High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri M S Nagaraju vs State Of Karnataka on 4 February, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri M S Nagaraju vs State Of Karnataka on 4 February, 2009
Author: N.K.Patil


1?}; E33 Efiflii CQLTRT G}? K?-;P££*–E§’1T2%§\iéx E-33? §A}%§AE.,.é’3«REE ‘5£.’Et}:-3a§.3€§¢.§ :23’ 73%;? mi miss:
maéiers

1

-35

as: I}-{E I-iii-SH cam? as mam ram A 2′ 3AH$Ai.$RE
BATE-B THIS THE 4TH BE? 3? FEER§3A.R’i’,V
ssmm %

2’35 ;¢s:4’sz.s 3:3. J€i$?’fCE ;4.x.§g :§g /if A T L

:¥-p.;e’a.3a4;§;2:}a:3;%«_
w.a:«:@.3e49 $23999; W’;’?.NC’;3053’1′–29.Q’3T”~._. U
.;ia__E§€_§ I ”

:a;.?.Na.s115;2m9 % £AP:’\é'{‘;1″‘~~,

§%i.F.E*s%G. 33535/206.9;

BETW EE #4

*2 SRé%a$3?~éfi_3AR;%.§i}-,”” ”

s;*os:a:::a*aQ2§%:aa. _. =
AGE9A392§;»is5vam::,; _ ‘
;:9:¢;c”=:i;2;~f<§;;\…..';. 2 ._ »
H.§\SS£§\%_;

_ _ _ V 4′ V _ _ mF’Ef§’§’%G%~£ER
gay :-::;}$ at .;;wAR$s.:g.é’e;g; ;

3:49; ‘_
3, _i ” 3*:A?§ fi?”§€AR%éA?-AKA
v- ;gg;=~.._a\* ms 35:3;-**~ $953?

BE?’-‘A§1?f§”?v%E§*éT’GF CG~%%9£%A”$”%G£\é

” — ?w%€.£%..}”%_3″é’QR§E% SL%§L¥3§?~«£G
‘ __§$:’%1;§’%i2’».§%.€’gEé;’-I

)2 V 3éR’S;£:.?:%§R 0% %e%ARi<;»E"'{%NG

aaeggg' ma amsagvaexé ages»
.. B$%%Ga%i..§RE -5% can

AA "'3-éz SEQREEARY

R33 i§¥..Ti..$Rfi:£. PRQQBCE ?sé§fi<§'~r;KE'§"%%"aéQ
CQ%s%?s§%'é"'i'EE, ¥-§fis$SA.§~§

FZ£$?G§'éQE%'s«3'$

*' :§$?»;5é"§". 5&3}-§fi1£%"é,. %,L$?¥%§ARAGEF{E?v%§§§H ECG? FQR R? é%£'=$§ 2

33%' 81%. T'r%%§#€§e%E'=.3C.%¢'§'£'ie% A3?' FQR R-3}

3% 331% EEEGEI €3€13§}R'Z' 53%' §;&.§§3'»§§.TAK;: AT B&E~E<3 §~.Li'}RE 'J=iZ?.3»&;.'3s$~<$§ af $}£z'9 mi £4312:

"SEE: {E333 '='§{}UE~'.T E<;£=g;'§.3*5§x"£'A_'z-iii'; A? : '§s',?.2~i:}.3§€}~2.§ 9f 3%??? £3331 £35315
maitegré

-”s
..’u..

“EH33 ‘°y”‘w’P. $3 HLEQ L}?”~éC%ER %§?’?%Ci.ES 22328 ANS 22? Q? THE
CQ§\§’.:7»: ‘:”e..}:’G5’-‘E *3?’ §é’\{{}§:’5§% PR.9Q'{§i%’»£{:’ ‘R3 LSALL FOR R {ZQR§.}$ AM}
UQNS F?é”.}%”#§ T545 R§S¥3*{}§*=22E?~§§’S. $’§°R§KE {.}QW¥’-4 §”*’.{..3§..1c::,_’33%°%:§§§_:}3:{§’#’§
RE:-‘:9 ‘e”v’%’€’s S’s3’éw’E$¥.§%L”£ N {4} OF TEE §.EA$E~C%.lEg%–§A£_E “§s'{3’§’2E.5,£3§*§ENT

\?F-‘§;’*~iGEQ TS WEE KAR?~%£'{§§.é<§ é'sSR$%.}{§'L3R§:§.. PROSLLEE 4E'%:%;'?:§3riL5-iaE'§"§§%

{REG{.§i_A"%"iQ§'€ as: A.LLQ"§?~e'%E?'»§? SF mcafisaw xx: ?é.fiaR§2.ms:.E.E AQa2′”§RAz”«°:: ma 9?<:;:s&a.f:J'9
'ma seaamgrasag A$R2cL:a.":uR;:.:. PRQESUCE :aaAR;NEf”~:€:”;-{.”Z<}%~%<1ER%4ET€} .g=I"}%..iA:?~3H ma '

?Qz'~T:FEE7{?.JRE QRSEFE: mi ?(€1<2% '4'E£?«§:é&'4}(–A'iSS%iEB-SYR3; _
'%€.P.?~3G. 3§49!*2§§9:

%E’:”;fi.!£E§=£

é $R§M$RA%’4fGEGQ1:*’£3A- ‘ _ ; »
3:®9;:$;:£s@¢ga§ –. i
2:553 §?J%%’¢€3.*§€fé:’%T%%5ks’C?i5¥a5’%?=;§’?v’§”Rz’1’=§’.§’.e5E£:’3EC’:§ 7 ~ ”

