High Court Karnataka High Court

Smt Ningamma vs Smt Sundaramma on 2 November, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Smt Ningamma vs Smt Sundaramma on 2 November, 2010
Author: N.K.Patil And H.S.Kempanna


E
3% TEE EEIQEE fifiiifi? Q’?

al 5:: §§.:§%:.§;%£

msfaa ms mg 92% mix’ Q? zvw :3 mBa:p;2a&:k:: %y1! %

?RElS§Z§%’§

§–=E§I*§’§L§ gm ;;§m:;*;g §LfA%::5’§§;T::%’» %i T

fififi . % I
ma Hgrwmg gig, Ei.$:E%Z§;Ex§§2§§§9E’%§;”‘ k

:v§_§;a. §§§i§$2a%¢§§{;:é$%%:W

L gm: Ei’5fi%$.é.’:%§°2§&%

Efifffi
éafifi fiifiiifffif $3-K ‘- ‘

2. $E.’€E;s’Ti’=iE ” %
35$; EATE §*@%,%§a%§§§§2?z:g M %
»”‘L§§333 @3313? E3 ” .\

‘ 3: ?§,?$§fi*5;a’i:%’;%’1’§§ % r ”

E3553 §.,$.’§’E; 335% sgaay gawm
.. ¢§@;%3 asmim-. .

” ~ $5

A ‘ – , gag mrma £?.$}§.,}.3&E*¥

V % _ -» A??L Eéaé

Ef’%§%$;§’§§§7z~§{§ A?
23$ ‘*§§.¢L fififi

7._nanm§*_*f§,_a.fimA ma

VA A j§§;a$5;%2~; §:§§* m:’f:*

EFEER Tfi§L-EEK

AM

if

é’§§?§.;i§&”E°§

;””~.:%<:i%§:%;s},§a:;§.1:§**;;a%a;a§§%§§§§ gm 5:
fig

.V 2%, K:"?§§'§*5§g ;;';'§§§,:2*E§E§ mg:

'Z5

& §.3::$§§'E.a%'§*§§ .§;§';¥,}

QB'? SEQ S 2:5
335$ :

E5 $E&§§’.Z §E§’§§Es%£fi;.%3;§2§;%
§§f€} 3 $§§§;§$E.§
sifififi fifisifififi’
§¢&W§§;.@QE¥§.§
Afifififi K%?§.é.LE}’
A%¥u§s§£7ri?§ “i’2%f..{§”§”?Z
§§;%S AEQ’ fiifififif

26 fig fi $L fiégsgafizfia §$j1;§!’;:.._:_z’r-.;2. _,
Rfifik’ EEQGEAE E§}:2;f*€.,é;§§iR ” jé ”
E,ES§BE*~€::Y Ram -. –
&%.1?€fi¢%$RE.—_ 5&9 :”;zL$w– _ ‘

{BY 3%; ; ii §:%+»;;a$g;a:;~:@:–;% Am? I:’§.’~–:;g2?,« A
g: « “§%’@’§’*ECE; E¥Z$}?§;E%”§S a§.%1a*:?m%§f§;:§E%§gé;%;f$§ 321 mm}

mg ;*~..§a ES? 1é%;*:§£s€;::;§§;:: as :1; $3 fiséif? &.§A§~§$T
Tim §£?§?fi9Ea%§;1’%”f §:2*iéTI}«. §.’:a%’§%; 2$,2,2§£;a 34.33% as:
zwcxag 5§§$€§$i§3 :3; mg 9? m m gmggzygga &
% _¢:::z:r§:.*§” 9? $2253.33; sgmgs, m2~€<3&§ag
?§"§"I'F§§1'€ Fax
§?

{:}§€ §’$R G§;§E% “€313 fifisyg
‘E’ $2

SS

L

5′

Téwmgh thfm a.§§m.§: fa pesstafi far aztiamg

%m§::t 63$’?

taimi my ffir éispegai

figzgmfii Em Emil”: géésa, _

E. ‘?l’2§;=s aywi azisssfi fsiii éxéff

azzfi awmfi datfi ” L’

i’§a.§:§8g’§€§f}2 ax; {E23 mg $f’€§E:§:;V::§z§;’EEE’–gfi1;.§5;i§;§3*&§:3,§ .=..v.§:%.}£§ge &
Eéemémzg §%§fi$”‘;i’, §:§1,:§?%;’%’_§i3§’ fiaxgaisrs

Ssmw :3? % wgbmwg? far

.é::$ impzigzzfiti juégmant and

awmfi wig”: imisezwt at

, &_ ffffiifi $§ gttfiiififl iii} {E35 éaig af’ fiagsifa

file fiaaflz cf 32%, $wam* élféawéaa

sgsimizxm fif £’€%£;§§fi§§$,”€§$f: awaréfii fiy

imwmfig E333 af lava

afiasfiazzg has sf

tafigmfis fiajmwfiafiafi mm Eésmarai

AM

1%

§$&fi§ fig §i§ ?$ fééi yséiatsé. ts §;r3sag:;’:. §:i?g§$

agwaé far

3; Ezief £333 aftha cage 4 A ‘

fipwlimzt }%a,’}1, 2 afizéfi

am}. mxé. mmr éazzghfteg ‘V

a§§m1§ar’;.i3 miztsaziégd .’§’I%”5.gi: W33
agaé awiza $3 § a wk AV £1 %*
awcatisrx, aafiaég» Hg was tha

gm}?

