High Court Karnataka High Court

Nanjaiah S/O Late Kapanaiah vs Ashoka S/O C Mallappa on 2 June, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Nanjaiah S/O Late Kapanaiah vs Ashoka S/O C Mallappa on 2 June, 2008
Author: A.N.Venugopala Gowda


S/”{$”Mal-§.ap;)a

% . _ , Bu3fai::;1h_.

“‘ivi:aiia:;a11, fséfo imikkznzzla,

v .2}. Javaxaiail,

E
:2: THE HIGH Cmrm’ GF KAR:~iRT£§.K& AT Bfififififlfififi
Bmm THIS trim 2nd my 0? mm, 26fi3; ‘:

3EF$RE
was 3033323 am. JZFS’?i€E M6. VEEiE’iJt’.:’:«fi_ij?;;F;§.!i§z;fiVV(§§E¥Lf:£*%Vi:iéT;E.;:3.§; _
‘Writ Petitiun 2%. 26′”?8fi c?::é§)ir?$

EETWEEEW:


Nalxjaiaix

S ,1 0 late Kapanaiah

Agéid a.b<m'L 7.3 yrs:-;1's, A 
B3/atKa2"igwdaE1§C:c¥;C§iV*'i}1a§§é:;¢, _  ' 
HLziiyu.1' Durga    "  
Iiufiigai '1'al1§.iz}    A       A
Tumkur 1}isl3t§<:£L_ 

 .Peiiié.o}it:1'
(By 8121. $3.3; jNaga:';;;%§. as;s;;T§_" %
A N D:

A A . Ageii£:128";,:ea1's.
32;" ._ "Kai1'a

' Sfo §:3;'{ci._E'?é.a1.::_}e:=:i;3}":, agasd 48 

~ : /0V"iate Nanjaiah, 3f~.'3 }'€fi8f'S,

S1 jwars,

S/Q Chikkagrma, 49 years,

 



3

apptiilain (_:<m1'§, has Iziisdimcicd iiseii' in passixxg um

ijxixpugxle-Li e:-}:'<.it:11. wiihuui, prupacz' (.;£}Ii%i.Lif:3I'a§.iU13. {pf i;%1c' sé:it:

deed and stigma' titxzmzxtzlzizs pmtiuisezi by me piaj;«i:;i:;'i."w.é_§1,:£;i,_V"

by suleiy I't:iyi:z1g up:-513:2. a Iziaizazzar Liai,t:£i_…_i£i:–a. 'i §f';5Ti,}§}='E+T»

p1'txiu<;c:~:<i 'by the deii-:1;:ias11£,5. .§,,ea;t1:;;-:20'. €;Z;)::}:x;'~;::i':{;m;i;:::;2;§€:£iA f

iixaiq the miai £;T§:_:su:r£. has igiizzxxtgi i.i1¢i".:'e§.t::ua::§; 5éi:s:Vfi,:§ &l§;i€ f

(:ir£_:mx;si.a11(:es 0f :33: cam 2:n:£.i '§2;*£i:.-3 %},_2::::;:s:::'i'~ S ': zé~:' :iI.}i§;3§.E.§;Ii{:£§
Uriitil', in excess of iiyzs juIi:~s_g;§3z:ii:2?_i;. . *4

%. Ptzzr ceisféfa, V»E-izjéatiiacgi"–.§;;ig3'i;1__;$%;g:i'._§b1' fLh,{: I'<:sp<.}mie:11£.:;
c<}1;Lt:11d<t:ivV'£I'i:::é;,T.A;§=;:s 53?::iai ‘i;t:V”‘;~;m~:1£”fi”:}:1i Luz: ma};-a Ed 3:’, iiietm
is 3:1 :'<;a<i vi; £11.15: i1L:I9t;§§T¢ir:ixi vsiii-<:"g:i' iisx: p;'0p€1*i3a. Tiifiijgli tilt':

rtzad is in t:}ii§§i,£tIiL'€i, iL fizz "tilt: piaéxxiiif wig; aiimlizpifiti L9

,v'é:'3s.:;'i;a;£:_i£~ L;i})f.}'I3.. fizz: mac}. and ymvmli, iijs Ufiiliiiilifiéi

i,l,$$:f' axici' _t%£:3£)3£ii:,§§:';–1i, E235 {Em vi.i§agt:::1s. Lt:aI°nt:{i iimxzaaiji

tin: ixiaizazar {iz:1§,t:¢.i .ié.}.i.:2'(§i}éi+ has

-. 116631 €.i1*:;1z%s:_1 i:§: {i’1t:: Viiiagtr: E}a::<:Exa;«;aL 'i.'s1.va:*z»3;k€:1'::: auezi me:

V' g:ai'ir,:i3ay:.~:;£, izazi wg;rai1.'<:::i Lise Imiai in §§3.{'L' jsfi::_:a3: TiT'§é§:?:i.

