High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri.N.Jagadish vs The State Of Karnataka on 22 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri.N.Jagadish vs The State Of Karnataka on 22 July, 2009
Author: B.S.Patil
E33 TEE HEG3 €§QR'?' Q?  $?&KA 3,? 3$§§$L§RE
§$f§'E§ *E"'i~§§$ "?i-§E 325% fififf $3' e§¥.§¥.J'f$ §$$9 

3331333

TEE §~IGH*BE.fi Mxasmxcs 3.3. lfimjfg  " '7  j" *

Wm? ?E'i°'I"}'°§§¥€ §I§es.1$§13 & 29_;a49'_§1«? 2"e??0'95£:.,,é."--§§1:;}s;§s3   K "

3ETWEE?€:

E,

1.

Sn N,.,.§aga(ii$h,

S; Q Eats z”! a1*aya:1swami,

Agéd abaut 412 yfisars,
Rfai Noa9i3§:37, 8&1 Main mad, –

313 Black, 334 Stage? V V’ ‘ V . ” ‘
Efiasveshwaxfiagar, I
Bangaiara ~«— ?9. V _ ‘

812% N .12’e<§§-zg:gi1?i;;»'_

S; 6 "Eat? +–Z%§gr9;;%a31a$i&§?::e1::§,.

Agfirfi aimut 4;£}jy€8;1;”3$, ‘ ‘ ._ —

Rfa? i¥§.o.95’5,8fi:wfx2€afi:T»E%c,Ati; ” ‘

31%? BI;ez:*E~:, zéré &;:g7ga:5._Lj~._ ”

§39.s:a:e3E31fi;?;a;*:};2:.;ga:;,. VA ”

B::mgai0:’t*: ~–*”?”3′ V’ FE”i”I’TI§EiERS

” “§§%.;j§,f S£fi{‘*f4.–&;3;e$h, Aéiv. Law Chamiasm}

§€§f&:”§1a£a§§a;

{}&’;p_3r”£3:;:€’Q{«–‘i>f’Ur?5a:2 ifieveiepmani mid fiaiizzégzgg
?%I S. Bufidmg, £Z’3z’.Am§3€iiE§a3;” Effiaéézi,

Bamgaie:2’é » 3&0 G0 3,,

V’ .. Ei§;i’i’.§s $€€f}:’€€€ii”f§.

1§8figa}.C}E’€: Beveiepmfiaszt. fisuihmii};-*,

‘EiC1’10wds.iah Read?

E3’3;i”k West,

Bazigalare —- 55{} {E26,
By fig {§cs:nm.§ssé::me2:

3. “$22: Sgagréai Lwrsd !§{‘.’q1’§1:iSfi§.{§§§ {}§.’§§.€+$;;
Bangaigré f}€V&iap’ma::t A:.::.h.ari»: ‘efiéast, 3
Baifzgai-m’€ — §5S 82¢}.

{fly Sn’; §.?§!§.a1:(;:i1ar, Aifrfi. fszs E51,
Sri Bagavaizaj V.f3a1:3a1′;:d, fidv. fer Rm? 552. 3}

irinfr

These ‘Writ F’m”:i1:i0I1s are fileai uzig-:£–.;é§i~::c}e”s ..;7>:%2e%,s
the {_1::au3t:§:§fé::’ti0n. csf Enzziia garrayiflg -gigs fiir§5~:;*{‘£-ihst i?:iK7”V:*:éVs.;p<3:1;i43:1t.»_ " .
EDA is cfifisigiar the I'€3§I'CSt3I1tE:Hji_O'13,' dat:::s;§__ '38{0'S§.27{}{}*;}"';1:r€~J
{me ‘$33? $5 émplemant the §ii1″€ctiQ:1*’i:§st1e{1_b}7 the’ Chisazaf ¥*Jii:1i$i:€r
by His £.£E’i£§r iiaiaii 2?.€)1.._2€3f)? .%J’id§:A2%._:;»¢x’arew’?% to figs WP and
atar, .~ A.

“Thssa §>€§iii:’;§:3__ camégijg fizz: “ii3§::’~_§}1’eéii1g;§é1e:.r}7 §”§f:&f”ii{}g this;
::;§a§,=’, ihf; €§€m:*’t :r».’a€ié;.jfii:e f:§_1i:)W§11g:#” A

.,… »._.,,._………………m..