§V.é;3**:§ ‘§;}I’vf3é;2’3a;f:;’§sa§:’«§2.2;§p$:*’£: gm ‘aha
ma zéigggazeames am famiiy is
{gum am &If’ gag mg Eagle mg

Ezzmitlfizggi .,:ava:izga.¢;§¢%§§m:. 53:: a famiui 22.3% an

A”2’3.*i§~€¥’§:.$§.:3*i?2 gm”; WEEER the éwasaég wag

° § ififiw 15% E3 33 mwméfi

fir; maiaégéf E §Z1§fi3§%

Qf ‘€§’3$ gaiéi “ismw érfiw

in E:i2:g§3: agafi agfii in rag}: mifi zgfilélgant

if _’__w_W__W_,,..»-u»
I
4

§§1@fl ‘aim

Cfifififii fif iiifi fififi fiafiiifi

L axmagfi 21:3. awn: fig? aim gag? u

.5531: t’r§_a£§$i:it2 _ ‘

e £3 a Yfilfii af which {Em §.:.;.*’.*§};€§’i;;§:§..,;z”;g;§;_u

mmmiziwfi sufiiairxad grigmzza %n§z§2*i3¢:s$ Afiamaiséfi L’

sumumfiefi is tfia gag Eue
ta iha mid ffisfifi and wart:
mxmwaézmd fig $. Eéfi af
Is€S’v’,§§s*: agaizmfc ‘aim

rmwzfiez1’$,, géfifigsm fiififi ‘$3′ the

:_!’:i ‘– ‘c:a;$;:;i?ff-~ V fa:%§~ ‘€,’%:§.%£:£ar&§§:§ fiezfam 223$

*:’2»;%mm; fig in turn? my gamma af aim

. A_am§: eviéenm $3} the 4 afimfi fix

{;§V§.v3″}’*gV $2′?

” 3. sum €3§ §3.2,§§},%iE!-=

mitééf kg. 63 witéi mm’ rwi at 3% ya. 3%

‘SE18 mmgwmaiémsé mwarzéig E33 3%’ Eggs

A Efim af aafata mxi mwmfia wagfigfiriafinfl

AL

I’
a

é
mifi filiififfii z::g§;@§:g&&§ fig 3§$:§;m&:2″£i§ Eaaéffi this

far mézammmfifii,

é». ‘fia Exam Zimrd E113 V

agfiémzés ami this: Eaarfifii {i€:§é3,::s*s%é:E” ‘§E:°:§&’~.

r~mm§$£:”;t~§z°:a:.;§*az1a$

3 $353’ &*:a%i;z&fiV;é:iVV:§f §E:$”~ azafél ané

mmmi
afiiiaiaég am arsé. awagii,
we fig mii” ‘$23′ 31:”: awafig’
R$§?§;§~..§ —.§.fi€::é :3?’ fiagzegfzéanagg mai

Rm£§€§§%§*%* ,: éf mnasrfium mzé the saw

, A’ 6.5 §*»2;*i.f:

. V V g taw

Lk R$.§;i:§?K’§§~.”‘.V Ezaaararég ,

3 _ ;a aim ‘§’§i’?m,z:m§ km mm fig amming
has fif 333:5 mg

‘_ «§§:;g*§: sf

2*’

fifi anfi §3§§§Qi’f§§«~ isgmrfis Ema 23$’ agéais whish

are an the Eva? aifie

‘?,, Takiw zinin mmifierafinn

aawsfig fiffi fimfié it fit ta awazfifi

3,353 sf’ imag 323$ afikfitimmé

an-é itmmgiaftatisii fiipemfi 1:333
af § is mmt fizfi _ A H

89 Far £321: :°’§§,a%§:§é$_ immz: apmal
am by gm 1&;§¢ggg«;«3i :1 3&5 jufigxnent
am éwaré k J(\§$}$£%2.:s:3a3a% pm a in MW

§*i*m.§};§&;’i3;{.7§@3i2v.a§: tim xx Aééiitémzai guage ag

Sauaaag

mafiifiéé. ‘fig Egrsmk zip is as

Tawmfis Esag Qf R$.i?;;§;;»43,QGGf ~

‘ ?§war§3 has a? fifiitfiifi

fmarmfis has ea?’ Ema anfi Eaa

§

§

E

&§E”m§§fi2′:;, . §
§

‘§’ewar;is: ‘

“zit = 7&&g mg; fisxmal

U1

3
§
3
!

mil i%%$w%»%§sfiW~ i

fix $.?§&§i;%;fl§’S$}’; fér a Esta}

aa aganm” t

Rs.2§;%§;§}{§K}3§~ “:::g ‘§”:+:§§urm3L ‘i’ha .

Em :fiag3;.§§§{%§ =~ wifitl imisrmt at 6%:

‘V g3;.:s;,_.»,”‘ fr:§r%;f§n éaifl 52%’ arséaim §%’t;i”E3}3f3 $33 rim fiatg «:3?

u_ ‘ V V

aémpfingazéwfi amfliifit fizitikiiz % i§?$§§{S fmm

/WM/»

(

3%, mmag « %

§
thé fiagis $2?’ mmipi fif ‘£33.13 mp}? Qf ihffi ;§:.::&g$m&z§?:'”–5;:g@.

awaré ,

-. mm§::aa§1&§i§5_zj;…,a£ §a_-.3; ‘” 2

irztarwt aimii has migafifi in ~:::%f fix:-‘~ _FR.§”:i’::St,”y’E3g§ :2′ *1:

§§:’3¢E.:,
rwpmfiszfit Emuyazmas j€:;$m§>g2,§%§§,§{

i Era dyaw EEE §fic§%’*

Sdla’ *

5315?; ”

$23, #33?’ = L’