High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Praveen Kumar P vs Mahaboob Basha on 6 January, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri Praveen Kumar P vs Mahaboob Basha on 6 January, 2009
Author: Huluvadi G.Ramesh
EN 'rm: Hi(;H coum' 0;? KL&RNA'I'AE;r§'-é'{T_
BAN{';AL(}RE    

DATED THIS THE as?" my 012' F]%2%:_:rs§% _  

  
1211:; HONBLE; zvm, Jz,%'g'.1'L:(:1§'z~1 uL:.5m13«:,[:;;

:\%1iSCELLA'Z\E'E()US B9im;i';xP:>§;i-iL :;\s<}.:12é3 <31:
   

Sré.Praf.;€<;%*i:.._§<ium--;1f'.§?}_,--    V' '
Aged ais.<;sui'éT,2E'3 }f'é3r:;,V  «_  °
Sic:"F'ar--mi§;:shi¥jmr'ap'pa;--..

Giza: ,A.s.1t§:é1i;3r3.?;_iiieABu5i13§ss;§ _'
Frrségtss. (Bf¥,,{1§3ifi'§vAE}2.1i73§£313:§t?}Qi}~{§ Shop.
{?::.zt't1§i" *;'§si5..1,.A:\£"§

v- é'Bfg"Sri";SfV'is§§i£%§ifh S§:e§ty;. Am; 3

 :. Ma;:%am Basha.

~~ Sfeza Bjamal $313.;
VV '}"§.}:"i var ef I...,(>rt"_v bcamag
'N0.GA~02;'"§-41 E9.
R50 2"" Main, 1*' Grass,
Jaiinagar. i}ava:1agere.

2» H.G.Shivamm"t§1y,
Sit: Gangadaraiah,
Uwnar mf ism' bearing,
Reg.N0.{}A~€>2_=-'T-41 39,

§(_,3v'"'



. The Branch Manager, I
Uzziied Eaéia Insurance Ce. IJ£{if_.,

R50 {).N<L4f§5:"_E
K.T.§.E«Iaga:i, Eém Cross,
{}avaz1agé3re.

Brancia Office,

I F100;', Maliilzarguna Cc~':§};t}_§}; "

§3'ra*vasi Mandira Raad,
Davazzagare.

§.S.P2"akash,  a
SEQ Shivappa,   V
Qwtrtaez' 0f E3a_;§__aj Cimtaii - 

B¢aring%__'Reg.'NQ.EA:   " '-
    '

§"§a1'i¥}::;'"5:7231.'§&§s:. " '

};}a¥*a:3Tafg;ere«"*)'§%11L1kg _ 

T§§a:;V F$I°§iI1§}§§_ ES/§é1;s1 g"<:r;" ' ' 

U£1i?;€L:'€§_V indfia I_11S::;£'a;§1ée CG. Lt5;.,
; ' §§3zfa.m:31 Qfifica,
"  IE Eicrgpxg Maiiiézagéiitla Compiex,

P'1*ava3'i:..Mat1éira Rimd,

'V  _ {}va.*€a.i.iagé';§.

' '  S%é'.'iE:}.§.?\E;:agafa§§a, Aév. fan" R~2,
aid"--Sri}A.;"=«I,Krishz3a$wamj,:,,

$32?

...RESP(}.V

Adv. fa: R:-3!}

T333 MBA. is filed under Saciizgzz §?3{ £3 (2? M'! Act

  a gai23.s§ flu: juégmeni zmé awayé ciaieei 26.8135 passed £22 E\.-IE"v'C
}'*30.'§2.:'{}4 an the 533 :;i:f'i}1e:; Cévii hidgs {S1:§}:1_} & fiaéfii.

MACT? Harihaz; gzartiy aiiexviag {he e;Ia:i333 petitiezz far
C()1*}"E'§"}€'iTi:'3a1£i£)I'} and :<ce3<:i31g erzézatieexiwsit 0%' c:"s:1§;ae13sati£i:n.

4%'



'¥'his EVIFA. ::H&_3Wing:--

JUDGMENT  

Counsei appearing f’0rS1*i,A§%§f%1fi’r§’3%’ V”§§1″”::ii’5§tEEi§.’?§§§T’ f

directad ‘£0 fiie vakalath fa?:re$;n3i1§t:.:;{“?*~§(§_:31v 5

2. This _i£-:L “i%7{£;A ‘c}a.:;21an§ Seekiazg £2}:

en§mn€:.eme:3?§'”:’}f €:<'3r§§;jé:§3v%€;1?i§{}:1V:'L»E3&:i:§g«. §€<":t :% Bliiik amzmd 8.45

j p.i::,_, ‘a §{.”3?!’jv’ baaring N0-G2%02.5T 4139 came is”: a zzegfigeaxi

V’ fiiazizzer and dagficd to the hifid pmfim: atsf fize smote? fine in

which he 53?} dawn mid gusttained injuries; He was treated at
C.{}.H0s;3étaL Bavazxgere and Bagmhgi Hi§§=.;3%ia§ zimi 333:: at

‘§V§’a::%pa% §~§::spé%a§._ ¥%a:1ga§are7_ {Ziaémifig :;u;2:p:::;:e2:iin=;%, i%”2:;:

p€’€fiii£3?} was fled. The matter was ctmiesieé %”1§_.=’ tE:é:.%””~%;zs;:::”€r <3?

