1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF' AT BANGALORE WRIT APPEAL Nos. 1733/2003 8: v236oAgA26/.2oC8 DATED THIS THE 6TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2010 PRESENT THE I-ION'BLE MR.J.s.KHEI--IAR, CHIEF JUSTIC.E*~..vv AND THE HON'BLE MRS.JUSTICE_MANJU_L'A' * I
BETWEEN :
1
STATE OF’ KARNATAKA
REPRESENTEDBYI’1TS”SEC;RIi,’TARY,
EDUCATION DEPARTME,N.T§”‘*~Rj I
MSBUILDING, 1
DR.AMBE.DKAR’v”‘»EEDHI,”»A,_ *
BANGA;;CI§Em1.¥:__ I I
CIOMMEI FOR -PUBLIC
INSTRUCTICNS»INITARNATAKA.
NEW’ PUBLIC AOFFICES
NRUPA’1’IJNGA~.RO.AD.
; K R CIRCLE, BANGALORE.
THE.I3IRECToR OF PUBLIC
CAIMSTRIJCTIONS FOR PRIMARY
A. EDUCATION IN THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,
I OFFICE OF THE COMMR FOR PUBLIC
INSTRUCTIONS IN KARNATAKA.
NETN PUBLIC OFFICES,
NRUPATUNGA ROAD.
I K R CIRCLE. BANGALORE.
TI-IE DY. DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC
INSTRUCTIONS
D.K. MANGALDRE
THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC
INSTRUCTIONS
COORG.
THE BLOCK EDUCATIONAL OFFICER
PUTTUR,
DAKSHINA KANNADA
(By Sri B. VEERAPPA, AGA}
A D SOMAIAH
S/O A N DEVAIAH I = -‘
HINDU, 56 YEARS, RE5iTD_’T.E’ACHER’
MUNICIPAL HIGHER TPRIMARYSCHOOL,
HILL ROAD, MADIKERI, A ‘ ;[ _
KODAGU, ‘R/0 KA_NTHo__0;R v~I.LLA;GI;«:
M
IX/IUSI.IMv;’.;’i8″YEx’&R.’5…_ A ;
ASST. ‘I’F3ACHER_,’F.1Ij;NICIPAL HIGHER
PRIMARYSCHOOL-IHILL ROAD,
MADIKERI, jK(3DAGU
_: R/.0 D.NQVIS–26._ GANAPATHI
KODAGU
* .
I W’/’o.A«C”KARUMBAIAH, HINDU.
.34. YEAIRS, ASST TEACHER
MUNICIPAL HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL,
“HILL ROAS, MADIKER, KODAGU.
R’/AT KIIRBI; VILLAGE.
(NEAR KAYIMANI) PO. KURCHI
SRIMANGALA, DAKSHINA KODAGU
PETITIQFIERE’ .1″; A: ‘-T: .’ .1
H SHAVANT HI
D / O S A KOTIAN
HINDU, AGED 57 YEARS
ASST.TEACI-{ER
MUNICIPAL HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL
MA}-IADEVAPETE, MADIKER1,
R/AT.I\/IISSION COMPOUND,
G.’I’.ROAD, MADIKERI.
N K INDIRA
D/O.N.KRISHNAIAH ‘
HINDU, AGED 54 YEARS
ASS’r.TEAcHER
MUNICIPAL HIGHER PR_I1’vI,ARY”SCH.
MAHADEVAPETE, MADIHERI, I
R/AT NEW EXTENSION; –. ‘*
MADIKER1, KODAGU I f ‘I
KTSHARADA V’
W/O. c.B;MUTIIANN’A _
HINDU;__’AC}ED 53 YEARS
ASST.’I’F§AC~HER ” I
S’f;”J–QSEPH§:.; SCHOOL ‘
R/AT.HOUSE.NO.’2.4/.29
MAIiADEV¥A?’ETE;’*—-MADIKERI.
