Karnataka High Court
Smita W/O Ramesh Ranasube vs Rudresh S/O Kempaiah on 4 March, 2010
IN THI3: HIGH COURT OF KARI\§A'E'AKA.
CIRCLE IT IEENC!---I AT C}[_}1,E;3x'\RCl}A
1)m_'£51__)'1:'_1_~I1ss'm1: 4% DAY (1);? MAI-{C}---1 2010
B {*3 F0 R E
'IfI~1E 1~i0N'BL,E: MR. JUSTICE I---IE.EI,LJVAE.)I <11. 3
MISCELLAN EOUS 131 RS1" ApPEA1.jN 0 §fE3:;a '1~ / :2()U1;V 14
I')IS'1':I3IJAE-"UR _
,, ; u --'"=...'APE-'--'i~.53[,I,AN'I'
(BY SR1. c 1. KQUJA.I.,AC}I, 2\'1?)§»'C)CA'--I.'I£} I 4'
RU 1:)RI:+:sn .3,/0' i.A1'xx1-_-I - _ -- '
MAJOR _ ' _
R/O NO.2t}./ 1 .- ':s'1'v.M2xm,_ RQ/-\;I_;)
11 CROSS. SR_I1\%A{3A'}:f{ '
BANCg'ALQRE. '
_ NV'f1"H.1:"£3rz2§3§'c:i--i«MANAGER
T1.-2:13: 'NLW 1A---ASSURANCE C0. 131)..
"GLJRUKU 1;1;-«§§c:../Sn"
BIJAPUR j __
(1Ns'aJ1{1:i_f§'ov1-r" TANKER)
-- .. "IAASI11-§E1='€'A1T~1M1~:1) S /0 A131) UL R121 IAMAN I\/[.Lj'LI.-A
' R/O"1':{1.0':' NO. 92/93. SAYICICID 'I'A'I'ESI IWAR
_ q\aé\G_«xA:T{. ANA_:\1'I':)NA(;A1;;s'1':
D HA1 WV' AD
13;»
E-J
4. 'I'I-----IE3 (DRE!-£N"I'z\I, 1NsURAN
1U1a. E---IUI---SEA
TI IROUGII E. '1'£4:M1'3) .
. . . I-e1.«:s1>oNj1j3
[BY SR}. 81 IIVA.NA.NE.) 1II>A'1'11,, A1)v(>(:;\'1'1_:: 1"('.>.Ii}f<': ~
RV.NAI..)AC3OUIf)A, .%\I')VOCA'I'(}£i FOR I'M.)
Mm I+'ILL3D U /8 1.73m 01-'? NW. A§f'1'
'm1«: JUDGMEZNT' 3.: AWARD D/»LfI'1-2::f')J~~' :2é+:...0':3._20Qéa4'---..'IN
MVC.N0.570/04 I{'ASSI:3I) BY MAC? ,;.1_1, I31JA£J'Li_12.
This 'Mis(:e11a11eous First "'A:}3j}')c:2T11 <:c)h1i :?1g 61:1 for
admiss;sio11 this day, the Cc)L:;_1.'1_. dEr1i\«rc.21'_cj%d._tj1:1_e i'<)1l<j3\-=«J.iv1}gV;,.~'3
JUnGMENT,
This appeal filed by the CtI&1iIiiéi1'ii1 ;«.xgéi«ij~:»'f.V.~1he J1ic1g,_§111e1'1.1
&gmyan1danxr10xx12QQafm§gm;byzheI1AddL,cna1Judgc
[S1'.Dn.] at " V.'I:\:Z£V'C.N().174/2007 scek.i11.g for
ex.-;'h;_--v1nc'.e.V_r1'1;':.31'1:t_._?GfRt.hé {i'c31n__gg_c;1sa1tic)ra .
2'. '()n_ O-8'.'05~.2'O04; when the c1a1ima11t a11(.i 0t11e;*.1* 1'e121t:i.ves
'-.,..wcrc p1*0V(?é§ecii.1T';g -iicVIr1c1i from Hubli in 21 'E'en'1po b<:a1'ing [\'0.KA«
":1éf:11f Fin: figm.i1'1g Offi(':e 21'1" Ne1\:*a11':a.1geT11". I-3aggaI11..
7--.01'*..c=§"-'1 E1Ij1{:€Ef'1' }f)L?£1.}'i1'}g N(_).KA~O5/A~2637 c'e1r1'.1c im1'11 oppo.<si1c?
