High Court Karnataka High Court

H.Nagesh vs The Chief Traffic Manager on 25 November, 2009

Karnataka High Court
H.Nagesh vs The Chief Traffic Manager on 25 November, 2009
Author: P.D.Dinakaran(Cj) & Byrareddy
IN THE PHGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE

DATED THIS THE 25TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 

PRESENT

THE HON'BLE MR. 12.1). DINAKARAN, C;1;«r:.1%"jg.II:JS§x'IcE_: "  

THE HON'BLE MR. JUsfm;__E   
wmrr AP1vEA1,.No.264}r 2_ooé 
Between '     

Shri. H. N21gesh ' _ .

S/0. I'.,a*.e H2111::1I:'21:1'Lhz1.;:)§jE1"'.  . _ . 

 about       

Res1'di1'1,<_'{ at;  5: »_  ' '  4' " V

7"" Main I'{Lfac?E,_. *_ . ' _ ,

B Ch1'.1'1 d_. S1-,a%)' I:'{<+_gis'%11;i?g:1 If (){fic':.(f;'.

i"1~21g:;117fii P1,:1*iI',7§i'3SK'.3. . '

Kl'. R(_)7a(:1,'-- ' V    '-

Bz1.1"1gaI1'  4-560 £179' .  "   _. . A.PP{.§LLA:\I'E"

(I.5_\,-'  n'. M .  I;3'2.;s32j1iv:z'11A9z-,.:'_;'b:.voctztit?)
AMI); "  -

AV  "FE7£§'L'(1hi.éf Ti*z:{i'ic' Ma1'1agcz1
~..(Eci~1_1 !'1":'12v. .C}{I'i€1 V V 

K; 1 J ;'--.R('}21€i.  j 1. A'
She:-1-..r,j_1t.§11'1'.1--2.": 53231;: ._

g £%3a:T1_ga.1p':-gs; 2 560 ()2?  I21j::s.;I>c)N:;> I~-:N"1"-



I .1

V

'I'his Writ Appeal is fi1(:'.{1 ::1"1c.ie1' sscc.Ei()11 4 of the
K211'112112L1k£-1 1--iig__§1'1 Court Act p1";.1yi11§.§ to S0? aside the order

p'.~1sS@d in the Writ' Peiiti01"1.N(.).7456/2008 d2,1.t.c:'.d O4.06.2009_

T}h11's writ pe1.iii01'1 (.'.lI_('3  :§§_ : "

 

JUDGMENT

}–}.’ea1″d the Counse-31 for the 2.113};.)e}I21_1:h1’t’i. f. u

2 . The f11ct:s 2111? that” i’?:1(i’«._21})13611-E}1i’t Vxve-15$ “Eh(?C){1C§i..§(?fOI’ , L

m’i,h the respondent ~ Co1″porz::1,1’bh. ,T1’1e.I31:s’0n W’11i(fh he
was on dL1[.y was iI1speéC.1éf’:€ by :1.,c:h.c*c_}}Ie(.t1i;’1gj _1’1:(*;,*_11.’a Ac’*,c<)1'c1i11g1y, he w2:1:~; (I'.}'1E}l'gC'~
sI1.c:g°.1§§c.§ c-1,}/hi z11'1V" was c'.('a1'I(h.1ct',t-3C1 2-,1gz1.in him. I—I0 was
from se1*v1'(ée. 'Ihe n'1a1.te1' ldaving been
1'i'ejf'r£§if_1V';.§Ac1V'"4§'ii_~v'.,n1':_l1'h:'"}§iaE3()uI" Cozsrt for adjudi(:z1t.i(.)n. the I,,21b01,.11"
C()LJ1'.1"i' ':;é:_}C?('2'I,C3d the :"ctf%3r"c::1<*e11am. \.v:«,1s g:.1..i.It.y

= …<)-f:3e1'io1.1ss n'1isc<}nch1(r1. and t'1'1.2-rl he 1"1ac} 21 1:):.1.<;f history of 44

8

DJ

(‘z-uses; out of \>\-‘hi(“h 8 \V€I'(? “re(‘i.–11’1a1’}.<" ('EISGS a11(i 1,he:t'+.-?I.'c;:1'e.
11:15 ojjineé 1,112.21 'ihrs: L2;1b01.1r Cmm \,v51s.s jL1s11ifie.d in I'Qj(?('f'i1'1g

{he 1*ci"e1'e11(*e. It is this w111'c'h u1'1c1e1* Ch21l1e1T1ge.

3. Hz1vi11;: reg:-11’d :0 the \-v(*!§–sct’.tE(:éd keg;-11.”~;gVr§)’sait.HT>z’1

i1″1s;0f21r as w01′”1m1cr1’1 smrE1 as the p1*<%:'-:e1[11 e_1.;1_pc3iI'z'1.1i'i;-._z'i'}f£7'A.

C()11(terne?ci. which hzwc? I*.3r::€%1'1 de(':ide§!M by 1.h'e'"1-7x}3x§_x, CnL13j'1

the i"()IIOwing;' ('T'c1S(iS. no §gr()1.11'1cI is 1'1'1'Z{iCiC';(')L1}-:' {"015'i111,61'!'r:_§1'e:1'1.g:cf': 1; '

a) Janatha Bazar {South ‘».Ff{ c”r:.1xarc1. ‘Cv€3)”;l”If(1Zi.’ (;”~gV)’4z),=:1e:*l:1I.i1;(3’V

Wholesale Stores I_,ir’r11’i’ed,)____ Se>c:fem.ry._;§Sahaka.r1′
:’V(‘)ulcarara Scmgha. (Li ‘mifl<).zjI"1£'rs2:_ !"b',3£)"L'{»'./:J:":' 7 S–CC 51 7.

I9] Kczriz'1(1I.ai_€(i 5f_-vS_::ciA£.r3 –.I€ c;'qcI_ _"!':'anspc)r*(' Corporai,1i()n us.

113.53;gm:-:gz.:t..(:;30m #2 ?4.

C) ?.I2i€’qVic):~zal fl/[E1fIi:!Q§I:.Wf{SR7’C vs. C}har1sl’1.yan1 Sharma. 2002

£11.}’.f,3f3l.?é?;?’I(if”{‘{ ‘£i5:Z,>c1r7’I!;l us. I(ar1’2a!”a.}ca Slaw Road. ‘I”rcmspor(

tf;or;;x:{r;z,’z::i&}:2.. (2oo2;.9 scrc 544

._<-xi .RegI'0"n.aI A/Iarza_ger, Rc_L,icLs'Ihar1 Stare Rr)c1d Trcm.spor'r

"(T'€$r*;)()r'(1.fi(J11 1,23. Sohan Lal. {2(}()4)¢'€ SCC 218,

6

‘1’ht>. e.:;.)}:)e;I1l 1*c:_jc?c1e<1.

Sd/–

Chief Tust§:<_¥ 4 i[j :

Sci/~
%;JUDGE :A

inclext Yes/.N0. ‘
Web Host: YCSNQ
1’] V 3 5 ‘L