High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri.Prakash Rai .K vs Sri.N.Thimma Reddy on 31 August, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri.Prakash Rai .K vs Sri.N.Thimma Reddy on 31 August, 2009
Author: Ashok B.Hinchigeri
QM fiflififlfig 0? %fi.WWfi"fi"&fi{& Mfifivfi  fig %¢fiflNfl'Wa%&. H§@§-'E fifiiiwfi' €35; mwmmm Eififififi  %7;'3%'* mmwmmmw Wmwm mwwm: wt" mt-mmmmwamm mwwm um»

;;§_

€"as.4s2, 1: Fhfififi, ??H.£RQ$S

M TEE §'fi§.'Z'vH CQURT 'SF' K&R}'3?!.TAKfi 3'!' B&HG&L€3i¥E

DA'I'EB TE-{IS THE 313*? my QFASGUS'? 

TE-IE HQEPBLE MIR. JUs:ImEA;IsHc3z<'g. ,z::;é<::;i«r.*m.§*x  

WRET PETITION NC},?§19A:{3Ii§'3;f3E}'§.§&","§rI§i~£Z'ei'~%§.3]'* "
sawgaga: ' ." V 3 a"VMW'

3RE.PRAKA3H Ra: .K*.

sza ? S§VARRA aaI'* _ . ,;
AGES AEQUT 32 ?$ARS ; *-=:
zarx MAIfi,,E?MLAYflUT:_f ._?],V y
BANGAL$Rfif}6gB :. 3'f _ » ""w' ... PETI?IGNER

(Ex 3:;:sE&x§fiK$A?Pag'§§v., E03
, %%%% ~-_f, v;M;3,KEsv$~&=ce.,;

1.

SRI;§.THEMEA Rags?”
axe aava xaaavgfia Raaa?, waaaa

–u %e.?§,§Ew*THz9EAskx§fi&.HAL
«; 1:: STE§E, §,B.HA$aa 3&3?
‘ i2aE%&LsRE”S§a a?5

“:;’a 5fiz”R§KgsH swam

“fi§$_a3?E RICHARE 393$, £5583
§§;3%1 332, SBZh&Y ?aAZA
qgaagags RQAB, E3fiGA&fiRE $2.

“n 3, §RI Aasgw 3 Rafi

Sffi I R 3&3, Rfi5$R
Rf£T fi$.13§, $%§ %$?§S
ififikfififi €HA£?Afi§ $GbB§Y

fifififi BEEL, ETE S?A$fi,
§}3§.a3}§R}’£J ESH’§I§.Rf ?4’R$RR
3§§RAMfi§Y%?8RR F33?
fiE§GA%8RE fififi $51,

§. 3&1 ¥fiR$§£ Rhéfi
SEE CHEKK&ER,EfiWQR

P1&§I1:?~~

3

has m izsay the must ffié in zmpcct af t}1e:_s§*fws:::1d

yraymg & fi% I.§:.E’n..2 submitfim that the

Im mt mm’ prmaed far thaa t*m:a=; being’ ,

filed LA. for rejacfion gr the was 2 2

théet the suit far mare i11jun¢tifiAi1__ ‘ VV

the absezme af deciaramfi? Ha}; V

made an I ‘sf C.P.C.
Ear t {If of the
semnd pra§¢e§.;g;.,L:Vl’ V. cammaon nrder,
&a’l;e:i 1′}:$etit3nr:2a:r’a. appIica&n
far $3′? axzci aliawad the first

_ “Exit the t sf the

pétifibn in

A. .. Eri § the mags: mmzaei

$13′! far Mjafiwsry & aim fer tha petifiarmr

T “‘9s3i;:brm”$ thai: finw a wrty E5, §fi£§ ts) $333123 3.

