High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri A A Gupta S/O Atmaramaiah Setty vs Sri Maqbool Ahmed S/O Not Known To … on 21 October, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Sri A A Gupta S/O Atmaramaiah Setty vs Sri Maqbool Ahmed S/O Not Known To … on 21 October, 2010
Author: Ravi Malimath


E
3% ‘E’%é§ %~%E§%-E §@§§§;’§”‘ Q? é§fi:;§§é§:?A§& §&§é§fia§§%§E
§§’§E§ ‘§”‘§w5§$ E”?-£5 223? ages? gg §{:%”§§E§; 2%

%E%§E

“§”%% %%§?§§§§«w§ %%Z§fi. éazgéfiaé ;§A2;§ %aa&;E??é§%7%”V§%éA%M£.jf* T

&%E”§’?%§E§-§%:

§%”‘§, ;%.&.9§a:§§§§ fifi yeésrgg
Egg §,2%’§%§ ramaéaég §a%%%;; _
§’%é§a§; 3″? %’§%§§2 Ewzig ‘ -_ 3. ,
%.iy§E§’%s:§%g§§f §§§’§§§§$?°% M33; h V .

” ‘V ;§§%e§»;%E§fl:.a%§”§’;

gay §§”%V§£%E%’?§§§fi§”§’§;.,§a;»g :é%:;§_%%é3£§§:§ 5% §gam:%§,§a2§:a,
&§%é%;”I”2C§§E5::* ” % I

§@:::%k ‘I

– . fig:.”§’?€§§%:;i%:;<§§";%§§§?*§%§Vg' """ '
' L–:.'?r,§:;s. §*:@*;.'§é;:*.gw«f;¥:s~ é;:;: fiéafe figgfié-§%::§;.i

'-'§§?2§§§:;:~;%§s wég.

?~é$§3§§§ ‘E*”?%w%Iae§;§§*’:f firaggg
§§§;:ji$ §:gz§;$§§*:–§% ;?=%§§3§§{§§
%»%.§¢§*§%€ga;g $§§*2*%:%r’%a§:%§?%§%§%§

“,,,§’§§$§§%*§§§§%§?

— §é*§z§a$§a¥&§’%§:; %§§§’%?”§E%§§§$§ §’%2§%s§$§:$ ~ é3é5@§§§}

ffifé fig-é mésg” $$€’;T§§§§’% §§ af Qééséi mwéazyg §§{.%$
agaégzéi 35$ ggégmgai ma? fiéirgg saw :§.§,E$§§ gaggaé
5:: Ssfigféaééégfifgé 52% am fig gf izégg ESEEEE figfiéé iii?

FM?

Qsiazé Jssgégag Efirggfiésara, §§§§?%é~§§§§*’§§ me $23: $3? §$E”§§§§i..:?a§§

iajgééatémfi,

“‘§”§2§§ aggaai is :£:§%;::§e:*2§ $52 5%?” %§g§§”€§:§ §§”i§$ §a%*f{ “i?2§

é:§a::”: figiégemé iifié §§§§iT3?é§¥’¥;’§Z »

[

§§§§§”§§;%;é§ fig Eifig §a§:§;§?:%&é§:<._a§';3_$i; §é;;g%é$e%~ '~

:§'§a;=;§a§ mm $1: Qa£§.%%§<.a§%3€;'if§fV§'2§§%; gigfizégagég;

me; aye: Eigfigfig §a::g.;Ag:&a;:s,%%:%g:giA;»%§%:%;::;§§ hag 'fféiafi ma

§:'a§$:z:~sa:§§%;$§%;;"

3% ‘?j;a§”%:%§f$ .%%§§:§§’§:€ “%.:;.§”‘~’=:<"§5'%?§f:&§ ?;a;2 aw §%:' 5§§'"%§§§' ¥"§%§'*§§{
fifiiffififi fiééa '§'"§§s§;§ €'$af2%'§§-

3;’.5??2_%’~«._§§§E§§:%§§ aigé-mg 2% fig ?;§%*§$ %”%?v§§”%%§” Q? a gig

A’%;%§§i§ji§g§~:V§§::;;_:;’§§;,-..-ézfiéaaaéfigzg $5: is ‘égégi 3%”; ?%§€:§a $3

§a:22.;§:.%2 §:é%%”§%”:$§ E-5: §§§.%§@,§§é~; Wsgigfgiéy £§§§§.Z’§§§§§ E2: fig

‘ “=. “§§a§§:% §s;§;§-*2Ee§§-gig: gmgartyz 25% £5 :§:*:%§§*§é%;§ fig? ggggrgfiaggé

