Smt K Varalakshmi vs The Assistant Commissioner on 6 January, 2009

Karnataka High Court

Author: Ravi Malimath

3: 23% wmi €£§}R'I' 5;? iéaﬁaafma 5:? 
msrag was "ﬁ4EE am my €35'   _ _
B§.;§'i§EE.....        A  
"E3-E HQEELE ram wmmég;  1%
WEE'? PETITEQR z§@;k:%3:§@:%; 5 A 
BE'm*EEK:      

am 3 V $EﬂéZ_v  'L = 3  
W!0MKm3m'¥j$.%%%    %  V
.&..G2:42fm;3   _  =
WE. SI§'3E;;§€?::  ;%§..%§£§§z%*f£?
    
 émug 333 $23'?
 ~~~~ %      .y.PET}.'TIQ§2&ZR

{By gm L  »..Lf£5s;:'&*'§,;{E5se'.;.Ti.3°E%i§':éj:§4'3';.::': mm g amma mU1~zsEL
ma x§a;%%3.g;av;a;;maa;2 s.mm,. ﬁ;SS:3€§§.'I"ES,
anvmaaazag  ' 

     A. A'   ..... 

     .  Cﬁfsﬁﬂﬁﬁiikﬁﬁﬁ

*     3:33 amgiag
smagimsmmmm

 X 2 " yﬁmgamma mmaa smamysgé'

COEIKT OF KARNATEKA HIGH €082: KAﬁNA'I'Ai(A i-HG?-3 CGURT OF KIMNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH C33}?

% ?ERE&ﬁsEE*RA
     LA%Rﬁ '§".&§;£{.§K ﬂﬁﬁ §§§'f'RE£T'
Ea? ITS SE€»EETﬁa§Y

3 P E? Rﬁfsfﬁﬁiﬁ REBEY
S Lﬁm Q jﬁ:  
AGE': :48 YRS
PEEE$$:.§§E2§

if';     R TALEEE Affﬁ SE3'?

 

   

/Aw



....W.... W nmanmninnn naun Wm; 5.535 mmmnm n-mm count or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA mesa COURT or xAmAmm HIGH com-

-59.,
ﬁne

    
  

4 § :2 am@*m;5§s  
vim R    % % 
ﬁ;GE :-4% Yﬁﬁ

  

5 C§ VE%%E€a?E8§§§W£3;
33:: mm mrsmws 
ﬁﬁﬁﬁﬂ YES  _  
?ERE$a§ma A   % k   
:7; :19'   'Q';  TAEEEEZ £33" EE§:*i§E§§"'?

 

39.59; F"AEﬁZ§DD§§    
am rim' mﬁm '§"Q 3?;-aa §~:¥<;%:.*:'i*1c::24;fz.:5& A
ﬁ§E:48'fﬁ$ V      
mzmgﬁgagma ?§;r€£H;§'2:§;*r;~.%LM % ~ '
PERE&@iE'3I%:_A k %  A    
  

 

M  *  *
§s«£:%JC;».R M     M %

%¢@%¢ﬁ '§;;Q'i,_G? _ "§ﬁ~.fPz1EIE?,}f{;iY§x'F
mmgamwm     

  

  %%%% 
. age Ii-'CST mam 'm Em FETITIQEER

 } :sr$.»3»:::R     

%§«$m E§;,§;;%;§?m Pazicaavsrr

$Eﬁi LﬁKf§$ 'E'ﬁ=.LE}K ﬁﬁﬁ §iSTRI{"','1"

 %::_::~;§<§§s1~ma
' _$g,$£¢iﬁ§%¥A??,&

~  %»§&}%E

13

%   Mkimmm, aémm ygmaayar
 Em Kasasaszg 

 

LI, ?E3RE$z§..§¥§R§s
C ﬁiLAPi}R% 'f'ﬁ.LI.}'K 3&3 SISTRIQYI'

 

rﬂir-

T  A§,L2'i?{IR& 'mama gm: §zs*:{ 5;  L



14
 2  'I   ..... ..
