IN THE man COURT 0;? KARNATAKA, CIRCUIT ;13EVéaf;~.,’:T::mT
DHARWA9 % Q V
DATES THES THE 27TH DAY OF N0VE«M :$ifi~i§;:VA;?gQ£)S ‘
PREsfi§@ 1 » v .
HON’ BLE MR. J{ISFIC:E l§”A¥C)n
% . V _ _
HON’ BLE MR; QJESTIC§”vBL§§.i§VfivE3§iVA$VEA Gtfwm
41aa,3.A.m’e;z37$ igigscy
a, 4%a5;;_1;-{xA~.,r§{>_.1;97e {Jr 2006 {LAC}
snwwfixgj _
THE. A-$’;E3′{‘. C£:2§2;:s4iss’:0r€’3R Ana
Lgzm ACEQUESIT1-0_N OFFICER,
” A Ga_::émc:f._ ..$U§3~§3iVES§O”.:——–GABfiG
A’ “:A._ 5
23
1:3′
EU.
‘ ggri ;S:R’%’«V’lVCV’-‘K.A”%’3’L’uv.’#”‘.fil–‘V:~1″”! ma.)
H z~I’Ii”:’ \.
” Niigqsapva aumypa aamsaamnrex
VSJNCE BECEASED BY HIS LRS,
RUDRAPFA $fC,3.N1NGAPPA BADARMDENNE
AGE: 3% YEARS. OCC: AGRECULTLERE,
GURAFFA S{<3.NlNGfiP?'A 3A§AR.flDEi"iN§
$.63: 28 YEARS. QCC: AGRECULTURE,
SEEEBAPPA SfG'N§NGfi;PP£5. BAEEARAEEINNI
ACEII: 2% YEARS, QCC: AGECULTURE,
ASBQK S;'CJ.I'vIiNGAPPA BM)ARAi3ENE"5';
ASE: 22 YEARS, (ECG: A{';RI'(f1iJ'L'§'URE,
APPELLANT.
EE. VESRWANATB S/ONENGAPPA BADARAQENNE
AGE: 21 YEARS, OCC: ACBRKJULTURE,
31?: KiI}«§ARi.SHARABfie. S/'{3.NEN€’3APFA BADARA_L«mN.i’:”~., V V’
AGE: 16 YEARS, occ: }%QUSEHQ§;13″WQI?£K,–_’ ‘
§$I}:~ICE MENCJR, MINOR GUAREJEAES.
REPRESENFEEI) BY HER NEXT Fasazrm –
Aim ‘NATURAL “MOTHER -+”<E;'s.P<3Nm";3;:T r~:<:2.2a' "
SM"£'.LAXI*e1IBAi '&';O.NiNGAP!?A'*F3ADARAD§¥fi?§i, '
Am: MAJOR, QCC: 'HOUSE%i(}£,fC}' 'J»'QRK.§ ~. . ' ? ~ -'
2. mxmzmx w 10.N§E*{C&APPA «23;é;i3A:ég9.n{:’1~.<z§s:
AGE: MAJGR, <:<::":a1<7;£3s2:_HC3Lfb V;'f__';RK;n _
3. ms EXECUTIVE EN<:;::\IE.§;Rv {ELE<:r'"*:~ra:c::x_L3,
1<EBI}:v1s:0N_,.{;Ar3As;'», 1.'
" _ RE$PONI§EN'I'S.
gm SRi.F.V._P,¥E’i’1L, 31:19., ~:-“em: :?.1(A._’%_”:’)<F} {£23.}
{BY sR1.B.s:KAm'su*E:;' 'F92 E,jau":sRAV., FOR 12.3.}
Ti-11$’: ¥41F’1\_vFlL?;I) U/’:3._s4{1; QF”LA AC’E’, AGAENST ma .J’£}D€3I%iEI\}”l’
ANS RWARED ;DA*:fEvr;;’~3.s;*9;:2.Qe€.» PASSED 1N LAC.N<3.83/'I995 09: THE
mm <3HT:«1.f::. Civii.'-«J'UiZ3QE If-:fsR.DN} & cam, GADAG. PARTLY ALLOWING
THE REFERENCE '?E"f§_'i'–§€Z3N-..FCéfi ENHANCED c:0M?£:NsAT:<:2N'
:Ji;:mi.no.1197a or 20% (LAC;
;a::r§«:§-minpa £’.}’UR*:§?’P,P. 8ADfi.R:%.§i)iNN§
‘*~f3iNC3E BECEASED BY’ HES LES.
.. 3.5. *é;fRmL5§§AP§>A$;’+::2.1~zmG.APPABxmafiamlmm
AGE: 4} YEARS.
{Bf Samziizgwa S;’Q.NING§.??A BABARAEXNNI
ASE: 3§ YElAR$. GCQ: AGRICULTURE,
SRLS1E’)3A?PA S }’ O.1’vIINCx1§PPA E&}C§ARA{3{NNE
AGE: 36 YEARS. OCC: AGRICULTURE,
,.m.
{“3
III)’ SRLASHCJI-1 S/'<I).N'iNG:A?PA BADARADENNE
RGE: 33 YEARS.
IE. SRi.V{SHWAI\EA.TH S/{).NINGA.P?A BADARAD§’N:’Ni_.” 3-
AQE: 32 YEARS,
ALL ARE’. AGRICULTURISTS. j;
§z;<1a1:'rAGE,R;,Trg: 55 513?: <;Am,m:;. ~
?'47
sMT.m:<:M1Bmw/<3.N1NGt<PPA EADARASINNI " ' ~
AT 35 ?os'1':£>ELLAm3.
{BY S§LF.V.PA’1’iL,.ADV.,.}
2. “me: ASEETL ‘:_:r.jV§~.z:~.t:1ss1<::_;q;é.¥2 mi§ '.i_"– .. V '
LANE) A.c§2w.;s:T;:;N'<;F;?1cER,,
C3-ADISLG 333$-"x)i"i{N.,€};t{)1§{3. V
2. ‘3,’I~iE~ EX¥~:cm’IvE% §;I’l{3IE¥l’§é_E3?. -(ELECTRICAL).
I<::~:B DN._, $A'I'.2t@iGV. _.
. _ ‘ RESPCENDENTS,
[BY $R:.c.s.LPa3T:v:.. A{3v_A.;.FG§§.~R.1.)
{BY .E3.S.i{AMA’l’E :s<3R'-BRUDRAGGWM, ADV" Ffififi 12.2.;
'."b'E"1;:–AIi»":'v« §i"E'.'A FELES U/S 54{1} OF LA ACT, AGAINST THE JUBGMENF
:AN1;"';'~« A1a;A.R;*34-.a;str;3ns: 15:9/22906 PASSEEI} IN LéC.NO.8;3fi9*95 02»: THE
?z_m'; '(:3 'aim: c;:~:%x_LL JUBGE {SRDN} :55 CJM, GADAG, PARTLY ALLQWENG
'-132%' RE?§:vR_Eb:é.€:'E ?E'1*m<::N ma ENHANCED COMPEEESATEON Am
.SE_EK§NG .;~*U*€<_f:'H ER amaawcamawr OF CQMPENSATEQN.
.. ' fHESE AP'?EALS ARE COMPNG C3153 FOR ORDERS, TEES DAY,
xKT.SREEE'}P{.AR QAC}, d., DELXVEREI} THE FOLLOWING:
JUDGMERT
Thff. iands sf the claimants are Within the iiztnits of
Gadag-Betgeri Urban Agglameratian. The Raference Ciourt
in its jilldgnetnt has obseivsd that 32% KM. away from the
land in qxiastzien the Karnataka
residential layrmt is fanned in 1983, res:§¢:1fia:MTV#s.¢1§§o§4:'T
established in 1993, Handkm; »Aiiiétitmgioxasfi. }i1;71_: 535 Etna
Gavamment is established.
Quartem 3. away. in
prafient case is iss11e;gfi’~-._in Claimants
have reiied upqn the the year 199}
where one Béfagtszri Vfiiagc is
sold Kzetping in View the.
phase: a1*om”1d the vicirlity of fiefgeri
‘u’i11;g:g’e i:11e3.§’a;t5_V_$fi%a.teV(i2 in Ex. F’ 3 can be saffiiy relied upan.
._ Advacate strenuously contandad that
t;hé”!an§is”éituated away from Bctgeiri, village the rate: fixed
f»:,:;*..4Ba:}tV;g<:rri viilagc cmmot be 3. compariscm fax" thci: land in
l£§i_y'€L;§,'fi§.'~;,1Ci():"1. The Eiefamncfi Court has made mfercitnca hi) the
fiecision in MFA 3428/ QGO4 and awarded csmpcnsatien at
the ram of R52 iakhg per acre. The (i<:":{3iSi(}l'1 in MFA
E'~E0.3428/2804 is chaiimzgasd in S.L.P. befora the Supmme
Cmxrt. The jucigment stated in the said MFA :E'.he
cempenfiation whatever awarded is high]yv_7excé_$siycT'
that the campensation awartied
'.0
canfirmed. Sri.B.S.Kamat€,.* C{)mi5.:~§'1, 4 fo19j'; FZ _.;,x
aciopted the arguments craf Q8. fl£*at«_§fi,' ieémed Govt.
Advocate. I A . VA L
Kéftpillg vifiwfiié' «if lands in question
and the stated abeve and in the
light Qf P at Rs.30,{)0O/–~ gar gunta if
conggidszied ua;:1;1' ié deducted tmvaxwds developmtentaji
vaiéé 0f the land per acre would be
Htzawever in this case the ciaimants are
seékinvg éniiancemcnt in a sum {sf R5.3,?'5,{}O0/- which is
R less than haif the amaunt 8.SS6$$ti¥d in MFA
;?§fi$.3428/2004' 'I'he1"€;ibr::*: an overafl mnsideration of the
ifiateriai, We find that the }'6(}L1(°i':S§ cf thc siaimants for
anhancement is just. anti rfiast;-rlabie. Accardingly the
appeai of the Siam is dismissed and the appeai ef the
tzlaimants is a110we.c;1 granting Compensatienéfiat ratfi 'cf.
Rs.3,75,06{)/~ per acre with coéts ;é§$;;f{t:,itt3Ij¢" V7;.2§11€:fi.€Ls '
as aghast: Rs.2()OOO0/' ~ per'a:::*e aiivrartirzd L.
mum.
M]@T # § E$flf€’
Sd/we
Iudgfi
%Vw- {%”