High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Dodda Shetty S/O Late Vittal … vs M/S Venkateshwar Enterprises on 2 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri Dodda Shetty S/O Late Vittal … vs M/S Venkateshwar Enterprises on 2 July, 2009
Author: D.V.Shylendra Kumar K.N.Keshavanarayana


‘.;:a:””§

5…

3%-€§¥’:’% E (‘2?

1′

:3; ?§§E; E-Eififi $%:3’é§}i§ 9? géaagm
gmmras Efiiéfifi 5:1′ gmxwm >
§;:m;:’§;§:;s “:3?-~§:z:§ ‘§”§:—EIEEE; $1221?’ iii?’ §.;z3:,.2-*’ 2eé;;%:§u
yggagm % ” ” % ” A

EH3 §%§{§§§’EL§ ..-I::i

,g§§’§§QE §,j¥.»g41§§2g;E:a’§§’g§;”§€?€§ Ea. u ” % k
&2>%’§’v, M A %

‘§§§§ §%E§’§BL§

~% §§s?;:zi’;f:§;.,gK.§§;’E%;g$z::§$g§e’;t;:%aYg%z%’g%%’
:25: %%§€fE?:§.§.,-A :1; RG23 5:; :§5~;’:’- V22″;->1′:-¢>§ai;5x§§’ , :.i?’?’:-i%§ ;;::::}€3§ £5′-mg
E~§E%ZT.i”E%£§%: ‘:5: H

§:§:’é Ef?:;:§<§2é;-§~'§%.2_<~:%§.§Q :_;».Ej.g:wz'€.i5: 1-?§2'§E'.%{f2;§ :§%':§:-:%';§'.jg"',
' –

343 f <3 3 é°%E;§;;:;.'§i:E":' §%:":;3;§'?.'§.; %;.:I:E'$§

i:'.%*i;::'§a::«2"; .:I§?5;":{§.:':. R? " 5,; E'_;~::3; "1%:;"2,:'§ ~ .31 Q 3 9 53%E"§'§.%Z; E' E4-;'%§§'§.'

§}:f%};' a§é?.i,:~7¥f?:a

" -; ;:'1,,{''§a«'a::':2-3£.:T:}

%?<::§;§:~s'§':if::;'%:%::i%._ '€;§:3i?.{'§{':E"' §3:'<s%;'%_&;%{_::'2s§ «caf
'E"':'5';é*. §:~é{:%£a:';:§*é ?'§3;§"§i§'§€3§'%§§'}§§:} ;'§:':i;
E35';:é§;;"s:5»;é:::':§':i3{'§ 22$; i"'a".:% géiaiiggiézié §:}:£:'E.:'1:;"::'_,

* :;.E:.—§€=~'€i1'§::{:§§'?'£ '§éi;;'aT;:T:'§i:-3"§;}:5. i§§";€{§:_%;}
_ fig géiijéi :1§§i3{_}f:n:§;. £3':

?v§::;:E”:2a;§2:;:<:23§ 'E"3{3s§g:§ Efizariézg
?§{:__2:*;:. E;-§2Z§.§ §:"€3:.';2i«;_{§§ E2? z:E§§%« , . 9 E"<::¥:*::2

§'§a".:.Z3 §.?'7;"'§ §’2if.’:”

: ‘
:’:;*:%s:;§_}@2:{§<fi:;'% ii 1:: §é.g2,b;€ {E5 :_:;;::,.:&;§,:':;;,; {::*§' ;;:§"<.}<§.z.:a::¥_it}:2 <3? 'i"':;1§s;s~%

:m<i§ {:{3:§<::*:}<:%_.::~{E §:?*;:§.€§::':§.:<:€? ?:}::?iEi}:*é-:: t'.E':,%&s2 {7i:'::1§.:"L

8, 3:; % §'}:€"f 3;':-"é3§<I§'E :=.-:«::.:.<::_E__%._
E'.§';§;":k {:2:€:*::": E? 1%-f<;% §'.3{f3."£'1E§'§' 3E'":5% :'*<:%$§.::{:2'; u '
S€?:<:%;§<"::: fifi ';3z::§_Tit.':<2;';{§€::i":§. mi: ?:;:::~:'1:1:+;, ' . .

$3. 'afica §'}s'3§"IEi§7i. fiiiii ?_ §Z'1€;':.

