High Court Karnataka High Court

M/S Oriental Insurance Company … vs P Vatsalamma W/O Pratap Simha P R on 4 December, 2008

Karnataka High Court
M/S Oriental Insurance Company … vs P Vatsalamma W/O Pratap Simha P R on 4 December, 2008
Author: Huluvadi G.Ramesh
IN THE IHGH c()UR'r or' 1<A1aNA'rA1i§%(;,kR;a3§ia§sH 

MISC1§LLANE()US  APPEAE, V:§¢);k?999;'0$ Cm? %
916ifl2_T('_§[i§j   ;

M.1r.A.:~e0.7999/es:a %'[%*   

 V  - if

MES. Ofiéntfii §fiSi1LraricV§;--Ci3n1'pai's--y Ltd,
Divi$iena.1 €3fiiE§e E-3'g)';'3V0'_,  " H A
No.213u2%k1i':, II"§*?'fi:;nt;~».,;"

4'h'.Cr0ss, .Ch72a.'3j*;1;2;r;2j;§t:1; '  --. ' '
Bafigfiicrm-1'3; "    

New £ep;e3entefi E:~y"R§g§0n&E Gfiies
I'{i'a.44--45,  "

_  £.,eQ__LShg_3p;3ing amrinplex,
A  'NGIEAS, _R3sédency Raad Crozas,
j "B_a::ga§§"m{--2--S.
._   _Re7§§ré's.t::2"§3}f its
'  23;d¥:?iIiiS«§;.r£iti%se Ofihzer, ...APPEL},ANT

(E$}gf__5§r§.A.M.Ve::katesh, SriB,C.Shi¥az;:2e GI(}W'Ci3

' AA ._and Sri.Krishna.'N., Adva}

»' 

L P.Vats~;a}amma,
W513 Prazap Simha.P.R.,
Agsd abeut 55 years,
C50 Geethalasmaé,
#5"

 



§«i;FZA.?§G,.V916}'07§ ' 
  .. ..... ..
._ _at§§a§ém3:3a,
'  \?v5fov_!ate----.E'ratap Simha.P-R,,

éékkgad ab£;1ut 55 years,

 A' 'TL-No.98? 63' Cross,
*  Ex-Eiie: Coiony.

fa.)

No.98, 6&1 Cross,
Mflk Coiofiy,
Malleshwaram West;
Bangalore-560855.

2. Sri.Jaichandra,  

S50 Laxminareddi, 

Majcr, N0.256M

Bereweil Road,

While Field,     
Bangaiore. _   8

(By S1nt.M.R.Vanaja_,'  ' ibf' R---  -_  »   -.
V H   _*§==i='  jw .. =
'§'h_:£.§_ Mf?.A..,i's fined under Séiitian £73m of MV Act
agajnst€'the_.judlg'ri1ent'":é;mi"a32é;3réi~,,dated 31.3.05 passed ii} MVC
No.69"72?£}i"d':%:,vthe .fi'§:*,_ '0f":h__§ Juséige, Court" cf Sana}! Causes. &
Miémbénw '*B ':;i31ga}<:Vr'17f: (SCCH Nag), awarding
compensati<in'ff'%RS';A2g3'6.GG0f~ with interesi at 6% pa. and
direcfing the aVp}"xéi§aiitA_fier=éin 1:0 deposit the same.

Cit) Geezthaiasini,

Maiieshwaram,
Bangai0H::~--56{}Ci55 . ...AP?I*:I.LANT

(By Stni.MR.Vanaja, Adm)
0473'

 



   Tiiis ~M.F.A, is flied uncier Scciiim 173(2) cf MV Act

"  'V'againsi'%'1}1c'"_j;udgmenI and award dated 31.3.05 passed in MVC

'- A '  on the file ofthe Eudge, Meinbct. MACT, Court of

 Sma~}}_ j€a1zse3, Bangaleare (_SC(2§§ N09), paniy aliowing the

. ' tgléim Vpetitian for compensatiran and seeking etzhancemant of
 n T campcnsafion.

deiivered {ha f:::§luwing:~--=

AW):

1.

Orientai Insurazacc Company Ltd.,
Divisienal Office N010?

530,213-«ZE7, If Finer,
4″‘ Crass, Chamarajpet, V
Bangaiorc-18? A

New represented by Regional ‘Qffi–<.:e
N946}-45, ' . V V

Lee. Shopping <:omp1e:s;_, V' _
No.25, Residenayf R0aé"t3r<§ss, V' "~ __
Bangaiore-25. V V .'
Repreaented bjvits ' ' 9'
Administfative Qfik:-<%;r. _ ' '

2.
ssh La.§§7s§1fi1é;3: Rfed;c1y;

Baréwgél _R’esad,– . é ‘ ‘ . _
W:-me Fielfci-,, ‘ L
‘B.angaI¢ra.’ A % …RESP()NDENTS

=i=**

Them M.F.AS. coming on for hearing ‘this day’, the Ccuurt

€459/,,

JLEDGMENVI’

These two appeals are filed, one by_ff?1a”~’ar1d

another by the ciaimant respectively, being

award passed by the }\fIAC”:f__ a:f1dA.. 4-:

Baizgalerc, in MVC .c}r:14.§-}§9AwV.i;1ateVVd 3i.;%Ji’!L5,

qucstianing tbs qzsamum 0f c4fu§1′;zcnsatiofi a*.v3§d§fl.

fi§x’:t§_a1:{‘of”R§:2,_36fi}§5k’L**’c§ith 6% interest has been
awar;§efi*w..E;j_§? ‘the death of €116 hzisband of
tI*1:;”V::__A’c;le”:i3z’:iéV,V1i’1’*’£v.+;’>’r.,1:c*~:’I§faf}iap’S’in3ha in the road tiraffisiz accident

czccurfegi {:13 13.30 pm. The cziaimant is present

ifhe .¢”c$¢;:ri_, ____ It £3 Statcé by the Caunse-1 appearing fax” the

‘ –v¥1}s1;fi%r:v”*:§§;”3.t–_ an amount czf Rs;.i_,18,000f- with pmporticmatc

£Vi1’te”:;jé;Sv{ ii):§f3 already bee}; paid to the ciaimant and that afier

négbiiafioya, a Ioint memo has been fiicd by the parties tats the

V’ v jféffeet that the Insaramzc Cempany undertakes is pay” anethcr

Rs.}.,2:3,00{}f’- inchzsive fef interest ever and abmzc what has

already been paid is the ciaimant, in fufi and final siettiemezzt of

‘£?.§_i$}3u*E¢?sa1;iar;3.teijy’.

the ciaim made in the case, for xarhich the ciainxant as weéi as Em:

Cminsei fer the Insurer have signed.

3. In View of the min: Mem{*;t2;eé7 b;§:1:T%~t§;¢k’a;§pea%:s
£fi$p(‘3S6d cf. An amount cf Eva:VA.{§i:p{>§if§d_.T¥Sxéii>re 3
this Ccmrt by the Insurm1cé”C6;zzpa2§y’ —x§2i’ih§1_”‘1_: _§§%V;H{vi$’$¢k3 fzfinz

away and ‘the c:11tiz*é: ¥§é’~disbufSéd “in the céaimatnt

by the Ragigtfi, is mated fix! the
ciaémant fiééi ‘a£ready beefl paid to the
e011cc;f3§é settle their

Sd/-E
Iudgg