High Court Karnataka High Court

B N Chandrashekhar vs The Managing Director on 5 December, 2008

Karnataka High Court
B N Chandrashekhar vs The Managing Director on 5 December, 2008
Author: A.S.Bopanna
J

a

'f

"IGUVIIEH-L£.ECI'ESS'a'd€lHV!£L'§'m-1LH'SVf¥I3€JI.L

{)hE&V8d VICIRI £10 HOIJJIULSHOS 511-1.]. .30 2265 Q 9% 

'S'H'I'.'JI.I2.'lV zmcmn CI'.'££"II.:I SI !IOLLLL€-H .I..IH& SELL

(3 axomnuv -- mmw mums was       % 

smzsmuncassu " .'1t-;':"='3i;!'IC3*I?I"'~::: %

aomwa HV"i*Dx 

aarzomueo 1vHi3*I1'~s3r'~I!::  'E:  F  7

'LE3  -4  J %

 *xvwmm.nms
saomio wya1;1.1%'«a:> 31.333
uo.L:m'aH:z sanzavszVi*z mu. *1

     ms ml

am~Iom.I.fid'%'_        1-I2:I0'I'ii'DHVH
   " =  '$90323 we

 L   A   %%k53ma'nna xvmmum

 - % a1di'I5£LAmr£nsv10nnn3A HVEK

 '     %  Vzgl-zluvsmaavclacaclom

  % 'uolswcl HVIGH

'$11.33)! 'amma-xa
savaa ssmxwavmav
WWWAVHVHGIS
éIVB}Im~ISV3£IBIVI~+IC) H 9

: 

 %  I+0'£8I'R mxnmd um

     . "VfliE'!iDE{ s V mam.-sn9'w\t mama am.

E30533

 %  aamzaza .210 AFC! 199 mm. smx. amvu

aéimmma .x.v vyxvmvaavx do mnoo I-H311-I :-mt. an



'I.

T

Wanda! mm fizzmoos Imasvmu mm mm 81%

000£'€'€."£ pawn 93-WIIOJG am-m me man man was an: 

'waned em in mm» firm mu trams»    V 

3:11-ma 'zooz:'z.'s:I ma women In m  .ac~:;z%'g:;%f%.;;&k%jjf  A  
no .:aa;.:{1 amzgnq, yo and aq; at;      A'
am 131;; [mm germ xuoaaud sq:     

-gmciwti zpua am   
[mnnoo peruse; 'ptxeuv umaafi  exp,

      m-mm:
an 10  %-Wrmmd ant: Xq
was named   mam an 'mam
9:1:   '__ftT5{It§"¢'fi peeved z.ec::'z*rs mute
 fitrmwo as -mm!-rznad mu.

     amao

3'£)H].MD'I'I0.:I '.'-11-IJ. EIGVN JJIIHO2)

A   sm'.L:arna9 a lull smavm-4 AEIYIE-'lI'i%d
aisfa.-z k%«-m;>%y%.%A9m1oo nomm um srm.

'S'H'»E}V1'A}II)Vfi

k1i ?i *   sxmmma wunanoasuoo 'aamas
% kT?sa%%zu.1nmmoo mm aomm mm aammxm
 3.I.v.I.s1mm cu. C3IJ.VHOcI2.-{OD mmuazusaa

'El-ll. LOEHIG (HIV G "9-WWWIV 'ECIIA '.£«00Z"8'6 GMVG
E0/I6'0H GI HI EIHOTVBHVE J3 LHIICJIJ §I'lO3'¢T"I



an

T

"¥W'°°m°qWfll1W°§W1IW~§"a51m1°=mImtqmaa

05: P9-EH50: can 1fi  am 'mm-mm awn :£.n;nhmW 

°'-W"'°P "'3 "=11 13-5 "I1 fiuwpzmoo 'PF["" 'W    %  _
WUOW'-I93 W11 'mIF93B mm A'.I;n'haa am guqg  .

z::x:z*u'sz pauvvmxrv was Kq mm  

Lwapmgaxd 13 an pmapgmoe mm  My  \,

PF'! 5-'!"b"'-" "WWW"? "B J30  ..:§: ' 
am '3-Inca moqug am axogaq  5:1;   1,,

W" "V "W   mm M
an on «warm am mug Ame:
rum an .10  ma zomuwa:
  541!"-3 min» at: Iraq: zuadm

