High Court Karnataka High Court

M/S. Sobha Developers Ltd vs Mr N Swaroop Kumar on 3 February, 2010

Karnataka High Court
M/S. Sobha Developers Ltd vs Mr N Swaroop Kumar on 3 February, 2010
Author: Ajit J Gunjal
  WWW" W mmmmm mam" «whim W mmmmm W£";'%§'**% a;:wW_'¥" W mmmmm §«§;::m @;*a:';~esui.%:m*

" ;~.;:e,  '

  -%%%:3%i2 mssza 

-1.

31 ETE Z"§GH CGURT' Q? §{fiRE'¥fi'E'AKfi. KI' BAHGAIQRE

mmn ms Tim. 3222 my 35* FEBREJRRY 2m§%:%«fj._k

BEFQRE

aim HGEPELE z~m....3z.:s*z*;<::E gm; ¢sé;r:;3:aLk%LL[  %  

 

BE"E'WEEK;

Mia Sobha Bawiaxs Ltd.,   

A fiilampany irmrpam:be.d%*x;nd£:r  :4 V' 
F':mv?siana cf the Cc:mpa22:¥T3:5Afi;:::t;.» AA " 
Havirg their rwfistmefi cfi"1m_a€'Lf' 1 . ..  '
E»-133$, Sumtzshe C.'§m,mb&;'3%;" *  " 
K332? {Ihacr   =:  " '
Bfialare ---~  'V '
Repm&z1t;ed:vby.§_¥t;s_,  » é 

   

{By IvEi3:vV'§;§%§i2sV?:eE mv,,;

$33: 1. -- --.

    ..... 

VSM. Latin: %£’$«vR’arayarm Rfidyg
332?: ‘max; 339$,
fiéjawiii ?.£a” hi ‘?’am§¥s§

}:%~— 5% i

Hihyaé

; Suaimia H. Raéfiy
_§i§ Leia €.. Earayam Reééy,

Einghmia Earayassm Eiiaya;
fidjamrit ta Isimaighi ‘E”e;m§i¢§

-= 5% 37$

-Y>§7″”MI:’¢mW% nmmmvaee %mt’%m’F”&.-E9’$’i’fi«i! ‘Iw’ez S’T\~u:a”‘<'e€{f'k§°'%ii-a?"'£<ai§£'"*M5'%e..11"'% z€"M*W§&"'"& MWMWK

<2 –w '<MW'vu!a§Vl wma

.2.

3. kin fit Sfmahmzk Kumm
S; 3 mtg, C, iéarayana Rafidy,
Sushmia. fiaraymm Eilaya,
§3i?= §{.!¥§. Eaibatta ;

afljaeamt to Maenaimhi Temfike,

m~ 3&6’§’5.

4*. Mr. C. Mani Raddy
Sig Mr. Cmmpw,
firaimre ‘filmy, T.

12% I<:.:.eL -rm R:.:;aaz–.,L_' V. . * _
B%1m*& -I 5% 0'?'6$ .;;R,@;,-éaszxdagxxim.

"E31513 SM? 13 £5) ef the
Arbiwafian ané Comiliatfitan f_Arf:'£, praying so
apwint arbiwatfir' tn az=fiji16;§::gat¢eA«.§:E-1,: tifiggutc tiiiat. haw
war: afimen a m§;_..i;he rwpaszzdexzmg
ms: af pafitiégh af'§:.-{stigma anfi muityw

%£t1s§£%%V%%%a$:;a.::gC¢:§'f¢r%agmss;gx; thia aay, the
Smart mads _ *

gggtigije-$:;«AA%%§Ta.« umm Sectlxen 1: 1 {5} {sf the

fiiangfiimatéan fir;:¥;§ 3i.§%. Tm

mmaé £2123 9; Ziéamsrmwfium Q3'

am imam im mm: 35 the szzfajawt

' Gf fig gaifi hiamamnézlm $f {.§z*1&se:ramnai ingg fix

' af {Em 533$ Euiemcsrmzéum af Undemmfiir§$

_ ."'mth 2&6 gmiitlissifi' as wen as the mpmmgms have

2'
* .