‘P M MACHAMMA
‘SW/O._P J AYYA.FPA
HINDU, AGED 56 YEARS
– ” YAASSTJDEACHER
‘ .ST}JOSEf’H LOWER PRIMARY SCHOOL
. MADIHERI, R/A’I’.HOUSE No.11/A,
208/AI, NEW EXTENSION ,I\/IADIKER1
do
VIA RADHA MANI
‘W/0.3 P YOGENDRANATH
II HINDU, AGED 52 YEARS
ASST. TEACHER, ST.-JOSEPH LOWER PRIMARY
SCHOOL, MADIKERI, R/AT.DAIRY FARM
14TH ‘B’ LAYOUT, COLLEGE ROAD
MADIKERI
10
11
12
13 ,
MRS. ANTHONY MARY
W/ O PHILIP SEQUEIRA
CHRISTIAN, 52 YEARS
ASST TEACHER. ST JOSEPH LOWER
PRIMARY SCHOOL, MADIKERI
R/AT HOUSE NO 9 / 43 (2)
NEAR POLICE GROUND, MADIKERI
MRS. A PHILOMINA
W/O A PUSHPARAJ % A ‘
CHRISTIAN, AGED 48 YEARS A A
ASST. TEACHER, ST JOSEPH P’OWERC–“.I. ” ”
PRIMARY SCHOOL, ” ,
RESIDINO AT 14TH ‘B’ LAYOUT, ”
KARTHIKAROAD,
SUBRAMANYANAOAR;
W/O 6 HINDU, iAG}E~D 5? "
ASST, ‘”1’P3AC~HF;_’R,«-._~..___ ‘-
ST. MI.CHA;E’,L’S SOHO, IL, MAOIKERI
RESIDIRG A*TERAHM1N*S~ROAD
Nv1ADIKEI%§,.,,K’QDA§}1J_. ~
MRS,COULOiNA~’D’SA,,”
W/O G:REGO.RY-.D’SA,
, ; ASST TEACHER,’
‘ MICHAELS SCHOOL, MADIKERI,
RESIDINO AT MABAPURA,
‘ – A KODAGU
“MRS’ SEOJIN SANTH MAYOR
W/O “PHILIP D’SOUZA
CHRISTIAN, AGED 50 YEARS
– : ASST. TEACHER,
‘ST. MICHAELS SCHOOL
I I ‘MADIKERI, RESIDING AT NEAR
RAJA SEAT, MADIKERI KODAGU
14
15
16
17
MRS. MARY CLARA W/O HARISH
CHRISTIAN, AGED 54 YEARS
ASST. TEACHER.
ST MICHAEDS SCHOOL
MADIKERI
RESIDING AT NEW LAYOUT, MADIKERI ._ A
MRS. CLARA MENEZES
w/O.PH1LOM1NA RAJ
CHRISTIAN, AGED 49 YEARS.
ASST. TEACHER, A *
ST. MICHAEUS SCHOOL, MAI}IKERi;~. Ci”
RESIDING AT p.13. N058, SIDDARAPIl;’i{A” ‘ ”
KODAGU PIN 57} 253
MRS. BENEDICTA LOBQ
W/O JACOB LOBO ‘ ;
CHRISTIAN, AGED 52’YEiARS– *
ASST. TEACHER — _ A _
ST. MICPL5i3L’S SCHOOL;
RESIDII\FGjA-“F D’3SOUZA’?J1L,AY.A,…:
NEAEARAGHAVENDRA ‘?EWIPLEa
MRS. MADA1.;i1AJEA’SAwANHA
W/Q.” MARTIN
CHR’E–S_TZAN’,._AGED..’C52 YEARS
. ‘ASST. ‘FEACHER.
~ ST;M;Cm1:S SCHOOL MADIKERE.
RF;€~ID1_NG AT HOUSE NO. 13 /69,
A ‘ C _C–.AfL.1’_SEEDU, MADIKERI.
ISA’
A MRS’.iEI;OSY D’SOUZA
W/OFRANCIS PINTO
~CH;_RISTIAN, AGED 52 YEARS
ASST. TEACHER, ST.MICHAEL’S SCHOOL
A A MADIKERI. KODAGU.
C’ A RESIDING AT “PRZYA VILLA”
KADAGADAL POST, VIA.CI~iA’}§TAHALLI
MADIKERI
19
20
21
J ELIAS MONTEIRO
S/O ANTONY MONTEIRO
CHRISTIAN, AGED 46 YEARS,
ASST. TEACHER
ST. MICHAEDS SCHOOL
MADIKERI,
RESIDING AT RACE COURSE ROAD
NEAR DAIRY FARM, MADIKERI
SMT. D PUSHPA
W/ O LESLY MAYORS,
AGED 49 YEARS
ASSt. TEACHER,
MUNICIPAL HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL
MAHADEVAPETE,
RESIDING AT DOOR NOV_EW._52’1..
KHB K BADAGA C’OLLE(fiE; POSTV,’ _
MADIKERI I. ” V ‘ _
M M
D/O;HA’RISI D /.Q__’A.BDU’L_’ KUDDUS
MUSL-£3/E… AGED
‘
13/I{JNICIPvA.I,. HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL.
MAHADEV’APE3TE;I’HAlVL:’§DIKERI,
RESIDINGV.ATjI’IO”4/68,
_BA.NG-ALI ROAD, VIRAJPET.
.’ M_RS,, SARASWATHI L NAIK
W,2’O”LATE LAXMINARAYANA
_ 141-INDUV,’ ‘AGES 44 YEARS,
I .ASST. TEACHER
.” G
C 4
MUNJIICEPAL HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL,
5 IADEVAPETE. MADIKERL
“RESIDING AT LASSA NILAYA,
” H ‘A s NEAR MADAPATNA POLITECHNIC.
. _ 4’ KUSHALNAGAR
E A DHANESHWARI
D / O E V ACHUTE-{AN
HINDU, AGED 54 YEARS.
ASST. TEACHER
29
30
3}
ST. ANN’S SCHOOL
VIRAJPET, RESIDING AT ISHWARA SADANA
MAIN ROAD, VIRAJPET
JOSTIN CRASTA
W/O VARGHESE P C
CHRISDTTAN, AGED 53 YEARS.
ASST. TEACHER
ST. ANN’S SCHOOL M
VIRAJPETE, RESIDING AT; ”
LANDON ELECTRICALS, ~
MURNAD ROAD, VIRA-JPET
SISTER JULIANA ‘
[)/O D MARTIS
CHRISTIAN, AGEB. 53.*’YEARS,O’~T_
ASST. TEACHER” ‘ ‘ Q ” j[ _
ST. ANN’SVSCHOAQL’, VIRAJPETE; _
RESIDINGAT ST. JOSE_PH”S. CONVENT.
MRS. RLEE-E§IA I”:’SOU_ZA
XV/’O–.P:A-UL”;*Ey{.;)U;IEPA
CHRIST’IAN_, ‘AGED T 44. Ems,
ASST T’E..ACH.ER . C S C ”
ST.».ANN’S=SCHOOL ”
VIRAJ.PEFE;–_ RESIDINO AT CHURCH ROAD
_; VTRAJPETE
THERESA NORONH
TD;/,_O..VALERIAN NORONHA
, AGED 56 YEAR,
O ASST; TEACHER
ST. ANN’S SCHOOLM, VIRAJPETE,
RESZDING AT ST JOSEPH’S CONVENT
* = 4% VIRAJPETE, MADIKER1.
MRSANJALINE BRAGANJA
W/ O JOSEPH BRAGANJA
CHRISTIAN, AGED 55 YEARS,
ASST TEACHER
ST ANN’S SCHOOL.
34
35
36
WRAJPETE.
RESIDING AT AMMATHI VILLAGE AN D POST
AMMATI, MADIKERI
SMT. C P MEENAKSHI
W/ O B C MADAPPA
HINDU, AGED 59 YEARS.
RETD. ASST. TEACHER
ST ANN’S SCHOOL, _
RESIDING AT C / O B C MADAPPA
PHILIPS DEALER. KAIKERI’1V1L.L¢XGE’..C :33
KODAGU. V,_
HINDO, AGED 59 YEARS ~ ,
RETD. ASST. TEACHER A 1. A ‘
ST. ANN’S SCHOOL ‘ _
VIRAJAPETE, R/AT C/O. H , NWAS
KAVER1 CjOLLEe;j3E, GQNIKQPPAVZ. ‘
SMT. V B DEVAKI W/OVTAM BORAIAHC
SMT; ‘
W/O 1\.§A.NAIAHH4–P”K ._ ”
H’IND{j;j;AGE.D 53, ¥EA’RS~;–
ASST. TEA.Cr«1ER_ A
A_NN’S S’C.HOQL4″
vIRAJApETE;.’RESICD1NC AT CHURCH ROAD
MRS, MEBEVLVAZ
W;/O’Am’HONY AMAL
– A _C.HR1€5TiAN, AGED 50 YEARS.
. ASST. TEACHER, ST.ANN’S SCHOOL
A A RESIDING AT MEBEL VAZ
av HLA SAMAJA ROAD
5* S3383
~V1’SAJAPETE
SMT. CHENNAMMA K G
” W/O K J MATHIEW
CHRISTIAN, AGED 50 YEARS
ASST. TEACHER, ST.ANN’S SCHOOL.
VIRAJAPETE, RESIDING AT GUYYA VILLAGE
AND POST SIDDAPURADAKSHINA KODAGU
39
40
41
42
MRS. JULIAN LOBO
W/ O ALBERT LOBO
CHRISTIAN, AGED 55 YEARS
ASST. TEACHER.