: _'9  sq: no mm muoymad can

 pix}   my 'mamqq mmmmi «taupe

    W M wnwnb u; mmznwp
 ,,m5@ mm, (,1 'mum
 H .Ig6.[.£|.6 an "E53933 mam" "mug

ffiwonpomd I-'q mmmcoqcma am Peumqo arm; :31; 33:11



It
1

T

""$1m0D'!*l1°'°§9¢iP°3-"I Wmumnaamngoammm

am 4; pcanov 0:: on mambo: mun mg 'ar.'mde"§p u; aqw 

3&3" -"-3131599 5!-Iflmop am 3:: zuapuaaiapuy  A' 

IIVHQFIW 6: 13-31063 R104?! 9'11 930.39% iidwmnu  

'mend ms eirmbuo aszmmop  =2:-11:  %

'""'""°' "F" 'W W" 
mm ttorlw amp»; go   
-mvqvl an tum   3::
WW '9' 'Wm   *9

*9-Imam  K4  an In imzrrm
cm who-Id ant;  am am uogamcmo
 pmgm m m mom

will   3:3: mm muermad cam ifiq

   "W "W1. WI! IMF mwrptzI_ _ 0'; paqmm
   tuxaumzaop zuunaqm cm 'W, qfirxmqg

  V  W393" PW Wfiwfifivtxmn mp Ieq; papuamoo

 pmamaqz 'umpuodm atngaguqoquo 3;



amt -warm mzmbar

mm mm pcqmm tx-aoq seq znmrno-op   .

.Ig.cqa¢I ppm sq; flq pants; uaaq     

raqz Kq poanpomd ezumtmwop     .

ma £9 mnvmpwa 9111 '*1 P°"F"'*E  
pm is mmmop was an   "W
'PJI~*'* gwara rm   W'-I3
is mm» is 1W[£§_t_  "5

    zzmmzw em
1-rum mom   we in WW5"
mm» W3   51% 'women? mmm we

mu fzvziowra we came am rmqtnw

 Era 1993 maq put; txapnsq my mtg

    *s*.~nm was an: J0 warms? v'1tw-um WW

   arq; ma nun E_[ txsrpanq an .&ga.zaqm

 moo: M1 tramm 2; £4 Mm-3 mm

Afifivumv an pmpmoa ma moo mom 9:1: -mzmm oz



'4
I

Y

paagoxx am; ;.mo::: maqq sq; map pruacmaa szguapmdasu

an ufincm, 'motion on: 54 none: um 

ca; 13%: anus Q1 3;; 330 mu; am no .aI_n;m zuqnpqyag '4 
Us 3% mm '01 tm mum-m 1°.W~W-I.L  

sq; pmnoae pun [names can 0; wuofifpgq at:    V

9'N'='=5I W P°¥I°~I as-am 321   

'mm fir-rnééa   rmq
amq cu; ppm umdm 33 n -3;
man; it; pwmrmd   ifirn mrusmad
'mm .10 :M9d1#m%m_wmn  Imam PW mm
  30 ms: an m wumnad

 am   mmp 1:: mm mwwzzaa

    aq as; any 1; 'xamcmoa s_rq:;

    mm 1&1 zmnpoui mmnm mmu

  aq; gm; muaggad amp rertrpaflw

 V wpmI   j  » 9313110? am 391;; mud on, po.zm_ box emu murtmhram

 %8uuwm sq; we was mm mpxnq B

#fi8¢§P¥W°In£qKIno1m'o¢uoaU8mI§°II2HI '01



II
-

Y

mm 0% wnrafima ‘woo mow: tvrruszrpw II ‘Mme

fiumtma am on mmm 1!! mm am, -pmmnb

-mime 2.905325 paw mm am ‘5I5’IEP«|>°°°’d’ ‘EK T

‘-Wmao pa.1:opv:.w.: mm em;

“M W3 ‘-m=-mad mm W rié
Igvaq Btzazaa 3 no popvaoooxd %
‘9’m*x3 In

-W fifififimfi W9 gm. nsaadfiw oz
“KIWI 1m 91? ‘me QURIB33
V 9’! “3 1!!!! Wm; muuggai
$11 1953 PIN moqvax .-am mam

“¢m{:x~ prams sq; ‘.raq1.tr1.,5

‘P°!1§5i–.. ‘3 qona qagqm tm egmaq

«[330 manna mg may “gnu

:3 pm sq: gg Klan uoqm amsq pmom

“R ‘pmndsna 10!! mean; gmwnrg 3,19 atmmap ppm mg mg: