High Court Karnataka High Court

Gurunath Keriyappa Patil vs State Of Karnataka on 28 March, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Gurunath Keriyappa Patil vs State Of Karnataka on 28 March, 2008
Author: H N Das
p.'

. CQQRT DE KHREATAKA A3 BANGALORE

um nnv r-st: nlnt:
NJ 4U'I- \

%ulol"| 1- ' ' l"dl"'l:i '\-dlu d

m
u
H
5E2
!---|
m
4
:II
m
w

can-u--;-nun:-u

UHHVUKH
THE HDN'ELE MR. JU$TICE H;w.wAsAMofinfi fi%é T *' 
lm'F:I'F PETITION i~10.3451r2§J_@a gs-R3_.~:S5' V' 1:': 
BETWEEI-12 I «'   4'

1 EURUMATH KERIYRPRH FRTiE_
$30 KERI?hPPh PATEL "

R13 ED 52 '€'El3.ES

EHLHFATHI, HfiRAGHfiAHALLI~_";'

nanmm cconozw PCJ'S'_1f';'~._MU_NflI§i3011I,I., A'*--..

2 EEIIVRFPA ERJAPEA I?'3=L'I'I'i.J3Q
::a..*'o ERAPP;5t'P3$;T'IL¢=__ ._ " V 
mass .53  flfatfl-'_sFf§THI_«-- 1;. V
]'€.'.I§:I [W31 ,5 megtgasi '=P'ti3E'!ff,.-- _ _ rriallmhvsonu
L1TT;=.fI=;3 1*€S9g|5J'i*IF;1;gal .  ._ 

3 1~Lv;I%;,nt-;I:n_.t4;fi[ '.9-5':-as-'s  ' «
:§fa'}u%uA&:ua'.},.* ".'"_
Mann ' 44'  ,~» A11»; f.tA_P}°.iF'HI
J.TC'u"FaGE?€I_.« v}-if-"4J.:.'r"-'u.G.'T_ 

a»n§;=:e;n.§.r3on'1_=..,T:uwwK '-
 Kfifiifiikfli... ..... 

 A"--»l3F:U.TI'HE.Ifs1«~II°:':';PL MPHADEVKFPA EITHMMBI
' "_T_s;.=*.::t.j':»s,;n.1+rp;EE1r:aFPA ummax
~. 'Assn « J;-_;j1,_ *m::i.1='..~:.-*. , HALAPATHI
' .__t3|3ThL?§ElJ1. C1-EO0§'PA
1'n:.I:.:.;-=.'L:.':r'v Ps::s'r, MUNIIAGOIJU
HTTAE KAHHAEA

1'.~"'.~'¥.'fi:'3u'--§E€a%uu"§-"w,'r"«u'-'a "-.-"E I'5'..*~.TPu'!.?=!.'-'.-.l'.n"'- E?-I."1T

V"3H0 WENERTREMRNA EHHT
Fain-"'Efi Ii 5 "1."EF\RS
flRhRFRTHI, HHEEGGEU POST
METTAPURR¢ UTTARR KANWREE

 'in ,

6 MHfl3UNHTH GRHHPATHI GDUDARA
Effl QhNaPflTHI GOUDARA

u\./\
k/'

 



£17!

10

11

EEED 54 YEAR5
flfiLfiPfiTHI, """"""

nnunuufifl,
SHIREI, UTTARA KRNNADR

ERRAMEEWRRA DEVAPPA HAIK

syn DEVAPPA HAIK

AGEH 53 YEARS, unnnnnwux

FEST HUEEANhEERJ, KUMTA
UTTARA xaunana

YEbhAPPA BAflEhRAFPA Asagngh'
awn snmsnnnprn ABASARA

HEEL' 1:4 vsmas, nampnrm .
nanwaana HRLLI, nasannxoarn
fifiifififii, UT?hfi Kafifiana 4,".
anmncammnna uRTTRTHRETA"HE§ERfiR
are DHTTHTHRETA Baanama 3 , =
Mann .50 'EEARS, BALM;-'rrH:_,..':'» 
Innguwnx Post, aomnuamnms u

vELLAPunA_TaLuK,;uTmnaa_xasn3fiA;f7

fiRJPAEHf$fl¥fi§flA"flE¢EDE:'7v

syn H&RP"""3~HEEEfifi§:'=.:

I ll fills!

AI3J£1lZ!__ 519 W' ,

flRhfiFRF*I;.ERfiAHE%nI, HG""""=""

uTT3EA_KANfiAflB* 'u

MARUTHI mAnnxnMA.NA;n _
are mnmaxnua uA1x'»"
A3En_4a VEARS' '
_flfiLA?fi$H1, Hngaxunu mes?

mHA_fiDom§v3Ra, UTTARH xamuanh

gdT?éfifiA fiufiauA1x _
--A5f0 HUREHAIK, AGED EU YEARS

»flEL%FEEHI, EELEKERI; ANKQLA

fiTTHE7KfiHNAflA DISTRIBT

«gnwfihxnnnm GUPALA xouasz
. are Gfi?RDF Kflflfifii

3."nnEn 49 YEARS

V muwnnsonm,

HHLHPETHK, MALES}
UTTARR KAMNADR

1

0""

 



9.4.!

14 NEELRKHHTR HRRRTHHA PR1

EEG Hfififlfififlfl ER}

REED 55 YEARS
flfiLE?fiTHI, EEERLE
MRDHWNR GERI, ANKDLA
UTTARH EHHNADA

15 SHRMBU LINGA M HEGDE
arc H HEGflE
AGED 52 YEARS ;Mm_
QALABAEH1 '
Hmauunavmmn SARA
@2331? UTTAEH xaumnnn

1% mnaafiawa GGPHhRKRISHHA.HEG3E
EEO EUPAHAKRISHHA HEGDE '
Aufiu an VERRS :  ,""
EHQAFHTHI, KhbAMHE" '
3IDflAFURA, UK

17 QfiRPHnA.fiNAflTHA BHAT"-}
aim AnAuwHA'3HAw:= *
swan 51,¥E5R3_3 __ _ , .,
QAh&PHTHIi=HIPPEmAHfihL1-;
5135;, U? "l* "v'**

12 5RNmAF?A $AwAPFA'ma1x .
EEG fiEfifiPPA fl%£K7.'=
Assn 51 Evnxs "f , _
flALmEnTH1,=Rfiflsufimywfiflfiflhh
LTfiAE.KAHHfiDE'
"V i9_ Tazmfimwna Gwvxnna NHIK
' »_*a;o,smv:wna mnzx
',52"rEARa;.naLArAmH1
-'£maAua??m3T, KUMTA
.gfi "a'

~94' . A« .
39 TfiIHHflRfi%.EH%HTH%H% P%u¥£Lu-w

n:£ND'$HmNTHAxA PATAGflfiA
, Efififi 54 ?EhRfi, fifiLfi?fiTH', G"'THRfi "fifi"E
*m1nJAm, xunwa, um

"~21T FRAEHRKARA RARAMEswAaA.JALIsAmeI
EKD EARKMEEHAHA JRLISATGI
REED as $3333, HALAPAIHI
vnwwxmnnnvanu, xnmwn um

(jgfivvx.

 



22

25

H3
£51

E Hfibfiflhhh,

 *ao

 _I...r.:n :2.' ..

flI€'W&".3»"h'hTHI HARNfPd'IA I-JAII-CA
5,-'0 :»JAP.:wAN.'n. N.AI1»-tn.

AGEH 50 YEARS, nALAPnmH1
HENESE. SIBDRPUR, UK

!£lPLGP:.F'.PLJP: ".TEERFkB1'.L"LDRA NAIKR

3.30 "IE EP..11.EHAEP.11. !|!§l.I!€.'.33-.

49 YEARS, DALHPATHI, HfiLAERI
31 fl}"1:.""I'.3R, $.11-i

jfirI\Tf'iF'J"F'F\ E'iRl?Ei'ifiW?E f~iF\1' KR.
'E-'~;"'D ESWSENDRAPPA MAI!'-39..
NEED .53 'r"EP'uFL3

£iJ'LL1P¢.F'P:THI , S1 RS1

UK

SRIHHARA mAnAvnNA'x3MAmH"'.T
$30 MARAEAH £KEHhTHf_A  ;j¢
REED fie VEAHE, flAbAPATHT~'J
Eflfifififlfi, KUMTA, uxw..% V.u

?HUKfiEfififiiLGL%uRfi'fiKIKR _. "'*w*

-P %
fiffl LumAPPa,mAIxA-,, x

HERB 55.ffiEE$. BELREHTHI"
NhDRMRSEfiRER1Q._' '~

m'*T~*'*r     
finmxflfimmnaa_isBKha§"nEaA1
awe zsmwnaa HE3AIfi'}
EEED 52"vnAa5; '_
gaua?AmH1;~anTHgHmAuL-

  ..... ..

M1:-sm "*2.

' .!§'Et;1}§vv'£'v'IrJ"WW'"F3'\ S':-TEE'
 "1"_.'_Jk3?Ps 3HEELnPxVM'£|TI'IPx
5 @ flfiLARRTH1,

It

as. 'um:-. I.1!':!1' 7

. _ V HULEKRLLU
3I3$1.uK

'namnhma CHIMANAPPA EATILR
=,3;o HHIMANAPPA PATIhA

3:34 YEARS, DALAPATHI, GUNHJIHALLII

UTTRR KIPd'lNP:IIIA

F~i..".l'dFL$lIf'IPsN DRRP F3": FLHDHAP PP: THEE URRHFLRP.

L':'I.u*"fl 1'~'Ii.'~'-:s'.'.i'r":}~"mPE THE${}%%}'sPu.

FRJQED .57 YEARS, DIHLAPATHI

OkI/\/\/



HELHVHDA, HHLIYABH
UTTRRA KHNNAHA

31 RUDRfifiQWflfi BHNGARHPPE GDWDA
EKG ERNGARAPFA GDWDR
HGED ET ?ERR3
HALRPATHI, EALEKDPPA

MUDNAEDDU u  ,
mwwaaxnwmana ... PETIT'QHEP$

1'3-um LN.-u-'. ''1'
i2)' .'Fn"J..L \

cumin.
:1
I

1 swnmm 0? xnamamnxn ,V»
5? BEKRETHRY ?o GGVERNEMHT,  
Hans nzrnnmnnmw V*.V :""=Vf
VIDHRNA EUUDHH ' * '-
BANGALQRE.

2 THE supsmxmrfimnsmiwdfi7saLI¢Ex '*«'
rnnwnn * '=» '. i*" '~ =¢«-m

-"nu --it

UTTAR Kamfianégg "; ¥,V< ffV,.. RESPONDENTS

(By 3:1 sag Ehuiéfifli,-fi£#§” 1

THI$ WRIT EETiT1fiH”lS FILED UNDER ARTICLES
236 AND £2?«UF–THE*CflH3TI?UTION or INDIA WITH A
ynnxxn. Tw»L%n1REcT1 .THE nmsrawnmwws To Fix
HUNUERRIUM “FAEAHLEAQ $3 ran PETITIDNER5 IN
AECDRHENUE WITH_ RULE lfi~I OF THE KRRMATAKR

g”VILLh$H»EEEFEHflE HRRREIES RULE 1965 Ann ALSO T0
‘,$Afl$TIflH”THE’ARREAR$ BE THE HUNORARIHM PAYAQLE TD

wHE.EamrmrmMaas.rnaM THE DATE ow THEIR RESPECTIVE
APPDIHTE Q? as aALA9AmHI’s uywm namg.

THIS ‘FET1TIUfi fififiififi Gfi Ffifi

._ V _ s PREL’fiIfiA”?

, HERRINfizTHl3 DAY, THE COURT MADE THE FOLhDWING:–

D H D E R

5 The petitimnera in their representations

‘ *»_ fished 25.4.2097, 14.5.2ou7, 29.5.2007 and

ED.fi.2flO? requested the respondents ta pay’ the

C;%'”LA

aa

honorarium payable to Dalapathis. since the

raspundanta failed ta react tn the request of the

1-.

11%

r” f,’;”_

E. fin grejufiice will b’ caused~ ta “-

f

‘,,.L

1’1

9”,-

‘ {Qt

raspmndenta if they are flirectéd to Gdfifiider

claim nf tha patitianarsy as «fgfind ifimjtfieit.”

raprawantatians stated abnvé} in acfiardaficé with
law anda as axpéd;tiofi§iy ; a§ fifissibla.

AccordingLy,’writ getitimfili3*fiér¢fi? fii33q3ed of.

Eri Ehasfiidfiar..S;Kfiffiafii,'”Iéafnad HCGP is
permitted to filfi méme fir éppearance within four

weeks.