iii THE mag 3&3??? 9? mmawam,
mrrE:§ ~"§*§~§:i$ 'FE-EE 1223 my 35* 351$; "
P",i'?.'£§$E'2'*ri''§::..,_ \ '
$32 §§§fi-'$1.3 §'m.Ji':s*:*:cE .,
ram I»mrs§'BLE mg. J£?S:T§:«:C:E--.E;--»1§§AR;éLYA.'¥Avv éwmy
$'"1"V1§1?*v;'f;€-9;-3,4ii;1V.';Z9 Gfi'{¥3'::'§f§_;'j;;];
3%§s<':.C§:";~:,530.s:.§és::'s§0§ $';'iii?,?ée.i4;23e}9€§';m
Rfifivfiaifigg Sf: ~ "
Wipra Li3:{1i§";fi§' §i:;'£§.:}ta:§§1= (VJ%;fK":§§A,:i.E7._ V
E46, vigielaggiég E11d'}%;1's;f1*§;gz,3,a Area. _
Meiagaih, .:v§.;=+sr;rs:_} V '§74Z'€_p«zf$$<%:1:fi€i
By ,?=.i'.$;V"R.7€gi{3«'i3.&"5L{ Fixiaxxitre 1'*v'!.,a;rf:ager
313:3. C}Shz;1s§:1§(}hai"*%i} . ?ET§'I'I@?§ER
{By Vasuéév éofilgany and Sriyzzfhs %2.%.PE~a:isi2,
'i?_;%",A.g§at:ti, E.Kir.a.;22«aa§ &§.a.§§aiama§é3 Aévecatesg
"
§°3tE.'.§}Z"€S€'Ei31:€jfi§ by ifiepuiy Cifsmmissiermz'
Q3? €Zi:3::;m$:'C§a} "F::zxes(Re<:c3w::§7~ E}
I191}-?s07i":;_ 1~ RES?£'}fiEQE§?I'§'
~0.e-$0»
V. '§'i3iS STRP is fisai umgsr ssczian 23(1) of ma KS? Ad,
WIQ57 agyzirisgt 'Kim jzzégment arifi Gzdezr fiaffié 1§;i:2e2i.Ti{§8
gfiamed in S'}"}%,E'~i'0.2é§jQé cm E1336: filf,' 5f the: Ka;r1:9£a;§§;~z
' VV '";%§pai§a'z::: '§'3*iE311§1al, Bafigaiom, éiigmmsmg fizgi apgeaaé 323%
Misc. civii 813éf{"}9 is fxitaci to stay fhé: Qptzratieri am'?
€§§€C'i§'EL§.€}31 of {ha wade? (ii. 19?. 12.29533 11:: 1261;) f 36*
E /re \°\.
'f'hi:3 petitian and fviiac. Civii coming Qn§._iE)f"éi.§:2f::L%s;re1€3::
this clay, RAM MGHAN REDI)Y, J. pasfieci tifi; f<:1;£¢m::ir:.g:*~--. _
The }C)€titiOI1€I' at
incorporated "LII1Ci{'3I' {he and 3
ragfitered deaiér ii inter aim, in tha
mantxfactmvsz and harciware anzi
suftware, la "c--:*<§éer stipuiatizag "afi
§f1C111SiV€: "fl in reiation :0 the
pr0a1TT'1v.%1ctg«A €"i1,:ri1':g £;E"'1t:+ aSS€S$II3.€I1t jffifii'
2OG1»<§2«,% xL?17;€V3;°;(::a§é.AV.'.1;*:t:*s¥f:{j,%:'é%s were wiséd using wf§}?'H1iX
A§x_§%§)i1r2i§11g "S§§*SI:e1::r1'* ziaveioped by Sy":11iX India
'~':Z§rg9 i1'é::i{;{:i~-Limited, Iihmxgh iIlC(i3I'}'3QI'S1.i€Ci a pariicxfiar
.c£$£ie the tax at the applicabie rate, aftar
ap§._f "v_{Z'§i:e:Viiir§e':'cia1 V
'1'axes{'i'rar1si1;ioI1«£), V§fs9:'6:j,-""§:n§ig--;- As§c3séir1gA §£3ut}10:"§3;}-?