"cg-i2si£§<:1'i11g whi{:h {3§I'€,'LlI.iI:-iiflliirij, tilt: i{}1&*{"3I.' agzyttiiaiss {zzmrt

ha3;:s paszscci Lin: izxxpugrmtj e:*«:i<:I* aiitiwtug $316 aypcsazi, :sé,1:s:c

/.'

:5

i.§.;t:m was ptizvez-:szT§,y am}. 3.ii<:gaiiE.y £:()3;I£HliE.E.tiéi ix}; :.£::~: iziiai
'1»:m.rE. in aiiowizzg 363% M), E.

:3. ti3{>1;si£it:;i:.:gg; him zévai £:{)ii§.tiE§i,°§£ir1.i:S.. 3..§::_;i;~:jtif’-«,§f:’m;.

a.1’i:;£.~:§ ii)? Iii}-‘ (2{)I§t§iiiti1′{:£.§.§.£}’ii 35;:

Wiitzliitir me: iowtir .a.§,)’_£.’?’§i§§§:i3g.§*.ZHH;i..::%i§§.,§”E’;§’.’ Afviéiés «V

€}£<"_'.{'3{Z(1é§:{§ as in ;3.;+;i{E.<;*

passtxi on £53: M2. 1 i.:»y ':..E3r..: i.1'1éa1§':.L.l(:J._.i§'if:-3

6. At. this siagc, ii; is :sLzi.J11;i£..§,£§-;.i.M hr}-* inc: i¢.+.;.g:c’1;té€.i”i;)Z::.;:.in:s<:2i "

apptialéng on i:s_{)i.i;1j.v»:sig.it;£s,« i3;_;?;,it. Lise: '£:;"iai'*VVé2i' Eh:-2 amt. .i1s–m Ex;

Lakc: piatztt, t.{:-._.i.i1ii.i;f.v;)L1{ i.§.x{§T"éé_(:i.{1é;t'i e:'§§;£.£::n!. of am: pz'<;p&:1~i3; :..::.£'

ihe piaiztgiiii'. w_.a;§°E.i:§.~ VE:;§$§«.i..fii:_’s§; £..E;:=, i<.ic:1.:i.ii.y anti aim; {he

tax i_.«::1’i.}’.;r= A:;E:;.*.fiiz:.;i4::i. £2}: izim. as waiiii £.m; ia.w§.’ui.

puss<~::s;:e'i(m aznzi '-s:1V:jt.}§x11;é:11i.. 'E'i1t:*:'<:: Hi ea (.£j~5'§§}i..1Lf": :*c~:g;1r:i2z'1g

i.i 1'c« .§:§5é;:.4:.i's;)§1 sgfizgé i.<.i<~:z1:.2i'}: mi' imr: :~sm'i. g_m;g.2t~:1'£.js:. €.§t)::s:a2<::1'1ng

i.I%.:;r; e1%.-"~:_:i't:i'1.1: :1: Ehcsi 1~3i.i’£E.. a 2″:1;-:£*m;g, £.I§i:i1.I:t:}§,

be m”i’~ivc:<i_"a:,~,. "£"¢:ga§t:'ai.i:1g Li 1:: a<:i.:..za£ €':xE.t:'I.1i._. ic2c:ai2:::: gaze: Liszt

<$i'"Lht: p3'c.2pt:I*£.}z in d1'.spuL::, Err}: mt: E£.l€I'€?: pc:t1'1.:e;a.E 0.3.'

_ i_h£:_(i'uCu:x1m12Lt; p}'(}dl.l€;(::£i Lg; Em: ;.:a1'i.1'.<~:s. S-:'t11¢:<.=. ii. is 32.131.