'..»J
(iIi1'c*:.:i'.i(')1'1 with a rash and 1:1c*g!i§_{£=*:1t. 1"r1;21i'111c1* e'.u"i(:f i(._).'§1 (:Q..1'j1I':1'()I
(}V(,'.l" the vcl'1i(':lc .:11'1d (*iasI'1n-=?(.i! 21g;'.1i.1'1.sI 11"} 0 i('t1npo as .21 1*:?;~'%:1V'1' i'5:":.44"U'.VI(_f
cl;-1im;.1.1.'1I amd (')t'l1er i1'3111a1i_cs ('I)fU1L"' i'(~.n'11')(:) .<ms£_21ii';;i§('1 1'vl"l;'E:i.vEv'i'i"(".';5-v.:"" H
for whicil U163 c:la;1i1'n2u'11" filed 2;} (;'l2,111i1'i' ""13'ci?1'.'i1'(:'-_'1"1 _.9€f$i(:-l¥:iI'1§;§=:i"c)19~
('(.)1']1 pc?ri1s2;1t:i()1'1.
3. The t1'ibu1'1al Elfijfi-31' inquiry C'<»)i'1";~';i(ie:1'i1'1'g;; ail{the"1:;r1aii,e1'ial
on 1*:'$v1'i'2iE'11. _i~$vi';r.>:.ffr)_1'*_&.-2: this C0ur't.
4. Heard the ]f;'£51'1"'}7.',}Vé.'d (%':_)1.11::s;»:~5i f'oif"t:-fie.;:1ppCil.a1"1i and the
resp(31'1 ciczrits. 1 ' _< cm the left. thigh, abrasion of
t1'1'?="x1V'i':'_;,§.11'11 «1,1..t,1€.1»_ ieft. }V1';n1'ci'Vt}1e c12,1in1a1'1t, also said to have
1ll'1dC?I"g_()i'1fi "E'.1.1é'-,_(:5pé1t;_1t"i*;):'1 and also I'*3x.I-".7" is said to be 1118
E.VCi'i.:s::!i1z;11'gc' {:a1'g:I. 'is:-jfilintci by tile Aacihai' Nm'si:'1g;'_{ Ii:I()n'1,
-- -K£,ji.l=1.;.1}'3-111'. 'E'}i;_0f-<;2 21 i'1'2:1<'?tu1'c of the .s1.i)i11;~:I t €i.E)i£r,_l:_(§ sit a1"1('i siamti p1'(.)p@rIy aifiri bL'(,',E.{1I.11('? pc1'm2-mc1'1i'iy
V j E
-«E»
('iis;1bI('<'1. As per £329-<.P.8 \.\~'i'2i(?11 is $e;1i('1 to be (52-ESC sslicol oi' {"116
AadI'1z,11' Nursiiig irionic-=, K0§.1'1z1p111' ii is $1"1m\-'11 '£112;-at tI":cfi'L§ is
c<.'Jmpi'cssi011 ii'z1<r1u:'c of i_§)*S§) a Li and t.1'1c1'c also 5'ez==1i(.i in be $3
])l'CS('.fipU()l'1 01111.3 arid. 85 ii1e(.1i<2e.il }.)i."$.
6. The i'.ribui'}a1 shown to have not i;.i§§ci'i";i'i1_i:G'.._.
c(msid.._l_ is 'i'('}er 1)21:<.:~:u.c.§ in E_\/IVC NO.570/2()()4
Qufiga 28£i2008 pasmmihw'UM:RmACT UL Bgapur
V sci as:si(ie.
.
K”
{iii} ‘£’1’1c 11’1z.1t’Ec1’ is 1’cn1i11(>.c’1 1’Jz1<.fk in tzhc 1'1'iE::)1mz1I with 21
(;1i1'cc1i<m to (ii:sp1′(.1i1’1g (‘)_1.)_pc>1’i’.1.1nity to l.3<)_.{'.h,'i'.if1'<?t_
parfgics i',e1ki'x'1g 1'eiCv::m1 d<)v1,1111<:1'1i__.s nu 1'T t'3:i'-'.€)i'_(Ai}VV"i.i:1{t'§ "'–_ *
(?()1'1Si(11CI'dl.iOI1 and the ggre-wi%.y._' off I.1'v1t-'-'.'4"T .1'i1Ei:1fi§§S7
s1.1s3f:e1i11ec1 by the (:I2;1i111z':m1".
i’?\’V V . I . _ , ., ‘ u