r1m13.g the: ezsriier :i:a.t.::<i'i

;2£'1*,8&5.2{}i}'?' }",?=EiSSffC§ cm }.§.N<xii}' in i;}.:£.fiio.1;3t§['2{}£}? "bi; the':

iéiarmzd E A::i(i3..{'fiivfi 311:3 g€{J1'. 1311} at igéigibarga, 'i'E§Ef:Vé.l§?HI?;:fiff{§
cepy 0i'wi1i::,h £3 at §iI111exu3°6-E:Z. " V" '

This; WP. ctmtnng ma. for §');'€-iifiaiiéargr–'_'i1<:ariiT:-g .g2jz'0'u.;:

this £333', £116 £10 {:11 ma{£-:3 the i?€3l1£:\i$i:3g;'4T ..

This writ ;2€:€iiiQ§: is iiifiti' 'figs a:v1icie::* (33166

4. IRZUQ8 passed 1’11 $1.515 $116: <21.' tin: i
r5s{i(i}.{iivi£ J13.s,vig§V{S__If. $14218 COI'}.f§3'"£I;E6('i the
order cigctejti on i.A.§*i0.£% in
935316 I &¢;ie:i}.C:ivii Juéigfi {J::1§.)1§},
{}u['iba;-g;:~'3;,,i:\ VA _ g – _.

‘§’i1e £2:-$$¢I1Ii:;aE faarts Et6:a.¢:£:1:zg to this vma; patrtioil is

. ihsit. “f.§f).€’.1T:€§€i§’§i)Ilf3I” .E1.cf.’r€i:; Ciaims ‘:0 Est: in ;3@ss<°:s$§i0'z:. 0? _pi:.:;E:

" .t:<:§__?f é1iii;2a::€:;i;""ViI1. ail app1":tava::i };afmui, mi" Super Maiket,

€;§'ti§.b2:3:g{é1 ~u:ii;i2 %:m3;:"g.)0r22:€y s;:1:°"u<.:t:t.1r€ W11}: :21:-':21:s':.11"€mz:;11:s as

' .As;;¢ci1iV:%:::i in i§h.::~ $<":Ei1.:::<i*ui€ refegtreci. to :33; the wmi }J{3iifj.i{"}}"i. "'i"§::e

= si;;:—5r:::1i:ic:: <':a_se of ti}: ;'}€:£1"£i€}}}f31' is iilat: Em is in :g_}{}SS€:?SS£OI§ £:3};1{.i

..-é::}<'3§;r:'1r3::€. :t;.ft%1e suit, sczhaciuifi §:)m§)€3:t§; for I'11{3I'€i {flat} §'f1£I*i}–='

years co;:1t1m:.m::4;ijs,j mméz tiaciarmg his {itie IQ ihiz §{1':{3£=s2'1€;::§ge
' M1

11.,-*1/I

E

grf 3%} H16: s:’:<;»:'2::€3::1€{i mrsiuciiatg the z"€:s3§}{321(§:%:':i.s iT_'t$f'€2'?:."i:,'i.".~_ is

S§%.'£bI}};i3§{ff(L§ timi: the };)€:'::§mn&:* v;2*aii<e:a:§[ 131:5; 3:33;-";" ::';t1.%.§_T£s';$§%:«::{§E;£<i2

;3r<)§)t::fé:'j;:" ahoui: £3 }"€ai"E-¥ ages zanri" _"i_1.22s,_E}e€::";:'aztflisiizg f§}4{:"SéiZ11€ '

R93' :1:1'1;:::12g; his Emssilixzass azzai §].£iS"?e1}S£§"Ei§}:O£%?:€€i S<";s.{i,;f: 3»2é'm.:§?{£::"s

to park 'z.§}.iei.1" v<ii3.i<3£f:$ anti '§:§)"';'§() i.he.i:'" bu:~:1%;[12f:$.s .2:';-.. .3{.i',1'f: Saki. V

gqiace crvm ea. }}€Z1TE€}€§ of 33 33.12 i::i,s;'- ;«:33_v11 §'1gi1i With
Ccmiimxous poss€ss3L;§:«:::’*ty, ac=c:c3r{£i:1g to him.
ht? was ;;>c=:rfEe-::ta:{i E115; 3:2’tEe _a3ri(:–.ir1€s has 3135;; become ai)s:;;e§m:€

ownér :31″ ‘:£1e3__.su§;~’sg:E3:%:i’11i;$ ‘V;3rt;_;ié&V,:~:fgé. V “”‘i”‘I”z:::z’c1′<:):'f':, he has fiicizi.

a suit: ii'? i E?€:':,(V =:.§i1" £i1§:§ Vifiie sf 'E11423 i R(i:ii.(f3ivi,i

J1z£§.gé{;}1~.'–,i.f}n}, V' *{:§i1£i)z3¥f§ge:_,'* .é;2:=.{=:§i€-:tuai
§1}.j11Z1(?ii(3i’_; _ r:::%;vi4r3;;I;1:i’;§g;” $,}:i}%; (“ie’;:-§§s3:3:ia:::.£Ts= {he £”t’:S’pOI}(i€§’}I.S

§;z.¢;tg§t1’1’1 n*.$t::a3::1.1;’3g i§’e:::1i:1 mi’t’:’ri’1s:1’11’1g Vsziikz ;}::a<:eii1'£ ;}<33$c$s1'<;:'1

é-ntgfi €:_ti;:::}7I;it::';.i 015' 31:11 Sfihéfiiilifi p1z'3pe1i't;<; azaci é'~2}S(} :10: '£0

.{_ii:':;:;.1rE:i' ?i#.'1v:='§__p£;fS§€?S$£é}}i':. 53152 a__g:)3:;127€::~m<:z:1 was aim": iifieci Em him:

sfiékzzzs .9133" 0¥"{iEf' of I'.s::11g}('2t*ar'}? il'3;j'E1,I}€?ii{31'I aga:I:.sE: '£.i':::'

H' affcresaix: cié:§ia1";::iaz1.tsjr:é§:p<:ns;i€1'2i.s Whiczh <?a;2:m £40 £36

giiisiziisaegi. $3}; 21 d;e'£;:2i£e{;3 {::2si<ir:r£{£ <:a1*der €i::–3't§:{.i '.2£}JCi8.i§'"!'.

V …'–'f'h€: said. (3I'(i€}:' of tziisimsgzagi of i.A.N::;.3 in the saizri 31,231: was

<:%;3ii€:2gr::.i 12;'; ¥.E':,(~: pt':'§fii.£%4fi.§7 «:31: $;h.<i: file 0.2' S.

1

A::’ia,§i.{_43:1;:§ K~4i!.1{.:§gCE§”S«’..S1’o 3,511}, €3u}i:)z«a3″gja a;:;<:'i the saL§i«~~:s;1';p£;§§i'.j'agisg;

Came to ht: cEéS;:n:3sf:{i E3}/* 5:11') €}I'(;if3:I' (.'§é3i€E,i. 4.,_i.'2'fif3{}'8{A_§ '~ If-is2't:<1':c:§ '

the: Sam? two or{ic:1's am E'm1:i1.g -::I53a£ié:m.gé<i' i;n7.ih:s; 1:s;.:z1?i_V3;x;:f3f:t<21i«.

3' fi,.f!ZEi{~ gallig ili1I'01,1§_?,§}..v"':{_f1f:'G3'(i£%1'S f;)a;ss{i?.§ i;;,;»%1:,,§;§:V if-:mrI.;; ' L

b:%£0W in angina} szzit as vi-viii a$,§V«.i:1 F§'E7;sc.£~'*;;zpéa£, is ciczariy-'

Sfififi {@131 the {7,'0'£3I'{,S Er.:%:_i€§:–*e-' §:–%1v¢;V– :'10'i~–.;§<'a.:§.&si;'iez.'é:{£ the §3ra§:e1' of

the pftIiti{'3I}(3I" }'1§;p::i::1 jg; i1.;;2_?4f;14iVbLcaf"'i'§iE':VV..';gi£adings anzi alsga
I116: n'1aieI1ais:_"V;};i.é:§cr§¥:§:§ ;31i;1;;g§;<:z";§:"e§' §;:§':€:i:–VV;é3iit28.di11gs. it is 366:1
ziaai the tilt: staitmzezzi. that
he scheciuié §JI'{)p8I"E'_3,z ;01*a
yfinaii "iilfii E<:r:.(m?it':v;ig€ 0fti1:;: <_€.ei'e%:1'1('£a'11i::s

.I'3s»34sV13{}ET p1*c5{§u_¢e(i.. 2:113?'.{.i<.::E.'::,;m6m; 11}, Supgxjrt of his ::.§an:; that:

" E1&_._i.§ in »::<v:a'§1t1711'L2i:’;§”§3(:rss::ss’:<3.n anci f'.i1"§O_1v'Zl]€I1'I' of me amit