Cicilia Kutino vs The State Of Karnataka on 9 June, 2008

KALEEE. PQST’

?£1AN§;5’xLC?RE ‘§’A§;}..fiK.

*-153; susagam P€.’>{)JA§¥Ei V’
0:9 aaaasgawa masaaa 4? YEARS
ma GURBKUMERR Hauisa.

MENMABEWU vezmsa’ 2
KALEEL 9:123″: * *
M.fi.N<35%LQRE TALLEK

4:;<:.'; £?€303A§3QQ3;%k§€–%.' _ H '
3:51: a4Ar¢;Am:éA P::»r;:.;m:;–.45?~r§:aRs' _ –
Em m,:R:.;.¢~<::::r1E.%'<*;a;,.:e~:;z3L;%s'_&f__A " .
!x§ENNA;8ET"€U_.?;'§vi,LAGE . — _
z.%2E”T!”s5\Li.;ii*-Ti; ”

35¢ §!*:2′?’:.%,i’*=i.:”%:.5_aPP:1′.,PtS;:r:)’;.;€§§Ré, _35<~'{E£;RS
REQ (3U§?,!_..i§<{}§v!E£'1A lr-'%<:1i;.?$E-._ '
z2s§:x:e4AaET?:i.v:LLAQE.'. '
!<éj«E.£E£.P{:1S"F_
?g:1§%!a§G§LGQE "r'g2_.;;;<

RES;53Q{'3C3E§iTSi

'S:éT:§'~éAif}i€%_f§.V:;'§§;§§1§A§§'AN£¥APPA, HQG? FQR R? & 2;

$Ri'\§13;"%.3%§'$HE?'é'fi;;3'§i{ ¥?;§§;,".AQVO%CA'§E FQR R3? Ref» {$52-$33}

'i'*9r*

?§r-HE WEE? PETET!QN €53 .'r7§LEQ UNSER RRTECLES 221$ RND 22? Q?

_. , H 3?' .Cf}¥*£ST§"§%ff"%t§.?~4 <3? EMDEA §'3FEfiJ':'iNG TC} QUASH "WE QRDER 'Z}T'2f3–5–

2.§3%’33f VQQRRESTEQM DT2§§–6i»2C¥§3 PASSES S?’ ‘¥’§-{E LANE} TR§8L£N.é%.,

V’ ftJ!i3{jJii%B_§iD%R%, f’s§R.?hé<3&LQR.E mg AN?~£.fi.

T?-92$ W§3¥T ?3'E?§T€{}§\§ SQMWG CM FGR. HEN-?Eé~£G_, T?-{SS 39:?!' THE

% f me.._L.:..:::"'§'* mag THE m;:..@ws,%4G:

'§°'E–:';?:§ %"%I:$£i :;R.T (E? }:.AR§:;%?A}:,sa 5:’? %;é%z~xz:3;:1,:2a§: ‘–A§.P”E€a,3{}l §s:::§a3

mg 32:33 :”iI’€3URT 0%’ £€AFJ;\ia§Té..KA 31′ B;’~.?:~Ej:}_£§,<}RE :&'.p,az:3a1;5,f2.§e3
AAAA N' 2

0R§ER

Peiitécnera being aggrieved by '(ha or'::iei'Vr':;,i:é*EeVe:*:éT:§V2'3."{§j";"5*–'% A "

May 2353 hearing Ne.LRT:41 i8″§’~82A kk

Mennabafizu} an the féée ef the Lead

Mangeéare, vide Armexure A, §1ae–~;s§’~p§e§:er:%$t§~.;-:’§*:&u §1;%§§é%%€
wit pazéféoa. V’ V’ A V

2. st 53 mt es di$§z§:*_€:fe :”§%}$.¥{_’V” 3 arzé 4
herein had easfiiéé;. f§V§e§–.A’:fi{r§.’i: §§é;:;¢:x; %§m3%3zgsmgs
befere ihés fauna cs’? iéiigazées
assaéfirsg .k:>r*ée:” éatefi 8% Fvfiarth