ST.ANN’S SCHOOL.
VIRAJAPETE, RESIDING AT BOYIKERI, I j
CHIKKAPETE. VERAJAPETE
SMT. BOLLAMMA c P
W/O POOVANNA C P
HINDU, AGED 57 YEARS.
ASST. TEACHER
ST. ANN’S SCHOOL
VIRAJAPETE, RESIDINQAT
SR1 KAVERI ASHRAM, S’ ‘-
AYYAPPA TEMPLE ROAD,» ‘
SMTSUSHILA M,.A_’W/O_ c”KUTf1jARRA
HINDU,.v57 YEARS, A A
ASST. ‘;rEA:~::HERi ST’;’ANN*.s”S’c{~:OOL
VIRA’JAI?ETE3,’.,__R;’-AT GAN_DHINAGAR
SMT,’SEE1}§;*V-SALOAN W/O .3 L SALDANHA
cHR1S_T:AN, -56
ASST, TEAC_HER;«.S’T. ANN’S SCHOOL
; “v’IARAJA?E’i’E, R/AT CHURCH ROAD
” …. 14 «
S” TASMT;EiLzI,1 K.J W/O LOUIS 1) SOUZA
OHRESRAN, 55 YEARS
A I ASST, TEACHER
Sfr;A.R*N’S SCHOOL
I’ C44
~.VIRAJAPE’i’E,
R] AT OPP CONVENT SCHOOL
A I AMMATHI, KODAGU
SMTKOSHET MARY MORAS W/O GILBERT VAZ
CHRISTIAN , 55 YEARS
ASST. TEACHER
MUNICIPAL HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL
4 ‘ .. 494
45
46
4’7
48
1}
VIRAJAPETE, R/ AT GANDHXNAGAR
VIRAJAPETE
SMT.C B PARVATI-II W/O K M MONNAPPA
HINDU, 54 YEARS
ASST. TEACHER
MUNICIPAL HIGHER PRIMARY scH00I;” 5
VIRAJAPETE, R/AT GANDHINAGAR ”
BLOCK NO.’7, VIRAJAPETEV
SB./IT.B SUGANDHI w/o D113 BAI,IGa,,,_&
HINDU, SOYEARS I I I ..
ASST. TEACHER, B.E;M._HIGHER PR£’1\/QIARY
SCHOOL, N£ANJALPAD’PU;INEHRUNAGAR,
PUTTUR, D.K. i:
R/AT “SHIVA KRU.PA” _ A
BANNUR, PU’i’I'{}F;'[),.I.?<'.', ; "
SMT.ELIZAD SOUZA-W/O._Iv,I_ DENNES THAVRO
cHRIsTIz=;*Ix1,',,' 50 ASST. TEACHER
B.E.M. PRIIMARYTSCHOOL.
' I
PUFfURD,lE3,»'. .
R/AT A:-RVIIRIVADA NELAPPALA
PADNUR, RI;iIfI*IJR,.D’;I:.
SM’uT’;SUMf’1’HaR’A’ RI)
. 41:»/,0 M KRISHNAPPA ACHARYA
HINDU, 54 YEARS
_ * B’*;E.M~.__HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL
. MANJALPADPU
,4’RI3′;I11RLi,IxI,AGAR, PUTTUR D.K.
R/AT’j_K’E}DAMARA MANE
CHIKKAMUDNOOR, PU’i’I’UR, D.K.
MANOHARA KUMAR S/O S RAJARATHNAM
” — HINDU, 44 YEARS, ASST. TEACHER
B.E.1\/I. HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL
MANJALPADU, NEHRUNAGAR
PUTTUR, D.K. R/AT ASHIRWADA MANE
NELAPPALA, PADNUR, PUTTUR D.K.
..\
6}
62
63
64
14
UPPINANGADY, PUTTUR D.K.
R/ATIANUGRAHA NILAYA,
POST:KADABA, PUTTUR D.K.
SHIVARAMA BHAT K
S/O.K SUBBANNA BHAT
HINDU AGED 47 YRS
ASST TEACHER, STJOCHIM HIGHER_P?}§INE;’X§!Y’ _
SCHOOL, KADABA, PUTTUR D.K.
R/A’I’.HI’I’HILU SR1 DURGANILAYA, P0ST’1″;KQK1< " A I
ADA, BELTHANGADY TALI::J'K.D'.'K,v -1' 4. .