– . {iits’gjz..:Lt:ti 1.1153,, me: pia.i.11Lii3.’ iiaving, iht: p}’£}pt:f¥.’E.}<' imi. me

.4 Atiispuic: its €}};fl§«7 wiih I'4:2gj.iI'(i to Lht: esrxaci. in{:a.t.icm aruci Like

i

,/Q.

axmlxi, of the }'(}£::1(i, in 111}; view, 131:: p1ai.1:.i.3;i}’ is t*:ni3£.Ec::g.i Ea;

haw: me: ‘:_;t:11efii, 0-,? an im.t::1’im 0r~:.ic:’z’ mi.’ i11§1zn<.:i:i.:m. ~"3:..'_i;::

£11541 Cimn'i. as wtzii i,h:~: apptiéiair: (l<.;m'iL ixavti "E£(}i.j};14E'§:Jf'fVi}'$:'f:L?iZi'

any a:un:”<,.:<::1' (.2E"F'§,.§i:.:;p:.2:7%::x4g

i11}1..131<:ii.u11 02' whiie va(::au:21g :5… in :.,§:§éHéfig_3g§:~:;«.gi. .;«§§:1}e;e é;§ if{~:

213:: 6.1%' iikfi p:r*c_;g.;t:2'i,}; E2}: gm: pia::;i.21i"i' is;_§1'z'+;_;_;. :1; :1ij§s§..§s:.v:i.&:: §.;§::.ii, '

the-: €iitip:.1Lt~: is 02:12}-* wish ._4i't:g,a1.:{i in-"'§«:;.3 '£:.}s::a£.1:;1: anti E4315

t:x£,c:I::L of iht: zromi, in 111}; View ;Z§, \'s*;'_i}I.:;l§£i' 'it}'v€~'§V 'i:i}jV Liixt: 'u£I}§,€."ZI'€13.%§.V mi'

both me 13a;»¢j¢g; 'i'.i;.e: i~:}w-'e1.

Appeiiaut (§(;Li3zi§.i. v§§;iiv9<;z1I1;:;£.z1;1::t::; oi' ijgtrr
case, izazg ;,;;.'Ey5;4_:§<;3.:i;«:LV::'ij,<}I;, in pazszgilig the
impugnfid t§1*gié1° £316; 0'£'£i€f'I' ed" §,t:3}!}p=1§1'££I'}'

izxjtixxcziitgjii g1'za.11£.t:<£ b}? (ifs: ixiiai Ci}{,£1'§., {.:$()}lS;i(i€fiI'iI1g me

"1_1ai."u1t¢ .§'”‘}Li.:;i-‘gj;.ii:spt..:1.t: i)e:Lvmt:1: me-: pg-sq-iA1it::«: s.3:ss:.i me:

31.1i)3n;i’.’:?§i5i’i}1:t§”‘3;i£:i£i€:.;’ii; wzmiai be 3§usi.. E1; e:.ii:sp(>:_~:t: :23 Liza: wmi.

V p<:Lii:£z3:'};«..i11 §_:.i.:';.:-Vi«i:':Ei4:)wi1;g i.€ii'E§I35:

*A.i;::a1':.1i:ci €.Z0u1::;s::E an ix-2):}; sieies ag:_'m.113{i:»:23*y mi’ LE;-:~: ssuii.

‘:2-;}fi”e(iuie pmp<:1'L};, wiii. c:c)I:Lim,;t~: in 11:121.-aixi ii; its ami wiii

be avaiiabie, $231' the U86 and (3Iij(}}J1I}(:i}.l£ oi.' imljg int:

1

//.=

as

(§30z.u’!,:s) E~<3ui:

pe§}il.ium::1’fpiai11E.ii}” siiaii kiwi and <:<;mpit:i.t: .i_!i?~_ {xiii

eividtimxti bt:i'<:rt~: 38.08. 1-3{§{}8 _ M ' V?.§;e:: _ '

I't:spomi<::11{,sfc.i<:i¥::11<ia:1i,s shaii Eeiadiami 4::-131:1:pi%:i.:e. i;i–:§:é1"ééigié

e::i'::\si<.iem:t: btifurti 1-29.1.1.i3§}i}8_°i'§;t: §I3$i§'i~.:(.)i.1IfE,.§f.t.3A1;§::qi1f§.S§,5t'3€;'§

in hrc:

31.12:2{){,’i8.

Ifiaaa