WWE QWUR? 9? %%W%§fi”%”i%§{% HEQH €0 ‘:£%?;1¥’ Q? wawfimam W6?-€ Cfiflfi’? ©E” mfiwawnm Hfiww mmm W? mfimmmimmm ruun «Mum W3″ nflxmnimnwm rmwm um

prayer; 229 mm: he petmitisé ta ta-izzsart the: samga

$3-.;&que2″;.t1y; as the 33% i3H%*rad by {kw mamiam
S .9

HIGH 6%’:

Wflm

WVWWWH WWI’ mmww'”rAMi&mM% mmm myjwmiz WI!’ mmmwnmmm wiww E.;;W&m’ ma mmmmm MGM EIQMRT 0? mmmmm MW” 606%’? 6? MflN%T%?’aii’=»:5i=..

ii

wntainad in Order 2 Rule 2 QfC.P.C. Ha ab} to

my autism the: prrevisions containgd in

zg-saga) is buztms his aubmiasian that
abandoxm any suit er mrt sf’

pmolttded firom inatituwfzg &

sanm. He fLxr*t%
mt mmm rm mfiadfizt ta seek
the re~«incarparatix:r;é ” prayar while
F’3’rmit§”‘3 ‘ii: ‘1″‘fit0f$.f.5aE)fl art” the:
amend r%a1*d§ ha read 9111:
the 23:11:33 ef C,P.C:.

wlfich Q [T

*2. ajparc cf

V. A. ….. ..

A -v%§?F%¢sae;’i?a4a; wmismaayzeaau

._ nmfijizil by reason (if
% % srgawms dam gr

Erf “::?’n’:¢ flaw my @mds far
gnawing rm pzmrfm tr: aamag as frm
3zn’£far£I’£es1£b_%;&-r:%e2’g’as2n£?32*$f£af

aaimfm

gym, mwmzemmgmmfi, grmzéwpzww

penm%m fims2wfi&&$r&whmfiaf
§mdmmw§h£badym afieshafimm.@ea
B}!

5

arms su®ec£~:rm:ter afsuci: 31$ ar szschpmt afifge

5′ Sri S pm aim

fimt rmpondmt has mafia the I,» far o1fth:a.

plaza’ tafim’fimwm nt;5f j,

5. sue Nmadm
appearing’ {err {ha that the
amend pray:s:xj’!..=u’ a,s m mme. He
mad wt 3 of the

firm’. ztfiuggwrt if his LA.No.2,

.. ‘ ‘
’23. pz@e:rm:=£e by me
i3’;_§ p¥a..*z:; 13’ga3__my zusnaay be man up as :2 is avmfi

” . ‘ ;9némm’ figrm am Eefiwa g

.’ ‘j_’§3′ & Frasafi submits that the

gubmsaéem, has has rakim gm mg

W mam” W’ mwmmm. Wmfi Qmfim” Q? mwxmm Wmfi WWW” W3 mfimmfflm MEWW m’mm” mm mmwmamm Mmw mwwm W- mmmwnamm amu-n m.

. éezvught is rguired in rwaixae the malt
‘ betsvemz the twat fits” $5 .*3ifird:£x:g has him?
V. anmndmmt a}:;p}iaation ifi: rm: ailcwefi, it wank}

fie muifiplicity fif the gumeaéinfig Kg: mggysrt mf his

t af iha

352%;

WM wwwmm mr” Wmmmmmm mmm mwAw:%,;ea mar KMKNIMRKM WWW %:.;&’.mm 0? QWKMMWKA Wfiévfi fiWURY OF mmaamm mm WWW? Q? mmfimm mm m

6

Hcnfiie fipear Cmzrt in rim case: (sf R&MCHM§DRh

saxzmaam MAHAJAN 2:, DAMQEAF’-}.A..__T R’E§&$;3m5g1{

TANKSALE (mam; Arm am E128 m.mjm%¢gea7

80$ 73?.

3, 31-1 . iea;.rrm::3 ‘_:

a for the Iaixasénakm his
snbmisaions an tfcm éu.:fina¥;t¢_:”§ii¢.VVs’i;§)missi¢n5 urgecl

on ‘V V

9* mm 2 Rays 2

cf mm. afi af the mfinquishmmt

sf a gift Qf cam, the amdavit

$335 i1f;:..«.5;’;~;;;;3§veVvx-t zmpmnfianfa 1,5′ which is

@1113: statm that it ia gésasn up far

it is it: mg mmm sf seeldng
far gayizg film war”: fag. Fmham

I :3Li¥§§:I:*AAVV:ksk3.§e?§’%w2- imelf wag gm: gmpnerly mrzmived, ms

erdem wem mam by fim ‘E”mfa,}; cam an tide
$%m5:a.r1y,me mm mm can ‘m aafi max-asmg
tim mmmssszmns urged with e m Grder 23 Rule