:*§é&–§:§«§*m§eri*§’ fig zgértzsa a? fig §§§é eéaaé éaigfi Eéfigzfifié

.,.%.s*.§§a §::§3; “°§”§°;$r§;2§%$%; 2&3 éfigfiéééfifii %zgé%§*-=;$;_§.: gray §’§§§§%:g

V 233% $? §§”%§$-%”§S§ we? 2% mi: $?§§fi§”§E§ a%EE§§”§°§§§§§§§ $3

§:%:§§?”$r§ azgéié 2% §§§§%’%§§§f§i§ §§§§§§:;§ §§$E£;§§§§¥§ §%§’s§€%’a

:§:*¥’:;%$§§$§ fzim ii’; fé-3% fig §z§§$§’:: %?£3§i §é:::;’ §§”E§;§§’%§%§$?§

Of/5′

3

§”%?$i§”fi§§’§§€”%§ %2:%s”sr: frag? §§’i§Z§%’°§§§’§§’%§ %%?§§:?’§ ?s%§ §’§§’§§§.f§§§’4;§§

§§£$%§$§fi$”: mg? eE§%§§3§”E”°é§$§”3:% 5? tag sags? §fi%2$§a£§%§__§:§%?af}§ii?&i§5*%5;f§;.a..:’ _

35 En gawém $§ :’:$:§£§,–*”%;§*:-~33 s;.,:%§féaisVg:ézi*§é:f%:V” ‘V

:*a$s*:&§a%%.g£ fig; §”:§$ gsamsaé. E-§@@é%:..%§*§:::%_;,T”%:§§%%’:§’%–.%:¢§$ f§*%§:é–:

*飧”§§§§§”§ sm%a§*:’;&§*:t fiiaaé ?:’a–f._ §esg§§ é31%*:§ v;§;V§é§v§,:’:*£’?§§§”””£V:*§§§=~
asaiaiéérgagé, _ _

3 ?%*:§ E?-ai C$:.:§”ii«._§’:*:_ §:f§§z:;§:3§T~–..:a%s§’~%%§$;2$s §§§§§°’§”§§$$§§
Eiw mi: $5 t%:$ gia:-é_%’::§%, fififififig §§§§%’v.:§?”§’&:§?§’§:.’§§§§%§E

E, ?§*i% 5 _»§§%§’T?”§§-i’§ “~ €§§;§§E$$§ 5$§§§§§’§§’§=§ §$? §:§”a§
§§§$§§a§é.’s:;;§si§i:%iE–§’§’s:%;f;:=%’:%$§§€§:*;::_ifzai 5:: a $255: 5%? f§§§'”§$ii§§§

ifigazfisiifim L?1:§3:$’7;7;”;ia§ ?::$§§”§.”§ §¥§§§§§f%€:§§§ éififiig £3; §$:::§$§€%§

“‘~..v_:§§%:s§f§< .__€:;_%g§g"'"g@. …. ._;%§§§ §:*a§&:°§%g§ ?%§%i=%%%%:§"3%%':§fi§i§":§ '§§"§%

:"a§'§§%§%:§§'~§&§}§'afiaaé 32% iréég :§§<g$:§? '§£§"§*%fi§'? éisaiggfi §%:§§:

§:fis;%§%a*1§§§£f%§?é'V'%§f€§..§$ %%§:*§§&§ ézéaif is fiém ass: %%§%§ sgéé afifia $5

'Vvgaié ga VEi§"%._§vi&§ §&§§ §'$€%§§:§ ifi $%é'§§§$;F"%£§ ififi €13%%'§'§$§"$§§§§ :3?

'.. ~§§°§$§'"«:;',}'§"$§$§'"§Z'g1 3% :%§$§'%f$:"§ €§§3;'§;%?'§i§§ mi 32% §§'§*:;§:s§§%$é

éggégéfizégé: am égzmsa %§ fig E5": égw gm §§%%§s§ ia: fig 3%:

" " -~§~$%§5:..

é

2? E ésava fifififfi iézg §$%é§”§E$§ $§§%;r§::;§ _4:§x:,:;§”-.._f£:§’*s:_§

§§§§§§fi¥”§t§§§&%%’§%§F§ sggé éfiéfifiéfifié Efie ?&£§%””§§§z

ifia :*g:~$§g:::§§§s*::t Ea gésgsfitfi

E, §i%€,§§ iégz; i%§§ §§:%&:”§E §§2a;§§:’_’_’@%V a!’:§§’§2?.é’é§ V

3:2:§~§§2 agiaaagiéfi fig gm §éeiév§3§V;§~;§:r;_§.:;g§’:%%§§”§:%§§
fiaragaa-a fieéfig fafiggagr :2?’ ‘§;§;§é§ .§§3::§%_§’§i:j%;§ Qaggéag
fifig tits gwéas” fif §’§::$:’*:’;z§°~’§;:,é’T§§*:aé =i§§°$&§”§%§2 iaaéasfieé
aha §§§%%’§§” §;$ §§§ § ‘%;%3_;$ gagét’ fig fififiaégéi 9?

§;§”:$ $35? $§§§é$’~»$:z5§i§;__–%’é’$:§%e:§_§%*:§§§ $§*§’§m?%§5§§§*%ya::% fieééag

53$? %%x.;e§:* %§:z§:::5§:§T§_-. s”;5mé3.V:*&*;$&’§»:§ fix; gafiaraé ggvgay :3?” §%§§m£*§
zigfeé ;’7-;i£;.__3§.§?§§$; :*%;s§§§§’z§:%§ §€§§§ fififié éamfi

E§.?,..§$€;:%=% mazggiééfi éig 2% gaéé §?:%%, §%é£a§§m:?:§ am fir;

%§a§§5gsg::T§+.§§§§§§jT§xb$4 ia Exfié am am Qaéé agcgggzs

-¥é§t;%_: r:=a§.§’;§;§f “Tag-iifzég 525%: ;£’%§”Q;§%§?°{E& “?§%§ §§§§§§§§%a:2 3? i§’%$ gfaééi

§{$§.§f:§,~a;-.s;a;$* A§°§%::§g§ avg? ifi 32% §§§%§::%’%*§’;’§:§§”%;%%éa§$§: “§”%:%

‘”r_ ‘a*?*};$§§§§§$’,_§:’§’§fi§’*§§$§”‘§ zésaméé §§§§§i§%§ §§*:§%;’ Eézg §§§é§:é%§§ §’¥§%§§§%§

::2;§§f§§é§gg§ $22 32.3%? §§”a§£f%:§ %’g véyiggg is? size %”£§§§5¥;’fE%f”&§ gaég

., __§§%téé§ zsiég §:&<,§3 333$ éggrs ii'? mfiféfiasfégg §$§§%§§§§§3 §§ ?;'.§§§

V wma ségmg iéégfz,

34¢

§

$2 "§'i::$ tax méé rggesigiza gigg %'§"§§§§E£§ fie §a;":§.é_%"'§§%:%§

saig Er: fsgvaigr a? gig §§§%%?E§E§§e 'fie gzzééeiéig &§. £§:*z& *

ififiiiié aigaz iéfifiifiaifi i'T§'%& §&§§' §a§:,. ..

?§%3§;?§’é§§:§§§§;fi§’%§§§§§ 2% @:é§::§§§*§§$;’ §3ré’a:i? ‘€:§%a.. ?2§%v:5é%§.§§ f

gggéiéégfifi 5*; am gigéféiéii §:?”;§”§§:*§a§4 §i2:§9s”: §$:sV%.::%V:’§v :§é$ ‘:’?:§’§&

Q? fig ‘§%§’3§€§?’ $1′ iéza §§§§§”‘%?§’§ iéiggéég gait ” §§f§§¥§§;§%g’Z :§§§ €fi€”§’é$
%§ 32% £$?’%§§%§§§$§”: Eififif fig -g§:”*zaa§%§.:*§§% ta §§%sz%§g* ifiat
t §%%’&§§§:%:*::’%s”:5 353% §§*§.H_§s§’; §§§§§*_§%;?i5§§’s–;5§~~.fi§§Q§’1′?§§._%§’ ?iéfi§’% $’¥’é’§’§é§”§