issueci a penalty :"1ot:i';§é%&' pointirag cut
that the géfifiéany {31:}i}€Ci€{i
2es.4,2o,"7?;<9':é};. ih§e':--.:;:is§§§j':1é:%$§"3--towards 'f..Sectiarz 18 <:::f 2:316 Karnataka Sajfis Tax
Aét,.1_4:'}.§r5v?.'§:f§;«;*?:Sher: "K.S.T. Act, 2195?") was liabla far
"-.-e._ ;36nait};? hence 31$ Assesfiing Authority imzokaté
*:;é*:;a;;.:i§:1 9(2) of the ifientmi S8363 Tax Act, 1956 {far short
.*:.%::.T$.r:'. Act, ;29.{)U Eh-3 excess - 'i"?i£s;€f:}_I4'::*i::;;';
when Carried in appeai 1"€giiSEfi'i'fi(Z§ £?iS'{§STf}§§?:.[ v
{)6 befare the giaint {3ommissi o'1:*.s;.§:r of C@?n1n_1erciE3l Taxes,
E§y's0;"e i;'3iv§.si0:"1, §»fi§i§€:*F§'ri,_fi;aS2.j_<iviS§1;fi3'.€2§%€:::?i by oréer dateci
28.1.2005
A11I1e?mre–:’T’I§”‘. . {he said ardar,
$5’ bafore {I16
Jeiiitiolzsr .. i’3I’e§¥3’i”1′”€€i ‘V
KaI’I18;f£§(a “i7::fii’i3’:;21..a1 at Bazigaiore, zflrficiz ‘figfléill
::2u%}*beCAi”‘é%vii”31 261 / 66 was diS1’I1iSS{3{i
by a;{:c;:11.1”:2<§.V§1 V-._r}c11e1:* tiéxtéfii 19.12.2868, irzzpugzed i’1€1’e:E.;;3..
V “E:’§<~::.:iCe_, ""€.§fiS' 'pagtitism.
:;_ _ :’37j3’fié pet,i:i.<;2ne;" has raises} {he foiiawing
._3u Ezsiaritiai questian 0f1aw:–
“‘%§iE”:é:t§161* an ‘aha facts anczi iiifidfii” the
€:ii”iL’}.1I’E18i31″}£Si€S of she ca-$6 €316
.E{a}:’:1ai:a£{a zfippeiéata ‘}”riE>u:1ai wag Z”ig,3′:’€.
in fioldizig that the 16?}? 0%” p&I1a1ii§:’
2231:1521′ Saciisn 9%} sf the £33′? £03 I’Ei.’»Zi{3z at/R
with Séctiézzz 18;: er the KS?!’ Act 33% ‘
has ‘$16 fixssesging ;%z;1’€}”z0:”itj-5%’ V’
{fi{)1″1fiE’II1{i(§ by me
Authority is corre*’4___. V ‘v .