3 $§CFC,

fififi;

‘E

10; it is trim that 3 mm, @333 s¢aB:fsi___ the

% thfi frzallawing EWQ mm:

m%. be %é an

Eb} E13 has ‘..§}’1s0§§”””€Ig§$.f£V *’E?i1$ a’ $3
mquérml td J ;;*¢i=s§€:7£*§’=a::’ . :*eaf:} manttfivarfiy

3% ma afidavit and in
3upfi:x+t.&f far the resstwatian of the
sfind §rayia1:.’_’ it game ta pauaity af fixxiéa,

firs? {mt pay flue cszmrt the an the

2?

3

:

§
g
E
§
§
3
E
E

3*
§
§
§
3
§
§
2
E
§
i
3
§
§
&
E3
Q
3
§
Q
E
§
3
§
3
§
Ea
§
§
§
Q
as
éfé
E

earzaaeiiafieri af the $313 fieeti. Prim

is rwuiraé ta mam {ha rm}.
the ma @’tiess £2.33: becausa the

. aiia net ifrmfitute gazmger apgiisaiisn, the
be ahut an him far afi time; The

. V shxmldg rm: mama in Em way af éiaing fuii

jusfice ‘km the ‘ .

QM fimififl? am: %W«%NfiJ§”fl%%& wamw $3 %&%N&§”A%5E==;;~;-~..=

nt aftm the cammenmrmt of the

gag 213 has 1:3 mm ti’1atg’6.é$3_:::*’.1:¢ §§;d::;g kk

§
g;

3

§
X

.. an fim Imam’ aiéeg gm.-

WW mwwm W?” wamwmmmwam mum mi? mmmmamam MEWM W? fiflfimfiffifim NEGW Cflfifl? U? Kfi£N&’§”&Mfi MEGH fiflfifl”? W? %fi,RNA?”£3%.!.-=.-=-..,

8

12, Thacm im :13 blmficct ban an tlm

t app}.m.a’ firm even after the :.:x::mm’eI@ .4111:

at’ the ma}, as ham by this Ccrurt *
B,N.KAMALANABHA REDBY’ §.”‘%JU’IiIVfii1§i”B’;$.fT§;PVFAV j

AND QTHERS reported ILRQQGS KA§£’.,522Q’, %

matter of allowing the the
Court has wide 2xc:;iFby in mm
case ex BGLLEPAEg13f:f’_ Arm mm v.
ELM. €r”AIR Kat. R 26.
Iwsansg I fmd that the

itI1pug n@2ér&§f.V$.p§’fi§}’iz¥Efw.b1¢, bu: the may thing that
is mgzgw 213 am the yefifinxtxar has tn be

% – ””’ gs ma re: the ixmzrxeenimm ta which

in far 1:33 fauit 5:’: his mrt. This {Stuart

M mpmnisn gr mat af Rs..5$§f- by tha ma:
brig; swm*x,a.ide-;:’1r1g the

” {ref iitigaitsnlaszz (suit is af mg ggezar 2035}. ?m¢:e* mg ‘mg

” ” Sm3.r~’£ v&&ms it E: and n%aa:’y is raiaaa the mat fifim

Ea.50fi;’- 29 Rs.,3,§QC?;=-u K is madea aka: thai rm bfifiéfit
$6 the 518$

:13? tiw impmmd crder shaii remw
flflfi

MEWH 5%

E
2
%
E
$
@
Q
3
§
5.3
x
§
X
§
E
2
%
§
$
§
iw
§
3
$
Q
3
Q
3
§
§
2

§
§
a
as
$
§
E

3

@M mmm’ $3? M&R%%”‘§a%%& Méfiéfi fly’

9

rmpanxicnt, only an the first rmsgaaaztzdant the

fifl amfi nf I?5£35€X}f~ {fiazlzama

Five Hundred” (mix) in 111% pefitfsamzsr wifiiifi ‘

finm ttzday.

m This mama

15. Fix rtlmr, it is mag; pétifiéfier
are at zibmy “tn file the in
rmwmxm tn the =

“”” .,
JUDGE