 A «:;m2m3§§R',"€;1mm Fﬁ;N{:H.P;'2*"ﬁ.T
  =§%.;*c2 Ei¥§R$§§f£§%iﬁLLI3 mmsmma m
'  TQ ARE BEST

L.'UUK'E" OF KAKNAVQKA HEGH 60%???  K&RMATM(A HIGH COURY' OF KARNATAKA Hiﬁ-E COURT OF KARNIWAKA WGH COUR? OF KARNATAKA MGR COUE

33

M%£}R
Eafﬁﬁiﬁﬁﬁ, Ggﬁﬁ Fﬁﬁﬁ §'§aT
Eﬁﬁﬁﬁﬁﬁg ﬁﬁiﬁﬁ   ;' LE

 
  

        

   

E1

 

Eaﬁﬁﬂiﬁy RWEEER} {§E.%f.E& Fﬁ..T§$E-i.§§'f}%T   
Rfﬂ K3REE§AH5"1..LLL }?EEE:E'~i;5i*§jﬁE& 2"~:::% % 2 
C  ' Aazamﬁggzapux 2%.§§V§§=i:_':'ITf'ii177';?TI\'f 

 

 

 

12 §{'V'1'3&'2"ﬁ;§ﬁ.I§'B RE§§'¥'"'-._ 
Sm \e'E§3"£_3{§%P§'a.L REID - g   "
Mama? ﬁﬁﬁéﬁﬁﬁ         X - 
gmm P.#s.1%C:§§m*A?:,~'  

336:» §§G§:£§.a.H:a.L:,:; WEE" V ma R3
C§~§i{E{ﬁ3§A§;LAFfJE irmfﬁ E1%i::mﬁ:¢*3*

  ..

§s:£AJC}R,,_ ii j?£E*3€L§H2°sYz§s.T
PEEE”8::§?%§E?§E?§
$ g§.L&m§’ “F§§.:i}’K mm ﬁ§%’EI£”i”‘

32 W

S;’§’}I ¥§§ ‘§’Q ‘gm ?E’E’I’I”IQEIEE
, A’§siz4;§IQR
% vémxfgmaa}

Pﬁﬁi £2 }~I§€’i”ﬁT

‘ ‘ IE? $33 $33?

E§§$§T Mﬁggxﬁﬁg
WE *3 E§ﬁ%”§.’§;§’§ﬁ3§5’ﬁ@
£233 :l’~e%AJQ§

I – _

T §%mam*2;&:’:*

% ,§_’§,–1ﬁW1%ﬁ. 31% mm @rIS’TT:7R7i1C’5*£?V:~–~:__Vj:.

PE»RE$ﬁ.§§=R&,
CEEQEQAL ER TQ AH}? SE3′?

3.’? SET? R REBHA Wiﬁ SE-§””$&?P$

.ac3«§:2«:w@§

Rm
mmax; aﬁﬁum Pﬁ§EC§~€A’£.5%:3″._
ymzgsmnaa 1
Cmczéa 539 E15′?

is z»+:vKA.mvam.swam*é_
am am’ mam m E’?-$..;F§:;?1’1*§*I£§£%’E;_R_.’3
£sGE:Zwiﬁ…IC9R
Rm HUVHi$V£§F;A}TﬂLE;I,i~ k
§ 1%§aH§;*§§’?.’CC ‘A

PE~REm§ﬁm _
smaygaggsmﬁzg C5533 g3n::r::s*E

m Smﬁsgﬁws
(By S::ﬁi:v:..2§7€§Ij¢€-,I:%?§£f’zf.7’x£§;E3f§*iEElI€i %;,;C:-1:<.:ae1v ma RE.

zfshmf. C1c:."§aR5?A:%5aV, éawmgm F'$R R3, 5 '$0 12,

' _ 1:'; mmrj 3 "

S1’ir§,. }§£.3UEE$};-‘~’E$}”9?§ WW3? amvmgm Fm
‘CR4? 5_,~V;3;a:é3:: M’;

waif’ C131-wmarg :3 9:133 Ur-mm Amcmg

22vaariI.1C¢2§2? Q? Tiﬁ. C$}f€E”I’§’E*E.I’FEQI€ ax? mags; mm

QEFASH ﬁf§HEX{§RE 3 HT. 23.1O.3€C1®

f§.s;S,SE;§;’§_~vB’:*§’§’§E E1 M5: gm? aﬁ E€’I’EREvi GREEK

5.1.3, ” %P%;mm§
V’}xTH§EEﬂ¥.

Sm? Exﬁﬁuﬁﬁﬁﬁ &§§ mmmﬁgﬁ G1?’
AI*IE*§EXG}¥fE E m’: mimgma msgam 3%’ ‘mm: R} AND
ER wgsuwca

TFHS WEI? ?ET1’?§§§€ ﬁﬁiﬁﬁ QR Fﬁg $33338

TEES EPLY, ‘ﬁﬁ CQEERT §v%ﬁ£ TEE FC3L§$?a?@G:«-

COURT OF KA£MATM*(A H365-i cougf KﬁRNATAKA HIGH COURT’ 0? KARNATAKA RIGR COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT 0?’ KARNMAKA HIGH COUR

w -«’..u up-o

ﬁﬁﬁiili

Tm patifﬁéwaar prayﬁ fax’ a writ in

maﬁa’ rari mi quash the Fma?:r§u,’£:is::_t;rz..:r:§§awa:}?:”.2§.:’§ ‘. ‘A V’ ‘

ﬁrmmcursw B .

2. £1: is: the £333: ﬁf–£§}:1§’-§§$?iﬁ9%1é.§i”¥§’hﬁ?€ she was
elmﬁed as a ;; f’ hayaﬂi and
fnzrﬁmr clésctfarzii «ééwrpﬁﬂémitﬁ 3 to

13 are af tﬁe Gram

ﬁg 119;»-cmafxdenm
af ‘rim zmmﬁem 9f the

Gram was achaduleé :9 be Emiei an

A’ “I§ﬁ5″‘£$um by mm” 25: af mmram’ ‘ mﬁxer éatad
it: ‘€§3’.§~”.§%$. 2.33$?;3:1=§a rmtramd two

‘§ai3:’&,$ am

._,……m.,..,….. IMIVIII ………g W nnxvtnlniul mcm mum or KARNATAKA men COURT as KARNA’!’AKA HIGH comm” or KARNATAKA men com:

mm mm» mm :21 the saiﬁ

” aémtimz ta mnsiﬁw {Em rm erjmfxdem

miémn :1}: ané in ail ten gmaem

in tha aaiﬁ. mzmimz. The ﬁssiatsnt
Qiiﬁmzﬁsaiszm cmm E9 the ammluafmu ﬁmt aintte the

3 alwtﬁ mamkers 9%’ 2% Gram Panshayaﬁa ears 1?’ in 321,

2 pexmns §m*sei@ Ema rmﬁaﬁzeé $3 {Em mraﬁer sf the

gr.

Q? ﬁle

w…m W mmmwu-. Hanan u…w.n we Mmamm mm»: com? or KARNATAKA HIGH couxr or KARNA’mKA mm COURT or r<AmAm<A HIGH com:

High Cami': {mm castirg thﬁér mm in Eh: §}wtF§J1'–'.§and

aizaxza ma': pemmm haw "saﬁtaé in fawn? af it

wmtituia twga fzzzirés Q5 ﬁg Ema}

xzwmbam af the Grrama '

that the peatiiiaceziar ma guﬁamis ;é;v–.:i?:s–..esnii:é;2::§§*4a; L %

ﬁrm yrment geﬁtimm

— , Smﬁcr

:3. S§n*’iaJa3:

Cammal §?3.¥:¥~’ ..§;§9§§i£%tw1*’s munsei
m::§bmi1:m§ %§ 3f the Eiawtaka
g_§v f§ﬁ£;*1L1§i}§1 axgwsirg Want sf
& majarity sf not LESS

am agaagkgaf 229% mm: r:n.;mbm* afthe mmbem of

‘V ﬁe iharafam, aubmittaﬁ that

-. Pamhayath are 17.

V –V tha ﬁziagim gram’ is» gmntﬁ r%U
§£”°%m mmkars ﬁmm waaitirzg their’ “win: in the
ijaéaééiatimn tkek mm%:::mE*:i§ ﬂaw mt maﬁa, Thgrafarae.

‘;t9m–&n*ﬁ” 3 ﬂ’§.ﬁﬂ3§3<=&ZE 23%' tha Gram Pa-mﬁayaﬁz wau§ be

twa iziﬁaﬁa sf' mm: memkﬁrs namly ii Ha tharefem
aubmiﬁmi 't.'t1a§: siim mrﬁy E3 mgmka mtaﬁ in {ﬁe mid

%,._.._

cigwticxn they $3 gm: wgzstémta majaﬁﬁr ainm Ewe-'~tp§$ds
{sf 1'? 9331316. Em abmut 11×32. .. ..

4. S§3r§.§§i,E%:*I,I§at&m3} V 9

for fwponaeﬁrzm 3, :5 ts: 1:2, 35

aut}3gr1%’ ‘ have –s_ cf’

the mcmbem an 31% §:g,aﬁa Iaﬁsﬁ. Hanan,
ma tram’ sf 1:; mnié
5, §9 t
Plaadar &pp¢.§f§rig_f¢_§”Vti*:£.%. m_;;af;r:<:iant 33,1 submiﬁs that

there is ﬁg' the assistant

_ Vﬂaammgzifaxéicxzaar g;$gi;:é$§.r:::g fhe garden

313 th& ﬁourzsek Sazzfﬁmzzt 49 mi"

" .

yv §{ .’a”” m ” ?Emhafg:a%’:i’1 fast wafers ta ma tmda

ﬁm tﬁtai mimﬁer aef mammm af the Grama

is zmwiiéizta a masalufﬁen. Tbs: mm}.

H V “”;?;*a;3;$E:’er 9%’ mﬁmbem aﬁmfi’f::ed%y-‘ in tha irzamzzzt mane are

LUUK§ Ur KAKNAIAKA i-IE9!-i COUﬁ’§’V-0}’ KARNATKKA H56!-I CQURT 3!’ KARNﬁTAKA H36!-‘I COURT OF XARNAWKA HIGH COURTOF KARNAMKA HIGH COUH

2?, Emma twugh thisi iliaurzg by vixma :3? an 5mt.&=rE1m

{war 3? $35 mamﬁmx ﬁsm

t”L~—~

nu–r-waxy -up:

gay. ‘gm asm

.w.m….nm-. mun MHIUITIIA ?..U,.;!’ RAKNAIARKA 1′-IEGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNA’!’AKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COUR

their was in ms: said zemaféitieg, 211$ sis: mt manﬁzé-i£;=::v be

firms membem cf ‘ tfém ﬁrama ?a.rmhayat}3..

mnbiaua ‘:9 $3 ﬁfm mambam af ‘Ehﬁ

the iota} z1um%r {sf memﬁam é

are 1′?’ and mt 15. Then ~~ ~’

iszxmwim sszﬂer grarzteé by C_3:au:?t,;: cﬁnﬁmxe
w.’1ti1 anﬁ unlms Qikersferc,
tim izzterpratairigzz iﬁnmmakaianer
ix: meiudzﬁg V’ mml number af
membms wazzid baa azwxmus.