4. ‘ii’her€: is fig 2 9f
$e<:i":i0n E? cf {he .4 ¢n1p0w§:*s the
auiiaority to iggpzjse ' whiia Section
38251 of :'iv9$?' for penaizy féilti'
<::£ie<:E:i2:«11-V Sectiori E8, which
n1az1d§§Li¢s" shaii :10: cofiect. 3:1};
amaamt E:§,%”-4§*;a};?V of fiapéz ‘~g.>:i a 13:6 0:’ rates exsefidéglg tbs
1″at£%{‘}3r;{j?a:a=;s at éL¥%:i:;t,%: he is Eiabie {:13 pay tax Uilfiifii’ {fie
“=V A{é§; ‘%Vs¢¢:1¢:’; fiésma 3:’ ma }.~<L.S,"£'.A{:§;, 2%? makes it
3_Ei}'?;I;;£€§8LI3?:ljkt. that Wham am}; aznozsam. is saécuiazed
'fby-' wa§;Qi':T tax, or purporting is be by way of tax from
"':V'§s&r$5}é}:1 by any deaiar in cozztraventioa af Saeiiorz 18,
K vzf.1i1eih€:* }<:nowi:1g1y mi not, 3113?: dfiakiif Shel}, pa}-1* {ha
entire amaurxt $9 Caiiecteé, t0 the aggesfiing aufhorétjg'
Wifhifl Ewamigf d&3:$ afmr the cfiage Qf {he mazitb in 13;§'3;i::§'1
M
such ammmt was coiiected, I}{)tW"itFiSf,€II1&iI"1g
dealer is not liable 'to pay such amount .
{H11}? .3 part ofii; is due from him astax Lr_::?;d€:”–§’._’1_*.€%”;¢%(::t,.
:3. In {has facts iaiu Vfgaiicedff,S§,i§J1°a,’: i*;i2éV
question far Cfiiisidfifaiififl isfi» »
“Whei:heI’ 1u:h?eT C’:9′:13 missione1”
{asf C(:=mme:1fr:’ia1 j “rax¢s{*?m:;s1t:on–1},
%f’iIij,~«”SV¢::’e %;~1g=m izfifriposing penalty
01:: ‘{i1é:”;§ttI:itir;i1«s::9″‘i?;§I” having sbown E1116
a3f:1£::,1I1i.’–z3f”‘3g’:«i*; fig ‘Tax in its remi*;:1s’.»*”
Léfififiuéatadiy, §E3S5.?'{)Z{i§’1§ Subsmtien {:2} if
–the C.S.’T. Act, 1956, ‘aha panalty G?
:2’s.<§;'?9?':'éi:%_.:3@ représailts 13% at' 225.9-"?,9:,:32<:~2.e’:;%:iar1e:: “Fha p€i§’ai0:2$:*’§ case is ma’:
$16 §*€i{11’ifiS filed; deésiaréng R$.4,2{§,?”?,954.{}(I2 being «<35§z"e
CS'? was a Zmnaféde miaake (£113 EC: 8 fauit ii": antwiszg
éhe mafia in the S§;:ni:2; Acmuntélig System
a 13138. of fiiing a return _¢0iié%t}’ E5 c:;Qn’side1F aé to :¥f1et.:1er Elie dr::<:ia1'aii0r: Qf
, was ma¢¢«*w:m maiaficie and Lzxzreasenahie
»i3?:ie}::ti(;r;S.v.$'t-. is I"1%§};6S$ {Q state £113? the petiéianer
""1:*,aV.*:"..s.'-3'.:;%;=;gVV"§";:'i5'§:».-<1 mmm riieciarirzg E316 311101211: sf {EST
CGE.€'Ct€§ . 4%? {ha mntexition advaneed £113: me
u was; an 8_CC{}1iZ);i af an ermr in fmdirag {E16
"pf&r.t%r:1;ia;* safia in the accmzrztirzg ssysifim, wag gm
aiigzzabie C0z:tenti:T %§m’s*:):}sm§
STEEL I.Iffi’TEB ,_ST2§ §.$ “‘€kR¥SSA j’1970(.2s;
STC 211; am ibflQ vg%%dVV f§3£<1'MIf;;'§«.2'fIvf '~' ;~.m;aKE:'r1:~$<;;RE: z%§\'=£'}
{)'I'}§E§€1S..V_{§5;:E€ f:<:;a1A%k::{:;-%;ax ;j4%:;:;;.