W, “”‘””””‘””‘”””‘”””‘”””‘””””* ‘*””W’°”” WWW” ‘W WMm-ewmmmwws wamm mwum wag’ mmmfiatmmw zmm €;:a;mm” fi%%3″* E*~%%@§%’ fiéfifififié?’

m the magmtsémam
éisgzzta

.3.

mt&& izzts an 8§ t ta sell afléi a mm of R&

3,QQ§fiQg£3$£§!–~ was wxid ta rwpxxnéenm anfi the

ac§a’%iedg@ £21 £313 t be 3811, It is ”
the §e§t:2ez:¢r tam: bath arm as
iizxdemtandirg as W522 as tints iv

arhifiai aiaufia, ifzwmuah a,=s,__ & T§*.ié.a;.. V

hemrs. the Eflhw, the Same
is an arhiaal ‘rr§h:;x§a:. thz
rmwrxdmfi rw_;,1_mmd .._ pay Rs.
2,25,m,am;-5% petiuzmm on
:3.2.2ma¢;%,§,§ a mind gr tirnse;
‘E6 the rsapenéenta.

831335′ 31% mma farxaxfi m macaw

. ~ »;§._’mc:ea: ‘§ 13_._Afi: -‘

af ifnéemmzfiizgg the

pmefifi L’ am Arbimi aiausa am Ems

awn tifzem m

by an a,f§3§Zfi’ai$r.2 Em

j2~&§¢nfi¢nts haw rcpiimé is 32¢ sa 1%’ tzatim aeimttizg

4-saviwtwuwv «lulu ~2z wmwu uswusmmrce ‘a>9″”ulVQrtl£”m. w :2. »m-nmn-.wrrm;a-

tire exwufiazx cf thza Masmrmfium sf EI:3£ie:”stax1sc17m as

wail as

mnmzé that they are wiiifi m refxfi _

which was rmaiawad by mam.

g, it is mama that am

wag issuaa to the rafipcndanaé

3. fizwé §m:;rm9;Z”f3r::’§T.’§’x9 Qafubmim that

a fiimpiztn hgs. and i113

1; ‘ts sefl, 3ms, they

wH….». ¢._..«.m-..»»_»«.».m«-.wm»…m..m,’.uy .a-_u.._…..u._»_… I\«wyq.=4a»MgwDm w

‘U’.”O£WvuoMcqwn«w ‘mean

wafi ax Ehg

zfiaspanxcierzm in ;wa§e;:’!:,.x::f_ af
Haas;-am-misg 3.3 eggs: sag Aggy; Ha farm
aubmim féimt aa an §§p§?3cati£1*: wag
mm zaif gag Am: hefarm am

fiity Qisrii ware afipted mini

afi §;£éa§;fV.’éf Eaisfi figfiatirg :2

{

fim ifimfirmiéum af

‘£9 $53}. Enéaafig

af Efnéwsmrfiixag as W833 as tkwé

“/?/

Ws<n'0M."WP|W4.§H "€m¢f't11' mmwmm k'E"NW'5%""'f£ Wmm W mmmmm wmkw a,.;:a;sw:"a" wax-mmagwm mm mm'?

.5.

ts 8&3} wx9*$agm an farbitral sgaum,

ixzasmrtmh as, if them 5m a éiapum batman time
firxe saw ia xwwaé’ in be r%n1v& by an .
Hauszg mam is an fact am: it a g&¢a&%1kAg:rk§ta1¢ {

claim’ § an arhitratcr ?n rmu2red’ i:

rwcshae the ciisputs ketweazn . _ AA
sg ammesalmw
P83213593: is fig; Formal”
Judga, K§g_:§ataiv¢sL;:.’v_”$;R:E:E :-iamiavpzv,
Kn. 534; Qoopezrafive

‘.

56% $635 $.53? firfiiramr ts raefiaiue the

“§,ifipu§§’«:.b§f§Wwfl ‘Firm Saie firfiifiam am:

gnaw’ cmzse xwblw as {ha

ercia? ta firm Saie

Sd/-

JUDGE

A §§.:1S~w’~