£2? t’§’§§ gagréé §%§;§3a%%§;%;.~v.”§”%:%r&§$;*é;égfzv”é*§e%;~§ :3? %%*§& §§§$§”§£E :2?
any méigrééaé’ é:§%% ;§§§%§::§§§’ 2% ségzzw gm

$%as::$§’§§’:§§Vé;r.§M:%:§ -§j;§?§§a;é 3::§-~1′:%§$ 3:5′: jgmgerigsg §§ifi §§§§§%:§§§

é_ §@s;:_§’£:55’«:;?%¥s;§%:&;% ?éeE:;%%%g%§-fé a %?’§§§”‘§%T§§§§§§ iiiifi ifi the §§'”§§$r%,:§a

” . h §§*:§§§a 2% a§§_:%.§§ ‘%§”;% réagfiaifig $5 irim ‘%”r%§§

Qggrég .%,%”§°:A§§g fiégmégskgg %§*§§ gag? 3&2 §§?”€§é%E? gaséi ég éfifi fér

..j}’%§§3%§;§:s;%;§§:r2. E”‘§2§ aaxézéééig §§”%§ 33% §’*§§§§§”§£§ §§”E €”$££%§?”‘§ %§%5$a§§§

::§gs;.§:”§*g ézsfizgifi iéaaiz fie gigéfiiii? §%§¥§§§§ §£é?”§§’E$§§é §Z§”:§

“=. §§ ;é”a§§r§:g§ iris §§§”%:;2;$ Q? §§’§§ §’§§§$i$§”§§ ggia éggsfi §£1§3 33%

fiaga gs? §§”e%:’§ ;§§§§a§§§§§”s &§ fig géffié. “fig “”§’:*§§§ fiméfi
?§%§¥*$;;%§”§ :»*s§§ $3: a ftarggaifii 3*: gséag éééifi ?;’i§”%% iéiéa g? fie ms

;§%”‘$§%z”‘”%.:”;-C “§”§:é. €:§€§§ gs?’ Eééa ;?§§§:~°§:%g :3 §§2?é§”: fmm 33% gig?

03/4″

§

§§§%§§:”§§ %§:” §§*2;?:,,.§r%£i’:@§-%= “%’%:a §$$§$§§§§’fi fi? ?;?§i§ ;§§§§:’:.i§§’§:”§%§%§

2% mi? §?”§§$€”f§ %§ 325$? 52$ £5: fiifififfififéifi %§;é§;?*;*§§§%:=;%”i§é*§:%;:A é”:;’=<:.-_ ~

'%§%%'§*¥ af flag §*:§:§§&§*é&§ am mgsrés %§$§i'§'.§i% %:*=*:§;7s5?z'§'*:'c§.:%'_%?*i:;§"'é:.*;~s'§"§:§"::;'%v

'§'":*§i§§ ;::3:3:*t ésgfléz ?%§%;%'é % firza iifié {figA.%;'%*:§=.g:;g~§t"';é":;§§;3§%¢§

§e%s§§ aéé-3:": 2% fiza gait §§':'" §%T§$?%$$:$-5§§"'%,V i§'%§AVV.i;_§T:§g.:§s§3:2§z;§ –. '

j§a§§§§'?'%$§'%i aféfi ziagarag :*$§%.s%§*§$ faéfii §a§§§.._ _ V
2.33 ififir %§'%% §§&:$;€{_§a:%E§?§ §"fi7§§$i§'%§'§~.%".f§'§$'%;'%§§fi;2§§ fig aiéawaé:
£3 'féég }?is'§§?*§":§n: a:§2–:%..aéj§£f$;évv.L§;?g§4:%@§§'"i1i~§-:'%;E§§§ §%%§$§

§fi;::;g;:§§§€;'u';f%§%§§$:i§g§i:s%:$:{:;é§' éag ifiza $3: ggféé fifty mg;
§:§§5§.i&§ %§§%§_é:§%s:#%'§*:e:g_'"'*E§ §é% fifiéfifié
;~ f%'°§"2é §a§.§§ §§'§%*:é' géééézitéfi :3 éfiiéfifiép

V" :%§:,§X:;z:*§5é:§3

Saffi

._.uu.na-

Judge

?§iEi§