V §aE$&

3. 31% 835;3.a¥:c;;3faj ‘ %?F$§’::.%%:?§.;%”_’.;(:.$.{E.§ §&a:”11ea:i <::'2':.;.:;36E '£3 {'§i:'f:ci::e{§ E9

..f:3§<€ ;::.§fi<:<%~ Eh}: and 315 :'=$*$g3m1s:%5:m.s «-~ E§E;'}2%, §,.@a1*::33fimm&::€ figdvccate {aims natiits §%:i;r fifiifl .1

….-.z-

‘? Eaiiigss wgzéi pe::i§is:3:’1s, peéjfiagssm are igiiekimg as :%é§&s;:i’;:?{3§:.

~;?:é”*& 1’6S}§£§1’1£§€§i¥L~°§§§:*;% ‘:0 gansiém’ $128 re;3§%:3e§.’2.:a’%;i<}§3 {§:«."§.'§.:~:€§

$'z§f!;mi€f£e€i injgr E2263: vitie z%%:n1€:x:1}~€~w.§ ,{"€€3f§I€S§3:§1g far

Qf Sfiiag §§€&§"'.§{§§ §~§9§_E2 azzzi 33 Carvfiii 911% in

31333 \»%;§1€:'5§ sf

siza ‘§xr:a;t:é.:1g ?~§s33JE’2 231$ E3 efagvaé ms?” :3? Sj.;:§’é’,£:%E§*::§?._’§}§§zf:Eu.

Vfiiagew Ekccafiiizzg £0 téamn ms Siffi §lE£3§i’l’§3.lI”€S é£}..Ei$%:iV iéét’.

‘°§’§::¢:: 83$ E133 ac:i;;.:i:*€:::§ their E21351 ii}; _g1§=:;:Si§;<:s:%:; 'E31? 'i::;s€é.j§3_:3;§i,

P:°€}:3£:n?n1a§§; §'4§{3tiii’§”}_i;”‘V-;?.§:>:* iifai”

?vi.E’§shw€:s%1§va:*aia;i: La’__’%;GE3;.'{., EE ‘”§””11&ai°4.§
Ei€’.’£'{“:’S <::€:mp1'i$:-3&5 in S}'.§§i.§{iw-735 as §§V§:':£R§VV:;':i*1 far fikfi
gsazpcsa. Eiégiai fiéfiiiiicaéiajg 'Liza: E§:a;:3.ga'§:*e
E}€v:31{;»§;me:3.§. fiis I an 31. E{}..§€}{}2
<:::;u§z°2'_:',e.g 33:1 93 E35, fig}; awani
313:} gasgéé-i%f2";' i:7"" [gave &ppr:33c.E3.€(E fix 2%
:'§$§:a::§:.{§.§2t::§};.?:~E:i§f§L_"1ifié, sseieigirig .%3';§7<::-rm.ati<;:}. as is

2vs:£%;2:€' ia ééim 313$.-'?'..§Z3§ '§:"3«;:a;*:_i<;::3. {)?f..€:}E;e Eaizii a:.:q'u§:°::{ii in E3, 3353: 3%};

.$i'i*'7.§Q§$€T}$,€fi§ €§;§$.7i€}€i§ {}3.{}8*:é3{}{"}*? igfiusid 'sf; 3:116 233

V'–:"és:.;§é;1:i£<';gt4*§%:£Z%fi{;' i: has; ifif$3'f§3}€§i filfi afi;jac€:m, a's¥;*:1:::* {that 3:":

€xi<i:;i1"é1= s::ef ézitrszas in Sj§:.:?€<:n13:3 was rm? par? 0%" fim

::':§u§s%Ei{S£:i 'E316 ifajfifii 0%' E53 §}€§';"§E§G}i}€i"5S 5:$ 5323*: '¥:.§3€:}: :%2€:1i'&. E_:.13.:;i<*::"

fifcfgé ,§:%:*:._§3r*€s3im1 that fiifiii" §2r’:i:’3::3. 5}? tfhs: E3213 wag .§:s:fi:T zeiciqggiyi:-:’i.