59%}: the vehzicies. figs '?¥§hu31a.§ Eta:-'Eng heéé £3253»

was éue fin t§E€ fiegiigence 0:: the part 91°ti1_¢_A{i;?§'sf:::f"’;’i§3é”3:?:;”:*§<._

in qucstitm and as we}? as fiat: If-fie? Qf7§T§}€"i§€r(.':%}iflf iizfhtt .:';1¥'i:7s 0??' ]

5&5?) awardeé 3 tmzai c92m7::__:z:§at'i{:~t3_ 5:»? R3; zv£tE*:_{5%
interest. Being not s&§i:«;fi€fi €"E-35¢ c;iai:zza€*at.E_S befixze §'§':é:.~: Cami

assisting fur czxhancemc'-#5:.' g u

~He3ri§:…. "

5; Ac-:.Q?d§:;gV'{r}A”‘th€ kamed Cmmzaei fhsr {ha ciaixzaafit

a§th0ug§:.Vt.h.¢: tifiirnaaat was eaming Rs.EZ{}0€):’- per m:’3n'{§’: afifi

._v.VL’1i}§ei %cc§’az2a§ has; égaiwrs the

*-“_iI§C<.;v!ii'eV._0:i}t§'§e: imver skis araé thai Em has :30: been s;:;i£a§3§_v

".3Wa.ifisé'"'tv;§war£i:-; less sf ftfirzjre ea.r:zi:f;g dfiét €33 désabéfitjv. Evez:

.=.};si§f} 1"' regard is meciécai bifls aithatigh e::.€}ge§§£ cvéésncfi: is

fifnducficl an {ha grcmné that {Ewe aufiaca-r ofiha biiise; 333:; am; 3562::

axazzxizzed, the Rains Ems been d%si}e§§mrad,

W/%

6. Per-ecrfira. the Eeamsd ($135332! Em’ the ¥;is:;::r€2- has;
Submitted that tfie quanizzm af <:0.mpe;3sati0n 9,5" :§ia;=~:£

and pmpci" arzci it aims nut reqiiire an}: §:2ier§??::?§:§ic¢;

7. As per 33% medézéi ‘«i?.’_g~’ié$:é<2%: 2:? is: :=:»¢1€é:*s'j§.?1;:i':E:Vf'_§?s:::*€: 2::
gracturs {If tibia, fi"3c§i,ire af §3;;m1¥ E3~:?=I3§s §%';i1ct::§"e {sf Eefi:
E33113, on {image §1ead:?'{_'R3,.§_'f,{}{§{}?~;"§3,S_.2{};.{§("}{?:"«= and §{s.2{}-{§€}{}:'m

has bezaii ,:;£%'a2'ée<:E' v%esg§c:;€:wf¢%§'. 7 '}7;:';:€;i;a*r:i3 mtaciizzzé {$3359

Rs.iO.€)€}{}:¥'_««¥::%;3v~'§9;¢é13.:_a§$$3r{§ed."A._"Q33 ciaimaxti és gaizi $34: Exam:

%'3€:3f';vE'! trééiiéci ai'?..%viai1§§sa§ E§'{:spé?a§$ §:§a:3g;a§m°s:: 322$ aéigiqts at
§}av&:zgere HV::Sffi€a3;«.._ f};3,–~{£32 Ezéad iaf iiziiééizai e::x:;":€§-ages §'E§?,-

weuici 'E35 aw$:v_'_i£%r:E_ :a:.¥$:~§i§1er R.<;u§i3,{}{}{}:»-( St; $332' as §<:;:~::~:; zsfi

_'fjeif3:~.n}_iL::g fiuszr t<§':i§—s:a«'i*:iié'tf_: is »:,a:3<;:é::':3::¢ ease}: as mg" éhzz %3%'i{i%§3{§i3

A " * £?sVf'::i;i::«."§ }:3 éE;é§° there ix 3.5% éé:<£':3%§ét§~' {£3 Em: Sega. E-~Ec':s's.;-=~.=':=:x-rm: ihe

'faker: ii at E5% and by aé<;§pii3'3g iha 1m.§E§§;"s§§t':r ('if

337 ééyidiakiaag 'ink; incmne at R.*:2;.8ni}.2"'- per :13}; hag awaréeé

"V . , }_.Rs,3'é;720;"- afier deducting 5{)"i.»~"'e raffiae eamiiig. "E53 same is; an

" -..'§_§§e Emvcr side. Ewinxaieverk faking iiis; §m:e.:m¢3 at RS; §€}{%s%~ may £%a_x~*

and Ersjv adzxpzéng {$343 riizzfifilfifsr {if 3;? Ezavéng regzmfi is Ehf: age :3?"

£338 c}a.%mar;t that he was 26 years aid at {ha iféme ggfécgiaéczzik he

wauid ha entéfied 'ta Rs.9§*Qi3{3:"¥– 'iewarcis $033"hf$§§£%':{i'3'sg:'.:ia€:sgm

dégahfiity. Farther. hr: wuuid. ~2fi.5:_:;3A a§;§":§1i;;«:".–'A'

Rs.5?{}€3{}:"1- inwawds C()f¥\«=*'€j~z'3I}fi'5t3 533315 J éiTé€._ a:z1;§, A

mwardx Ems {:s{an1ez315a'c:§» 'a;:fi éiV.e1:j<§§1z3g:.izt..A§:i_; "$1115, §i§er
dcfiuszziiflg tag.-*1a?rd5§VVv:¥a33a af funare
incmma came to cii.§aE*'fi1Vi"ij§i :{fif€.JLi3d be exsiéiieé ti} 3.
mtg} c§):z3;§é£%§§fi'é@1z !.';1'".3I{ and abiwe wizai has
been %t§g逧ief wifia éaierest ?_i:r'l= fi% pa.

fmnta ii«§:V§: ‘t:2’%;_g:xséf:.

” :’5’s,a:<:(3:'d§'§'s'g§fs§;: apgfieal is a}§:im~'ed én part,