” %ia§?ifig—-:*:;~:ia:niz1eci €316 ardarra 6}” {E35 fixsgessizzg
Ea? :é;is a3 the fippefiaite fiuihezfitifis, we are of
ti}? Eé0z2s§é:é.1j:=:’3d o§i:1§a:’:: :35: iiififfi is faiiure :0 Z’iitCGF:i§ 2;
<._fi1:di1':*g 31:3 is wfzether ifxe igzcairestraass sf the 1"€*:':1m1} as
V"-"_:;§.ai14:i'ed 31:}; £316 gsiitiener wag éufi ti; wag: af $9.335': an the
33511': mi' Eta €1:1§§.<:23,re€ and that thsre was :20 Ieasgnabié
V' $§{p§aZ{}£ii§€}IE ibrihcazning fmxn €316 assessea far gash
waiit of cam arm Eizsrefare? ii: {zsuid £35 iilferréii that. the
9
J
:*et.w:*z1:«; {fled is 2:1 deiiberate feaise §j<3t.fpii':1$,–wA.:" _'"I"}:1€e'
auéheriiies haasizig fajiéfi ta Ifilinid .,gé}
::oI1{.t3r:tion, it carmot but bf: $ai.{ié§;.?1gt= the :1-f';:§:«::": L.
15sSSf3SSiHgf Au€:i10§';i'€jjg finn6%ii1§f€4"A" ' féhév; opsiers
impugne-:i of 4. A;_;'f;e_§.1§3;'te_V__V._ "s'§,L1thori'§ies are
1H1sus'tainabie. in E136… C§j':311ii1$i;a:t§'t;:€S;V'-'i.jt2ia question (sf
iaw as raisfici p¢:5;iti&)_fi'is S'i§éz*t3'é accorciiiagiy.
9.» “”” =E.z§{‘1:hé’:31:i’%:s::£.§;;—Ehéixetizien is aiiowed. “}”‘E”2e
‘ ardar é ‘:«,:té3z:E’_ ;:Ef:Qi€}’;»;2f}(3_§’§’T’–. ,§Lg’nT1€X1.11’€–“‘:%f; Q?” me £’}@pu§;§;
(j:Qn1mi3sioI1:i3′ * V<2;i:"._ 7-;<'_;?:§:i1n1arciai 'i'a§ges.{'i'z*emsii§0r2~E},
{.11-I'<i::':V'i"':;"§a°'%";€d 28.1,2{}{'}6 Am1€:x::re~"5B" eff €316:
<":i1',§?1"'~{3€.;':it:;i::§iA&:.$ie;:::e:* Gf Ganzmerciai Targes, Mysore aria
Efié' §':'*{£e1f {;i§é?;§gr:<:fi 19. 1292888 af {E13 §{a.:cr1at3}§a Apggeéiaize
'<.«4._"'?:"é[b':zI:a?; 1-15:1 S'E2%,No,26{}/€36 are: 55% aside. The
"g:i':*c:<::::5€}i§:2g is re111;Zited :9 the Deputy' Samnaissiafifir sf
.C<}g_f;:m€:t:ia£ 'E'axesfE"ra.msitio1'1~i), Edfiffififé, far
~ .. '::<3§2sid¢1'3'i:ir1 aiifresh and :0 pass <§1*de:r==s £2": ms Eight if
the afczrresaié o§Gs$fva%ti0:1s arm {E16 ciec:i22rai:i::z'1 af' iaw by
M
the zapex Gouri, supra, aftar axtszriciizzg» .'}I'"§?i.@ii_'t.f":éi€
opportnsxiity Qfhfiarizig $0 the petitiener, V
12:}. “1””};”:€ GOVf3I’31.I17§1f3I’1’£ 3%dvi:%_éa€e ta_ 1*iE,;6,m§i1<:%j:.<nQf'
gzpgjearazzce w':ii:i"1i:"2 four W::+_¢5§{.s.
11. Misc. V3313-gfiiiczitjon is rejectad as
Eiiillfiifffi” $3 (