§~§{:s.:§§{::.: ‘.9 ‘§>€%ET’:é:}:’: ::*zj;:}s:’::$2:_%mg €.%”:€:

<;::§%3.s:s';_:§,, éisiéi £3..V§:::;'4mtg§j}{}:.:a§{::;3: %:TZ*::<3: {;:*%g§:::».:§ ;:2€:i:;i:§{}3'1, by
§;%;I3}":7§:§._§a s§.:z§.'§;:;. ?%1v%:;;2:'§',;–%f§'€'}€V:}i! ~ 2:3; Wé:%}=' if {.: :’I’§.§’E,”€E{?:f, §’:E*’:s;>; 5?-%;.2:–,:.§i E’i”i§3:S’§E.§’§%2§” ii’: é:”z:a:2′::§;.’.;€ E326′: S”%_,§,§}§’E’ii$$§{‘:iE Inaziéz ‘£21?’ %”§”:§*%

‘-<§'E7%;:*é§':{t::%:-3:? '§=%;3§3::e{§ £'§i"}EZf1$€vi fez' §'}'i€'f §§,§}§I')€§é§E"iil aE::=.:":a_1%_: {E19

g}<}$fi§é§§E§€.j§' {sf Ehf: f€S§}{§Z1{§€§'§"§l .§'1&'§f'§§3§ E;€r;%€:::'.;€ iiafzfie fa)?

V§?ifL:§T;§E%§"i§.§fi€iI3§ $33 §&::§*:.:':::§ :3"? S€::i'.E<3:'::s=; $3, _§._*§{€:§ §,§§§;§ am? EQQ

:';§ Efiéfi §:":£'§§§::;': ?s:3;:;~2l fifiaerizé, f<:;::' <:a'.%.:8§:"':g §§£'£}{§'§.§{Z§",§{}'§"2 <3? fiiségsi"-2

§'i'5£§{f§{'f§"E{Z§i afiéi aim g;§"<2::t:_:§’_:’;6::”;’i,és:,

» j”§§§%%_::;°ér§<::':I,.gféiié

'§':s_::?§:§:€i"T:= V' E: aéiizzz' $23? 3%

2

.5},

:”é:’§::’:::’2é§.’i:mg §{:z’ge:””f; :;m{‘§ IE1€%;E’1§.§j}E.E3é%;’E.§€}£’E <3? <_%£:<::::1:t::'1t.3,

sa=*E_T_:i{7%': :»:;'*e: :'%;:}"a__:§2,§3a§ E15: Ex: gééacszai §3:~:.£%::'€: "éézizg {ffs;2:..;é*:: €ff1I,{?.,

5%. ;'§€*/=.2.1"?'Z'E's 0? 312%

Q
./

£~.ii"}d {:3 $1..§fE}3I3§: 3; §3§"€"3§.i'}.'};.§.'§f':£iE'}»" z'<:§:2:}1,§;’E””§i§1:’:.. }§:?E§1121

faciét ::a_;§€: §.’i>:a* ‘i:a}<:'i:'ag §1_:1'z}'2s2:* £i{I'€'l§O£'} {E}?~§:§"}§}S~(§§}%}E7'E…, 9

2'%e:'i:”:2-ii E%€:*.g§Es§1’a:” C'{f:§”Ei’ii’§}% iii; :;~;a,:§;;:;’2§1f. ‘€:’§’1t:. :*i:§:é:;5b’::__§.;sa;tE<é.<5

{i"i:,_:.:’i s:21’T:_j§js:’ fa: ;*,%*:,’:<:§'f.: §3;z:?:__'§{::»;§: 2-az€'a.},_:§i'; €ig;;i'*:€'.A._é::;:§:i<s5l :2*~::£ >

éegiézy by §SS”é1§§Z§3 ;;::2<:€:ssa:'§; :i§::i:i::;3.§’*i’,iF*-;%$ zzmii $231′
i::3_,§{;%?’: g*;::i*p<}:%;’§;s{:3,.i:;:;£’1’£.j_ :33′ ‘EEK? :”€:s§>:):§{§e3:’T2i:

are <:E_%§"t:::é§:':{E ?;:€:2 a;3§:;z–:a;2*. .'§}af?§€:%3f%i f..§T}§:_ ;f«'%}.:j¥'v=fi§iEi<}:";.21§ 3'~¥<3g3'5s:E:'*ar

{R2 2":é;;:::*a§_ e:}_E'..§{,f<:::::*i:_ €§§'f.:._ E..;"§%'5T% £2. :2}; 3=ii}{}<3.