Tm ﬁrgﬁm Paxmifmyath baing 17
shag 2.? unﬁi mi mxm ‘£1313

gtggizgés $3 :

__ :3? the zwiutziﬁsn imvuiga Ems: pamed
sf Seséiﬁn 4% Wauﬁ thxafam mama

a rmés ﬁat § a rmhztinﬁ

wax}: af mgaﬁﬁarzm hag Eugen =:§$1%ﬁﬁ’6d 3116;

V’ maﬁ” by a Cmamﬁ Paxmhagaﬂy 3 aﬂiar” rma11.;1®I:z

E13 Impact zaf 331$ sama shag mt E: gim neiiiza af er
; Wiﬂ’1i.?1 arm yam” ﬁﬁm the éataa af the éa::§m£.ac;m; sf

z”z;-w

COURV OF KARRNAYAKA HEGH COUEX KA|lNA’§’AKA. I-KGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA WGH COURT OF XARNATAKA HIGH COUR’

€323 Gram ?a:mha§;at;h. Er: ﬁg iI’}$ta.3§2 ::£.’3_§§ a

rmaiutimn hag 5&3: pameﬁ it: View af

wmréaﬁ by $15 Egﬁiﬁtﬁﬂi éﬁamwgiazmr ”
numbm” af ﬁamﬁmﬁ :3? Gm.maa;’3?é£1£:E#a3}iath xii’: 9
View 0%’ azclusiarm sf “mm m;ﬁ;f.K_ihI:3:”§”ffE:”:i§’i*§:3 ‘i:é:v€.::i.-

by way sf an aréezr vcha.*i

in favaur sf tha m¢€é§*;_::z.’ta\m nmjsrity.
Thmfmé in sﬁf imga absve,
the ma: $5 «rm ihirds of um
53% an 6% baais cf 1?

in «am $5 an bar
§E$’if:£Q sf Semzimi 49, the

ﬁnm 1&3 sacgxmzti

§E§Wﬁfﬁ$’§ I ﬁaem ii juat aﬁé prsapar that in vww’

zméa hy Q1335 Cuurt with @ard tn

the at’ me {was mmims at” am Gram

“Fa.§§n}ia$«*ath% it wauﬁ he gust and ﬂair in the largw

sf démwraﬂy arid ﬁrm abjacﬁ aaught ta be

“5 by Eke yatéz Raj Ami {Eat the game: $3311

mt wme: in aha way sf ﬁg mamégrs Emvzi.-mg Eibcrty is
& tiwir ﬁht 29 mm 3 Imahjﬁnn if faund

MAW

V’ 3’m3m&ﬁn1’2s3

uwvnx an nnnlvnaﬂnﬂ nmvn uutusi IU-‘\l(NA?AK.A liitiﬂ COURT OF KARNATAKA I-HGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA H¥GH COUR1

§1m%aa:’}7. The mséaiuticaﬁ pamad an §3;1&2€ﬁ8f”‘e¥;cu1d

mt mma in tias way mf ﬁrm mazzabem

rmsaiutian if fcurﬂ zxamaaary. Thmefarﬁ, 15%-:’&j_

that ‘rim in t?mn

Cﬁ i¢ﬂ%§ in r&§::Eati::n_.via«

T’ha mm} xiumber sf Fépnimyaﬂl
until mﬁmbera w.aaé§§”j:c2 E%c §=5§:A:s; 1?’ and
ms: third’ 5 af ‘:7 in

Vv§7’€:’:?:’ rﬁsiéazéé, E gasa tie falhwim

*1′:’:.~ue aama Qgxmaa gwﬁaeé by the

ia harﬁhy gumkm,

Fstitimn 5% ciiamaaci sﬁ’ in mm :>f’ {ha

3d/-S
Tudgé

Like this:

Related

Leave a Comment Cancel

Smt K Varalakshmi vs The Assistant Commissioner on 6 January, 2009

Share this:

Like this:

Related

Leave a Comment Cancel