‘$984.53; En as far as it reéates is

géaim fig?’éeéétéaraéfaésézerein {respendenis 3 and 4 herein}

¥T3’%’*f;§SF4VA.§:’.T%f’Efi 24??’ Fnfiarfih ‘%9§2. The said wrét

V §e?:é=;§r.3;*’:–.%?’:a5d’ é{>;*é7z..>§Vup far cansécierstéem be-fare éhia Caufl:

_ 2:3 3:?’ and’ thée iieuri after hearéfig fiafh sides

_gé§;€z*.§e? §”~«§:%’2e writ géééééen and sat as-Ede flea aways gagged’

fife Land Tribunaf, ?v%e9dabidfr’%§ fsfiangaéere dated 85″

*»»..:?é;”§arah mag and 24%” fiéarch ‘%§§2 with a éérectéore in the

cn………_….._……._…,…_….,

mz Eééififi ~;::3.;:a:.,e:;2,;«: 22;.;>%:a:a;.:;:::;’:T;é.=’2§:23

‘”§’HEi E§£§}’§%% QQEERT €35’ K.i&R,:’*~L%?A§<l.f% BC? E
__M,,,,,,,,,Mm.__W_\_¢__Wm", __, /W..__4.M,.,M.__€M,,V___.A, , M

petétéanem feit neceasétataé fa present 33% §ns1:a::2 .–'grit

p&"£§'£§{"}€'2_

3' % has heard kamad saunseé g§§'é.{$ri§g

setétészéners ané Eearnaé azzmzéései

respsnéents.

4. After casefzéi g&rzsaa§'”~c:Vf’ ?’.§¥8 Sérégiifiéé régccgds
mafia avaééaézie $3: ‘A.§aégrné%d ,G;1~&._a”€~:%*%’;~:x}er2’£ Pieaéer
apgearéng far s”es;2_a:”2é§r;:%:::–. Ef-antfi =2, “§.é*z_s.:£:£§¢%’§r§g tha sréer

passad by §_3a;r’:-éd §§fJh$~é ij&’efa§a§§9Q:ie$ is that, the

Tyibunai has 3g:. 3’§*:z’V«::.:3_eg2″:r:§’§tz§;é{§gggfafiéa ersar and ifiegaiity

in gssaéadéngg’ 33:: l?,:s:~§’§2.${‘i”§§é”–i;f%é’;*:sz;;gT:*;ed ewe? wéthaut aim?

camgiéense Bf ibfi ?&£a?::3lnf-?’;:smv%s§a:2§ sf ‘rhe E-<am%t32<a

__.-;L"and 1¢:§c"§"a,n:iR::§es. when ma parég ms

E3;-£<g?é"a:$;;é{:%f%:;f"§rm,znd befsre flee '§';'§;'"2;.;ne§§ it is ézgty

.. czasf::?§"fhe ?"%§h2;éha§ 29 mg mm {Sag same arzd cenaédar

staid _'€.'s2£<e:*e by bath peéétisrzars am resmnéents 3

.a'ei%7af" .é{ ';3r2§ after ce"§t§ca:2¥ evaéuaéésn at' the r.:23§er§a£

…_:駧* g'§_$éb§e an regard: ihe Trébasna§ mzght is haw given the

,)k

' ' a;9::«pe153fr*'%~:§g , [

£35 335 Eiifééi €"f'€f§§_??f§ {Z}? §<Z:"&§x'.§'€:§?§&:€A A"? §5g§g§'=§}3'z51L{}_RE 'L.3iP(E.'~Ecx3§£ £§{2j§_{L_?_§
{S

gaaaanéng and firzééng am decided ma matter in faéi

e:3mp§%az"2¢a af Rage 'E7 5? the Lané Qeferms R:_22es.. '~ .E«:§:~V._

in the instant cassa, 9% 33% exarsége has mt bégézn _d:{3:*ié*; '

Exam? nazraténg $23 enégére §'$%$?Z£;f}?~–.G;f Etifée

iarzd Eébunai has mi assigned an3i"§::ég,e:;*':€ ;'é+;:=';.$s:ss. §é%;%:é'~.. V'

pmceedea? ta reject Ehe $€as2§'i§<';;~2:*a by'—-;3_s5e§:§€%%:=§2é':;$.VV in
fag, ting Lend "¥';*éé;:22.;r*sa;§"'~g¥_1 as ."§§e¢i§E::駧y récééfiéd zéze
giand 'taken fig getitéanera ordaaz at

§§"%'§i§%"?"£8§ §ag$.fi.;: Saki, =:u':éfQf:a;%rVa:%1&§;:§ were is :33
cengfieratéasi Q? sé'§::t§ .a55é:;§&%:%":€ef';§§2y findéng 37$ given
is aha a_:sa§d_A §';_'–;e§§é'""z4s:*, zgfand. faker: by peiézéanera

Therefsra, 3;.3L%;éev;!sr3f.:'*:a§€"'—-§éE:dus€ sf pmper engum; in

strict Vpgszikgiiancé Rgxgie '2? cf the Rages read 2«v§€:;*2

:"'~.S§%¢%é:3 k:} 3§. As3f–:§?:a%\_?<arn3€a§<a ienfi Ravenae Act am far

:'e:3'é'1~.é':.."–2zf:"s§i§'2'$f%?*;_<';r*:.&"T.:::§2"v the déreaiésrg éssagad by this Cam? :8

flag ea?§'§e:""s':.;Léré§ sf fitégatéeny the impugned awe: passed

é:é§;e'VV¥_xa%§d..ATr§bu::aE cams: ha sus!:a§§'*:§::§_

éfssé "£35 :–:§é:2«;§ <::<;:A:;:? 52;: ;<:;a%:2é«-:m.:s;2'*..«a.,;';'q.:~§. 9;: }?§,»'Q*»E€Ci_~'éE.)£}§«¥:'£ 3 , .

33%' '%''§"{%?: £E§i3E§ {"ZQLl'RT {Q}? KAEQQ AT 2;Es1.Li.3RE '.§§j\EQ.3C¥§ §f?¥.f'2€§§§§

_e'

§_ Having regard €23 the facis and gézaumstsngasg

af éhe ease; 33 gated ebave, the WEE? pe%§'t%{3§':

gatitioners és éispased 3?' as fciéawaz

:1; Ike ms gassssss fiiedgbjx p¢:;gme%y3     %

affsiaxee' in para';

£5′ The i:23i¢;:gngv§?V…4.;§;%:¥;s:g2a;$séa§….i»*é3:-g
gecsncf :*es,aer:dV.«s$’é?€ ‘ – *4 L. , ifiéfifiai,
Maedaéifiéi . ‘V flééggafere
asses’ 25?’? ‘§£_0 {G§.§§$’e:*f?%*};§::’§’$g?o..–£.R?’ X if 1/5 :22
SE” Armexazra A,
is ” .

«. !€2j “‘ . :§£a?ferA”‘-s:f;é %:ds remiffac’ éack is

&V;c’3:§g:ai:?;’;? zissfgéfé-55%;? ~ Land 2”;éba;ne!,

V,2.’t§f.’*§’a5c;5a::.’:_§¥”§’.V.§3{_:4:;’ff;i;V:-.§?ar:ga!s:e ?”a!£;£<, Maizgaiare far
A.**33.cez;':s:a{%§?éf§a:; G? {be mafia; afresh 3:25' is

A. 533% a2;s¢m,ar;'a%g éeaisgaa £3'; ascardasfsm yarfitéz

53% 8!?§ fa fake apprsgsiste d&£iS§6?} is":

'T asaerdagce vaifé fay; 1!; sampfiianee af fége
fiv-w—————-m—

TEE {fa}: £3? 5:? £.’E”::,.A:§§”;’;%7″é;,r’:;Z;’E”-.=’£’§s<_§;:5_-';§§ AF' 'éZéf%£:3;a;,aaE