3 E:-. _ {E%T:§'";<;%.§%%:fi£a€:,= 'E §i:€,'.?i.§;§.§.£.}E§ *-a:§":%;:’§: %:;.:«3.§§ ‘:::s<T:*.§-*«::"1

§E,§.é:é3:% $§%::::' ";–*:»::§;p{:e:'3{is:::.%1T %;£:§':¢s§

fig-:=. 3ij}§:a§*ws;:s:’§;, is; g:}i*:;:’::’:§E.i°%”5:{§ {<3 Ex-3 w§%4.E':<.§:'a:a?':';Q

'3

E

R

§_.%':§A: :':.:<3:':S€é<;:_.::t§1';é3§

<§<3%e3;§%?:;3§::€::a%;,, afiszr ?'§'§€ fifiéizfg :;:sf §;§::5:~ SECEEQEZ Q 3;p§;§§::%g:E.i{;:T:

A€z:?;E,¢g- 'as; §*€::2::":<;§ 0:'; 3.33:? 2:§:}'g."§§E§::§2:¥;;§,<:::"2 zizzéfiéef Ss:§:%§.:33;: §;5§§ig

§'§§.SS;§;€'i§E%$fff{§ 5:25; 2a*i_%:w§5;:§:'a%s::': a§"";<% §:_E":£: ';'3::,–:i§§"'.§é::§:€::* <:z:z32z'::§:: <:§2:7§_;;n

V

§'a-'E§'?2 33" 133$?'

'2;f't»<

i

§'i§,"'§_%-' %:e::.':@fit, 2:;':_c'?;:-3:'° 31%;:-: §E3_§:'{}{:s.:<::;§n:1g:§ §:":i't,%;;;"E'<2i’: <3 §'3€':"i'§E.%;{2:'1¢

L2. '}7'_':;ir: 2'ei~::’s;,:§’:;<~;€:£ 1%}? *£;.h:: pajs,-<'i§;1g ihsé mag; Ex:

2
3

€;é3:3:ia3r{3={§ r:’1§_3’i2<:'£T}§.;' 2:1} _ {:::2:;.j_:'s5é§"–iégf"{($253 apffiéifiéélfi :24'

{§£:p<}£~;,%:'::i{E -. _§§§%::§'i}z5{%§i.; §§':–§.:3'–. €3:fi;*::'E'.,'" azzzi; ?:E"3<:;'<3:;2§E5::'*, iihe
;£§_};T}<~33§Eéi::;N.'.' is V;£L;"?§i3fiV';'.'1i.§'zj.:!;'€.":3'€§ 3 is;::_é§::*;;:§%;' E§":<:* §5=;§§:’:T:a§’3’§”, §’.E”§§’:}%.E§2§T. §’?:.§’.$
€.Tf{3 3 ;’=?a:%§ .

C1€§’§.–3:f§éf:3{i’*§,EéEi§§”il§’%’ if: 3 ‘::<:a§ ::3:§’~.%: ;:’:{§%”: $2′;:”a?Ei;a3 :;:fi<E
_ . V i, K, :1 .

:::%;.§§;.”;’;{}:–»;%:%{§”_~v..{;f§” ;a:$ §§::av§:T2g %3§:::::'”: 52% gwiazigiiizszé Egfiffif ms E35: 1a:i%’§”2{.§§”232%;§1

” V’ §z%:;s:;1:«_::§Si%;:%§;é;iz’:g {€355 ;’*”§<:{:€.%.<3:z_': €31? §3<:§.§i.ia:::'::. §%;§<2%;'§"',

1%,;

?»”‘§?§-‘E §”=§:.>.;3? 12$}-Q?-E

“‘§f’%”:§: ;§§,s:§%’E:;7;{:=§:€zE_ .E%f!::~g;é$§:”2::’ {E-<–:;;.:<2§'z_i2..§ if 'iI§"E§§§ {ff{::.3_§"'? Ea}
;7:§.{;?E fa}? @%,':si:7§': ;3:;:';j:=<}:;<: <12? %'10§{%i:3;g <i::{§g.§.%.:'}=? zmzi. §;:T:% :f§:§j§;§ "£316:
E'°{f§}{§§"?fl f V. L" ,_ "

§~§:’3′:§’