VALSAMMA A J W/O A K ,
AGED 46 YEARS, ASSTTEACHER, * ,_ I
ST.JOCHIM HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL KADABA, I
R/ATPUDHU RUPADI VILLAGE
POST:KADABA, " _
PHIL0M1HA,_B A , .
W/O.SIiAi?JF£A K. CHRISTIAN’ I
AGED”«i1S__Y7R-£3, ‘A$S_’l’-~..TEACVHER STJOCHIM HIGH
KA;jABA, PUTTUR D.K.
R/AT.SUDHI-N1V_ POSTKADABA,
mT*r_UR_D,1§A._ % A
SKARJYAIK, ” A
. ‘S/O.A’ s, VARGFIESE
~C_I31’RISTIAPE.AGED 52 YEARS, ASSTTEACHER
ST’.-JO~F:_IN’S HIGHER PRIMARY SCHOOL
A” Y’ KAWJE-{.RA,.DI
CPOST:=’i§A’QKKADA. PI TITUR D.K.
, I R/A’I’.j_SUDHI NIVAS, KALARU,
KADABA pos’_r, P{}”I”‘I’UR D.K.
ELIZABETH MASCARENHAS
I D / O. ROBERT MASCARENHAS
I I CHRISTIAN, AGED 49 YEARS
ASST TEACHER, ST.PHiLOIV£INA HIGHER
PRIMARY SCHOOL, UPPINANGADY, PUTTUR D.K.
R/ATAGNELOGLES, CHIKKA MUDNOORU POST.
PUTTUR D.K.
._.\
66 JECINTHA PAIS
W/O.BERNAD PAIS CHRISTIAN AGED ~41 YRS
ASST TEACHER, ST. PHILOMINA HIGHER PRIMAR
SCHOOL, UPPINANGAOY, PUTTUR D.K. R
R/ATSIDYALA HOUSE, CHIKKA MUDNOC’RU..4
PUTTUR D.K.
67 SABINA LASRADO
W/O.THO1\/IASMADTHA .; . I
CHRISTIAN AGED 47 YEARS I
ASST TEACHER, LITTLE FLOWER HIGHER” S
PRIMARY SCHOOL, PUTITURSDE-III.
R/ATBADH1 BAGILU,
PUTTUR POST, §3U’I’I’UR_]j_)~..K’.*~
68 KSRINIVASA , A.
S/O.K KRISHNA VMUCi1INTHAY£I.I’V_’; ._
HINDU AGED 49 YEARS
ASST.T_EA*§3HEI§,~. MAIDE’ DE–US…L§IGHER PRIMARY
SCHOOL, P.L?:’-§”{‘LT_R__D..P_K;–‘S
Ry’AT,KAN(i¢HIN’I’&.DKA HOUSE, POST:MOGRU
1IJPPINANGADY,*«P’U’§’TUR D.K.
‘ I I I I ” _ ….RE’.SPONDENTS
‘II3y.SrI-O BHAT, ADv., FOR
R52’=-54 3; R59,-6e~*& 68, OTHERS SERVED]
WRIT….APPEALS ARE FILED U/S 4 OF THE
, a”‘I<:ARNA'TAKA._HIOH COURT ACT PRAYINO TO SET ASIDE
PASSED IN THE WRIT PETITION NO.319 TO
V 386/2mj4.DAfTED 12/ 12/2007.
THE: WRIT APPEALS COMING ON FOR ORDERS
V THIS DAY, 'CHIEF JUSTICE DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
JUDGMENT
C.J. (Oral)
Mr.B.Veerappa, learned GOvt.Adv0Cate for the
appeilants.
4′ 1.rideX:—yes/no
16
2. EL Qsimilar controversy as the one raised in the
instant Writ Appeals arose for adjudication in Writ
Petition No.44103/04 decided on 15._1i’;2ocop7
(I.Rudrayya–vs–State of Kamataka) it is .
.3 Judgment rendered by this Coulft in”Writ;tI5etijtionI ll”
No.44103/O4 has since attained”1.fin-laiitly on
the order passed by a Divisio11._Bericlr_12 of’ in = L’
Writ Appeal No.346_./’O8 VA liarnataka vs.
I.Rudrayya] decided
2. Acco3rdi1::igly-, the appellants
states, be disposed of in
terms of t__he__theL Division Bench in Writ
Appeal No.’3’u*.lcE:_’5/2v(‘)0§3V.”‘C1’deredysaccordingly. ‘ ,._ Z
sa/ ~
…… .. Ckéei Eggfiflg
Sd/«E
Tudgé