A?-*a§£”§5§a:a V ‘

_ _ , _ ..°P§:?:T;c2»:Ea
{E}: 33: ,ifi’w§#R§%;%§}..Ai}¥§}f¢é’§?_’ ,

2 s;’::.a*;2=, as ;<.,AH:4A'rA':=a;;: "
REP._3'£' £'§S :~E;EC£~'%E?AR':*
_ _ e§PAm':;:ah;:v–.a¥*se;aPE?.A?:e:~.2
; ' :=;:ur:"; S"E'€.'2=R§E$ auzzazsee
' V _E5\?aZ$£a§,{%R'€E« {r:.__.. «

§éR2=;¢':*<;£2 £2? 2¥%AR3€;E:'%§'~é;G

rair _ . V

V _ " ss-q$_o;~2$; 2:49 :'1iR..é8H:%VAs*éRQéQ
~ .ss::%gz;:::2£ 9:

12%; Léé:&2’éR§’m?.’~:

~.;%zs?~;:c2;;”E:.;%_ PRQSUQE §a«’§AR§<ET3?«£Qs seaming;
~. agmage

§%':E8?f}§'£3E%u*'FS

,5eSHA $2? §{{$%é8.%Rz§$ER§?g%RTH HQQP §3$§ Q-é Fe?%D 2
SE-ié; H31. "{§~%§§'e'E%§EGQ'*«"'¥Qfia AG?' %7QR R3}

"5%~§iS '¥'a§§P. ES F%§…E§ U?*éG§R é3R"%'§.C2..E5§: ;T$;"§ A343 2%'? G§ "'5%%E

" £S£*é3?E?i}?§C}%% Q? §?'{f§%1′”£’ 2}?’ ,.»’–‘~.”§’ flég Q3 ‘-§si?1}I«a Esiiluifs :3»? $32}? mé. 0:323:

4

{E} Thé W??? muefiiians ffiefi by peiitierzegs

are afiawaé in part

{ii} The %锣’¥f3U§¥3e€i fafiefiure e:’é£z.£}j”
3: 2 2993 iaearéfig 95¢. Eiruii-£3:*:1:.:;4..3.:§«.{i~§’$}Vj:

QGB8-3% passed by the

Fxfinexure-A {§¥”£ aéi ?£%’2es”7e,§*3*at$éa:*s -5s},_ifs Sm ‘far as
‘Ehase §$”£:’§f:§fi§’§€*?’é__ ‘¢:’v.i~2T& €;§§¥”%§5:E§£’¥i_§.*€3f,’*~.§3i?’& %°:éé”éA’sy% get
Efiififi.

back: ta ffie

‘:§:;§§%§~ “‘:9é«éinf:”:s£fier3t§a:’2 cf Em
V %~ ” ~ ks aggrafiréaie éecisian,
*3f§A1r.érL4§}§5¥f€f£:’§%:§7g %3ea§;3fiabie Qppafiufifiy cs? ‘fiearing

peiéféfiéfiarg and fiégaem 3% the same, §¥”‘§
was As? 3:’1é.R:.;%es; 3:36 keepifig in View fiéa

A392 Quart, §é”?t3§i.§é§f”t§ tha ardar psggeé by the

fiivésion Bench ‘9? 9 Cmzrt date-3 1&5

U–“”‘””°°'””_Mm”Wmm#n”

E’? EEKJEE €’.’7Q§.:’§.T 5}?” E€l§’1E3:,}§ ;’-‘{§;3z1é§x 5%? *,.é.,%£:§ :’%.L{}§.§i§ Ef 2:35;’? fig}; 53:3:
3333:3515}

372$ EZEE EEESEE €3fZ:E_EZ3:’i’ g..*’}x§3.’-3. ‘}I%§{5»k 3′-if 3?£€GA§,{}§%E $»’;._}’.:’«’;.”§i.”:.3%{3§-3 :3′? 393? £52 xtiéiaz

4;’.

$3 exgeditiaugiy as pessihie, 3′: any rate, wiiififx
an ester fimif sf fine yea? frerr: the;

§€?’I’f’i§$$§€¥i”i grenfeé by the M
:2-ampeient auiheréfy, f3%%§:’:=§{J€}%£*§§t;§1_%
Eire aufimrifées ta taige _§p§ r’a§?’§–:;$te n
aécaréanae wiih Eaw. ‘V V V. ‘V

{vi} ‘me tag:-a éirggteé ta
reggiva iiiggv s3g’:*;A’;1_;=-;.. V. ” €f’1.’a§<§¥":g…

§3é§%%iar*:ér$ aieng

?k:’§é:*i<e% Cammiiiée
%n '%:_$9' fifié 'yfeafs térm wéih a
5' ::.5§:e€:§%fi:::V_A §ei§i§a$2e;'s is t;':fi%'§'§§§é%€ ihs
%i%:2s:j%:§1s¢;%ss::«,Vv"éé e;<§edé€%::~a:§%y as mssifiia at any
a geféfifi as? ma yaeai. Fafiing wfikfia, it $3

is ciafify $23: ihézfi reaparfieni is: 8fi'€§§.§éfi

$553" égi-fie 3gps"a::rEaEe éefiiséafi ii"; aamfiarme wéih iaw

am is"; s:§:"s§%§a§m af 1% ::i§§e{:%:%:sm 5'? {his

Cami éatea 1%' 3ec%9, 2&9? passeé in writ

E3'? TEEE Eiéiiéi <3»? '»"=, $5? 3.53:'-iii? giilfifi' mé £313:
mafia';