– f.–?§é*5:é*€5e:’, wégegz fizey :’€:ai:2§;:’:.{§ Efémé; iiféza §.:»m:”£ v«:%1s-:1″€§3;; 21:26}; irzaw:

” Vgiviéé ‘gag {:<3:':s;$1::*t2¢%,i»::s§:: i5–§'?1$ aim) "gigs Sufz:jr::<:£ meztzfir {sf a€<;4ui:§i'ii@;':,

%h:~:f; 33.3%: §::s;:.3:%s§;z:& Eshe £iL%§§3{}§"'fif§s'" fie a§€%§, {E153 p€;:"i;i:? 39 am {G emaésie Siam 12:3 §_31°<;a§{—:{_?'£ 121$

;€'€$i<:§&§1';*;i§3§ hmma éméi a'£§1€::* {:tm"i$%;a"s1{%§&:'§ §_§8§,"%Z§s3E2; .%55¥T;7}§s

has 110?. €?£I§I1§ifl€I'fi'{i this rfipmsezafatéan, §;;atr1: £ion.€1fé;éE1$fnv'a '

a§;}:*e:;a<:}::5:{i this €.T:<::u:*t.. ».

4* Cfifiiififii ii): 231:: grrstfiiozzfiiffs §”;§’é.z:.g’i;:.:_g’~–E.:} {($16 7Ii3{:31ti.x:§6 fi”}f “£_7’1:eV.

{‘.cs”art the giudgmszzzt fg}3S§3€{§ in t§1é’L’L»<;Lé&:& 0f~».f&*I§J1&.'%§§§é;7§&

Va. 11% Bazeaazfing i:£vf£;:.3_ep§;m%':§?r* .I§§z§;;"*§~:¢fR:T§*; 3? rm
mmzismaxaa, BA.z§¢..a;LeRa ss§ ¢£1's%«1:vr:€sf'g::%§5é:%£;s'3.f3* $63; siziéméég
ma: £3: gimfiar V'u '£3663 zimzcéad '{5}
<:*<3:1s§z:§§:r éirm VV2_"»*;s;k'E§"l:.*"V:VcI:.€<:i iilfiévifiuafig am}

§:.:a$ issa£:a:§; Vzgesgé 215$ &%f;L;<;t:;;:_§wé<:21;:£$§_ '

3 33% §?":':3sé:v§_-::'::f; \~'C_L$:3b';f=.__;'éz:5§..V~"a%<3:'§§;:S<:1 ag:s;:s{~:a:*i:1g §f}i" "i}':e:i §3§.§z'§§

:-2-a:"§}mi"£:'~z _€.;E1a':. ii.' fiaéé _§~:L"'~€§£1'{§fiei?;F.'iEé'I'€:?1"S are <t.:':§i'§§€s§ as @521' E3 ? azmii in

':::;%m;;:;.L._::§'f 321:: }:;{§g::2&:izii"':.:.s:fiizég {T921}? :=€§€:'z'm:i :9 supra éiiléi if Eha

"?§*g;':*s:T3%;:2Vi:;;:;§§;2."*.%.$V Siili gggemiizzg atafisifiieraiiaix, tjiié same $55331 EH3:

{:<;':3;$_i.:§9£A-$553. aéiiéfi iizfi §é:€:§.%31s:»::m:"S wéfai '$38 attiéafziingijg iiziiitsziimfizé Gf

i"€$§l~§;?,§

' x _ ii: E3213 Sigh: {;ef'i1";e aiéave $"ubm.issim';$s; 33$ 71:: izfietssz 3? %fm:

§u{i}gm€§:"{ §'f:.§%:t:':'§:~zI¥; is Ezerségz §ib€3¥§E§ éhéisfi W:'i§ §€'{3§?if.ZTJ§:S am

' V::§i$§;s»:)$e:§_ Qf Wiiié a {iiztéctiimz ':9 {ha 3:33. '£15.: é1,T'{};1iiSi{§€Zi' 3315

s§§aii0;: s'2§'$mi?E.a{i 22}; {Egg ggeiiiigszmrg 312 aC,::3s;}i'£i81'1€'€ wifi;

Eaw 3,353.6: ii} 31%: Ezighi: 02$' €315 judgzziézzi r€f:~::'r€z§. ta Ei§€Z'€'3ii'3 abavfi as

€}i§}fi£§§€i{}EiE§§:§=' as §§z:'}?§:§i?33§i:'..

seam